Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 695842561.mp4

Downloads

Content

Let's discuss these M1 myths that JUST WON'T DIE. Two of them are really training issues.

Files

Comments

William Brooks

I always thought the "Ping" was hilarious, as no one used any kind of ear protection, so how could anyone hear that one little sound out on a battlefield?

Sean Smith

I thought I was going to be a cool dude, and I took my Garand to an Appleseed to try and get a super fancy Rifleman patch. It didn't happen. That rifle beat the wheels off my shoulder, and it was 100% a training issue. I did not properly shoulder the rifle at all during the seated and prone portions, and after a day and a couple hundred rounds, I was done. I didn't go back for the second day.

Hobie

If you could have device that would simulate the ping...

SDKI

m1 recoil? I guess nobody has shot a 91/30. I always though the recoil was enjoyable compared to similar sized cartridges

Ted Swinford

If it was a "thing" then I suppose one could keep an empty clip to throw down as a trick. ...

InRange TV

It wouldn't really matter even if you did hear it. There's a guy next to you with a loaded gun and even if there isn't, a reload is 2 seconds.

Nuke Road Warrior

Yeah, in all likely-hood you're in a fire fight with your buddies shooting and enemy soldiers shooting back at you. No one is using ear pro. Really loud bangs going off all around more or less continuously. An enemy listening for a ping he is unlikely to hear to time a "banzai charge" is the least of his concerns.

Jorgio

Thanks, Karl. Happy to see more garand videos if a good topic comes along. Maybe an updated video on ammo selection for accuracy as well as rifle pressure tolerance, since there is less surplus and garand-loaded ammo on the market, and a lot of myth.

Jason

Ah! M1 mythology! It never dies. Unfortunately. Yeah, press that sucker against your shoulder. Applies to any firearm. More so if it's a full-power cartridge.

Jason

More so if your target is 100 yards away. Yep! That's audible. Not!

N8R

I remember hearing an old WWII story on some TV doc years ago, where US troops would shoot 5 times and the enemy assuming they were reloading would move positions. Only to get got with the last three rounds.

Christian Øelund

I am the owner of the thumb that is pictured, during the section about the Garand Thumb. I must admit that I chuckled when I saw my picture being used. (I gave myself an M1 thumb on purpose, to catch it on high-speed camera... did it three times, and my nail fell off a couple of days later..) I would say that the highest probability of getting Garand Thumbed is when you inspect the rifle. To do it properly you should pull the bolt all the way back firmly so that it catches on to the bolt catch. From this position the bolt can only release if you push down on the follower AND apply backward pressure on the bolt handle (with the back of your hand exactly like shown in the video) so you will have control over the bolt at all time. The problem is that if you don't pull the bolt backward firmly enough, it will just rest on the follower, and as soon as you touch the follower the bolt will slam forward whether or not you have control over the bolt.

Upstate Scout

I can’t help but wonder if the original thumb position wasn’t a hold over from stripper clip loading like used with the 1903 Springfield.

Tony Amaro

The ping is quite loud and can be heard for many yards. Do not think it was a thing in many battles but in CQB fights it is highly plausible and even mentioned by at least one veteran who described clanging and empty clip to draw out the enemy. Not sure why it is so eagerly debunked. The first was Bloke on the Range, my guess is people tend repeat what they hear all the more if it is someone trusted .

Coty Coyote

The early method of loading works but the key is to put your thumb on the shoulder of the topmost cartridge rather than down on the case body. I suppose it might slip if your hands are wet or something, but as long as you hold pressure on the shoulder of the cartridge the bolt can not close. It's how I've always loaded my M1 and it hasn't bit me yet.

Bruce Brodnax

Entirely nonsense: the ping is only audible to the shooter due to bone conduction, it lets the firer know that it is time to reload before they even waste a second pulling the trigger to find it dead and the action locked open. As Karl correctly states, it is irrelevant since you're part of a fire team and while you're busy fishing out another clip from your belt and reloading, someone else on your team is firing and keeping the enemies' heads down while the other team you're supporting is maneuvering and when *they* light'em up, it's your turn to maneuver. All thoroughly covered as official doctrine in boot camp. If an enemy was close enough to hear that PING! when you ran out of ammo, you should already have affixed bayonets in preparation for CQB anyway...

Bruce Brodnax

Certainly more sustainable than the recoil of the M1903 Springer; there is a noticeable difference, ask anyone who has fired both...

Bruce Brodnax

Everyone kept a spare empty enbloc, since the rifle is practically unusable w/o one. With an empty clip, you could always filch the tracers the MG crews pulled out of their belts (so as not to give away their positions) and use that in a pinch. [Also used in night fighting, when forward positions would fire on a target they wanted heavy ordnance to find: two guys some distance from each other on the line would fire their clip of tracers at the same target at the same time, the forward observer would mark it on his map, and call in fire support if the MG crews couldn't satisfactorily suppress it. Per my dad, USMC during KW. One of his very rare expositions on his experiences therein.] But yeah, you always kept a spare empty, just in case you were reduced to scrounging loose ammo from other sources. [Possible example: the BAR man gets a bad mag that jams in the middle of a firefight, chucks it, reloads and moves. Meanwhile, you've run out, so you grab the half-filled mag, shuck out the rounds and even if there's less than 8, at least you can have *something* in your rifle: just drop in the empty clip, and load rounds singly from the top until all 3, 4, 5, 6? are in the clip and close the action. Hey presto, you can at least defend yourself until you can get a fresh bandolier of clipped ammo!]

Bruce Brodnax

Probably only worked if you kept a slow cadence for the first 5, so they'd think you were manipulating a bolt-action like theirs...

Bruce Brodnax

My dad said virtually the same thing, that M1 Thumb was experienced mostly during inspection, and he had never experienced it during action.

Tony Amaro

If we are talking 100 yards, I would not bet against you. Problem is that combat could be as little as a few yards and it happened on a vast scale at close range in WW2 with that many millions killed. Even today we can see so much combat in Ukraine measured in feet let alone yards, same thing was demonstrated in the Syrian Civil War. In desperate fights, people will use any trick they can think of or were taught, they will take that chance. Sometimes it works, sometimes you meet your.

Bruce Brodnax

Who is John Galt^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H, er, Cormac McCarthy?