Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The "battle" of Wounded Knee was not a battle. The US military was ordered to disarm the Lakota, While in the act of this gun confiscation, horrible events ensued that still resonate to this day. This video is a modified republication of a previous one published 4 years ago, but given current events, it is more relevant than ever in this slightly modified form.

The Medals of Honor issued for this horrific event were, imo, used to assuage guilt and horror over the realization of what had been done. As a result, these MoHs tarnish the legitimate recipients of that award, many of whom did amazing things to save the lives of people other than themselves.American Memory Project music video courtesy of: Vocals by Ogre and Mark Walk. Written by William Morrison. All percussion and production by Justin Bennett.

Files

The "Battle" of Wounded Knee

InRange is supported by viewers like you and every $1 helps! https://patreon.com/inrangetv The "battle" of Wounded Knee was not a battle. The US military was ordered to disarm the Lakota, While in the act of this gun confiscation, horrible events ensued that still resonate to this day. This video is a modified republication of a previous one published 4 years ago, but given current events, it is more relevant than ever in this slightly modified form. The Medals of Honor issued for this horrific event were, imo, used to assuage guilt and horror over the realization of what had been done. As a result, these MoHs tarnish the legitimate recipients of that award, many of whom did amazing things to save the lives of people other than themselves. American Memory Project music video courtesy of: Vocals by Ogre and Mark Walk. Written by William Morrison. All percussion and production by Justin Bennett.

Comments

'General' Dipper

I have zero issues with serving US cavalry. But I always find it weird that so many civilians still mythologise Big Horn and Wounded Knee. Even some officers at the time lamented the US policy, but it seems to have come down to the US culture war trenchlines. I look forward to catching the video later when I have more time to do it justice.

Tony Amaro

This is not that heavy of a statement, but one of my favorite movie lines is from Platoon when Charlie Sheene said he "volunteered" because he didn't feel it was fair for all the poor kids to fight that war or something to that effect. The other guy responded that " you have to be rich in the first place to think like that", your alright he then said. To look at this terrible event in a vacuum does not tell the whole story. It was a different time with many people that had memories of direct combat, murders,massacres etc. There were many traditions that we would consider horrible today on both sides with groups shoving their way into territories to survive. This happened Euro vs Indian, Indian vs Indian, Euro vs Euro. If there was no warfare, there would be no peace pipe.

InRange TV

The Medals of Honor issued for this horrific event were, imo, used to assuage guilt and horror over the realization of what had been done. As a result, these MoHs tarnish the legitimate recipients of that award, many of whom did amazing things to save the lives of people other than themselves.

Jason

Thank you Karl for republishing this video.

BeAuMaN

So Karl, I agree that Wounded Knee was a massacre, and I think it's good to use recent events to highlight one of the many horrific acts that the US Government has committed. However, the recent event was the review to attempt to revoke these MoHs more than a 100 years later by the previous administration, and then the current administration ending that review. Do you think attempting to revoke the MoHs of individual soldiers more than a 100 years later is the right tack? Mainly my first thought is: What is the limiting principle for revoking MoHs? Is it that the MoH occurred in a rather horrific US Military Action? Because we have a lot of those, and I'd also hate for this to become yet another political football. My second thought is: Setting aside that the standards for awarding medals afaik has changed a lot through history, are we really remediating these horrific events by going after individual awards? I mean, looking at the wiki... is the issue that "John E. Clancy", an Army Musician, received a MoH during the massacre for "Twice voluntarily rescusing wounded comrades under fire of the enemy"? Or is the issue that the US Government had such policies and stances against the Native Americans in the first place? (Granted, Clancy is the least offensive one I could probably pick, but I figured it would be illustrative of the perils of going down that road). I'm also not going to pretend to be an expert in this area of history, and I know based off your wonderful vignettes that you're more well read on that. I always appreciate your opinions, and I hope you can see where I'm come from.

InRange TV

Yes, I do think they should be revoked. This history needs to be addressed to assuage it's impact. Not addressing it is to perpetuate the guilt into the future.