Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I did an experiment with an AI thumbnail for last week's video on the PBS-1. The result? You all hate it, but you also watched it about 30% more than when you saw the regular thumbnail...

Files

The AI Paradox: Results of My Thumbnail Experiment (Ad-free)

I did an experiment with an AI thumbnail for last week's video on the PBS-1. The result? You all hate it, but you also watched it about 30% more than when you saw the regular thumbnail...

Comments

Matt

The AI version looks like it could be an ad for Forged in Fire.

JARED

I like the old thumbnail pattern, you can tell at a glance which videos are yours quickly and easily. It's also very professional in appearance and less 'busy' looking, which is nice too.

Dan Boyle

my left ear enjoyed this experiment

Josh Amsberry

I actually ignored the AI thumbnail subconsciously, as though it were one of those slop channels that keep flooding YouTube like a plague. I didn't even catch the Forgotten Weapons channel logo in the bottom left until I saw this post.

Philip Straatsma

For a channel like Forgotten Weapons that focuses on the historical vs the hype the clean and more classy black and white just fit. This isn’t the armed scholar after all…

Simon Sultan

People also probably clicked it because they were curious about the change of style

Terry

The thumbnail doesn’t drive my viewing, or even clicking. If the subject doesn’t interest me—such as suppressors—I just don’t click.

Skyking

I watch your videos because of your skill and reputation.

Sticks

Had to watch this whole thing because I was VERY ready to cancel my patreon. Glad to hear you're not going that way. AI might be "cheaper" in the moment but the environmental, societal, and personal costs are very expensive.

Tom Kominek

Please, do not go this way Ian. You are one of the few genuinely respectable voices in the firearms community who avoid stupid sensationalisms, egotisms and bravadoisms. Good humor and honest excitement are something else. All this is far more important than it seems. It does not draw in crowds as fast as cheap sensations do, abut it gives you credibility and respect that almost no one can genuinely challenge when something serious is at hand. In the world where guns (and people around them) remain as ignored/feared/demonized as they are, the firearm enthusiast community (worldwide, not just in the US) seriously needs every tiniest bit of this we can get. Making your videos appear like sensational slop for teenagers (even if just via thumbnails) ... I just don't believe that will help anything at all, beyond YT statistics. Staying on YT is important, playing it their cheapest way is not. IMHO

CVH

Content over book cover. I really wanted to see the silencer and history

Rusty Shackleford

If more colorful and dynamic thumbnails are driving stronger viewership numbers and community engagement, then IMO their use is the creator’s prerogative. (Like when any company refreshes their product packaging to attract customers.) That said, I think AI thumbnails communicate a sense of laziness, are associated with prioritizing “clicks over content”, and are seen by viewers as a “sellout” advertising technique that compromises reputation/authenticity/credibility in pursuit of a bottom line. They’re associated with low-effort and low-accuracy clickbait channels, and that reputation seems to transfer to other channels who adopt AI in their content creation. Forgotten Weapons has a brand built around extremely reliable, well-researched, knowledge-expert presentations on interesting topics provided in a more academic/educational format, and that’s something I think the viewing community deeply appreciates about the channel. Remaining “on-brand” is important even if deciding to update/modernize what’s presented. (Disclaimer, I haven’t watched the recent upload, so I’m just commenting on AI thumbnails generally.)

Tom Briggman

Your thumbnail looks crisp and clean, the ai looks way too busy and obscures the flag or origin.

Beccaskye

Did Google break down the preference by current subscribers vs NON subscribers.?

Chad Smith

I personally prefer the classic version. The "Silent killer" headline is trying too hard and wouldn't be appealing to me if I was looking at a unknown creator.

Robert J. Hansen

Ian, I've been a supporter since you first opened this Patreon. I was the guy who submitted the first question answered in your first Q&A. I don't begrudge anyone experimentation, but the moment you start using LLMs in content creation is the moment I politely step off this train. The line must be drawn. I'm sorry.

Larry Schwartz

The thing I didn't like about the new version of the thumbnail was that the flag was covered up. I also like the light background on your existing background as it makes this easier to see the actual firearm (most of which are dark).

Cleo45

I suspect more watched this single video to find out if the content of the video had gone to the Dark Side, that is, AI at its currently primitive and highly annoying level of authenticity. Maybe A-B tests on 10 or 15 videos would give you a more realistic answer?

Steven Minniear

Thanks for the video and the interesting experiment. Your choice, of course, but I would suggest sending a note to the person who pitched you the image and thank them for the time and effort. There is some creative effort that went into (I presume) and they should appreciate the feedback.

Steven Minniear

I prefer your version. It does the job very well for me.

Benjamin Helton

Here for the content, I really don't consider the thumbnails as important to me. I will watch everything anyway. That said, the Yellow font does pop more to me and catch my eye amid a sea of other thumbnails.

Mark Blundell

The subscribed viewer numbers would be interesting if Google made them available to you. I suspect the new style might grab people who aren't already subscribed, where most subscribers were going to click anyway. It sucks that creators now all put their face on the thumbnail with some dopey expression - because it works. I wish it didn't work, but statistically speaking 50% of people are of below average intelligence

FrugelViewer

Thank you for staying loyal to your loyal, legacy viewers. I just thought you had a slide template with the black/white background, “Forgotten Weapons” logo, spot for flag and spot for text and just copy and pasted the text, flag and appropriate image of the item into and sent it. AI has it’s place in things like cancer research. When it comes to stuff I’d like to watch, listen to or read it will be a very long time before it’s up to the level I want. Thanks for doing what you do, the way you do it.

Claus Økær Holdt Hansen

I can see the reason behind such a thumbnail. But I personally would never click on a video with that kind of thumbnail unless I already followed the creater, as I link it to AI crap.

Carsten Moser

I try to give an explanation: I saw it and thought: "Oh, that's something new and special. Have to try it." If it would not have been "new" (as it would be in a few days time, when i get used to it, i would not be so curious.) I Personally like the old, FULL weapon picture style :-D

Earing1

I would watch it even if it had no thumbnail, but if it works, go for it! #GoSkynet!

Squid556

Thanks for not caving into the ai trash

Retired No Bad Days

Your correct in all of you assumptions. Your thumbnail is your trademark. Do not chance it. With regards to AI, when reviewing some of the text books I read 25 years ago that explained how AI is a digital knock of your nerves cells and how they react, the state of AI to day would be similar to a one year old baby. AI that I have used so far has no inference ability. The engineers I have talked to that have used it found it unreliable and requires close review and many correction.

Felix Raithel

I prefer your classic thumbnails. those AI created ones may look more catchy but they put your content in relation with AI created content wich is mostly annoying. your content is excellent. and those AI thumbnails don't do it justice.

Philipp Hintermüller

please stay with your own thumbnails - i hate AI content! love your CONTENT

Ryan G

Hey, Ian, this was a really interesting video. I think there's a happy middle ground here where you can spruce up the thumbnails of your videos without resorting to AI. Software like Lightroom makes it very easy to select an object and "paint with gradients" to add texture and definition. This is a standard trick that photographers have been using for years to make photos more visually appealing, and it works really well on round surfaces like that suppressor. Putting little blurbs on the thumbnail is a bit cheap, but it does definitely drive some interest in a video. You should check out Mustard's thumbnails. He is a terrific educational channel, like yours, but he does use these tricks in his thumbnails to appease the almighty algorithm. https://youtube.com/@mustardchannel?si=COmo5jVIkHdggWbR