Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • PFT47.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

Welcome to the show where you receive recommendations directly from someone cursed with Perfect Taste Forever.

This episode is under the thumb of big sentence.

Comments

Aaron King

Thank you for deLishing me.

Jolene Zubrow

Okay i was driving home from a reading group listening to this, and thinking about how Garielle Lutz is like a dark-sided version of Rachel Anne Bouvier, who is also a trans woman living in Pittsburgh, like Garielle. Bouvier’s thing, though, is that for many many years now, she has rented out the same billboard to display her poetry, which is all very….hard to describe? It’s all very lovey-dovey, almost greeting card esque. I was thinking about it because I was discussing it with someone, who was describing how she saw the billboard partially obscured, but filled in the line she couldn’t see on the assumption that it would make a rhyming couplet. When she did see the full billboard though, the line didn’t rhyme, and in fact ended very flatly and plainly, but in a way that sort of reinvigorates the poetry by virtue of it’s inappropriateness? It reminds me of Lutz, for some reason. And right as I was thinking about all this, you mentioned Lutz!

drei dog

Cheered and dismayed to learn that Lish was not a militantly workmanlike minimalist but rather a pseudomystical charlatan (complimentary), excellent work!

Sasha

I don't know if this was remainder'd exactly but when The Beguiling moved from Mirvish Village (a genuine tragedy for that area because it is a bummer walking down there now) I did buy that Gary Panter set on markdown and kept that thing dry from the rain on my way home somehow.

Evan Douglas

I bought the Complete Lutz years ago and it’s lived unread on my shelf in three different apartments now. I’m excited to finally crack it open tonight. I’m (blissfully?) out of the loop of practically any literary news, so I had no idea she had transitioned until listening to your pod. Always feels a little odd reading older editions published under previous names (Perciado comes to mind), but I guess that’s just a strange condition of collecting physical media.

Frent

Not all of us bought the Gary Panter boxset from the remainders table, I bought it in the Picture Box closing down sale.

Jess Harvell

great, great episode. those carver stories meant a lot to me in my late 20s (i haven't read them in at least 15 years, so maybe they still would), but even before the d.t. max piece i remember not really enjoying the pre-lish/post-lish stories in where i'm calling from, thinking they were too baggy, too sentimental. (they had, and i say this as someone who was/is also an alcoholic, so it's less a judgment than a recognition, the kind of big-hearted soppiness/sloppiness you often get with writers who are also famous drunks.) obviously who knows what kind of writer carver would have evolved into, but it was definitely a weird thing to realize that very specific voice that drew you in might have actually been someone else’s. i guess having occupied all three positions (reader, writer, editor) i’m of three different minds about this. as a reader, if something gives me that hell yeah buddy feeling, it ultimately doesn't really matter how much was writer, editor, whoever. as a writer, obviously i get carver’s position/discomfort. no one wants to think they owe their career to another guy, or that what the public is positively responding to is actually the invention/intervention of someone else. the extent of the edits (and the kind of high-handed, take-it-or-leave-it attitude lish seemed to have) obviously makes this feel different from the usual primadonna griping about how editors (much like parents) just don't understand. (the vollmann thing, essentially.) but those are the really great carver stories so… as an editor, well, a few times early on i was like “i don't really have time for a huge back and forth, so i’m just going to chop this into the shape i feel best,” and as you can imagine it did not endear me to those writers. for me an actual negotiation between writer and editor is kind of delicate work, with compromises on both sides, a conception of the job that would probably have lish calling me a soft-hearted baby or maybe just a slur. it's weird because obviously he was interested in nurturing writers, cared about them and their work, but also had a massive (and not entirely unearned) ego that had no problem making people feel like shit if he felt they failed his standards. i can understand why people wouldn't want to put up with that (i wouldn’t, his classes sound like hell on earth), but of course you look at the list of writers he discovered, taught, and/or edited and again it’s hard to argue with the results. i tried one of lish’s own books like 20 years ago (probably after hearing that bookworm interview) and did not vibe with it at all (it felt kind of wacky in a demented literary vaudeville routine way that maybe i was too young to get), but you did make me curious about trying again with this particular novel (which at the rate I'm reading these days i’ll probably get to in 2037, but nevertheless).

David Chapman

The long-awaited Kid Podcast x Captain Fiction crossover!

Tombstonehead

For what it’s worth, I don’t think you’re fucking up the podcast. I love it. I also love how you paraphrased the “attack sentence” of Lolita. I can’t stop laughing about it

aws

Visual imagination, it’s a continuum. You actually do have light receptors inside your head, a genuine third eye in a sense, and a mechanism for projecting light onto it, and I’m not talking about the normal process of light that goes in through the eyeballs. It gets more active when you’re dreaming. Can’t remember the name of this organ. Do you have visual dreams? Maybe you were born without a projector.

Joe Briggs

It's funny that Bourdain hated Lish as they both remind me in their bombast of the same bloke and that's Henry Rollins. That unapologetic confrontational approach to art and writing also reminds me of some of the futurists like FT Marinetti, particularly his introduction to Mafarka the Futurist. A short piece I was very taken with as a teenager. I think it's interesting that the art critiquing and commenting on true crime were there from the very start. I can think of more recent examples like John Darnielle's Devil House in reaponse to the absolute glut of serial killer stuff about nowadays or Jake Arnott's truecrime which takes on the 90s kraysploitation craze that the first part of that trilogy itself was a part of. The mechanics of a sentence fascinate me. There is always more going on beneath the surface than needs to be known. I don't think the reader needs to know that stuff, but the writer should and if they don't I guess the thing that editors and Lish maybe in particular can draw out or make them question. In my job I have to know about all sorts of stuff about how English works like tone units and adjective order or ablaut reduplication but you don't need to know that to speak the language, to use it for a lot of purposes, but if you're using it as your tool then understanding it this more molecular level is certainly an asset, like listening to a director talk in detail about what lenses they used. The film's audience doesn't need to know but the artist or worker should. At one point I got interested in replacing every latinate word in a piece of writing I was doing with phrasal verbs, a kind of grubby take on Poul Anderson's Uncleftish Beholding. I've definitely thought words on that level in lyric writing, I remember a long discussion with tla member of a band about whether a line should be 'the fence you're on' or 'the fence you walk' because I feltz regardless of subtleties of meaning difference, the line needed a hard /k/ plosive not a soft /n/ nasal as its punctuation. A lot of the writers that I really love are sentence writers: Toni Morrison, Cormac McCarthy, Steve Aylett, Will Christopher Baer, Lutz of course, but then I also prefer novels to short stories when it's very hard to maintain that sentence by sentence intensity over a longer form and thus the ones that do feel like miracles. Despite being a language teacher I am a pretty pathetic monoglot so the idea of translation always baffles and astounds me. A friend of mine wrote a novel in her second language and then it was translated into her first. I feel like a word might have 5 or 6 connotations, in sound, reference, form, shape, a translation is lucky to get two of these. In a sense everything is both translatable and untranslatable. Lately I've been reading some Knausgard who is the least sentence writer you can imagine. It's easy to see why he works in translation. The art comes from the accumulation of detail and personal moments communicated in a flat affect. In Where I'm Calling From, the last collection published in his lifetime, some of the stories are more similar to the manuscript versions from Beginners and some are the Lish versions which suggests to me that Carver probably agreed with him sometimes and that it wasn't as directly adversarial relationship as is often portrayed. Only recently realised that the person who gave Carver the 'dirty realist' label was Bill Buford, writer of the seminal book on English football hooliganism Among the Thugs, surely an influence on Arnott in his books. Anyway, I for one am shocked Sean that you'd be into a book in which someone introduces themselves over and over again in various convoluted ways and forgets what they have and haven't said.

Nation William Crow

Great episode! Sorry not a more substantive comment but appreciate you as always

Unfeatured Films

Endlessly deep episode, this is my third time around. I find something so intoxicating about the excerpts and considerations about Sentence is a Lonely Place. It's these types of analytic frames that I haven't considered that go really granular that get me super excited to kind of sort of inhabit a similar role. Cultural analysis is so fucking inspiring every day! The one idea that I wanted to sort of expand upon was on the way that this type of intense sentence-by-sentence writing rarely gets carried over to novel-length projects. I've noticed a similar thing happening with movies and I think that at least partially comes down to economies of storytelling. Of course there's the labor aspect to it all, but I think that the larger the project, the more you need breating room in it. Classic Bayhem-phenomena. If every sentence is an ocean, it's easy to drown. I've been watching a lot of film from his canadian director called Isiah Medina over the past year and he's The Guy I started to think this through. His short films are kind of a hyper-montage: really fast moving streams of images that sometimes overlap with maybe 3-6 layers of images layered over each other. It's exhilirating in short form! The amount of ideas you can get every second is insane, because the consideration to every bit and how they play off of each other is there. But moving unto his first two feature length movies 88:88 (not a Hitler thing, it's about how digital clocks flash 88:88 as a test pattern when cold started, the movie is mostly about poverty) and Inventing the Future, the editing style starts to work againt the experience. There's too much to consider and eventually it will just start washing over you. Medina would find a new voice later on with a lot less visually busy form that mostly plays out in shot/reverse shot of two people sort of monologuing one after another, but when you get those intense montage-ideas, they cut through. You set up tensions where they're the most impactful instead of maximizing the galaxy of every sentence. No doubt it can be pulled off, but I'd imagine that the scale forces you to consider things in new ways.