Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hi friends,

The next Mentour Now! video will go out to YouTube subscribers on Monday, but of course we want our fantastic Patreon crew to see it first!

This is a deep dive into what happens when a country tries to go it alone when it comes to commercial aviation.

I'm really looking forward to seeing your comments on this one.

// Petter

Files

Previews only

PATREON EARLY ACCESS : Why These Jets May NEVER Take Off!

Comments

Lakshmi Kantha

Modern high BPR (actually low FPR, for higher propulsive efficiency), high core temperature (for higher thermodynamic efficiency), two-spool engines with a geared fan and light composite fan blades are engineering marvels and perhaps the most complex engines ever built by mankind. It takes decades to build the needed technology and skills to accomplish this task. Not many countries have the necessary knowhow and resources (money and human). True. However, unlike China, a late starter in the game, Russia has been at it quite a while. Contrary to the thinking in the West, the engineering skills of Russia are nothing to sneeze at. If you don't believe me, recall Sputnik, first man and woman in space etc. from the 1950's Soviet era, and more recently, the superb RD-180 first stage kerolox rocket engine and Hall Effect space thrusters, which Western engineers never even thought possible. RD-180 design philosophy is a worthy paradigm, unlike gold-plated expensive western designs like SSME. Just enough, cheap but highly robust and reliable is the reputation of RD-180. Communism played havoc with Russia and it has taken decades for Russia to recover from its travails, no thanks to the West. So they have fallen behind. But MC-21 is a superb design, even better than the Bombardier C-Series (Airbus A220) in some ways. However, Western sanctions designed to defeat Russia economically and militarily have made the task difficult as Petter has shown. But Russia has a modern engine PD-14 and composite technology. The shortfalls of MC-21 (5.75 tons overweight, not clear in just MOEM or MTOM - Yakovlev website shows 5.75 ton increase in MTOM, but no data on MOEM - this makes a difference) prototype will be fixed. Recall Boeing 787 "production" teens (less than number 20) were 8% overweight (MOEM) and hence resulted in 13% reduction in range for normal payload. But as experience was gained from actual flights, somme design restrictions were relaxed and some parts redesigned etc. and B787-8 met its design specifications, eventually. B787-9 did even better. I am sure MS-21 will do the same. PD-14 may not be as good as PW-1400G or CFM LEAP-1C, but will be "enough" with performance not too far behind. Russia and China have no need to sell their aircraft to the West. Their domestic markets are large enough. Oil is cheap in Russia and so fuel costs are not as critical as for Western airlines. "Time on the Wing" of engines and hence maintenance costs may be an issue, but ... their political systems allow for government subsidies for such a vital part of their economy and so won't be a concern as in the West, where fierce competition and lack of government help affect the very survival.

Lakshmi Kantha

It is important to remember that both Russia and China did not "choose" to "go alone" as MC-21 and C919 projects demonstrated, but are being forced to do so, due to nasty geopolitics! With survival at stake, I am sure they will succeed with "good enough" products that will satisfy their needs, even if not necessarily the "latest and the greatest."

WoT_Hog

Regarding your Novium pens infomercial: you didn't mention what color inks were available for the refills (if any), nor did you say anything about whether you actually liked writing with it, or other cool features such as if it writes upside down or under water like certain brands of space pens.

Charlie

When I click on the link the video came back as private. I am a member.

mentourpilot

Hi Charlie. Apologies for this, it’s because our regular channel manager is on vacation and the stand-in has scheduled the video for release in one hour, that turned the video into private while we wait.

mentourpilot

Hi! I love using them actually. The ones o have are both blue but I’m not sure if that is something you can order.