Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

WATCH EXTENDED EPISODE REACTION HERE :)

Kuina was done dirty...

Now Available for The Phantom Troupe!

Files

Previews only

Comments

Pepperoni Pony .

I've seen this episode a dozen times, and the more I watch it the more I appreciate it. I feel that when Kuina's father first saw Zoro and heard his challenge he saw an opportunity to help his daughter grow as a person. While the translation described herself as self-conceited I feel like from what was shown it was more like she was the big fish in a very small pond. Once you're better than everyone around you it's easy to rest on your laurels. With Zoro around, they pushed each other forward as good rivals should. I also wonder about the scene where Kuina was eavesdropping and heard her father say he couldn't leave the dojo to her 'as she is now'. I had to watch the episode several times over the years to pick up on that. It's very easy to tell children that they can be anything they want to be, but it's also fairly lazy on the part of the adult. It might be technically or statistically possible, but knowing when to temper a child's unreasonable expectations versus allowing them to find out on their own is a difficult part of parenting. And in the world of swordsmanship it would be easy to imagine that 'finding out the hard way' may entail death. His very neutral demeanor and the limited amount of screen time he had makes it hard to understand his true motives. Kuina was as obsessed with being the greatest swordsman as Zoro, but could she find happiness in running the Dojo if she failed at her goal? Or if she gave up? It might be cruel to leave the dojo to her if she were unable to reconcile not being the best. Perhaps he wanted her to regard swordsmanship as a passion instead of an unattainable goal. Difference in gender aside, only one person can be the best at any given time and that's a monumental quest that everyone in a lifetime will fail except for one person. Whatever the real reasons are, it gives Zoro a truly compelling reason to chase his and Kuina's dream, and makes every setback and victory he experiences so much more meaningful.

Anton

I've heard the theory of the dad killing her from others, but to me it makes no sense. Not only is there no motiviation to do so, since she wouldn't ever inherit the dojo despite him acknowledging her breaking expectations for girls; but it makes less sense in the way the manga tells it, where the flashback is more brief. I feel it's only the way the anime portrays it, with him being emotionless and professional over her death (even if I do prefer how the anime portrays the flashback over the manga, personally).