Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Print gun magazines used to be the standard way to stay tuned to the new scholarship in the world of collectible firearms. Then we got the internet. Today, researchers paid to write articles for print magazines have been effectively supplanted by collectors posting equally detailed and well-researched pieces on free public forums. While this is obviously sub-optimal for the people who relied on printing magazines and selling writing services, it has made information more available and (most importantly) far more discoverable for the general public.

Files

Print Gun Magazines are Dead (or are they?) (Ad-free)

The best firearms reference books: https://www.headstamppublishing.com Print gun magazines used to be the standard way to stay tuned to the new scholarship in the world of collectible firearms. Then we got the internet. Today, researchers paid to write articles for print magazines have been effectively supplanted by collectors posting equally detailed and well-researched pieces on free public forums. While this is obviously sub-optimal for the people who relied on printing magazines and selling writing services, it has made information more available and (most importantly) far more discoverable for the general public. http://www.patreon.com/ForgottenWeapons http://www.floatplane.com/channel/ForgottenWeapons Cool Forgotten Weapons merch! http://shop.forgottenweapons.com

Comments

Kenneth Marshall

Film photos and negatives associated with printed media were 1) Non-Adulterated 2) a form of permanent record. 3) because the cost to publish it was a barrier, an investment required "well" reviewed and edited to be "appropriate" to be published. 4) A fringe benefit is the archive of advertisements in periodicals of an era which are sometimes a source of information in and of themselves - nobody archives advertisements, but they are occasionally ancillary to the research.

Kenneth Marshall

It would be interesting if an institution or business would create an official repository for print media that is scanned and searchable and serve as an official copy of photo or printed information. A digital Iron Mountain of archives watermarked for credibility. Currently no online photos can be trusted and made into anything the imagination desires, there should be some for of validation watermark to show the article or photo is not just AI garbage. The Department of Energy spent a huge amount of effort to make very old print docs digital so they could prevent good vintage research from evaporating. It was a conversion from Microfiche film which is the official record due to film negative lifespan, but not searchable.

Bernard Owens

The highest quality information in the gun magazine world is not being replicated by online amateurs. Lots of good work is being done, yes, but the really great stuff is not being produced for an accessible publishing venue. It's locked up in very expensive books. That's fine, I suppose, because people that care dearly about a particular subject can buy the book. However, those of us who like learning new things from knowledgeable authors are often left on the outs. We don't have a good place to browse and stumble across things we don't know about and read high quality articles on those new (to us) things. I miss the various publications that came out under the Precision Shooting imprimatur debacle. That company put out 3 (at least) different magazines over the years. The writers were some of the most knowledgeable alive. That whole body of work is priceless. However, when the publisher decided to retire, he just didn't care about any of it. He never tried to aggregate all that fantastic content in one accessible place. I'd happily pay $200 for a CD with everything ever published by them but they can't be arsed to meet that demand. What an astounding loss! Forum posts can never take the place of those articles and most of them aren't for subjects broad enough to warrant a book. We are all the poorer for the passing of magazines like those.

Ryan Thorne

I’ve noticed that magazines have have largely evolved into large format illustrated books that are generally non fiction. Print magazines are often costing as much as books, or magazines for a firearm. You can get three or four PMAGS for what one issue of ARMAX costs.

Larry Schwartz

One of the problems with the Internet is the lack of permanence: On the one hand, that embarrassing photo from your college days seems to never go away. On the other hand, several Internet gun boards have suffered catastrophic system crashes over the years resulting in huge troves of valuable information being lost. Yes, you can use the Internet Time Machine, etc. to recover certain items, but only if your tech savvy and then only with a huge amount of work. The end result is that even in the Internet age, good information is often fleeting . . . plus text is being displaced by the highly censored video posting services at an alarming rate.

ERB2

Just like my boxes and boxes of of old car and motorcycle magazines going back to the late 1960s, my old gun magazines predate the internet and provide impressions of these machines when they were introduced and first driven/rode/shot. So these old magazines give you a moment, frozen in time, when a Ferrari 365 GTB/4, a Honda CB750 or a CZ 75 were first introduced to the world that marveled in wonder.

Erik

The problem I always had with magazine articles covering historical firearm topics is that they were usually little more than teasers that barely scratched the surface of what I wanted to know. In a lot of cases, it was effectively a secondhand regurgitation by someone trying to condense a master work like Clawson's 1911 or Duff's Garand books down to a scant five page article split into two or three sections by paid advertisements for crap I had no interest in. Sending guys like you and Othias $5 a month on Patreon gives me a much deeper dive; better points me to the source material if I'm that interested; and cuts out the publisher. While I generally despise post-1980 technology, THIS I tend to regard as an improvement.

Guido S

the way I started to, well study would be an overstatement, but to learn about firearms. with like 12years the first from 14 into my 20s I was a keen reader of "schweizer waffen magazin" (later "internationales waffen magazin"). 10 magazins/year. sadly since yeeears not as a standalone thing in germany. that was 1986 into the mid 90s. years before any internet. deutsches waffen journal sucks. so I went with the swiss.

Guido S

I think back in the day we read kind of quality work by more or less professionals with a background. in English I do like to read, or watch, massad ayoob or clint smith i.e. historical research is one side, much simpeler reviews is another. the later has developed into often less neutral less quality. not everybody who owns a smartphone or camera and can post something is an expert. just saying. some do really good work. others look for the most views and new subscribers.

Dale Farmer

Is this a good thing or a bad thing? Yes. lol.

AnotherPatreonUser

I enjoy all your videos Ian but I particularly enjoyed this one. 😉 This problemis not unique to firearms publishing, and arguably there are subject matter domains where this situation is even more noticeable, as general interest in the subject matter fades. If you were an English speaking hobby machinist/model engineer, up until the early 2000s the best resources were magazines like Model Engineer, Model Engineer's Workshop, Home Shop Machinist, Machinist's Workshop, and a bit further back, Popular Mechanics. Now of course, as Ian says, the most accessible information (and if you can't find information, it doesn't exist 😉) is found on the internet. The problem is that the correctness of the information does vary quite a bit. There is a website, lathes.co.uk, that contains an astonishingly large and detailed archive of information about all but the most obscure manufacturers and models of lathes, milling machines, jig borers, surface grinders, tool and cutter grinders, and most other machines you'd find in a workshop (not much on CNC but this site is mainly about manual machines from the 20th century), from all over the world. It's free to access and as far as I know, always will be. Tony Griffiths, the owner of the site, has done stirling work in keeping this information available (a very agreeable chap to chat with on the telephone, too). But still and all, there's the occasional mistake or ommision of useful information here and there. You can look on YouTube and you will find scads and scads of videos about machining techniques and restoration of vintage machine tools. Some (Joe Pie, OxTools, Mr Crispin, The Lazy Machinist, This Old Tony) are treasure troves of fantastic content, but sadly a fair proportion are full of regurgitated BS. Then there are the forums, which are an invaluable resource, but then again, some members will happily repeat 'recieved wisdom', as if it's ordained from on high. Some of this 'received wisdom' is worth keeping, but some of it is just dogma that's only considered authoritative due to its repetition. I suppose in the researching of the history of firearms, finding out why your parting blade terrifyingly breaks on you far too often, and indeed any other subject with any depth, they key is to have a critical mindset, try to gain an understanding of the underlying principles, and be suspicious of anyone asserting something without decent backup. 😉

Robert N Ayres

I lament the passing of the print magazines. Just this fall we lost "Guns Magazine" and going forward NRA's "Rifleman" is going Digitan with quarterly hardcopy( I wonder how long the hardcopy sill last). For quite a few years now, have been physically clipping articles of special interest (how to reload an obscure cartridge for example), putting it in a sleve protector and organizing into a binder. For "Handloader Magazine" I bought the DVD Handloader set. AS far as finding more/better information on the internet - MAYBE !! - I recently acquired my first Thompson Contender - It is an early (not east opening) in 22 LR. Great gun. I want to buy more barrels BUT I can't find a significant information source . What barrels go with forends? Will an octogan barrel fit my fore end that works for a round bull barrel 22? Long list of questions. I can't find a book anywhere and nothing comprehensive online.

ERB2

In my opinion, the greatest advantage of gun reviews being presented on YouTube by (hopefully) independent creators is that, unlike articles in the traditional magazines, reviewers on YouTube will actually say “THIS IS A BAD PISTOL! DON’T WASTE YOUR MONEY! They will do comparison tests between similar firearms! They might even declare a WINNER! While car and especially motorcycle magazines have long history of doing in depth comparisons tests, gun magazines seem afraid to do them, lest they anger the manufacturers and advertisers. (That’s right… I said ”lest”). YouTube has been a breath of fresh air for understanding the real qualities of a new firearm. But I still get excited when a new magazine shows up in my mailbox. The written word has its own special charm, especially in the hands of a great writer.

WayneWiiki

My initial thoughts? I kept a great many magazines for a great many years. Guns, G&A, SOF, SAR... I read them over and over again. I love YouTube vids. But I tend to only watch them once. Its an interesting paradox.

WayneWiiki

Imagine if you will...a place...with a searchable database that allowed you in for free...to look at and even take home (for a short period of time)... books about ANYTHING. Oh wait, here's a library. My favorite place when I was young. Young nerds are really missing out on the experience.

WayneWiiki

I think Ian actually understands musicians...he just doesn't realize it. There is so much synchronicity.

Forgotten Weapons

When I was growing up, my father's office was in our local big library. I am well acquainted with such things as card catalogs...but I've yet to find a library that subscribed to these sorts of gun magazines.