Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Today John Keene and I are comparing and contrasting a pair of quite different submachine guns. One is a Franchi LF-57, a rare second generation stamped Italian design very similar to the Walther MPL/MPK. The other is twenty years later, a Colt SMG - a closed-bolt third generation design based on the AR15/M16 platform. The question is, if you could have either one, which would you take? It's a question of collecting interest and uniqueness versus practicality and shootability. Which would be your choice?

Files

Franchi LF-57 vs Colt SMG (w/ John Keene) (Ad-free)

Today John Keene and I are comparing and contrasting a pair of quite different submachine guns. One is a Franchi LF-57, a rare second generation stamped Italian design very similar to the Walther MPL/MPK. The other is twenty years later, a Colt SMG - a closed-bolt third generation design based on the AR15/M16 platform. The question is, if you could have either one, which would you take? It's a question of collecting interest and uniqueness versus practicality and shootability. Which would be your choice? The best firearms reference books: https://www.headstamppublishing.com http://www.patreon.com/ForgottenWeapons http://www.floatplane.com/channel/ForgottenWeapons Cool Forgotten Weapons merch! http://shop.forgottenweapons.com

Comments

Daniel Standridge

I had the opportunity to fire a LF 57 back in the 1980' s I remember it was surprisingly heavy,but very controllable.

Kenneth Marshall

I would go for the Franchi - so different. just on that alone.

Troy Janda

There’s someone who is issued a Colt SMG, it was a really decent gun. Higher ups, head issues with HK customer service, even back then! so it was the alternative to an MP5. And we all liked them very much.

Troy Janda

As someone who is issued a Colt SMG, it was a really decent gun. Higher ups, head issues with HK customer service, even back then! so it was the alternative to an MP5. And we all liked them very much.

Guido S

the looks... that colt is tempting. the cool no doubt the franchi. mp5 and praised closed bolt or not. I have a real weeeeaaaak spot for 3nd and 1st gen subguns.

Benjamin Helton

Another AR or something unique. From a collector's perspective, there's no question.

Martin Morehouse

I'd go for the Colt, sort of like getting a Cessna 172 instead of a Globe Swift. But the Swift and the Franchi are both pretty cool.

WayneWiiki

I've owned 4 67-69 Mustangs and 1 66 Galaxie...In all the years of the Mustangs I've had dozens of "I love Mustangs" conversations...and in the 2 years I had the Galaxie I had 50 conversations of "My uncle had one..." that went WAY past the average time of the Mustang convos. Rarity becomes a life of it's own.

Pat Patterson

John Keene's philosophy: 'Acquire the one that you are less likely to acquire in the future." That's a really good approach; I wish I had adopted it 25 years ago.