Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Old West Vignettes - Yay or Nay?

  • Old West Vignettes - YES, more please! 446
  • Old West Vignettes - Nah, don't bother. 0
  • Old West Vignetters - Not for me but I don't mind if they're put of the content once in awhile. 70
  • 2026-03-20
  • 516 votes
{'title': 'Old West Vignettes - Yay or Nay?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Old West Vignettes - YES, more please!', 'votes': 446}, {'text': "Old West Vignettes - Nah, don't bother.", 'votes': 0}, {'text': "Old West Vignetters - Not for me but I don't mind if they're put of the content once in awhile.", 'votes': 70}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 3, 20, 21, 15, 37, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 516}

Content

Hello everyone!I can't use Youtube analytics to judge anything in regards to the content that applies to the core audience - y'all here that keep this channel alive.I just published a new OWV, discussing the historicity of "Boothill" cemetery in Tombstone - and the views on YouTube are pretty dismal when compared to the normal firearm related content.That said, history and OWVs have been part of InRange the whole time - so I'm asking the core audience here, the people who matter, how you feel about it via this poll.I appreciate your support and your time, and thank you, of course!~Karl

Comments

George R. O'Connor

Perfect opportunity to debunk and educate. I'm all for them!

BG

I wouldn’t want the entire channel to be old west vignettes but I like them and think you should keep em coming

Robert Glinka

YouTube actually recommended the video to me before I saw the email notification (I wasn't even in the subscription tab), so apparently my Youtubes are curated properly.

Alex

I like them a lot!

Sean Smith

I think they are great, and the fact that the garbage promotion system of YouTube doesn't help speaks volumes to its lackluster nature. I further believe that the "views are lower than normal" is just bullshit pumped out by Alphabet trying to force you into purchasing more viewer base as well as advertisement

Thomas Kinsey

I catch myself saving these for later (which sometimes is a long time) when I can focus on them, because they're not junk food and I want to properly enjoy them. Maybe others do too.

BSJ

Not the same without Ian's janky camera work. 😆 But I really like 'em!

AlunB

I certainly enjoy them!

Flabby

IMHO, next to your progressive/equality views, OWVs are the main thing that sets you apart from all the other guns & history channels. More please!

JB Robak

I like them a lot. It's not a topic I would go out of my way to research myself so it's nice to get them in my subscription feed.

Patrick of Tucson

All your videos that deal with history are a big part of why I support the channel.

Nicholas White

The history content is always on point, and often a good commentary on current events. Good does not always mean popular unfortunately... but this is a youtube issue and not reflective of the quality of your content. If you enjoy making them, and it makes enough financial sense to not stop, we will absolutely keep enjoying them.

Twotoedbob

Love em I just havent had a chance to watch the latest yet 🙃

Joshua Kerner

I've been a Patreon member since almost the very beginning. Old West Vignettes, to me, are a core reason why I have supported the channel, why I support it, and why I want to continue to support it. They are some of my favorite pieces of content you put out.

Andrew

I watch em. If you love making them, keep posting and I’ll keep watching.

Hunter

This is the year my queer friend group is getting into lever guns, revolvers, historical costuming, leatherwork... Your channel is a safe space where we don't have to worry about a guntuber praising Charlie Kirk or the NRA while discussing history. I say this as a graduate-level trained historian who knows the conservatism in this field.

Emily

Your historical content is always top-tier, so please keep it coming! :D Speaking of, I'd be very interested in hearing the follow-up on that KKK book when you've got the time :)

Austin Lopez

Old West Vignettes was always one of my favorite series from this channel, I’d love to see a resurgence of them, personally.

Martin Moser

I love when you visit those places I never knew existed like the cemetery or the stage coach depot. The stories really humanize locations.

SU37YELLOW

I always enjoy the Old West Vignettes. Its a welcome change of pace and I appreciate that they're almost always something that more people should know about but it got buried/erased

Nick Beckwith

I like the Old West Vignettes but didn't find the title of that one compelling enough to watch, very possibly a mistake on my part. I inferred that it was going to say that Boot Hill was sort of mythological and a tourist trap, which unfortunately as you have made clear is the ultimate dog bites man story in the tourist trap elements of Tombstone.

Neil

The Old West content is my favourite content you do.

Mike Goldman

#1 - You should wear the Skinny Puppy hat more (i have been a fan since 90, they were the first concert I ever attended in NOLA 1992). #2 - The vignettes are really not my thing, BUT, you should please keep doing these. This type of content, the whole "not whitewashing history" is just as important as your 2A content and your other assorted content. Not my thing, but I am very happy that you are doing it. Please keep doing what you are doing. If you need more help getting it done, keep letting us know.

Hobie

I'd seen it

Julian Corbett

As someone who lives the other side of the world and is very unlikely to ever get to see the places made famous by the old Westerns. I love the "Old West Vignettes". Not least because you research them properly and 'bust' all the random myths that have grown up around these places. I also appreciate that you 'correct' official versions of events that don't reflect so well on the relationships between the settlers, army and indigenous peoples, such as Wounded Knee.

Jesus

I watch them, just usually later in the week when i have more time and capacity to really learn something.

GruntyGinMan

I watch them when I can. I frequently have YT playing at work, and alas my work network rules seem to default YT to restricted mode so sometimes I miss stuff. But I really enjoy them.

Evan Jones

I'll usually get around to them eventually, which I don't really understand myself, they're more relevant to my life than most firearms content and you tell a heck of a story.

TheOlsonOutfit

I appreciate the old west vignettes very much

Dan

I haven’t watched the latest one, kinda have to be in the Wild West mood, but it’s great content.

Lee Reynolds

Same. I really enjoy, so put on my watch later queue

Randy Reid

We get too much sanitized history, thanks for telling the real story, love both the gun related content and the western historical content

Jesse Reda

I like them a lot and they are a nice break from straight firearms content. Would a second channel dedicated to them (and really other any historical vignette you want to put out there) versus them sprinkled into main channel perhaps do better in the YouTube world and appeal to more? Either way my vote is yes please.

Rarewave

The Old West Vignettes consistently deliver a story that I simply never would have found otherwise. I genuinely love all of your social commentary. I don't have any advice on what the ratio should be for this stuff versus GUNS. Clearly you need to trash talk more optics while shooting 300BLK into the dirt off screen. (That was a joke) Make the content that is true to your vision. We'll be here.

Gary A

Haven’t seen this one but I’ll go check it out!

Jeff

They are interesting, and I generally watch them. But they are not my driving interest in InRange content.

David Adams

I'm here for the history and the guns. Hell yeah! Keep em coming!

Jason

Please continue the OWV and other historical content. They are what make InRange unique.

Christian Allen

I really enjoy the Old West content in the context of guns and history. IMHO that is where InRange content shines (alongside crushing the dreams of gimmiky guns and accessories).

Kilian Ortmann

They are not traditional gun content, so they'll probably never get anywhere close to the same attention in YouTube. They are however my favorite content of yours, they are interesting, off the beaten path, very nuanced and well researched and show a window to the past as it was and not embellished.

Nerdherder0420

I generally enjoy your Old West Vignettes but generally find them an annoying focus on a very problematic America. I'm glad you usually place the time historically.

Chad Merritt

Love it. Not much like it elsewhere and a great place to start our own research. When you posted it today I immediately watched it.

Michael Llaneza

The third option understates where I am sitting, keep 'em coming!

Riley Wilson

I'm a fan of the Old West Vignettes but I also understand how resource intensive proper historical research is. Please do them whenever you feel Karl, that works for me.

TpzBlau

I like the tangents Karl, you often present information that contradicts the narratives the normal history we usually get of these places, its information that me an East coaster would never get a chance to delve into hands on like you can. I understand if you need to tone them back but don't do away with them.

Bedfordtec

Great stuff Karl, Jim Schindler LTCL USMC Ret

Jordan Walsh

I like the Old West Vignettes, but by their very nature, they cover a lot of different topics because any time period contains infinite stories to explore. For example, the specific history of Boot Hill is not of particular interest to me, but the general idea of an in-depth look back at the mythologized past is of interest to me. I know the YouTube landscape changed a lot between the videos, but I think the fact that an OWV is the number 2 all time video on the channel, and an OWV is in the bottom 5%, kind of shows that subject may have more impact than genre. For an anecdotal perspective, I probably would have clicked on a video titled "A Fake Boot Hill? - Historical Fabrication in Service of Entertainment" or something like that, which would indicate a broader exploration of the topic, rather than a focus on a very specific investigation of one historical misrepresentation. I'll watch the new OWV tomorrow, and I'll leave any specific commentary on the video.

Eric Sammywaifu

I find them very interesting. The one about the potential trans woman was sad but just goes to show that "trans" isnt some new woke phenomenon.

James Faine

I absolutely love them. Some of my favorite content on the channel, but I am a hard core history nerd. I know its not everyone's thing but I very much appreciate it. Would it be helpful/appropriate to spin them off into their own channel perhaps? A history focused channel might pull in folks not interested in the gun stuff and gun only folks don't feel like they need to sit through a history class.

Tomek Jankowski

You love lever actions and period guns so the vignettes are a natural extension. As for me, I always enjoy learning something new, especially when it's well-researched.

A

I don’t watch every one that comes out but I do like them.

-Kris-

I love the Old West content, I just watch it on here rather than Youtube

Niel Greeff

For someone not from the USA the old west content are very interesting as we only know it from film and novels

Dan Pritts

I watch about one in Three of the old west things. If they make you happy go for it.

'General' Dipper

I'll just speak for me, not anyone else. Three main factors in not watching it already, although I am watching it now because I do actually enjoy them. Detail, integrity, insight, all your thing. 1) Americana is a lot less fun right now. I can't escape into it because it just reminds me of current events. Maybe if you leaned into that up front it would feel less dissonant. I mean you do actually do this in the video with the bit about the KKK. 2) Linked to the first, I am not motivated to watch anyone talking about common Old West stuff. Whereas if you posted something about the (I'm making this up) Four Man Siege at Crowsbeak Pass then I'd be all over it. I know this won't make viral content, but Youtube is standing on the hose anyway. 3) I am editing a story set in interwar Shanghai. So it just wasn't main axis this week.

Matteo Manino

I like youre POV/take on old west a lot, I like history in general, and the variety of topic is a huge part of the channel's charm. If I have to find a negative, at the moment, in this particular place in history, some are too related to current topics to feel like rest/a breack from reality and not enought to feel "immediately" usefull (as silly as such a descripion can be for historical content).

Ryan C.S.

I wouldn't go so far as to say "Not for me" as that poll choice says, but I do not mind them and I end up watching most of them.

Guido S

absolutely rather more than less.

Nonya Bidness

I mean, I basically love all things InRange and your approach is the whole reason I support this channel in the first place. Yes to all of the things wasnt an option though haha.

Tony Amaro

I find them very interesting especially now. I’m in the midst of a western/ Civil War binge. Thanks, of course I would like to say that if you yourself are interested in that content to share, then do it. Don’t let it become just a job. MHO.

Daniel Sturm

I don't watch every one, and I am definitely not the target audience. But I love the variety and the channel following your interests makes it different and refreshing instead of just another "new gun" review/competition channel. I hope you keep making them, even if I only watch half.

Ben

I've voted yes and it's normally pretty interesting content, however I suspect that even without the algorithm getting involved it's probably not going to be super-popular. Probably a good idea to keep doing it but figure out a way to do it simply and cheaply (eg. not taking special trips just to film - film where you're already going), so it's not a massive outlay for a niche type of content compared to your other stuff.

Austin Lutzke

I'm not really the target audience for the old west stuff but I still enjoy it and often learn something new. Keep making what you like to make

Teddy

I came for the match footage and stayed because the OWV showed that you had a variety-show of content, both on guns themselves as well as the reality of how they affected human history... And not in the sanitized Network TV way.

Bruce Brodnax

If an OWV isn't for me, I don't watch it. Same as some of the match footage. Or anything else you produce. It happens occasionally, but still far from frequently enough to cause me to reconsider my support here on Patreon. A diverse array of content just means you'll attract a broader audience, which will hopefully assure your channel's continued success.

Ryan Thorne

I’m still waiting for the Porter Rockwell OWV you teased years ago