Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The National Firearms Act of 1934 is the prime example of gun control being ableist and classist. We discuss that and more in this video.Big thanks to the people who contributed their experiences to this video! If you'd like to see more of Gun Bunny, you can find her here: https://www.youtube.com/@LittleGunBunny

Files

Comments

Guido S

and such SHOULD NOT even exist to begin with. NOT in this hobby. --I know krl hates them but: 30m1 carbine. great for people with such issues if that length it ok to use. don't know why but I know people who do okish with a handgun but are horrible behind any longgun. one should think longguns easier but sometimes.. . vz61 skorpion comes to mind without regulations.

Guido S

latest example in germany: we have to have safes. ok. an a/b certified was standard when I got started entry prices like 300 in home improvement places. some "politician" screamed not safe enough. my 2nd one the need was a "0" certified now entry prices about 700. I chose both with keys. now for the joke: that class 0.. twice the money of the safe enough a/b... where do you store the 2nd key that comes with it? some jugde went "oh that's not safe..." now we "allowed" to buy thanks to that a sfe certified no less than the one with keys TO STORE 2nd KEY IN IT! --- that is how you rule out say less fortunate people from LEGAL ownership! and they wonder why people get illegal guns...

Guido S

btw NOBODY can tell me ammo prices now is "only" caused by inflation. can't be that is pushed from "upstairs", can it.

Reverend Charles

Someone ask Mr. Runkle if he knows a US law firm who would take such a case on behalf of IRTV patrons who were harmed by the NFA/GCA.

Ian F

It's been my position for a number of years that a reworking of the NFA is an opportunity for finding some sort of compromise in Federal gun regulations. I am not holding my breath it'll ever happen. The idea of fighting the NFA as an anti-disability case is interesting. It'll be a matter of finding a lawyer willing to take it on and a group with the resources to fund it.

Regulus

I have several NFA items and I'm also a lawyer, and the fact that I had to make a trust so that my wife and I can both bear the arms that we jointly and severally own illustrates the absurdity of the regulatory scheme. Right? We had to create a fictional person to facilitate our exercise of rights that we've had on paper since 1789.

Russell Middleton

The following might give an incite as to where some of the NFA/GCA ideas came from: "All the Way Down the Slippery Slope: Gun Prohibition in England and Some Lessons for Civil Liberties in America" — Olson and Kopel. "The Failed Experiment Gun Control and Public Safety in Canada, Australia, England and Wales" — Gary A. Mauser. And to further reduce firearms ownership there is Project Titanium.

Emily

Interesting angle & conversation! I must say I like it when you talk about firearms legislature, because as someone not living in the US and who probably will never go there, I have no clue about all this stuff. I'm sure someone will tell me to google it, but I don't feel that'd give me a comprehensive (and trustworthy!) view, plus I wouldn't get anyone sensible's thoughts on the matter. Please make more of this kind of stuff, Karl & friends! :)

Michael James Blum

In the early 1930s (just before the NFA) a full-auto Thompson cost $225 ... in the 1933 Sears catalog, a Browning Auto-5 costs $46.45; a Sears "Ranger" pump shotgun (actually a Stevens 520) is $26.98; a Sears "Ranger" double-barrel shotgun is $19.95. The Abercrombie and Fitch 1936 catalog (more up-market than Sears) has Remington "riot grade" pump shotguns (Model 31R) for $39.50; the Remington Model 11 self-loading shotgun (5 shot magazine) for $42.50; a Grtiffin & Howe magnum Mauser-style rifle in .375 H&H is $298.50; a Remington "Woodsmaster" Model 81 semi-auto rifle in .35 caliber is $64.50; a Winchester Model 54 in .30-06 or other "serious" calibers is $71.25 with a Lyman 48W receiver sight; a Colt Government Model pistol is $36.75 with one magazine; a Colt Pocket Hammerless in .380 or .32 ACP is $20.50 with one magazine; a Colt Police Positive revolver in calibers up to .38 Special is $27 (the "Banker's Special" with 2 inch barrel costs the same); the S&WE .38/44 "Heavy Duty Revolver" (ancestor of the .357 Magnum) is $37.50.

Christian Hedegaard-Schou

I've always felt that the best way to attack the NFA, from a legal perspective, would be through this argument and invoking the ADA.

jade

Using the goverment inflation calculator linked below $200 in june of 1934 was equal to $4,689.18 in june of 2024. That quite classist measure to stop regular people from SBR's, SBS & silencers. https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl

Danny Hanny

It would seem that a few of the people videoed would be able to fight the ATF with the Americans with Disabilities Act.

alphawhiskey

The summary at the end is really applicable to the adoption of the M1 carbine for general purpose, rear-echelon use. Lighter, higher capacity, with proficiency coming with less intensive training.

Dennis McNamara

perhaps not entirely on point, I have long said my favorite pistol is an M1 carbine. Of course, I'm a "guns should be wood and steel" kind of guy.

David T Klein

I have had hearing injury for over a decade. I was too close to someone firing a .30 calibre, and I didn't have hearing protection in. I hear a high pitch whine at all times, and I have loss of hearing acuity in certain ranges. I am fortunate, I had the family help (encouraging me, helping pay, not needing to work full-time) to go to college and get a degree that opened doors to a good career. To me, the 200$ to request a tax stamp to build or buy a sound-suppressor is not a serious impediment. But I am above-average means. I have a fraternity brother who is self-employed, for whom it absolutely makes a difference. The multi-month waiting period, on the other had, in a pain in a tender part of my anatomy. I have a form 5320.1 still outstanding since early November, to make a baffle-based sound-suppressor for my MP5k (I <3 my MP5k; the telescoping shoulder-stock, vertical front handle and drum sight make it incredibly accurate and consistent, and much easier than a pistol, or even a revolver). I have a form 5320.4 outstanding since February to receive a baffle-based sound-suppressor for my .223 rifle that I already purchased, and an outstanding form 5320.4 since last month for another wipes-based sound-suppressor for carry handguns that I already purchased. Having to send the handgun suppressors back to Gemtech to replace the wipes (since making replacement wipes at home counts as contraband) means multiple weeks during which my carry handgun (which rotates between a few different 380 automatics) is almost as loud as a 9mm or 38 Special. Having to wait many months to more effectively and adequately protect my hearing is absolutely frustrating. I wear high-end earplugs and earmuffs to the range. If I am ever forced to defend myself (there are unleashed/feral dogs as well as coyotes where I live), I have to assume I will be further deafened, and that is not exciting prospect. I get the point of the NFA and GCA, and for certain things (machine-guns, destructive devices, screwball AOWs), it makes a lot of sense. For things like short rifles, sawed-off shotguns and sound-suppressors, these laws do more harm than good, and I would like to see amended.