Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

This is a podcast about the internet. It is not a real episode of anything. No research was done. This place is not a place of honour. No highly esteemed deed is commemorated here. Nothing valued is here.

This episode is about the numbers beside a certain list of records and the long shadow of the pause game.

Files

Comments

SFULTRA

Somehow missed one of the main things I wanted to talk about which is the way the list just gives up, after years of attempts at compromise, and reclassifies mixtapes as "albums", despite the differences being extremely important.

anthropophagoose

Loved the first half of this (not a shot at the second half- just felt compelled to comment before I finished) So many more interesting things to talk about on the list than the ranking. One thing I've been thinking a lot about, tying into the whole regional revisionism angle, is the way East Coast/NY rap has been distilled, sort of ahistorically, into a really obvious cannon, and then all the other stuff is just absent, mostly because it's just not very cool I think? Like you are not going to see Fabolous or Terror Squad folks on a list like this, but that shit is still ubiquitous in NY and anywhere else that lots of people from NY live... I've heard Fab playing over more slice shop speakers than I ever have Drake. It actually feels really similar to the importance of someone like Boosie to the larger canon as a largely regional artist, just in terms of being the thing you are actually hearing out of every car window in a huge area. I mean, you can make an argument I'd largely agree with that Boosie is a more compelling (albeit more frustrating) artist than Fab or Fat Joe, but if we admit that a list like this is really more about overview than qualitative ranking, it feels interesting to have whole chunks of stuff like that missing

Jonathan Kennedy

Listening to Jim Cornett at all, never mind for three weeks nonstop, would absolutely destroy me.

Joe Briggs

If Pitchfork had done its 100 Greatest Hip Hop albums 20 years ago what position do you think they would have had Nerdcore Rising?

Ruairí

"Got caught with the pork But you gotta kill the cop in your thoughts, still sayin' 'Pause'" – billy woods

Shapey Fiend

I first became aware of rap music during the Vanilla Ice, MC Hammer and Snow era then skipped the golden era so luckily my taste wasn’t irreparably damaged. I’m stealing the opinion rap is a singles genre off Noz but tbf I have always listened to it like that anyway. Who doesn't know that lists are rage bait at this stage in their lives? I've heard multiple 90's magazine journalists explain the process. I’m watching the new season of Beavis & Butthead with my son so constantly being interrupted with “You said X.. uhuhuhuh” for the foreeable.

Jess Harvell

only halfway through, so apologies if I'm repeating anything, but from what i remember of the (roughly) first three or four years of the new millennium (back when my relationship to pitchfork was directly mocking Ryan for his bad website on ILM), the big problem with pitchfork (and basically all the sites/blogs launched by dudes who'd spent the previous five to ten years reading indie-related zines) is that the gaps went way beyond rap. they were basically covering * nothing * besides indie/alt rock, and whatever coverage of other genres they did deign to offer was laughable in terms of historical knowledge, current context, condescension, basic factual fuckups, performative racism, etc. we are all familiar with pitchfork’s early stabs at writing about metal, jazz, dance music, R&B, rap, etc. it was infuriating because (as a cantankerous guy in my early 20s) everything interesting at the time seemed to be happening outside of guitar shit. my recollection is that started changing between like 2004 and 2006 when scott became editor, making a point to reach out to writers who covered certain things the site did poorly (I was one of them, but I upheld the site’s tradition of writing poorly), and then later mark. (if anything i feel like the problem with pitchfork’s rap coverage between like 2005 and 2012 was a surfeit of white indie guys who were born again street rap evangelists, but without the depth of knowledge and personal investment of noz or drake or whoever.) but you're right that it was a long road. i feel like only in the last five to ten years did they achieve an actual balance between indie rock and the “other stuff” in terms of coverage. (in the past few years it seems like you're more likely to get multiple rap reviews per day than multiple straight-ahead rock reviews.) of course this is all just casual observation after a certain point, since I am definitely one of those people who *can* admit they aged out of the hustle. (by the end it was a relief, as I suspect it is for many people who spend a decade grinding out reviews for any medium.) it seems telling that the only negative reaction I saw to this list (didn't even click on it, not remotely my problem at this point in my life) was from old folks, who likely haven't read the site regularly in years (if ever). it's a young person’s game! even if youth occasionally gets the better of them in terms of a longer/deeper view of music history, i’d rather that than a bunch of elderly cranks dismissing anything new out of hand or people with age-related back problems pretending they still go to the club. the guy currently running things after conde nuked the old staff seems very young (to me) and seems to have hired from a similar pool of people who barely remember life before youtube, which is probably wise for the market but again none of my business. this went way longer than I intended so the last thing i will say is that based on certain things I remember chris ott saying about black music in non-public venues, an audience of school shooters is about all he deserves.

HC

Nothing insightful to say aside from: Chris Ott Mentioned

Dan Taipua

*Old-ass man with a Pubic Enemy shirt checking in* Weirdest thing for me is the lionization of the album format, absolutely a rockist invention, not that important unless you are a guy who lives in a time and place and within a demographic.

astrid

75 best john prine voice cracks LOL

Fripponomics

One of the most illustrative examples of the shifting critical canon shifting has to be the Rolling Stone's 500 Worst Reviews of All Time list on RYM

Kev

At the beginning, I thought you were saying “Dae Woo” and I was like “oh I better look them up, who’s that, how have I missed them?” Had no idea Ghost had an album out; Raekwon mentioned his dropped the same day as the Philly concert. There’s a few songs I really like (600 school probably the peak), none I really hate. I write all this other stuff but now I’m thinking about the influences of the Israelites and the 5% nation. Deeply ingrained. You’ve got an interesting approach to Pitchfork and Rolling Stones lists. It’s cool that they have a voting process (transparency or whatever) and that you think of it as a space for possible engagement. I’ve thought from time to time that these rankings of any medium or genre aren’t necessarily the best of anything but the favorites of the people writing it or, as you say, the ones they’re most interested in discussing at the time. I have found that people know that the whole thing is just a framework to troll/talk about some stuff (songs, albums, movies, games, whatever) but like you say push past that acknowledgment to find something to be mad about. (And I keep mentioning games because “these aren’t the same rappers/guitarists I liked 15 years ago” is reminding me of when folks, myself admittedly among them, commented on The Rolling Stones best videogames list being “presentist” and “safe” probably largely—though I’d contend not exclusively—to do with the numbering.) I also hate the enforcement of orthodoxy and appreciate its naming here; feel like it’s a big part of the movie internet (including tying into the unnamed four screenshots style of posting you were talking about on the first murders episode). And the importance and legitimacy comes from people getting so annoyed. Like, none of these publications has any “objective” authority on what the best albums of any genre are, but people create that authority by being annoyed they made the “wrong” choices or are in the “wrong” order, which I guess does its own generation of discussion. E.g., who cares what rolling stone considers important video games? … except that because they’re outside of the [overlarge, corporate] subculture, they’re given a lofty perch as cultural arbiters. The actual value, as you say, is probably in learning about some piece of art we didn’t already know about. Infinite Coles “somehow ties this all together,” like that wasn’t the plan. Dame saying he knew Jay was leaving when he stopped playing the pause game is incredible. My lasting image of Dame is in the *last* Kanye docuseries (jeen-yuhs) before the new one, where in the early part you see Dame as this guy with a lot of money and authority just doing very little promotion for College Dropout and showing up at Kanye’s release party in the middle of his rehearsed rant about the label not supporting him, to in the later part during the recording of, I think, Ye, where he’s milling about as one more person waiting on Kanye to stop saying weird shit and just finish his album (the way the cinematography and the narrative contrasts over this 10+ year period makes it seem like Dame goes from being important to someone else for whom Kanye is a lodestar/meal ticket). Don’t know that you were talking about me specifically (that would be conceited in addition to parasocial), but entrepreneurship being considered exceptionally “ethical” is different in my estimation than entrepreneurship *being thought of differently than “selling-out” within some parts of resource-deprived communities*. I’m pretty fervently against “black capitalism will save us” (including within the record industry) but I understand the impetus. Comment on rap and country music reminded me, in addition to Shaboozey, of all the hubbub around Lil Nas X and Old Town Road, or - in a pretty different but definitely tangentially connected way - Beyoncé’s last album. Your comment on the broadening of the genre and people’s myopia or regional biases is interesting too because at the same time as rap is accurately critiqued for rampant reflexive casual homophobia, it’s also easier to name (at least in 2025) multiple prominent queer rappers (Big Freedia, Saucy Santana, Lil Nas X, Cardi B, the aforementioned Tyler, for example) than prominent queer, well, country singers for one. (Or maybe that’s my own genre biases) The brief mention of Tyler the Creator reminded me of a recent social media dustup I heard about but didn’t see regarding his old tweets and youthful provocations spurred by some of his present young fans not knowing who D’Angelo was (with a step in there about how he’s cultivated a largely white fan base, which - as I believe you mentioned on account of populations generally - is not as uncommon as people sometimes posture)? (This is all funny for several reasons, the most obvious being he’s always been transgressive and provocative, which is an observation rather than an endorsement—I just didn’t know that people didn’t know about his tweets from 15 years ago, because that’s when I started following him; and separately that was also when I learned who D’Angelo was, already almost a decade late, whereas if one has only been following Tyler’s work since IGOR or is between 17-24, you might not have that context, I guess)

Robert Aitken

not a good side for humanity in general that we still haven’t figured out lists are just made to make us mad. good chance you are but are you familiar with the Pro Wrestling Illustrated lists? they’re ranked by *kayfabe* accomplishments and people still get mad like they can’t believe The Incredible Hulk isn’t higher in the Wizard Magazine character rankings. still might not be as embarrassing as every year when people need it explained that it isn’t the Time Magazine *Best* Person of the Year