January wizard #2: Which is your favorite?? (Patreon)

Hey, is this a BONUS January wizard?? I hope so! I just applied to a local Valentines Day craft fair on a whim and got accepted, so I'm trying to make something sweet and pink to sell. I don't have any pink wizards yet, so...here we are! 

My partner Gannon and I have been in a heavy debate all night over which of these is our favorite, so I thought I'd open it up to outside opinions. Which do you like most? Your feedback is greatly appreciated! :)