Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 772678998.mp4

Downloads

Content

The 1879 Winchester-Hotchkiss was the first US military repeating bolt action rifle put through field trials in the 1880s. Interestingly, the Army Ordinance board decided to reject it and stick with the single shot 1873 Trapdoor. Were they right? Lets find out.YouTube Link:https://youtu.be/skDPlCksjs0

Files

Comments

VM Kane

I think it’s quite interesting that anyone with knowledge of modern firearms is almost bound to approach the early magazine cut-off designs, before charger-loading, from the perspective of ‘you get n shots and then you’re back to single breechloading,’ whilst the period thinking seems to have been more ‘you have a single breechloader, but with an added reserve of n rounds rapid fire for emergencies.’ It’s very hard to shake our knowledge that history is heading towards magazine fire being the norm, not the bonus feature.

Bradford Perry

This is why I'm here. I had never even heard of the 1879 Win.-Hotchkiss before today. This seems like another case of a lack of faith in the intelligence of the avg. soldier mucking things up a bit. I don't know a lot about that particular era as it pertains to tactics and things like that, but if it functioned as intended I feel like having the repeater would ultimately give you the advantage. Especially in cases of ambush or other "shoot your way out" situations.

Satsuma Grognard

I love these historical firearm videos, keep doing what you’re doing Karl.

Åmund Breivik

Yep, that is how most militaries intended them to be used. Single shot most of the time, with a reserve magazine for rapid fire in case of emergency. So if the enemy suddenly charged, or your patrol got ambushed, you have those five extra rounds on tap rapid fire. And looking at him shoot it, although Karl says the trapdoor is also fast I suspect the Hotchkiss is faster in single shot mode than the trapdoor is. Fewer hand movements needed to reload it, since you don't have to manipulate the hammer separately from the breech mechanism like you do on the trapdoor. You also can be a bit sloppier in chambering the cartridge, since the bolt will push it home. On the trapdoor, have to get the cartridge most of the way into the chamber before the door will close.

A David Merritt

Would it be practical to use the Sharp's Carbine butt loading option on this rifle? That should simplify reloading.

Carl Soderstrom

Regarding parts breakage: I saw a video by a reenactor whose unit represents frontier-era cavalry. He was really surprised at how much the guns just *fall apart* when bounced around on a horse for a few dozen miles regularly. Sights fall off, springs break, screws come loose, etc. There's a reason locking screws and staked screws exist. Given all that, I can see why someone might be very concerned about having the absolutely most reliable (i.e. simplest) rifle, or the rifle which could be repaired with the lowest technology level.

Bruce Brodnax

Well, as Karl mentioned in passing, the average soldier of the time got little marksmanship training or practice at all, unless he made it himself. The USA was still largely a rural nation [heck, hospital births didn't surpass home births *until 1950*!] so I suspect the Army expected the vast majority of recruits to already know how to shoot, having grown up on farms and been tasked w/ keeping critters out of the crops, since most of the recruits were joining the Army for the relative life of ease Army life represented vs. subsistence farming. [See "1st World War letter home" for more info...] And of course, the Army wasn't far wrong in those expectations, for their rare standouts [Sgt. York, et al] but the reality was that the Civil War led to a swing in the demographics where a lot of city slickers w/ zero firearms knowledge ended up in the military, and that trend continued as the nation grew, cities became overcrowded w/ mass migration from Yurp and getting a paid trip to the frontier to see what opportunities may lay in the West was a recruitment enticement... 😄

Bruce Brodnax

"Spencer Carbine," perhaps you meant to write? Aaaand... when was the patent on that due to expire? 😉

A David Merritt

Pardon, yes Spencer, not Sharps, If the Patent was extended, 9 years, if not two years. Unfortunately, after some research, the Spencer Arms Co. did not survive the post Civil War loss of military contracts, and was bought up by Winchester. So then, why did Winchester not use either of their magazines on this rifle?

Bradford Perry

I feel like you got over eager to answer things I wasn't asking.

Tony Amaro

James Lee was a real leader, Paul Mauser a superb problem solver and refiner. Very interesting, thanks!

Bruce Brodnax

Probably couldn't figure out how to do a quick-loading magazine while retaining that slick "pop the next round into the chamber" feed cycle.