Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Since everyone has been so helpful with the title of Jake's #2, I figured I'd just share one of the dilemmas I'm currently facing for the JMM2 audiobook. TL:DR at the bottom.

Basically, Travis Baldree has NO availability. He is booked until 2026 and isn't even accepting bookings into 2026 because he doesn't know what he'll be doing. He is publishing his own books and was already slammed for time, so it is literally impossible to get a slot with him right now.

I have a couple of options on what to do. There is one audiobook company (Podium) that has a few open slots pre-reserved in 2024/25 with Travis. I could potentially sign with them to secure those slots, but signing with them typically involves a HUGE cut of my royalties. I'm in negotiations with them now just to see what they will offer me, but I expect even the most generous offer they give me they're gonna take like 60% of my royalties or more. The more likely cut might be even more than that. Meaning they keep the majority of the money the audiobook makes. That's a lot of money that I need to be able to keep writing full-time.The other option is produce JMM2 myself, but that would require me to hire a new narrator. I know how much people hate when a new narrator takes over a series. If I had to go with a new narrator, I could either keep book one with Travis and just hire a new narrator for book two OR I could remake book one with the new narrator and release it and book two at the same time, that way people have the same narrator for both books.If I don't re-release book one with the new narrator, then I get to keep all the royalties for book two myself but then book #1 is Travis and book two is someone else. If I re-release book one with a new narrator, then I likely have to bargain with the original audiobook company to have them re-make #1 for me, which means they'd get a cut of book 1/2 as well (mostly likely). But their terms are more favorable than Podium's are likely to be, so I wouldn't lose quite so much - but obviously I'd lose more than keeping all royalties myself.The benefit of this would be I could likely get the audio out sooner and I get to keep more of my own money. No matter what, the situation is a total mess and I'm struggling to decide what is best to do.Here's the TL:DR options:1) Sign with Podium to have Travis narrate sometime in 2024/2025, lose a huge chunk of royalties.2) Hire a new narrator. Produce book two myself, keep Travis for book one, have fans be upset about the switch in narrators. Keep all the royalties myself, minus paying out of pocket for the new narrator.3) Hire a new narrator. Bargain with my original company to remake book one with the new narrator, give them a portion of royalties for book two to get them to agree. Get to keep more royalties than with option #1, but have to pay to remake book two, and people might still be upset at Travis no longer narrating + upset they might have to buy book #1 again to have the same narrator.Thoughts?

Comments

Anthony Glenn

Go with option 2 or 3. 3 is a much cleaner break for fans and won't put off new fans which should be a concern. Travis is great but is he 60+% royalty great? Plus what about any future stories, if there are any? A clean break now before you're too deep in is a better option. My 2 cents.

Brandon

2! Keep it simple and keep your money, you earned it. Sometimes new narrators can be a good thing.

Ethan Gibbens

That is kind of you to ask. My opinion would be to keep the larger share of profits and not deal with book 1. I am more looking forward to your career than worried about a different author. You are in a pickle so it is understandable. What a crappy position to be in

Kyle Hempel

First of all, Podium does some good work, and Travis is an amazing narrator, but that being said, I would be leaning toward something between options 2 and 3. I you found a good narrator for book 2, does your contract not allow you to pay out of pocket to remake book one? If it doesn't, I would see if you could negotiate to pay the production costs and let the original company keep whatever royalty they have on the first book for both narrated versions (still keeping book two as self-published). I have to believe that a good compromise can be made somewhere here. Either way I wish you look and I am looking forward to whatever way the audiobook comes out.

Brandon Wright

My vote is #2 - I feel that people will get over having different narrators eventually, especially if you continue using the 2nd narrator moving forward.

JumpingPotatoSack

I don’t listen to audiobooks now but I did as a kid, and I personally was indifferent to when the narrator for certain books was different, I just wanted to experience the story. And since that was the first book narrated in the series, and that it was so well written and received, I think changing the narrator for the second book and keeping the first one as is should be fine. As long its not some guy breathing heavily into the mike and eating chips that is. So yeah, go with 2. And who knows, the new narrator you hire could have the voice of God.

K P

I’d say option 2. I’m guessing all the people here are really into your characters and stories. And you need to make a living that allows you to keep writing the stories we love. So I say let’s all be a little selfish. You for the money so you can live your life and write or do whatever you want to do. And the rest of so we get the chance to read your stories.

MambaDown

I would recommend number three just because I'm biased enough to put out Andy Weir as a new narrator. I'm not sure of his availability, but I love his performance. He puts so much emotion into his narration and is one of the only people I know that adds implied mannerisms (sighing after something depressing is said for example). He makes it sound less like you're listening to an audiobook and more like you're actively listening to him living in the moment of the book

Joe

Option #3 is the best. Travis is great. But there are others out there too that are great. People are usually upset with the change in narrators because the feel of the story is different with a new narrator. It is extremely important, in my opinion, to have the same narrator. It doesn't have to be Travis, but it should be the same person. Option 3 keeps the best of all worlds. Also, when you are selecting a new narrator, hopefully you can find someone good that is also not as busy. Just my hopes and thoughts. There are, in fact, some readers (read me, for instance) that would get the book again just to see how the new narrator interprets it. It's a thought. Option 3 makes the most sense.

ReadingObsessed

Can you sell book two as a bundle? Make it a bit more money but the bundle is with the new narrator both times?

Verdant Sovereign

That's tough, like others have said though you have to think about what's best for you personally going forward. Are you planning more books for this series going forward? Do you have other series planned? I read the first book and loved the voice you used for Jake even without the audio. Narrators should adapt their own recording to that and it should carry through to the audio book experience. It's a tough choice but if option 2 lets you keep writing and expanding your series' then that may be the best option for you and your fans. Good luck and just know you will still have support no matter the result!

Jayhester12

I myself will listen no matter what. I don’t mind the change but I’m probably not the majority lol.

Reno

I haven't read/listened to the story yet, so take everything I say with a pinch of salt, but my concern here wouldn't just be with audiobook 2. If you're planning to continue the story into books 3, 4 etc, pick an option that works long term too. Otherwise you might end up with the same dilemma for the next book and potentially waste more money. And yeah, people will be upset if you change narrators. Enough to have a "stain" that stops people from continuing, or one which hurts your portfolio of books long term, whatever such a portfolio is worth. Whatever your choice, be open to the readers/listeners. Dakota Krout did something funny with the narrators of one of his ending books and acted disingenuous about it (he tried hard to explain away a different narrator as character growth without giving another reason), so I'm not checking out his other works again because it just didn't seem like he cares about what readers think. People were more upset with his responses than with the change of narrators itself. IMO I wouldn't leave it be with two different narrators because you'll get bad reviews. Having a good portfolio and track record has its uses even if it's only a way to advertise better revenue streams. Especially if you don't have a lot of series. Other than that, do whatever pays enough for happy living. From what I hear, Audible's royalties are already pretty bad.

Cameron M Pierce

I think that option 2 is the best. It's better to change narrators than to cripple your earnings. You could check in with Michael Chatfield to see how it went with his community after re-recording some of the Two Week Curse audio books for additional input. Having two versions of the audiobook for the customer to choose from could be a good option as well. My brother is not a fan of Will Wheaton's narration of Ready Player One and I have to listen to his complaints from time to time as he listens to it over and again because he loves the story; he keeps dreaming of a new recording with a different narrator. It could be that your new narrator knocks your socks off and you really want them to record a version of book 1 down the road.

Gabe

I personally will be really bummed if Travis does not continue into the second book since his performance for the first was partially what made the story one of my favorites. However, I recently picked up the first nova roma audiobook to re-experience the story and am happy with who you picked for the narrator! He just fits so well as Alexander. So long/short, go 2.

Eric

I'd go with option 2. I wouldn't really mind the change in narrators. Travis was great, but as mentioned in other comments, there are lots of fantastic options. I also think the change could work, since Jake is evolving at the end of the first book.

Tezq Gelrock

I've seen authors in similar situations to your own take different stances. Out of all the options I’ve seen, the most annoying would be to not release any additional audio books for the series. Which I’m glad your not even entertaining since I prefer audio when its an option. Though I understand that this path may be the one with the least drama in certain situations. Out of the options you’ve listed I would suggest option 2, just releasing book 2, it's the most logical option. It’s the most financially responsible option that enables you to continue your writing. I would also support Option 3, re-releasing book 1, but not if it will cause a long term burden/loss. As stated above, openness and transparency in this aspect is extremely important. It shapes the discussion around the constraints/consequences of the available paths, and enables us understand why it was necessary for you to take less popular choices. The knowledge that you will loose at a minimum of 60% before other fees/cuts or wait for 2 years, makes any other choice significantly more palatable.

Brandon

Ramon De Ocampo is good. Voice would match with character well.

Brandon

You are gonna have to pay out of pocket to get a narrator to read a book (book 1) that sales are going to be low for. They won't get much on sales since most people aren't going to buy another. Don't worry about book 1. Children will whine, but this is business and you will make nothing if you have to pay for narration for two books with the sales of one

Alan Vitale

I understand the advantages accruing from the same narrator… continuity and a comfort level with a tried and true industry voice. Travis is great, no question. However, as good as he is, you may be missing the point. YOUR writing is the reason we follow you. Not the narrator, but your characters. A year or two wait to reserve a time slot from Travis seems long… and may result in lost readers in the interim, and by extension, lost earnings. The long reserve time needed to book Travis is a sign that the industry is maturing… and it would pay to develop alternative options for when Travis isn’t available, (which could be a lot) Heck, you may even benefit from trying on new voices the same way the New England Patriots tried out an untested back up QB named Tom Brady… admittedly a stretch. My advice is assure yourself the income stream you need and get the text to market with someone you trust. Then, add a writers note at the start to explain the situation (as much as you’re comfortable revealing) and move on with your work. Your Nova Roma series is off the charts entertainment and I cannot wait to see where it goes. IMO, that and the Primal Hunter series are the best in the business. If it’s any consolation, I’d buy your release if it was read by a geriatric potato farmer. So trust your work and thanks for asking. Whatever happens, I can’t wait… and I’m not alone.

Travis Snelgrove

Honestly I would do option 3 and try to get a female and male narrator, I personally mostly but audiobooks and I find when they only have either make or female it becomes very hard to listen to because one person can only do so many voices, there are exceptions like Travis but again he's a rare case.

Justin Zaun

I don’t mind switching narrators, though it’s always nice when the original is rereleased so it’s all the same. Several series have done this recently. If you do go on your own to hire someone, give a new person a chance 😀 there are a lot of amazing narrators out there already but they all seem to be booked for the next few years! Awesome for them but hard for authors to get out new books. Someone new might be an option.

Gabe

I just listened to the audiobook again and I have to reiterate what I said in my earlier comment. I'd be really bummed if you switched narrators. I understand if you do but Travis just does such a fantastic job with the humor but keeps the serious bits around for when it calls. The Shadeslinger series is also amazing due to the humor involved. If you take JMM in a more serious direction I think switching could work. Just my take!