Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

S&W released the TRR8 as a tactical revolver for mil/leo/hunting application - optics rail, light rail, 8 shots...but they also released this 2" version, lightweight and Scandium, as a carry gun.   Did it make sense then?  What about now?

Files

Comments

Emily

Very good video! My favourite videos tend to be your Old West stuff, but this was a really interesting video about a modern gun :) I find the idea of revolvers in the modern world of firearms fascinating (especially weird ones like these), but it's like you and Ian have said many, many times: if you're gonna carry a gun, don't think "interesting," think "practical". Your life might depend on it. A thing that strikes me as a "solution" to the problem with bulky moon clips is using half-moon clips, since surely they'd print better? It would, however, come with the problem that reloading now takes twice as long, which isn't ideal...

David Allee

An excellent and interesting video. I don't carry anymore but for decades I carried a 442, then a PC 642 in 38 Special. The moon clips and speed loaders were okay but still bulkier than I liked so I just tucked a speed strip in my pants pocket. I also loved Ahrends grips and I see a set on that gun. I really appreciate all that you are doing here Karl. :)

Arthur

Don't have much to add to the snubby discussion, but t's so green out there!

Jim Jam Shimmy Shatts

Have you ever tried the speed strips? My LRC is the lightest gun I own so it's the one that gets carried every day and i find speed strips convenient to carry and easy enough to use. I've never tried moon clips or a speed loader so maybe I shouldn't compare them, but speed strips certainly seem easier to use

Guido S

smith & wesson is talked here. got a 986. man those scandium cylinders cycle A LOT faster than steel ones, huh. the trr with cyclinder walls THAT thin no thank you! LOVE sw. but nailed to the point perfect carry size to me... ruger sp101 3". or in real hot environments as az or florida or something... J frame maybe? 2" or not.. a N will be big! did myself a moon loader DIY. just bought the arbor plastic thingy. unloading just a piece of copper pipe. 7rd 9mm not 8rd 357 though. don't get to carry cause... germany. so competing with that only.

Guido S

that 2incher is kind of.. why 357 and 2"? right. for same flavor easier than 357 lighter smaller... they did my 986 9mm as carry snubby. more sense than yours sizewise.

fineape

The cylinder on the this model of 327 is titanium not scandium. As for the Trr8/M&P R8 the cylinders are blacked stainless steel. I believe it's the same treatment that Smith uses on there M&P line of semiautos.

MechAg94

IMO, speed strips will carry a lot better, but are only a little faster to load than loose rounds. However, an 8 round moon clip is not small. You could carry a few speed strips in the pocket easier than one moon clip.

-Kris-

For a while I was getting paid very little and had to work 60 hours a week to stay housed. During that time, 9mm was also 60 cents per round, and every other centerfire cartridge was even more, and I had only just started carrying and trying to practice, and it was pretty cost-prohibitive to try to train with 9. So at that time I took advice from Rhett Neumayer, Darryl Bolke, and Chuck Haggard, and I carried a Ruger LCR in .22LR loaded with Federal Punch, which I tested in a class with Chuck Haggard to ensure sufficient penetration. That was 8 rounds in a gun I could actually conceal, in a cartridge that was still affordable enough for me to train with on a regular basis. Now that 9mm is 25 cents per round, I have a Sig P365X, which is almost exactly the same height and length as the LCR, but is thinner, takes a red dot, offers a 3-finger grip instead of 2, and holds 12+1 rounds of 9mm instead of 8 of .22LR (or 5-6 of a centerfire cartridge). I've owned and shot revolvers a lot, I like them, but I think these days you have to have a real specific niche in mind to choose one over an auto.