Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Welcome to the show where you receive recommendations directly from someone afflicted with Perfect Taste Forever.

This is about a podcast about the film Predators - 2025 - David Osit. Content warning: discussion from the beginning of the kind of thing associated with To Catch A Predator.

Comments

Jess Harvell

it's funny, for the first half of the episode i was thinking: materially things are much worse, and politically things are far graver for basically everyone who isn't a white man, but culturally life in the US felt more diseased to me in the 2000s than it does now. part of that is just a last-gasp-of-the-monoculture thing probably. i’m sure the stuff being pumped out on TV is just as deranged now, but it impacts me very little outside of the occasional glancing contact via social media, where in 2004 a show produced by NBC felt culturally inescapable and the bulk of what mainstream US entertainment was creating felt similarly disgusting. (i watched a few episodes of t.c.a.p. in my callow 20s, and I'd like to say I stopped watching out of some moral conviction but it was probably just that it all felt repetitive and sad.) then of course you got to the stuff about streamers (that tiktok boxer, jesus christ) and yeah of course things are just as bad or even worse, it's just easier to opt out of various cultural inputs. the whole discourse around the modern wave of streaming pedo hunters is so poisoned by bad faith political stuff (and also a basic understandable instinctual revulsion to the men committing these crimes) that the existence of this doc is actually surprising to me. (the letterboxd reviews are not.) i have seen some minor pushback on twitter, but people immediately get jumped on for saying maybe encouraging vigilante justice by morons who'd be doing prank youtubes or some other content scam otherwise isn't great, so i do understand why most people don't bother. on the other hand there's now a generation of new adults with first-hand knowledge of what qanon etc did to their parents and grandparents so who knows.

Harper High

“What do we owe morally to the worst people in society?” is not a question most are interested in answering, I find. Some for good reason, but also something some of the worst people in society have a personal interest in not answering. I find even vicarious cruelty extremely emotionally draining, so it’s really easy for me to say that we should put limits on how we act even towards complete monsters. But I think even the way I’m inclined to talk about it kinda shows why it’s difficult to speak about. Like there are people who may oppose the death penalty in the abstract, but then say, “Well, of course, Charles Manson must die.” Very understandable opinion, but it makes it hard to be honest about limits without gesturing vaguely and not explicitly mentioning pedophiles or specific murderers.

Ethan Fowler

Fascinated by the weirdness of how the Youtuber copycats are compelled to maneuver within the shape of their content and its worldview, what that looks like when it runs up against the complicated reality.

drei dog

Great ep and definitely credit to you for grappling with this stuff, I’m getting my masters in social work rn and one of my clinical professors specializes in perpetrators of sexual abuse, often specifically with pedophiles, and it was kind of incredible and alarming to see how much hatred bled out of otherwise extremely compassionate and morally decent people when the topic of pedophiles was discussed, my professor even admitted to passing on certain clients bc he felt too much contempt toward them, in school the idea of minority stress processes is often discussed which is basically the experience of being a minority and feeling that the world hates you, obviously this is a varyingly accurate thing to feel, but in the case of pedos it really is basically true

sebastian

Wild to me how many ostensibly anti-carceral anti-cop ppl I’ve known irl and interacted with online who will see a cop mag-dump a suspected sexual predator and be like “yes more of that pls.” I’m far from knowledgable enough to make a definitive pronouncement about what did or didn’t trigger this or how much of this is the result of or complicated by lived experiences or cultural stuff, but i do feel like TrueAnon emboldened a lot of people to the “hammer, nail” dichotomy wrt predators; like zero nuance, scorched earth policy.

Jerelephant

This is the third time you've covered a doc I've seen at a local documentary film festival. The other two are Spermwold and Zodiac Killer Project. So I'll fan this flame a little bit and give you a few more recommendations of documentaries I've seen over the past couple years at this festival: The Dating Game - Dir. Violet Du Feng Middletown - Dir. Jesse Moss and Amanda McBaine Agent of Happiness - Dir. Arun Bhattarai and Dorottya Zurbó Alien Island - Dir. Cristóbal Valenzuela Berrios Dancing on the Edge of a Volcano - Dir. Cyril Aris Look Into My Eyes - Dir. Lana Wilson If you can find them, I hope you enjoy them. Thank you for all of your great work over the years.

Najwa Red

I have an eight year old. She walked in while I was at the end of this doc- I happened to watch it a few hours before you posted this ep- and she wanted me to explain the subject. Keeping her safe while resisting the paranoid urge that my own mom and now the entire fuckin rest of society feels is probably the hardest part of parenting. It was not exactly upsetting to have this talk with her but it was really difficult to articulate my moral position on TCAP and predator hunting at her level, even more difficult to explain to her why this type of vigilantism doesn’t make the world better. I was preyed on online (and elsewhere), I have a child who that could happen to, and yet I easily abstain from this weird bloodthirstiness. I have been talking a lot in the last year about how children are an oppressed class. Even other Marxists have a hard time internalizing that fact. I think this reactionary pedohunter shit really lays that bare. If a conservative has the same position as you on it when clearly they don’t actually care at all about the safety of children maybe you should interrogate your ideology? Getting all pruriently punitive does nothing to liberate and protect children.

Zach

I just listened to Osit’s appearance on How Was Your Week. One observation that Julie (personal friend) makes is that there’s a direct line between the predator hunters’ appointing themselves judge/jury/executioner and the current trashing of due process by ICE. It’s a great conversation, and Osit is good at talking about his work.

MJ Sanchez

could not stop hearing that one tiktok of the guy doin a chris hansen impression asking for a slice of pizza in my head

Kev

Seldom felt more on the same page than when you derided people that don’t want to hear about copaganda anymore because they read the word three times in 2020. Might’ve said “thank you” out loud. Real talk radio feedback vibes. Glad you mentioned the boondocks because when I hear the name “Chris Hansen,” My mind goes to his cameo in the “Booty Warrior” episode. Appreciate your insights and reminders of the constructed nature of thrill seeking infotainment that tries to pass itself off as crusading for good when it’s more about profiting from suffering than anything. Especially when it’s extremely evident by the wealth of predators networking in our institutions (some of which facilitate abuse to the extent that that seems a tertiary purpose at least, and in one very high profile instance seems to - let’s say “quite plausibly” and not *very clearly* - be an intelligence blackmail op) that a project like to catch a predator or a million YouTube copies could never do what they pretend to, even if they genuinely were interested. It’s just another smoke screen, in a way. I guess society relies on a lot of self-delusion that way, buying into one’s own grift.