Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

WWSD - 20" Variant High Desert Brutality Poll

  • 4X ACOG 197
  • SIG TANGO 1-6 LPVO 127
  • Alternative 1-8 LPVO 108
  • Something else entirely? 34
  • 2023-06-08
  • 466 votes
{'title': 'WWSD - 20" Variant High Desert Brutality Poll', 'choices': [{'text': '4X ACOG', 'votes': 197}, {'text': 'SIG TANGO 1-6 LPVO', 'votes': 127}, {'text': 'Alternative 1-8 LPVO', 'votes': 108}, {'text': 'Something else entirely?', 'votes': 34}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 6, 8, 17, 6, 18, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 466}

Content

When the WWSD project was first born, there as a 20" DMR variant that was left to the wayside for the initial commercial version with a fixed muzzle device, and then later with a 16" for broader ability to distribute, etc, due to stupid laws.I am revisiting this now with a refresh of the product line with KE Arms and bringing back a small run of 20" DMRs.I have decided to use this as my 1 primary rifle in Partizan for High Desert Brutality, using MK 262 77 grain ammunition.So..a poll for y'all, what would you like to see for my sighting system?I am thinking, that while it won't be the most effective for score, that showing off what the 20" AR with an ACOG CAN do would be interesting content, if not a match winning decision...but curious about YOUR thoughts?

Comments

Ross

MPVO and Red dot

Evil Skeleton Witch

Primary Arms 3x Prism scope (I'm not biased, you're biased)

Magnus

Will KE Arms release a 20” WWSD upper for separate sale?

Zack Z

I voted 1-8 other, thinking if you are using this for very long range and can probably show how truly versatile a DMR can be.

Calvin McClory

I wanted to say Acog for the sex appeal, but 8x seems more appropriate for a DMR. And I curious how adjustable magnification can be used.

Jeff I

MPVO( 2-10 or similar)

Josh Ross

I think something more of a 2-10 powered like the primary arms GLX. A DMR is a specialized tool and should use a more specialized optic.

DP

1-8 LPVO. I think its the "boring" but best choice for a DMR. I also hold the (controversial?) opinion that an 18 or even 16-inch barrel with a can is a better option for a DMR. I'd take the velocity penalty to save some overall length when adding a can.

Kevin Asimakis

The primary arms PLX compact 1-8 seems to fit with the theme of the WWSD project perfectly.

LeKa

ACOG would be very interesting to see, doesn't seem to really be around in the competition scenes

InRange TV

That is in the works right now and we'll be useing them at High Desert as part of that project.

Rick Thurman

I second the thought of a PA 3x or maybe the new 5x version with an add on red dot. I'm currently running the 3x with a 45' Romeo 5 on a 12.5". I'd think the 5x with a red dot would be an interesting experiment for a DMR build. I prefer enclosed red dots as I'm in a wet environment and have many issue with rain & Cmore & Competitions in the past.

Dan

Or see if PA would give you one of the new 5x for T&E

Reverend Charles

Elcan SpectreDR. Nah, seriously I’d go for the Trijicon AccuPoint 1-6 mildot.

ZeroSuitSamo

I think it should be an LVPO for sure, but given the nature of the rifle, I think it should be the lightest one you can find, assuming the cost isn't prohibitively high. Whatever you choose though it will be cool to see. I bought my KP-15 with the intent to do a lightweight 20" build. I don't have the money for a CF tube, but it'll have a pencil barrel at least.

Jesus

I did vote ACOG but i have been looking at the P.A. SLx 5x36mm Gen III Prism Scope - ACSS Aurora Reticle.

Joseph

I’d recommend the Spectre DR (I know people think it’s a meme), but it’s a great optic; having 1x and 4x is much better than variable. Plus, no Trijicon religious nonsense.

JoQuin

LPVO gang cuz I wanna see how it performs in this type of match… and some ppl say it’s obsolete 😅

Arnout van Mameren

Why would you put a 4x on a rifle labeled a DMR? Go with an better optic and show us what Stoner would do with current gen stuff!

Sophie

2-10 MPVO would be sick. I've been enjoying the trijicon credo personally

Alfred Gawron

I'd like to see your evaluation of Primary Arms Compact PLxC 1-8x24. It's not cheap but maybe PA would provide one?

Juan Cisneros

Nightforce ATACR 1-8, PA PLXc 1-8, or Vortex Razor 1-10.

Mitchell Booth

I think that, as others have said, the Primary Arms PLX-C 1-8 is a perfect fit for the project! Small, lightweight, and affordable, with excellent performance.

Vityaz

I want to see the acog just because I used one overseas on an M16A2 and now own one personally. So I'd like some confirmation bias please lol.

Chariot

MPVO and offset dot! A 2.5-10x, 3-12x, or 4-12x to really show off it's potential. Those used to be sniper system optics but are easily found on dmrs now

b

I'd like to see an ACOG for the historical value. We see them so often in media set in the GWOT, I would like to get a sense of how it actually performs in practice.

LFD Research

1-8 lvpo is great and I would argue ffp since your holds won’t change with magnification but it requires good design for use at low magnification

Derek Elsberry

I shoot 600yd Matches with a 16" barrel AR, bipod and sandsock under buttstock, ACOG 3.5X. I can consistently put at least 6 of 10 record shots on the 2' x 2' target paper...and sometimes actually in the target rings. Do the ACOG!

Infin1ty

If you're talking about the original WWSD rifle, then an ACOG would be best. For the polymer lower, the configuration should be completely up to the customer. I'm building mine to a 6.8 upper with the polymer lower for a hunting rifle. I'm honestly not sure why you guys settled on a single caliber for something mass produced.

LigerNoir

Since the rifle was designed around the most modern materials; we are going on the principal of most modern system: it's an LPVO. Pick the best based off that principal.

Lead Cloud

I'm going to also cast my vote in for higher magnification, if this is seriously intended to be an exploration of a DMR/SPR capable system intended to be able to engage targets between 600-800yds. The 4x acog is a great optic, but it is a carbine optic, intended for use at or below 500yds, and it would be a major limitation on an otherwise very capable system. Ideal would probably be a 2-10 optic, but a 1-8 with a mil grid should be plenty to actually demonstrate what the system can actually do

IYFace

If not an LPVO, perhaps a Primary Arms etched Prism scope with a BDC and magnifier?

Aw Fisk

I set my build up with RDS and would like to see LPVO of light weight

Matthew Jackson

I love the ACOG for the historical value, and I think the PLXc 1-8 is the most WWSD-DMR spirit optic choice. Either seems like a good fit for High Desert

Nick Rudd

ACOG, easy. It stays truest to the principles of the WWSD with respect to light weight and simple operation.

Bryan Deneen

Other. 2-10X or 3-16X with offset or piggy back red dot.

Faustus

The ACOG is a capable optic, but dated. Why bother bringing a WWSD rifle only to handicap it with obsolescent sighting technology? The whole WWSD philosophy (as I understand it) is to reconceive the AR15 using modern materials and technology. In that vein, lightweight and functional 1-8 LPVOs exist today; use one!

Damian Allen

ACOG seems like the route you’re most interested in, and I think the priority should be you having a good time at the match. I remember the Desert Brutality where you shot the 1873 fondly because the videos make it clear you were having a blast.

MichaelPee

2-10(or12+/-) MPVO with a piggyback reddot?

Louis Wu

The ACOG has a rep for being super rugged. How does the Sig Tango stack up? Does it offer enough advantages to overcome the added weight and potential fragility? ETA the tango only weighs 2oz more and was good enough for a $78 million DOD contract. I'd go Tango in keeping with the WWSD principles of making the most of the AR-15 platform with Stoner's goals in mind with modern materials

Louis Wu

I made it all the way out to the 750m target with a PA 1-6 ACSS and m193 ammo on my first long range attempt, 50% less magnification at 33% greater range without the BDC reticle would've been a real challenge tho.

Steve T.

I built my own with a Faxon 20" gunner barrel, and am running the 3x PA prism, so I would like to see you run it with an ACOG or any other lower power prism optic.

Stephen Bukowsky - Blind Squirrel Enterprises

White Oak 1-4.5x service rifle scope, and when you're done with it you can use it to earn your last 2 LEG points! seriously though having just legged out myself, it would be amazing if in-range could shine a little light on the high-power discipline and CMP matches generally, as it seems to be catastrophically under-represented in popular online media. I think a lot of people who only shoot action style matches could benefit from the cross-discipline training provided by more formal marksmanship sports to really hone their basic marksmanship skills.

Adam Dümdie

PA MPVO 2.5-10 in true DMR fashion.

Mark Lee

I think the ACOG limits you unless you pair it with an offset red dot. The Sig-Tango is a good choice (maybe), but I have no experience with it. For a 1-6, I've been pleased with the Primary Arms ACSS offering. FFP and SFP both have their advantages and disadvantages so pick you poison.

Faustus

I think the Tango6 is more than durable enough for a match. Brutality matches are not *so* brutal that people are breaking quality optics left and right, so that advantage of the ACOG is probably less relevant than the added magnification offered by a 1-6 or, even better, a 1-8, given the ranges I understand are going to be involved in some of the targets at HDB.

Dragomir

The ACOG is definitely an interesting idea, I'd say go for it if it's your curiosity! Might want to add an offset or top mounted red dot, but in the interest of Partizan division maybe that hasn't survived whatever has gone down.

Jason Driver

2-12 everyone has used an ACOG and 1-something to death

Erick

PA 5x milrad prism if you can get one with an offset red dot

Danh8su

A soup can with dental floss for crosshairs!

Brock Gouett

I would like something fixed power. There have plenty of runs with LPVO’s so I’d like to see something different. The ACOG fits that or you could do a 3 power

Kyle P

2-10/12 with offset or top mounted dot

Haris122

Not to be a sadist but I’m going go throw out the idea of “iron sights”.

Horatio Nelson

I'd like to see an ACOG - could be that I'm a GWOT era optic Fudd but I still prefer an ACOG over most LPVOs (preferably a TA-11 with the longer eye relief)

Brandon Sandie

I agree with the others, most people will likely be using an lvpo. So though it may be challenging using acog, it will definitely be more interesting.

Retired No Bad Days

The whole idea about WWSD is use the best materials available. So, the 1-8 LPVO is a no brainer.

Retired No Bad Days

Don't forget to hide the long range targets to drive the ACOG guys nuts.

Bruce Brodnax

1-6 LPVO. 1-8s were ghostware when you guys began the WWSD project, 1-6s were cutting edge and 1-4s were the norm 7 years ago. But if it's DMR, then it's made for AT&T ["reach out & touch someone"] so the 1-6 would be most appropriate within the original params of the WWSD ["What Would Sullivan Do"] project...

Bruce Brodnax

Nice. How do you like that 3x prism? Have been considering that configuration myself [being perpetually broke & budget-minded...]

Steve T.

I like it a lot but wished they had come out with the mil reticle earlier, as that would have been my choice. The BDC works as advertised though. My primary goal was to keep the complete rifle under 7lbs, so optics weight was also part of my criteria in choosing it too. With the KP 15 lower and a slick side Aero upper, Aero 15" ATLAS R-ONE handguard, sling, and the 3x prism it is right at 6.9 lbs.

Ove Toranger

Perhaps a VORTEX RAZOR HD GEN II-E 1-6X24 ? Or a Gen III 1-10x ?

Matteo Manino

1-4 is more a general purpouse thing, 1-6 or 1-8 for a dedicated DMR.

HarFiend

For a modern WWSD, I would say go with the modern optic. If you were doing a GWOT run with a M16A4 I could see the ACOG, but I kinda think it is outdated at this point, not quite obsolescent, but its on it's way.

Knathaniel C

Not relevant for this particular event but at some point I'd like to see if the leupold Devo is worth a crap. Just something I wanted to float in case you know someone

Quacktar the Unforgiven

I'd vote for an Eotech Vudu 1-10 FFP LPVO. (The MOA version, since I don't speak MRAD.) As an aside to that, how hard would it be to make the WWSD lower have some kind of direct adjustment for length of pull and cheek weld for use as a DMR? I'm guessing that the ROI on something like that wouldn't be profitable.

BadgerTails

New here, obv some catching up to do on a brutal match; running and O course? DMR iMHO hits out to 600M, shot my load onto your 1-8 Alt...drive on

Louis Wu

Given the poll splits the vote between two LPVO options but it's still plurality LPVO I'd go with the most popular LPVO choice, the Tango. This is why ranked choice voting is best