Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Stripper clip fed non detachable box magazine handguns were peak technology before World War I, and really went away after that in favor of detachable box magazine designs. KelTec has released a brand new stripper clip fed non detachable box magazine handgun, the PR57. Let's take a look at this unique design and why, or why not, returning to such an old concept may still have merit.

Files

KelTec PR57 - The Steyr-Hahn we have at home?

InRange is supported by viewers like you and every $1 helps! https://patreon.com/inrangetv Stripper clip fed non detachable box magazine handguns were peak technology before World War I, and really went away after that in favor of detachable box magazine designs. KelTec has released a brand new stripper clip fed non detachable box magazine handgun, the PR57. Let's take a look at this unique design and why, or why not, returning to such an old concept may still have merit.

Comments

Frank Leonard

Watched on YouTube, my question is this: have you tried simulating a malfunction, especially a double feed to see how challenging it is to clear? All guns jam in due time, and the stories coming out of shot show range day were not encouraging, so I'm interested to see your interpretation on that. For me, the lack of removable magazine represents a lack of simple and established malfunction remediation first and foremost, then unloading as you mentioned, with combat reloads as a very distant third concern.

Emily

I was kinda fascinated by this gun when I first saw it. My girlfriend sent me pictures of it, and my first reaction was "What in the actual fuck are you doing, KelTec? I thought this concept winked out of existence a hundred years ago!". Then I kinda forgot about it, assuming it wouldn't go anywhere once a sensible person looked it over, so I was surprised - pleasantly so - when I saw this video pop up in my inbox. I think I understand the point of it better now that I've watched this, so thank you for that. The main thing I'm wondering though (since my perception of the idea is that it's supposed to be as simple as possible so nothing can go wrong) is why they decided to go with that little plate for the barrel. It seems to me that a piece that's easy to lose goes a little counter to the concept of a simple gun? I might very well be missing something here though. I guess it could be a piece that gets a lot of wear on it, so it should be easy to replace? If anyone knows or has a better idea, please enlighten me; I'm here to learn :)

BSJ

Interesting. I'll have to research how my magazine restricted state views non-removable magazines...

Frank Leonard

Usually they exempt the gun from assault weapon definitions, but not from capacity restrictions. Keltec themselves maintains a list of states certain guns are legal in, and I don't believe this gun is legal in any capacity restricted states.

BSJ

As written the VT law restrict "feeding devices" in excess of 15 rounds for pistols... 10 round stripper clips would appear to be the "feeding device" in my opinion...

Guido S

last one I remember was that 90s grendel p... something. aweful look and shape. hey why not. the steyr is an awesome handgun so good gens so to speak. they should get some credit only because they dare to bring it. I wouldn't mind a, usable, DAO trigger at all. the cycling out of the ammo in the mag though... that is an issue. they should have copycat the button of the steyr there! not thrilled about the caliber. 7,62tok maybe. if doing something unique why not going with a commieblock round. better than 5.7 in my book.

Guido S

the weight is WHAT?! damn that is light! I like kel tec and their ideas.

Frank Leonard

It specifically lists "a magazine" and does not specify detachable or fixed, which means any.

Frank Leonard

" As used in this section, “large capacity ammunition feeding device” means a magazine, belt, drum, feed strip, or similar device that has a capacity of, or that can be readily restored or converted to accept: (A) more than 10 rounds of ammunition for a long gun; or (B) more than 15 rounds of ammunition for a hand gun. (2) The term “large capacity ammunition feeding device” shall not include: (A) an attached tubular device designed to accept, and capable of operating only with, .22 caliber rimfire ammunition; (B) a large capacity ammunition feeding device that is manufactured or sold solely for use by a lever action or bolt action long gun or by an antique firearm as defined in subdivisions 4017(d)(2)(A) and (B) of this title; or (C) a large capacity ammunition feeding device that is manufactured or sold solely for use with a firearm that is determined to be a curio or relic by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives. As used in this subdivision, “curio or relic” means a firearm that is of special interest to collectors by reason of some quality other than its association with firearms intended for sporting use or as offensive or defensive weapons."

mclstr

I love 5.7 and have two guns chambered in 5.7. I'd be tempted to get one. Maybe some day.

Hunter Olsen

I may be the only person to want this gun in a different caliber, but I think that .30 SC would be a great option for this gun. I must admit I've only ever held it in a gun shop, but the Five-seveN had such a long grip that it didn't really feel comfortable, and a shorter round and thus shorter grip, that has the same relative diameter would be nice.

Matteo Manino

KelTec is the only gun manufacturer to be consistently different. I love them. This one has even some practical utility.

Ted Swinford

It is the sort of gun one might find in a vending machine in an alternate universe, that is..., nearly disposable. IMO this is not a beginners pistol and the main reason is the unloading process.

Bruce Brodnax

I've said it since it was 1st announced, and I'll stick to my guns [pun intended! 😁]: If KT had made it in a 10rd version w/ a self-ejecting enbloc clip a la' the M1 Garand, they'd have managed a neat end-run around various gun bans w/ focus on mags of more than 10rd, and detachable magazines. And it would still be a faster reload than a mag-swapping gun, just no "tactical reloads." As it is, the usual suspects already have statutes in place for >10rd capacity, so no sales in those states right from the start. As a backup gun it may have utility, since small and large standard capacity; when you run out just do a New York reload. But you won't be doing it in New York [or CA, MA, CT, NJ, etc.]

InRange TV

It's not great. You can lock the slide back at any time and at that point you need to push down on the cartridge in the magazine and extract the one in the chamber with ...something. Or, perhaps, drop the slide over the depressed cartridge and cycle it manually to hopefully remove the one in the chamber. It's definitely worse than clearing a gun with a detachable magazine.

Frank Leonard

The Grendel P-10 was a 380 fixed magazine pistol, yes.

Dirtbaggin

Can't wait for a mud test on this one.