Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello everyone!I hope you already intrinsically know and understand not only how much I appreciate you all, but how important you all are to keeping this truly alternative voice alive in this very hostile space. I was quite happy to see the positive response to the recent Patreon only exclusive content, "Apocalypse Reloading", and I will be putting together quite a bit more Patreon only such work soon. I have been hamstrung by YouTube policies for years and, as long as there are people here who can support the project and want that sort of stuff, I would love to provide it. So, in that regard, expect a lot more of that to come.I do have a question, however. The recent republication of The Opium Wars video has done horribly, and it didn't do well the first time I published it either. In my opinion, that video and content is peak InRange, at least in regards to what I care about. Clearly it is not what a lot of the audience cares about, or at least not the public audience at large. I'd love to hear from y'all about what it is about videos like The Opium Wars, and for that matter, other historical and sociologically conscious content, that just tends to "flop" in regards to views. Is this something I should just generally scrap? The dichotomy of this, is that these videos get almost no attention, but also all the comments are wildly positive. It's a very interesting conflict to experience as the content creator.Anyways, thank you again, and I look forward to hearing your thoughts.~Karl

Comments

Kyle Desseau

For what it's worth, I love those kinds of videos.

Michael Llaneza

I have already started putting together a list of where I need to share that Opium Wars video. I have a deck I'm working on about commerce warfare up to WW1, and adding addiction as a weapon to hunger as a weapon will be a nice touch I think.

Warlock Engineer

In my mind, one of the reasons to support you on Patreon is so that video content isn't strictly dependent on the view count on YouTube. There are a lot of important and under discussed topics that InRange is willing to cover, and I appreciate that a lot. The size of audience that sees a video is so dependent on the algorithm that I don't think "success" is something that can be determined by view count alone.

Jim Jam Shimmy Shatts

I don't want to see the historical or socially conscious content leave. I love that as much as the weird firearms stuff you do. I do get around to watching everything, but it's not always going to be the day, or week it launches. Make the content you want to make

Bill Field

I've been meaning to get to it because I have some familiarity with The Opium Wars (and their impact on Chinese policy to this day) and am looking forward to your take.

InRange TV

Fair, and that's why I'm doing exclusives and such - I just don't understand the lack of engagement.

Jennifer

I wonder if you could keep them on Patreon? I love those kind of videos as well, and would hate to see them go.

WFL / Pain Propaganda

I ended up watching it (and liked it), but I will note that I do occasionally skip some InRange pieces if it doesn't sound super interesting to me and I've got a lot of other content in the queue. Sometimes I'll come back and watch it later when I have time, but otherwise I tend to have a very tight window of time to actively watch stuff.. Some content I'll "passively" watch while doing things (working on art or making my patches and shit), but it's gotta come up when I'm about to do it otherwise I may miss it (I have a lot of podcasters I follow too on YT & more).

Jobbe Smit

I'm gonna be honest, I don't watch all your videos. I fund this because I believe your voice is one worth being out there.

Warlock Engineer

I hit enter too early, just added more to that comment. But yeah, engagement on even the highest quality of videos will struggle if the forces of YouTube aren't pushing it. I think InRange has a fanbase that is split between gun people and history people, and I know that's an oversimplification, but I do think a portion of the audience will click to see a weird gun but don't bite the hook for the historical content

InRange TV

Maybe this one, at a run time of over 30 minutes, is just too long?

Kir-Sheng Chen

I actually became a Patreon supporter specifically because of that Opium Wars video. I think contextualizing historical firearms is important and better than the "rah rah rah USA" content you usually see in the firearm space.

JB Robak

I am very interested in these type of videos. My problem is a personal / mental one. I see a 30min + video or a video I want to give direct attention to and say "I'll watch that later when I got time" and that turns into watching it over a week later.

J

Same. I appreciate the videos a lot, but bc regular Youtube mobile doesn't allow me to just listen on the side I can't just tune in when my hands are full with work

Eric Sammywaifu

Hard to say for me. I watched the video the first time and again the second time cause I had forgotten the full story. Wish it was more successful.

Jay Loy

I found the opium wars video tremendously interesting the first time it was posted, and I watched it a second time as well. I agree that it’s emblematic of your content which makes the low engagement really difficult to understand. Part of me wonders if the specific subject matter is the issue. The opium wars are rarely talked about in American circles outside of true history nerds, I find few people engage with that history. I wonder if it has to do with a largely American audience generally not engaging with stories from conflicts where the US is not an active player.

WFL / Pain Propaganda

For some folks, possibly. I do know the 30m+ stuff I usually save for when I'm working on patches or something just because that's usually a 45m stretch where I'm just doing some generally non-mentally-engaging physical stuff and like having that sorta thing going on to get my mind going.

M.S. Patterson

I was going to say something very similar! I support InRange via Patreon so that Karl can pursue his vision and make stuff that he thinks has value. It may or may not reach a big audience, but that is somewhat secondary.

Christopher Eng

Only speaking for myself but what drew me to your Patreon was the historical piece on Japanese internment. There are lots of content providers in the 2A space but what sets you apart are the historical pieces that give more context to what we are seeing today. Like others have said, I look forward to having the time to see the Opium war piece and hope you continue to post those informative videos. Edit - I just upped my membership level. Thank you for the good honest content.

alex

I think something to consider here is that not every view is of equal value. I've seen loads of your videos about various niche firearms that are fun and interesting to watch, but don't nessecarily *stick* with me. Meanwhile, I think about your video about the Danziger Bridge incident quite frequently, and it's made me view the world in a different way, especially when I go to visit New Orleans. It's also a topic that I've discussed with others in my life, meaning your work made an impact on 4-5 people while only showing *1* view on YouTube. One of the things I've always most respected about you as a ~content creator~ is that you make videos about stuff that YOU want to make videos about, and not just what's flashy and trendy and will get lots of views. Personally, I think you should focus less determining if a video is worth your time by how many views it gets, and more on if you found it fulfilling to create. It's not the particular content that got you the audience that you have, it was the mentality you have in not letting others dictate what you make in the first place.

Lefty

I personally like that video and that type of topic. The "interview"/discussion aspect may be what turns people off though. I personally follow some channels where even though I will watch nearly everything they do, I will skip an interview/discussion/live video altogether if I can tell that is what it is in the thumbnail/description or I will skip the portion of the video that consists of the interview. I just don't enjoy that sort of thing with regard to certain topics. But please note, this is not the case for every channel I watch (InRange and history channels I watch through completely because that is my interest) and my opinion reflects me and not the viewers as a whole. Just offering a possible reason based on personal experience.

nirename

Echoing some other comments here, gun and shooting content can require less energy to watch than documentary content. Your documentary content is awesome and contains information new to many, so it's no surprise that viewers like it...if they're mentally ready to view it.

InRange TV

Absolutely true. It's just disappointing to see someone who is ranting at the screen in his truck get 100k views, and this to get 10% of that. 😂

Rusty Gulley

YT might have buried that video in its algorithm because of drug reference. AI can’t tell the difference between horrific colonialism and the illegal drug trade….Wait a minute. 🧐

EstherThePester

For me, Opium Wars didn’t immediately grab me but it is saved in my watch later playlist. This post that you just made makes me want to watch it immediately because you conveyed how passionate you are about it and you stated that it is squarely in the middle of your creative lane by saying it’s “peak InRange.” So that makes me wonder if some sort of informational or hype post is a good idea to pave the way and generate excitement for the video. Rather than just upload, maybe you could do a post like this ahead of time talking about how excited and proud you are of the work. Then people like me would look out for it. Because for me, although the topic isn’t immediately in my zone of interest, the fact that you care about it makes me want to watch out of curiosity. And if you did already make a post like that, I am sorry that I missed it. Hope that helps a little!

Matthew Sheridan

Yes keep doing those videos. It is very important to keep in mind not all view points are taught in history. We must remember the good the bad and ugly of history. I tend to lean conservative camp but I realize if we need to remember that other view points are nessary so both sides can go forward. What worries me is that both the left and the right will not listen to each other, and that is a great shame, for we can and must learn from each other.

K B

I’ve seen the original version maybe twice and so I didn’t really watch the reupload all the way. I stayed a minute or two after the intro. I do really enjoy the historical content and the long form videos which this was.

Emily

I *love* the historical stuff, but I suppose that a turn-off for people might be the runtime (30 minutes is something I, personally, don't think that long about watching, but I think people in general might give it a pass if it's over 15, maybe 20 minutes). It's also probably considered a niche subject (which I like that you cover!), and that, along with the runtime, might contribute to people passing it by. I think people in general might go more for a "highlights"/abridged version when it comes to "neat subjects I know nothing about and aren't sure I'll like", rather than longform. Those are just my guesses as to why they get a low view count, but, like I said, I really like them myself! When it comes to runtime, I think somewhere above 40-ish minutes is where I kinda put it off, sometimes for a very long time.

Chas Becht

Same here. I'll also say that my schedule isn't always conducive to keeping up with all of the content that I'd like to be following. If I get around to watching something six months after it's made, I'm not showing up in the statistics in a useful way. Another thing to consider is that IMHO there's a huge gulf in quality between things that are made by someone who genuinely cares about them, and things that are made to chase a market or algorithm. I'd love a star trek future where everyone's basic needs are met and they are free to follow their individual passions. I don't live in that world, and one small way to bridge the gap is to support people who are doing worthwhile things that aren't otherwise financially viable in the current economic system. Incidentally, this is why I also don't care about patreon perks or exclusivity or whatever. I'm not paying for VIP access, I'm paying to make things exist in the world that otherwise wouldn't. Wide availability is an unambiguous positive outcome to me. It's possible I was radicalized by growing up with PBS.

Chas Becht

Also: librarians, archivists and curators are fucking heros.

F4_Phantom

I for one enjoyed the video post. As always, I've learned things that I thought I knew more of. I support your content because you put non-biased information out that it is up to the viewer to decide if they like it or not. As usual, opinions are like assholes, everyone has one. Keep up the great work.

Brandon

I also concur; I've backed way off from watching videos or consuming social media--I barely use social media anyway, but point still remains--so I don't watch that many of your videos anymore, but I don't watch *anyone's* videos very often anymore. Because of that (and more so, financial difficulties) I stopped being a patron of multiple people who I know have more than enough subscribers that removing my contribution was very unlikely to have even been noticed, but I kept it for those like you who are providing content that I am willing to pay something to help ensure that it's there for *others*, regardless of if I watch it or not.

Joel Furrer

I put the Opium Wars video in my "Watch Later" instead of immediately watching it, like I do for most InRange content, simply because of it's length. I'll get around to it at some point when I'm working in the kitchen or shop for a while, but I'm going to watch a shorter video while I eat breakfast or on my lunch break.

TheBigOne0305

I do enjoy the historic content, but I didn't watch the republished video, as I had already watched it when it was originally published (have been a subscriber for many, many years now). But I suspect that I'm in the minority and most (still active) subscribers haven't been around for that long.

Kyle

I'll be honest: I have a visceral reaction to "very special episodes". That is because I grew up when, and where, I did and that I have a very negative reaction to being dictated to as to how I am required to feel about things. I despise ham fisted emotional appeals, I know they are emotional appeals intended to bypass actual thought. That said, I trust your integrity and earnestness. I enjoy your expositions on these subjects. I'm gonna watch and learn, if not now, eventually. I appreciate your view point. But, for the masses: The presentation of the the video in the thumbnail and title may be a trigger which causes them to move on to something else. Because "A very Special Episode". Many of us are scarred. I gave up TV in the eighties. There were reasons.

David Hemsath

I watched “The Opium Wars” its first run.

Bradford Perry

I'm a very new subscriber, but part of why I love this and Forgotten Weapons is specifically for the "educational" aspects. The problem you're running into I think, and I'm sure this going to piss some people off, has something to do with that 54% functional illiteracy rate of the general U.S. population. I had a novel typed out explaining what I mean, but I think I'll leave it at that. lol. Keep up the great work; it's much appreciated.

Tom

I watched the video originally and watched it again. My guess is that it’s not content about America, so people have less interest.

Nuke Road Warrior

Karl, I have been a Patreon supporter for several years. Although money is tight right now, I intend to keep my support as long as I can. I don't always agree with everything you post, I wouldn't be human if i did. However, even the small amount of content I disagree with, I still find interesting. For the record, I did enjoy the "Opium Wars" video. I was already aware of how the British Empire addicted China to Opium all in the name of affordable tea, and seizing Hong Kong as a side benefit. I did, however, learn a few new details Thanks and keep up the good work.

George William Herbert

I hadn’t seen any notification on YouTube about the Opium Wars video, though it showed it immediately when I brought the channel up. It is something I will watch tonight now that I see it’s there.

Brandon

As I mentioned in a reply to someone else's comment, I appreciate your content regardless of whether I watch it, as I feel it has enough value to others that I support you with what money I can afford (which isn't much these days, granted). That said, the reloading video was great for a variety of reasons, and the fact that you can post content like that here makes me excited for what other things you'll come up with that aren't your average GunTuber slop like "here's the latest cool gun!" and "let's see how many sheets of tin foil it takes to stop a .50 cal!" ...although tbh I actually would watch that second video.

George William Herbert

30 minutes is long, but some topics can’t be short. It’s too long for daytime viewing. It’s fine for evening but I need to remember to reliably check my key channels for long form stuff YT didn’t recommend.

Bryant Easton

I'm sorry it didn't get the views you were hoping for. I thought it was awesome and would like to see more of that kind of thing. But, I'm kind of a history nerd.

Jason

Please keep the historical and socially relevant content. Back in 2018(!), it is the historical content that convinced me to support InRange. As far as it flopping, it's not 'GunTube' content. So single issue viewers? Also, people don't always like having their beliefs challenged or questioned. But sometimes it's necessary to do so.

Ian F

I would agree with that sentiment. Many Americans seem to ignore topics that are not directly related to the US, but have definitely affected the US relations with associated countries.

InRange TV

It's not leaving, I shouldn't have implied that - but I am trying to figure out how to package it best.

InRange TV

Yeah, It's not leaving - I shouldn't have stated what I did in the way that it implied that, but I do want to figure out how to "package" it best.

CYF

The Opium Wars video is fantastic stuff and strikes a great balance of energy (especially with a guest new to the shooting part of it), historical detail, and demonstrations. The shooting portions were particularly well paired with/segued into from the historical discussion. I watched it when it was first uploaded a while back, so I didn't have a big need to watch it immediately when it was re-uploaded again a few days ago, but I'm sure I'll check it out again as there's plenty I'm sure I've forgotten.

Electro_Static

It’s possible that youtube’s algorithm is suppressing anything “woke” so any facts that the current regimen doesn’t like

'General' Dipper

This is just off the cuff, but I wonder if having the 'man in his truck' format makes it feel safer to some audiences? Like a kind of ritual. Because it's such a familiar format for waffle. Whereas you do something more like an announcement. It feels more direct, and lands with greater authority.

Mark Elliot Cullen

Would a second channel make sense? I watched it, I love these types of videos, and your interests are what make InRange different, but maybe they don’t have a chance to breathe with the more firearms focused channel. Also maybe YouTube wouldn’t punish you in the algo as much if they were their own thing.

Tony Amaro

Nothing wrong with history that is uplifting about your country. If people want to go negative, they can easily find negative aspects of all civilizations large and small, primitive and sophisticated. More space than we have here to talk about it. Difficult to balance, as a matter of fact, Karl has irked me twice with his timing. His right, I calmed down and came back for old times sake. Not that he needs me. Best regards.

'General' Dipper

Being British, and especially working with Anglo-Chinese history at the moment, I was pretty well aware of the details. I can see how it is especially important to throw a stark light on imperial adventure in the world right now. But the (relative to a book) short format left me _feeling_ it made out the British Empire were just narcos. The reality was far more complex. I don't know which is more valuable, in the end. A polemic against empire, or a nuanced history that explains why kind and honourable people participated in it? I suppose it depends who you wish to convert.

The Renaissance Tinker

I don’t know if you can see this stat but Did people started watching it and stop or just not watch it at all? I don’t know if it’s just me but I found the dialogue/ interplay between you two to be a bit, I don’t know, awkward? It’s hard to describe and it gets better towards the end but the beginning is a little hard to watch. I remember feeling this way the first time it aired and had the same reaction just now. TLDR: The content is solid there’s just something a bit off with the presentation.

'General' Dipper

On the other hand, having a chance to bash the British Empire seems pretty popular. Viz the baffling endurance of The Patriot.

Jim Jam Shimmy Shatts

Couple ways of looking at it. If it flops on YouTube maybe just release it here for us so it doesn't further crater your algorithm. Or just keep on keeping on cuz you already know your algorithm is permanently tanked. Or potentially start a second channel for that type of content? I don't love that idea cuz I feel it's all interconnected to a point, but it could help your view count

The Renaissance Tinker

Just to clarify. I’m only talking about this video. Generally I like your presentation style. As for the bigger question I don’t know. I really enjoy the historical content.

Calm Survival

I like your oddball content. But then again, I appreciate content from people who I have a bit of trust in, who take the story to an uncomfortable place. I wouldn't watch an opium wars video from a lot of creators, because I need to know the level of research, and the point of view it comes from. I know folks like you, Robert Evans and the crew around him, J Draper, will say some hard things, but will have put the effort in. Do you have the bandwidth for a second history forward channel? Or the ability to create insert content for other folks like you have for the Andrews? On the other hand I see more and more that the humans have to be the recommendation engine. I don't know that any of what I've said helps.

Flabby

Yeah, PooTube tends to take a dim view on gun content, drug content, and historical content, and then you put all three in one video...

Sky Jordan

I really liked the Opium wars video personally, but my ideal inRange video is something that reads like a condensed episode of Behind the Bastards.

Bastien Rousselot

I will be brutally honest about it. You and I couldn't differ more in terms of political opinions. As a european being brought up in a european school and higher studies system, and very critically aware of the typical discourse around the field of history in academia, I feel like I already know what you are going to say in broad strokes without even starting to watch the video, and I don't particularly care for another mediocre retelling of the same story (I haven't watched it mind you, i am sharing the a priori judgement that made me not click on it, i will watch it afterwards to make sure i'm not talking out of my own ass). However, when it comes to the subjects you touch in your firearms videos, your personnal expertise in the field even in quite niche, nerdy subjects, and your ability to efficiently transmit it can make someone like me, very opposed to your worldview, shut up, pay you, and sit down to listen to what you have to say. Yes, you ARE THAT GOOD at it. I am just trying to be honest with you, I am sure you are aware that the majority of the firearms community doesn't share your views, and that a large chunk of your audience by extension doesn't either, so I think what I am saying reflects their thoughts too. Play on your strengths, use that beautiful brain of yours to keep exploring original ideas, and not some overdone socio-political historical account.

Grinning Serpent

I *love* the historical content. It's one of those things that really sets you apart from the rest of "guntube." But a man's gotta eat, too.

juwara bobrok

Paying gladly to support your work, Carl, but I'm overloaded with historical and current events content. Opium Wars is always a fascinating subject, but given the selection of currently burning fires, it just fell off my current selection list. I prioritize your work in my daily streaming/consumption when I see cool technical content, fwiw.

Creaky Log

N = 1, but I really enjoyed the video the first time it was posted and didn't rewatch it. The subject matter looked niche from the thumbnail and title, so I did start watching with some reservation, but it turned out to be very engaging and relevant.

Dirk

Hi Karl, I like you and respect you as a person. I am very happy with your content and your opinions. I don’t share some of them, but I respect them and I’m very happy that voices like yours are out to be heard. I see a couple of problems with your approach. YouTube channels are normally single topic. By covering a wide range of topics on one channel you always confuse or irritate part of your viewers. I watch C & Arsenal and real time history. I like both of their contents, but there is no reason to put it together. They work better separate on their own. There is also the problem with language and choice of words. You have a worldwide audience with different life experiences that trigger certain responses. I dropped out of the opium war video, a topic I am very interested in, at the word anarchist. We need to find a way to describe situations and solutions of our current time in current words and phrases. If you stuff your solution and concepts into words that are between 100 and 200 years old, the bad history of these words will drag down your solution. Certain words are toxic and will be for decades to come. Anarchist, socialist and so on. Another problem with a mix of content is that you do not reach some people when they’re ready. I can watch one of your gun videos to relax and one of your history videos to engage. If I never know what I’m getting it’s kind of annoying. If I need something to relax and get an engaging video I skip a video and forget to ever get back to it.

Matthew Jackson

The core reason to be a patron is to make the content that will never make itself popular. There's a lot of tricks to making a video do numbers on Youtube, but that road ends with eyes that look dead inside, all the energy and most of the enthusiasm faked to make the shot work on time. It's a fine line to walk, because you do need some level of engagement to to get noticed by the people who also want to see the interesting stuff, but part of the point is that sometimes you do the interesting things that you know will flop, because the world is better with them in it,

Bastien Rousselot

Well I did watch it, and I wasn't wrong with some caveats. The video clearly isn't preachy, which is the main fear behind the avoidance of it in my opinion, BUT it does feel like it was made to make point, a comment about today's politics. It feels like you wanted you subscribers to hear "the British purposefully hooked the chinese on drugs, but drug used is only bad when government régulateur (?)", and then you remembered you had to tack on some guns content because you're named InRange TV, and It somehow ended up being the best thing about the video. IF you wanted to make a more attractive video while not compromising on the underlying message, in my opinion you should have : - put the guns front and center of the video, they're the main reason why people watch - gone at length to demonstrate the technology difference, enter more in technical and historical details about them - really demonstrate accurately the IRL difference it makes in performance - use this subject to seamlessly get your point across more as a conclusion rather than an entire video - named your video something like "guns of colonisation - a tale of two empires" - your friend seems like a nice bloke, but I don't get why he's here. It feels like you just wanted to push an anarchist group, which comforts me in my opinion. Shouldn't have added him

General Grievous

A better title - "Addiction as a weapon: How England used opium and (weapons) technology to conquer Hong Kong" for example - makes the title connect with all points inside the video, and we know what to expect in the content. That's important, because then we look forward to those specific bits and we know what to expect. (Look at the channel The Operations Room for example, which is fantastic, even though it's a monotonous voice about battles. The headlines connect with the content.) And to me personally, and some might disagree of course, it was a bit off-putting to have an 2:30 long sort of advert about something I've never heard about, don't know if I'm interested in, and after staying for over two minutes still not sure what I'm watching. What is the Four Thieves Vinegar Collective? How does it correlate to the "Addiction as a weapon" title? What is the Anarchist Medical book really? (It's for saving lives..? Huh? How?) None of these questions gets answered because you're rushing through the presentation, and at least I got just confused and uninterested. After 2:40 (which is a long time in Youtube) we get introduced to the words "Opium wars" which is what the video is about, but those of us who don't know about that, we're still a bit confused of what the video really is about. I think, again, my personal opinion, you should've started the video with a very short "This is a reupload, there's some cool new stuff including Anarchist Medical book and Vinegar Collective, stay tuned (to the end)" and have the rest presented either right before the shooting sequence or, the best, at the end for those interested. Then you can thoroughly explain what it is and what's it about and why we should care. Again, my personal opinions! I'm just looking at how I think other channels do it, and how those feel more natural in their presentation of the content. Still love your content.

Ben Nicolson

I watched it first time round. I did find it a bit long potentially. Maybe a two parter would help. But it was good. As far as tone I live in Australia where arguably feminism, crt, gender identity stuff and wokeness are now the orthodoxy that can't be thoughtfully and respectfully critiqued in polite conversation a bit like the monarchy and church when I was a kid, but nonetheless I didn't feel like I was being bopped around the head by the tone of this episode. I certainly think Americans need to remember that you're the most terrible imperialists except for all the other contenders. Much like the British were in their day. I have a pretty good understanding of the opium wars but it certainly gave more information. I think the great travesty was the tea monopoly which I'm glad Robert Fortune liberated us from. I do think there is an interesting opportunity that was missed probably for access reasons to highlight the interesting further developments in the world of match locks in places like China. They certainly became a more elegant user friendly type of firearm than a lot of European munition grade match locks were when flint based systems took over. While inferior in some ways they were quite impressive in others. I have attached a YouTube channel that covers this region more than others do that deserves some love. Asian muzzle loaders and firearm development itself does too. https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLugaf4JE2z6Y2VoRir8tcrBnykQjqjvs9&si=hVOxmKxiE8yt9XRS

Flatrabbit

Personally I love the history and sociological videos. They are one of the main reasons I watch InRangeTV. My dad was visiting for the week and we watched The Opium Wars video. He really dug it.

MooseOfTheAges

Relatively new-comer here, so I haven’t even attempted most of your backlog. However, I do enjoy the historical context you provide to weapons, and self defense. As for why some of your content “flops”? I’d hazard a guess and say its baked into YouTube to limit or squash nuanced content. There are several creators that I watch most of their content on YouTube, and I have do find their content by going directly to their page. It doesn’t pop up in my feed a lot of times. The “you may also like…” slop that I keep seeing is annoying. Keep up the great work!

Timothy T.

Personally, I have had a lot going on the last 6 months- my fiancee drowned a few weeks ago, just moved, nearly had a big career change- ended up turning down an offer to double my salary to stay near family in the wake of everything, been working overtime split between 3 big programs... I don't know when the last time I logged into Discord was or played a video game... And I'm not necessarily the target audience for your vignettes and social content- I'm not politically aligned closely with most of your audience and I'm a straight white guy that doesn't really care about or engage with that type of content... But nonetheless, I stopped what I was doing and watched your opium wars video when I saw it, and same with your reloading video. I have not caught everything you've put out lately, but videos that you're passionate about are absolutely the most interesting, and your vignettes provide insights I would never otherwise get... I guess my point is everyone has shit going on and they'll do what they will, but your core audience is here for you, and we want to see you making videos that you enjoy making and that you are proud of. The point of being demonetized is to not be beholden to the algorithm and the opinion of the masses.

Timothy T.

I'm always looking for long form content like this that's informative and worth holding my attention- I get very tired of short clickbait content everywhere

John Hieronymus

how do clips of historic content do? i get lots of clips like this in my feed and feel like snippets of interesting facts could get people hooked

Peter Ciccolo

I didn't watch it. I think this is a fine topic and good to raise awareness, but I'm already pretty familiar with this history and didn't feel the need for a refresher, personally.

Joonas Iivonen

Neither YouTube or Patreon told me about the video. Watching now.

Ian Stobie

As a brit, I found the opium wars fascinating (if quite repugnant) when I read about it many years ago . Watching the video was hugely informative as I'd never quite grasped the sheer technological difference between the two sides.

Åmund Breivik

I watched it the first time, then sort of watched it again the second time while mostly focused on something else. I dunno, I am sure it's not your intention, but as someone who has had to deal with a lot of opiate addicts it came across as perhaps a bit dismissive of the problems with opium. Sure it has legit medicinal uses, but major addiction problems do in fact also exist in areas of the world where opium is available and there is no real attempt at regulation. Parts of the video could be interpreted as promoting drug use and downplaying the risks, again I don't think that's your intention but it could be seen that way. Communication is difficult, because you as the content creator have no control over what mental lens or filter the viewers see the content through. So if you expect us to see it in a certain light, and some of us viewers see it through a different lens based on our experiences and worldview, some of us are going to get a different message than what you intended to convey. This is especially likely to happen with controversial or fringe topics. Which is of course a particular challenge for you, since a lot of what you do and that we love about your channel is the fringe topics that others don't even attempt to cover. And the "DIY medicine" parts, when presented in a very surface level way with no real explanation of whether this is based on actual peer reviewed science or not, unfortunately comes across as possibly promoting dangerous quack practices. I would have liked to have some more details on that. There's a big difference between saying "If you have no access to medical care in an emergency, this book might help save your life. But see a real doctor as soon as you can, in case your self-diagnosis was wrong" and saying "Don't bother going to a real doctor, this book makes you your own doctor". Your video didn't quite give me enough info on what is in the book to know where it lands on that spectrum, and unfortunately there's a lot of harmful quack nonsense out there. Like, is it about improvised first aid techniques or is it more about making your own painkillers from willow bark etc? Even factually correct medical information can be dangerous if mis-applied, and people without years of medical training are very likely to get some diagnoses wrong. And even natural remedies that do work have some pretty bad side effects or risks; painkiller made from willow bark, to use my own example, does work but is also terribly bad for the kidneys which is why synthetic aspirin is better. The way you promoted this book without going in depth enough for me to evaluate whether I would find it trustworthy on such topics was a bit off-putting to me. And I have no doubt the YouTube algorithm really pushed your video way way down, combining guns and drugs in one video? The algorithm isn't smart enough to understand that most of this is very interesting historical content.

Peter Hillier

I honestly think that as much as it pains me, you could do more clickbaity titles and some framing. I actually think that the people who really need to learn about history do need an in to get them interested. "Drug dealers with repeating rifles vs arrow infantry. The point modern guns made everything obsolete." can still have the lessons about imperialism in it, but getting people who aren't on the history train or have a narrow view of it already is in a way more productive.

John Hollowell

I like both, and I provide support here so you can make what is important to you.

Greg

It's a length issue for me. I have very little time in a given day to watch media, so when someone makes a 30+ minute video, they are competing with all the other equivalent length shows I could be watching, and YouTube--regardless of the creator--rarely wins. For me, YouTube typically gets 10-15 minutes while I'm on the can or eating a meal, or eating a meal on the can.

Andrew Porter

The opium wars video wasn’t shown to me by the algorithm, even though Im a subscriber. Not been keeping up with Patreon lately either which I probably should.

Adam Jacob

I very much enjoy the wide variety AND depth InRange provides. That said, the deeper dives, by necessity, create longer videos, and I tend to save those up for when I have the time (and mental energy) to dedicate to them. YT analytics can only show a creator a slice of information, from a particular point of view. Context matters. Rarely is InRange . . . "fluff" or . . . "something to have on in the background", and life can get busy. You do you, and try not to get discouraged.

Robert Glinka

Honestly, when I saw a video about the Opium Wars, I kinda shrugged and clicked on it cause of you, not the content. Then I was pleasantly surprised at how much I enjoyed it.

Wayne S.

Karl, while I have questioned some of your content, you have never had questionable content.

Scott Vaughan

Karl, For subscribers like me, your content is enlightening, educational and shows a viewpoint just slightly different than most other "guntubers". In my opinion, it's this different approach that doesn't always appeal to the general gun tube audience. That audience is perfectly happy with your straight and strictly gun-focused content. When you deviate from that script you lose the majority of those folks who maybe have a narrow and perhaps closed view of society and life. I for one am always interested in the adjacent content which you present because firearms and their use doesn't and never has existed in a vacuum but rather in an historical context that deserves to be explored. Keep up the good work, Scott Vaughan

litgeek

I obviously don't speak for everyone given the performance of the first posting, but in my case I did watch the video the first time it was posted and skipped it this time. I genuinely appreciate the historical content you post; "enjoy" maybe isn't the right word for some of the topics covered, but learning about them is part of why I've stuck with the channel. In general though, I watch it the first time around (I'm one of the lucky few who's never had issues with my sub feed omitting stuff) and skip re-posts/re-uploads.

Dominik Dalek

It's a single data point but when this video was released originally I did not watch it beyond 60 second mark or something like that because I didn't vibe with Michael. That's all there was to it. This time around I kept the video running in the background just to feed the algorithm. Passively listening to your discussion was enough for me to re-tune and view the whole thing through. This is probably a solitary POV but I had similar reaction when I first saw some old Q&A (which is how I ended up subscribing). That time around I didn't like that Karl-guy interrupting Ian. Familiarity and consistency is a key for me. But I'm sure other people have other reasons.

Doug G

History is a fickle mistress. The Opium wars, or Asian/Chinese history is well buried. I will absolutely, believe that because the topic is centered or started because white people LITERALLY infected many cultures with drug or addiction, and then turn a blindeye to it. It is a dark time period and one, specifically the English do not want to bring up, with all the other atrocities and general horrible empire policies that ge,so a guntur with a pension for nit politically correct history. Your real question is not why this gets buried or how do people not know this. It should be when will you stop shoving this down the throats of everyone. While I, personally, have some familiarity with the era, i don't know the details and enjoy topics like this. Not everyone knows why it should be important. So, go forth, continue on this path for it'll you get but one person to acknowledge this 1 person to turn and say that they they were effected. Then you did your job. Since you don't get paid, you aren't loosing anything.

Bob Dylan

I really enjoyed the video, but i already watched the original upload. so i just didn’t rewatch it since i already saw it before

Nomp

For me, and I recognize this may be a niche position, I watched a few minutes of it and then clicked off because, well, I did my MA in the period immediately thereafter and my knowledge was massively more in-depth (due to the long-term economic impact of the Opium Wars). I simply wasn't learning anything new, which is my biggest reason for watching you. Entertainment enters into it sometimes, but this was clearly not an entertainment video from you. Also, you are one of the few channels I watch ACTIVELY, not just something in the background, so it didn't fall into my usual usecase for a 30m video. Again, I don't know how much useful information you can glean from this, but I do want to encourage you in these pursuits, so I'm gonna go put it on in the background while waging war on my AC unit.

Wilhelm Screamer

I am glad you did it, I just have not been in a state where I can process the institutionally driven mass human suffering the topic centers on. I need to get myself mentally fortifued with that tab on perpetual standby

Adam

I am a new supporter on patreon, and I joined as a way to say thank you for the years of educational content (and entertaining) you have provided. I do love your historical videos and I always intend to watch them but I always put them off for "later" and then of course it's months before I get around to it. The shorter "how to" videos are what can trigger me to watch immediately. I love them both, but one I will watch right away and the other I tend to procrastinate on. Please keep trying new things but also keep the historical videos. I have shared many of the stories you have told here with other people many of which are stories that are mostly forgotten. You always shed light on subjects, events, and people that are forgotten by most

Jefferson Green

I really enjoyed it when it first posted but didn't rewatch this time, at least not yet.

Albini family

I appreciate your expertise in firearms history and lore, I learn something from almost every video, and I really appreciate your point of view in the 2A community. I've also enjoyed your historical content, especially collaborations with subject matter experts. And when it comes to firearms you are a subject matter expert. When it comes to history...well, there are people who get entire college degrees in history and put in the time and original research to present something genuinely new, or present an informed analysis on familiar events. There is nothing stopping an interested layman from doing that, but that won't be the first place I look when I want to explore a historical event. Please note I'm not recommending you stick to firearms or their place in history, but you have credibility there. If you want to present historical topics one way to build credibility would be to spin that content off into a separate channel. A body of work with legit scholarship will build trust with the audience. It took time to build your firearms history audience, and because the content has been so honest and informative you have subscribers like me. A history show would take a similar amount of time to build an audience. So my recommendation is: go big. Give it time and trust the audience to find what they love and trust.

SDKI

The historic videos are part of the reason I appreciate you and your channel.

Bruce Brodnax

I remembered being kind of bored by that one the 1st time around, so I didn't bother rewatching it. I do enjoy the Old West Vignettes to no end, which you've also said in the past don't find as a receptive of an audience as the (now somewhat cliche') Mud Tests. More Type 82 content too! Haven't seen your classic car in awhile... 👍

David Mandeville

I wouldn't sweat the lack of engagement too much. It's everything from simple time constraint to to people actively avoiding modern existence's complicit relationship to the past. You're not dependent on engagement took keep going and that's good. You're giving space to voices that regularly get dismissed and that's good. Keep doing good. We'll catch up eventually.

Tony Amaro

30 min is not too long at all for me but I have an interest in history, perhaps not all do. But I think pieces like this are not your bread and butter. If it underperforms it won't make or break the channel. People either do not find it interesting at all, find it to long maybe but have doubts, or third it may be the truth but is a bit of a downer. Any group can be made to look plain evil if you dig especially the world of 100 plus years ago, truly competitive and could be downright cruel, all groups on all continents could be just about.

Brian Herzog

This is exactly what I was going to say. Maybe it's just a consequence of losing the ability to focus on long-form content of any kind, but a 9-15 minute video I feel like I can watch any time. Something 20+ minutes I feel like I need to come back to when i can devote the time to it. I don't know if that helps with your question, because I certainly don't want InRange to become a watered down shorts-only channel.

Chad Smith

I value the gap that InRange bridges between gun technology and other important history topics. Granted, I don't have time to consume all content in a timely manner but I like the work presented here.

Jimbobalinski

I sometimes need to prepare myself before I dig into another historical tragedy, especially when I'm already aware of the bigger details of a given event. I eventually watch all the videos, but not always right when they come out.

'General' Dipper

Very well put. I wonder if timing the release makes a difference?

'General' Dipper

The technology is only part of the equation, mind. Training, logistics, comms... lots of other stuff. Nit to mention political strategic clarity.

'General' Dipper

As I indicated in my own comment, I do think a single video is inevitably fall short. You could burn a whole series giving context and exploring all the dynamics. However, if we want context on how we view history, should we not allow for context on what Karl is doing now? A mob stormed their parliament. A new agency has been force fed a budget larger than the USMC and is detaining people without habeas corpus. A war is being conducted without oversight. Blowing a horn for mistrust and critical thinking in that context is more understandable. I still didn't get much out the video, personally. However, I don't much enjoy raw vegetables but I still eat them.

'General' Dipper

Any BLUF on how it translates to modern policy? And do you think it is elective or subconscious?

'General' Dipper

I think your key indicator, mate, is that you've got 100+ replies. Even those of us who were not fans of the video still respect you enough to want you to know why.

Bill Field

Short version (as I understand it) is modern actions by other countries (the U.S. in large part) are seen as a continuation of a historical pattern that began with the Opium Wars and bled into the Century of Humiliation, with its forced treaties, the UK takeover of Hong Kong, and any other example where China’s perceived weakness allowed the country to be taken advantage of and its future decided by others. Avoiding a continuation of any part of the Century of Humiliation, and gaining the perceived position the country would have had if the century never happened, is seen as a justification for China’s foreign policy and military buildup. It also means that territorial claims are seen as particularly important, given that past violations of its sovereignty are central to the Century of Humiliation. But such claims may also be part of making moves to bolster the country's security in the face those modern actions by others (South China Sea, for example). Either way, military strength today is central to countering a repeat of the patterns that began in the Opium Wars.

Elbe

I haven’t watched it…yet. I am somewhat familiar with the story, having read a book on the Boxer Rebellion. I will say that I’ve enjoyed content like this previously, especially the ones on enslavement and the Underground Railroad. I’ll be sure to watch this video. Please keep up the great work!

Elbe

Maybe we just get too much media thrown our way (from all sources) and only so much time to view and digest. Tbh, I think I need to prioritize your content to make sure I see/support it with views. Also, I’ve severely cut down on my gun-tube watching so I’d have to specifically target your feed to make sure the algorithms bring it up to watch.

Jack the Aviator

Please go into very controversial political history. I think you have the balls to confront some very ugly things in our past. And I respect you enough to suggest it my biggest suggestion would be Huey P Long. His share the wealth speech on the floor of the Senate what's one of the greatest pieces of war Asian in American history On a weird other note, could people literally patronize a subject. Could I pay you to do a video on a particular subject?

Bill Mayo-Bedford

These type of content serve to remind us of historical events that may otherwise be downplayed on other sites. Please keep up the good work reminding us of the inhumanity of the human race.