Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I have a question for you! I'd love to know what your opinion is. I'm working on this commission, and I'm wondering if you like a thicker lineart style, or a thinner one, considering my style overall.

(just curious. very curious)

Files

Comments

Super

The thinner lines look cleaner imo, and it tends toward the anime style. I prefer the one on the right. Your style works well with both for different pieces though.

Denson

I am not an artist of course but prefer the softer not as thick line art. Furthermore, I feel the thicker lines are somewhat overpowering and pull too much attention to them distracting from the rest of the piece. Additionally, the smaller lines seem a bit cleaner if that makes sense, allowing you to take in the entire piece in when looking at it.

Manu stuff

That is very insightful! Would you consider the thicker one more like a sketch-y style? But thank you for taking your time to reply!!

Manu stuff

Thank you so much! I see what you mean with the anime style, and I see why you prefer it. I'd love to make people choose between the two styles when commissioning me!

Denson

Somewhat yes. Perhaps having the colors be more saturated or dark can help them blend better with thicker line art? As a way to offset the line color

Manu stuff

I see what you mean. Thank you, will keep ya updated :))

Spedeb34rd

I prefer the thicker lines, both look good tho

Manu stuff

!! interesting, a thick line enjoyer. I also feel very comfortable with thick lines, so I'll definitely alternate between the two styles

Spedeb34rd

The thick line has been your sort of trademark for a while, so it's the one I'm more used to from you, not to say that the thinner lines wouldn't work

Shou Haruka

hmm, I like the thinner lines since they do look a little cleaner and more refined but from a distance there are certain regions that are hard to read because of colour contrasts (like with the outer vest and inner tank top) and it does make the colour look a little flat (because the thicker lines served to add some shading and contrast), so maybe playing with the colour a little and varying the thickness would be good!! bella e carina come sempre :) è interessante verere come sta evolvendo il tuo stile!

Manu stuff

Grazie mille!! It means a lot to me, really. I feel very disciplined lately, mainly because I'm living on my own (well, with a flatmate, but still). So I'm drawing a lloooot!