Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 742703396.mp4

Downloads

Content

There were a lot of comments in the last video that essentially stated that barrel length has such a minimal effect on 10mm that a longer barrel is useless. While some cartridges definitely experience more advantages than others in this regard, I'm skeptical that it's a zero effect with 10mm. Let's find out what the reality is with three separate loads from three separate manufacturers.

Youtube link:https://youtu.be/bSyJItNbbik

Files

Comments

Quacktar the Unforgiven

Seems to me that ease of aiming with a long gun is likely a bigger deal than the change in velocity. A 15% gain in velocity isn't nothing though.

Ted Swinford

A reloader might be able to maximize a 10mm cartridge for a longer barrel using a slower burning powder.

Hobie

About what I expected, though somewhat surprised (disappointed?) that a cartridge supposedly optimized for lever guns didn't have better performance and more of a drop-off in the pistol. Is it possible there is some marketing hype involved?

Hobie

Probably at the cost of a lack of performance in a pistol, plus a lot of muzzle blast.

Reverend Charles

Ammo manufacturers even make different loads for long guns versus handguns for this very reason. Kind of surprised how spicy the Hornady load was. That’s great.

Ted Swinford

Of course this would, for me, be a carbine only load. Out of a pistol it would, at the very least, be a waste of powder and money.

Emily

I'm not too knowledgable in the field of ammo types and how they behave, so I might well be missing something elementary, but it seems a little 'duh' to me that a barrel longer than a regular pistol barrel would increase the round's velocity, at least slightly... To you kind people out there, *is* there any round where barrel length really doesn't matter? If not, any where it matters so little as to be inconsequential? Thanks in advance! /Emily

commandZee

But Karl the people on the internet say the 10mm is exempt from all rules of physics 😋 Have you tried .40 S&W in the Marlin yet?

InRange TV

No, this is what you should expect - there just is a weird idea that 10mm is somehow immune to the effect. Some cartridges, based on the powder, etc, will see more (or less) velocity change with barrel length, but pretty much everything will see *something*.

commandZee

Might be a fun video opportunity 🤔

Emily

Ah, gotcha! Good to know I'm not completely off in my thinking! :)

Scott Gardner

I imagine the Lever Reveloution cartidges have a better Ballistic Coefficient

Bruce Brodnax

That's their selling point: the soft rubber point prevents tube-mag detonations under recoil, while still allowing for better external ballistics than a big flat meplat does.

Bruce Brodnax (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-21 12:00 It's going to vary from cartridge to cartridge, and loads within those; for instance, 22WMR was (originally) only ever intended to be used in a rifle, so the powder burn was optimized for ~ 18" barrel lengths [most rifles had longer barrels in the '60s when it came out than are common today, where the minimum legal barrel length in many states is 16", so that's what people want.] Firing 22WMR in a pistol was a recipe for a big fireball, for such a small round. Nowadays however, there are 22WMR loads optimized for use in short barrels for self-defense; those rounds will be substantially slower out of a rifle than a similar load optimized for rifle-length barrels.
2026-09-17 06:25 It's going to vary from cartridge to cartridge, and loads within those; for instance, 22WMR was (originally) only ever intended to be used in a rifle, so the powder burn was optimized for ~ 18" barrel lengths [most rifles had longer barrels in the '60s when it came out than are common today, where the Federally mandated minimum legal barrel length for a rifle is 16", so that's what people want.] Firing 22WMR in a pistol was a recipe for a big fireball, for such a small round. Nowadays however, there are 22WMR loads optimized for use in short barrels for self-defense; those rounds will be substantially slower out of a rifle than a similar load optimized for rifle-length barrels.

It's going to vary from cartridge to cartridge, and loads within those; for instance, 22WMR was (originally) only ever intended to be used in a rifle, so the powder burn was optimized for ~ 18" barrel lengths [most rifles had longer barrels in the '60s when it came out than are common today, where the Federally mandated minimum legal barrel length for a rifle is 16", so that's what people want.] Firing 22WMR in a pistol was a recipe for a big fireball, for such a small round. Nowadays however, there are 22WMR loads optimized for use in short barrels for self-defense; those rounds will be substantially slower out of a rifle than a similar load optimized for rifle-length barrels.

Bruce Brodnax (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-21 12:00 I wonder if the reason why there was only 200fps between the pistol and rifle was because the rifle barrel was already long enough that peak velocity had been reached inside the barrel and the bullet was already slowing down? Since you live in AZ Karl, you can get an SBR now w/o the $200 tax stamp, so I think you need to test a 12" barrel to see if the Vm exceeds that of your Marlin.
2026-09-17 06:50 I wonder if the reason why there was only 200fps between the pistol and rifle was because the rifle barrel was long enough that peak velocity had been reached inside the barrel and the bullet was already slowing down? Since you live in AZ Karl, you can get an SBR now w/o the $200 tax stamp, so I think you need to test a 12" barrel to see if the Vm exceeds that of your Marlin. 😁

I wonder if the reason why there was only 200fps between the pistol and rifle was because the rifle barrel was long enough that peak velocity had been reached inside the barrel and the bullet was already slowing down? Since you live in AZ Karl, you can get an SBR now w/o the $200 tax stamp, so I think you need to test a 12" barrel to see if the Vm exceeds that of your Marlin. 😁

David T Klein

But Carl, does the HSM bullet natively support the new Quantum Safe algorithms, or does it only shoot out RSA and Elliptic Curve signatures? That pun was bad enough that I made myself groan. I’ll see myself out.

Emily

@Bruce Ah, I see! But .22 for self defence? Is that a thing?

Tony Amaro

I imagine the burn rate chart would come in handy.

Hobie

Still, you'd think they could squeeze out a couple hundred FPS...

Bruce Brodnax

Agreed, if you thought Hornady was doing more than putting the fancy bullet on top of a standard pistol load and marking up the price. As a life-long cynic, I remain in doubt that they did anything more than that in the search for easy profits from a new product.

Bruce Brodnax

I was just using the 22WMR as an example of a round optimized for rifle-length barrels that someone might think was normally a pistol round [vs. something like .223Remington or .308Win, which are obviously bottle-necked rifle rounds.] But 22WMR has a devoted following as a carry round, since it has more power & penetration than 22lr, and some people have limited hand strength or are otherwise extremely recoil sensitive. 22WMR is ballistically very similar to 5.7x28mm FN, which round was developed specifically for a NATO request for a PDW. No modern military is going to accept a rimfire cartridge as a general issue round [the US had some 22lr made up w/ jacketed bullets during WW2 for use by OSS operatives using their High Standard silenced pistols, but that was an anomaly], so FN arriving at something quite close to the 22WMR in a centerfire package is quite interesting. Convergent evolution always intrigues me...

Emily

@Bruce Ah yeah, the 5.7mm I've heard people carry! It feels a little weird to me in a civilian context, since I think the design intent was to penetrate body armour (?), but if it's a bit like .22 (albeit what I assume is quite a beefed-up .22) in recoil and such it makes a lot of sense :) Cool that the OSS had .22 pistols in WW2 - didn't have the slightest idea about that! I don't know why, but .22 stuff fascinates me. It might be because it's such a far cry from the military content I usually consume, so it's like a breath of fresh air? Nevertheless, you keep enlightening me about things whenever I have questions, so I want to give you a very big thanks! People like you are why I love this community so much; friendly, helpful, and knowledgable :D