Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

44WCF (44-40) was an amazing design and cartridge...for its time. Unless you're hellbent on blackpowder shooting, however, it's totally irrelevant today.

Files

You Don't Want 44-40

InRange is supported by viewers like you and every $1 helps! https://patreon.com/inrangetv 44WCF (44-40) was an amazing design and cartridge...for its time. Unless you're hellbent on blackpowder shooting, however, it's totally irrelevant today.

Comments

Frederick Bieling

I jumped into it without thinking, just wanted a cowboy gun so I traded a perfectly serviceable Ruger sp101 for a Vaquero in 44-40 . What a challenging round to reload! Super thin brass at the neck. I eventually snagged a 44 mag cylinder and it dropped in with no issues and I stick to 44 special loads.

Hobie

Thanks. I just watched Capandball reloading 44WCF and he made it look easy.

Guido S

1 round or 100 or 1000? just saying.

Guido S

357/38 strictly because of cost. I would LOVE to have everything in 45colt but in europe that is an expensive caliber. even with reloading. great caliber though. I'd like to shoot 44-40 if some fairy would provide the ammo...

A A C

Good information . Well presented , thanks Karl

Jason

Thanks Karl! This is the best explanation of the 44-40 issues I've heard yet.

InRange TV

What about it? It's fine. Also a straight wall cartridge, however, so not optimal for blackpowder.

Hobie

His brass was pretty old, so a lot. He also makes his own paper and rolled brass sheet (using cut up aluminum beer cans) for various black powder breech loaders, so I'd say he's worked out most of the kinks. He has a free Patreon channel with some really interesting videos.

Tony Amaro

Puzzling, I just watched a vid where the pretty experienced fellow was reloading 44-40 blackpowder cases that had been reloaded dozens of times according to him. Guess I'll find out, just bought an old Navy Arms US made Henry in 44-40 and am on round 1 of the rounds I loaded, only BP so far. I'm more concerned right now with managing fouling than case life .

Tony Amaro

You can reload it many times as he showed but I do believe Karl’s points are valid. Right now it doesn’t really matter as much. 44-40 brass is plentiful, more expensive but anything but prohibitive. A lot of times like in my case we buy the gun for the deal it is as long as we can work with the cartridge and there is nostalgia. 44-40 I think is fine and anyone can make it work. I’ve had zero issues so far so moving on. I think he stirred up a bit with the premise not so much what he said.

Tony Amaro

It is as easy as Balaz presented it. 30 grains Swiss BP with a Lyman. I am not yet sold on his lube but I will try it once I can find the Lyman mold. So far my Lee 200 grain mold experience has not been the greatest. Not bashing the Lee yet for I have much more testing to do. I buy the rifle, you can make any cartridge just about work well if you put the work in.