Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

CivDiv - How to Survive in War: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aj7aufhLfWA Weaponized commercial drones are part of modern conflict zones. Let's talk some theory about strategies on how to deal with that new reality.

Files

Comments

dominic

Very compelling topic! Thanks for the video.

Max

Hey, I was on the Marine Skeet team had some conversations on cUAS. I also have a Part 107. I'd love to explore this, FAA issues waivers for a lot of different things so never say never.

Guido S

well that get splitting hairs on LEGALITY matters what sure is not advisable. just food for thought... say a broken unit on the graund, not airborne, at 50yards? --- heck I like no5 shot---call me crazy but there's a reason why claysport shooters have an O/U as THE standard. like in pre m203 bloopgun m79 times... have one carry kind of an coach O/U for drones next to a short light carbine? masterkey thing underbarrel?---next thing you know we need some sarah connor. read a fictional novel KI thing called "prey" not that long ago. bit silly and amusing but same time scary. if drones get smaller and armed... we are done.

Guido S

damn! being a shotgun fan I´d be the DedicatedDroneDude...

BSJ

There are plenty of videos showing drops from much higher altitudes. CIV-DIV even speaks about the height at which drones are inaudible in one of his other videos. An AP munition-ized attack FPV drone could very well be lethal to a shotgunner even if engaged at 50 yards.

Max

I wasn't part of the conversation directly, but the Marine Skeet team was asked about this problem: they asked about magazine fed 3" chambered semi auto or automatic shotgun and after some back and forth a light automatic rifle like the IAR was the ultimate suggestion. This was a few years ago, and drones and TTPs have changed a lot since then so perhaps there is some target that's a good candidate for goose loads and civilian available guns.

Bill Smithem

Hanging a 3D printed mockup of a drone as a ground target such that you're hitting it from the same angle as if were flying should demonstrate whether or not a shotgun is effective and won't break any of the rules.

Tony Bouza

No idea about the filming aspect but for the drone lethality test you can take a page out of the military's book and put a balloon or tennis ball on a string below the drone for a target to see if you can engage a small target that moves like a drone. Then to see if shot would work you can shoot at a drone on the ground at 50 yds. and see if it can still fly after.

Tomek Jankowski

I have a stupid ballistics question, definitely reflecting my own ignorance: Is there a difference in shotgun spread patterns when shooting horizontally (parallel to the ground) versus shooting straight up -- both at 50 yards?

Max

I would even say a super safe way to proof-of-concept it is to do patterning at extended ranges. Set up a steel patterning board and keep stepping back until you're either at expected drone ranges (400ft vertical is FAA civilian maximum ceiling) or your pattern becomes ineffective. Iterate this through your proposed loadings and we can get an OK picture of the effective ranges.

Max

You'd miss out on the effect of barrel inclination/ballistic arc but you'd at least have an idea about range and pattern density.

Max

That's a good question, I'm not sure I've ever seen it examined. Most clay shooters pattern horizontally. I would make the educated guess that it has *some* affect that's dependent on where in the arc the shot string is. The shot tends to string along the axis of travel, gets more hotdog shaped than circular or spherical as you might think.

Guido S

maybe something like a 203 or 320 single or double underslung?

Nomp

For basic stuff you can get some data out of this, but Karl points out something absolutely critical that you really do need a functioning, flying drone for: destabilization. A quadcopter will behave differently while flying than lifting off, so even if you raise it up on a 50ft pole, shoot it and then attempt liftoff you may still get liftoff (with sufficiently weak load - I suspect even the first turkey load Karl and Russel demonstrated would prevent liftoff) and a skilled drone operator might be able to get use out of it. Whereas if hit in flight the drone would de-stabilize for long enough that even a skilled drone operator would probably not be able to recover the drone (from 50 feet). And then there's the difference between a drone idling and in motion, which will again have different reactions to being shot/getting destabilized. And then in response to people being able to reliably hit them from 50 feet, drone operators would move their "engagement" range further out, which would change, for example, the chance of recovering a destabilized drone. All of this affects your doctrine and how you develop it. Off the cuff you want to be identifying and engaging a drone at a maximum effective distance but also you need to be able to react effectively for one that gets the drop on your while you're pinned, like that AK shooter displayed above - all of which is going to have many different variable to account and test for. So yeah, tl;dr on a too-long post: Some data is certainly better than none but to get effective theory you do need that functioning, flying drone target.

Andrew Cook

I wonder how #4 buck with a full choke would fare?

Andrew Cook

Or 3 1/3" 00 buck is 18 pellets

Jason

Looks like I need to pick up some turkey shot. I was thinking goose shot might also be effective... Had an idiot neighbor flying a drone from his backyard and looking at people. Thought about doing some testing but the "discharging a fire arm within city limits" held me back.

Mist Sparrow

I feel like those net rounds or the ones with the wires attached to the petals would be better for tangling the propellers , not sure on their range though.

Max

I see where you're coming from, but I'd save expensive target drones for the last stages of testing the hypothesis of "Can a shotgun reliably defeat a sUAS?". There are a few factors that compound, and you're limited by the payload a commercial 12ga 3" magnum can throw (muzzle velocity/peak-chamber-pressure times shot-cup volume). You absolutely need pellets that are carrying enough energy to break something critical. That's going to be pellet mass times muzzle velocity with the tradeoff that more energetic pellets means fewer pellets which negatively impacts your pattern density. That in turn influences the effective range of the pattern (which is different than the lethal range of each pellet). Effective energy for the pellets in a high density goose load probably drops off at around 100-150 yards and effective pattern probably at some point before then. That's what's worth testing in a controlled environment and then deriving a functional live test (or more legally permissible proof of concept test) based on the results.

Max

Check out the app "Drone Scanner". Drones over a certain weight need to be carrying a transponder, and many of them can be detected and identified by it. Every state has different laws, but in many using a drone for stalking or recording of private property is unlawful. Proving either of those is a different story, but you might be able to get them in trouble with the FAA.

Donald Davis

Karl: Hang an inert drone from wires at 50 yards and test the FlightControl rounds...

Jeff Price

i was thinking 4 or 6 shot. but leaning toward 6, it carries further but still has enough pellets. But would be curious to try a range of sizes. If No 8 pellets do enough damage (have enough mass) then more pellets is better. Get a size big enough and no bigger soyou have as many pellets as possible and give yourself the best chance of getting hits.

Jeff Price

I am pretty sure you can shoot down your own 747 as long as you aren't endangering anyone... Sounds like you need a lawyer on this project.

Charles Easton

Come to the gun-phobic unfree UK - you can shoot down your drone if you wish. You just might have a lengthy process getting the shotgun in the first place.

Steelheart

Is the additional expense of tungsten worth it vs steel or even old-fashioned lead? I'm not disputing the higher energy and payload of 3" magnums. Plus Flite-Control (or equivalent) will greatly assist.

XM21Karl

Do you think 2 3/4 flight control 00 buck would work? I have to tell an army story. Once long ago they brought out an RC flying wing to give us some experience shooting at moving flying targets. Some of us were helping set up the range so they did a test run with us. I had an M14 while everyone else had M16's. On the first test run I put my M14 on auto and knew how much it would climb for each shot so I basically put up a wall for it to fly into which is what they were trying to teach us to do. I knocked it out on the first pass (more luck than anything). They had brought out extra wings but no extra engines because they didn't think anyone would ever hit the engine. Well that engine had a 7.62 size hole in it and there would be no more training for the rest of the troops that day.

Christian Allen

Hypothetically, if you shot down the drones and spent all the time filming it before you looked up the laws, that would be a super bummer. I also notice the drones are gone in the final shot. Bummer about the laws. Maybe some kind of mythbuster set up with a drone strapped to a crane? If it's not actively flying, is it a drone? Like, can you shoot it on the ground then see if it will still fly?

Bob

It appears we have no waterfowl hunters chiming in, so I'll add my 2 cents. I would wager that a Canada or Snow goose is a tougher ( i.e., more durable) target than probably any drone, and while 50 yards is bumping maximum ethical range, geese are regularly dropped with a "mere" shotgun all across the US every year at those ranges. And when I go after geese, I use a 3 1/2 inch 12 gauge for higher payload and loads/wads designed for longer distances. A turkey load may be equivalent, but I still carry a shotgun capable of handling 3 1/2 inch shells. As a side note, a shotgun is often used for coyotes (also I'd wager as tougher than a drone) using similar loads as you used in the video. At one time several companies were making coyote loads just for this purpose, with intended lethal ranges closer to 70 yards; unfortunately, I'm not sure if these are still produced. As look into an extra-full choke to extend the pattern. If you want to really rock your target, find some BB, BBB, or T-shot in 3 1/2. For maximum wallop and heavier load of shot, #4 shot, 3 1/2 inch with 2 or 2 1/4 ounces of shot turkey loads would be a good choice. Waterfowl loads are generally lighter for higher velocity, to limit the flight time error. I'll be interested in your video about red dots on aerial targets, as I learned to shoot a shotgun as an extension of my eye with both eyes open, and only relying on any form of sight as verification of proper mounting and alignment. You don't normally "aim" a shotgun, but rather "point" it where your eyes are looking (following and leading the target). Perhaps a red dot would seriously benefit someone not familiar with the mechanics of aerial shotgun shooting more? Very interesting, and I hope Ukraine can figure out how to use this to their advantage.

'General' Dipper

Anyone know what the restrictions would be if Karl came to the UK? Might be able to set something up at a farm, in Wales.

'General' Dipper

Given that drones are often hovering, and do not require a lot of impact energy to down, has anyone here tried a 40mm tube?

'General' Dipper

Made my post below before seeing yours. Find a farm and have someone who already has a license do the actual shooting?

Charles Easton

Well, quite. I've got my section 1 and section 2 so it goes to show they'll give them to most people with the space and patience 🙂

Brandon

If the idea is to test what damage (including spread affecting hits) on a drone 50 meters away, why can't you just set up a drone with no battery, facing perpendicular to the ground with its "belly" facing the shotgun? If even that is technically illegal, you could even pull out some circuitry so that it can be down at all, in which case I can't imagine it would legally count as a drone anymore. Then set it up at 50, shoot its underside, and see if the damage is enough to disable it, were it flying. It won't answer the question of what are the odds that you can actually hit a flying drone, but it would at least give an idea as to would work and what wouldn't.

Alex

There is an FAQ on FAA website: Q: Do the FAA rules and regulations apply to a commercial UAS or drone operations conducted indoors ONLY? A: No, Part 107 would not apply to operations conducted indoors. FAA rules and regulations apply to operations conducted outdoors in the National Airspace System (NAS). Theoretically, if the drone is indoors, you can shoot it. Should the shooter be indoors as well? It's a question. Maybe you could fly the drone in a garage and shoot it from outside.

commandZee

I'd be just as interested in watching you guys shoot trap or skeet with several combat semi-auto 12 gauges while wearing a full load out. Shooting at some tethered balloons might be a good analog for drones too.

BG

A low cost and definitely legal idea for testing effectiveness might be to buy a whole bunch of replacement propeller blades for your drones, set them up on some sort of holder, and shoot at and/or near them to see what kind of damage is sustained from different shot sizes. As you said all it takes is the loss of one prop to likely take down the drone. If the damage is questionable you could then install the prop(s) onto the drone and see if it will still fly. If it crashes on takeoff then you can probably conclude that the damage would have been fatal in flight. Hopefully such a crash wouldn't destroy the drone itself so you could continue to use it for multiple tests.

'General' Dipper

C&Rsenal have a series on trap hurling. Maybe team up with them? Seem like good people (I also Patreon them).