Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Vote on the new Nerd³ Series!

  • Recommends 468
  • Reviews 673
  • 2026-07-13
  • —2026-07-20
  • 1141 votes
{'title': 'Vote on the new Nerd³ Series!', 'choices': [{'text': 'Recommends', 'votes': 468}, {'text': 'Reviews', 'votes': 673}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 7, 20, 11, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 7, 13, 11, 53, 35, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1141}

Content

So, a couple of months ago I made a video recommending the fantastic game Mixtape. The video was 3 minutes long and consisted of me going "I can't play this game due to music licencing, go play it anyway." Standard stuff. What wasn't standard was the response. A whole bunch of people started going, "Hey, make more short videos like this."

So, now, I'm going to.

I have dabbled with short videos before. Way back in a previous logo we created the Fab Games Friday series, which was basically my way onto TikTok and YouTube shorts. They did fine on YouTube, died on YouTube Shorts and Instagram whatevers, and did UNBELIEVABLY WELL on TikTok. The Shadows of Doubt video by itself hitting just under a million views. I loved scripting these, but the company started to enter a financial death spiral so I switched focus from YouTube to finishing off my book to bring some much needed money in. Excellent plan. 10/10. What could go wrong?

Anyway, now all that is behind us I do want to get back into the shorter video realm. The main reason I do this job to recommend cool games to people, and if the people are watching shorter videos, that's where I should be. Don't worry, this isn't going to touch the current channel staples. Planet Coaster 2 will continue to be several hours a week of neon light placing, the Plays series will be 15 - 20 minutes of whatever I fancy making that week, and livestreams will still be an hour of chat followed by however many hours of video games I can get out before the internet dies. This is an additional video, likely one a week.

Here is where you come in. I have two ideas for these shorter videos and I'm outsourcing the decision making to you, my lovely Patreons.

Recommends.

As the Fab Friday and Nerd³ Quick before it (remember those!?), these will just be a video going "play this cool game". I'm thinking these will be between 2 and 3 minutes long, so I can go a little more in depth than the last TikTok lot.

Upsides: It's a fun joyful series that I've already seen success from. People dig it too.

Downsides: I might not have anything to recommend so it may struggle to maintain a weekly release.

Reviews.

Essentially as above, but I'll widen the scope to games I either don't entirely recommend, or are actually shit. Anything can be covered and then, at the end, I'll do something I've never done before. I'll give the game a score. Specifically I'll do a star ranking of 0 - 5 stars. No half stars or crap like that, and I may go over the 5 star limit if something is really, really special.

Upsides: Easier to maintain the weekly releases, plus I can really shit on something if the mood takes me.

Downsides: Review scores can... agitate folks. It might take a bit more ban hammer wielding to maintain our lovely community.

Anyway, that's the pitches, now it's over to you! What's the next Nerd³ series?

YOU DECIDE!

(In the poll below. Also these won't likely start until after I've moved. T&C probably apply, IDK.)

Daniel xx

Comments

Kelbi

I worry with the reviews people would just scroll to the score and skip the reasoning why and then get mad for no reason?? I love finding game recs (and even mods!) on TikTok by some random creator going “look at this cool thing I found!!” Its one of my favourite ways to find stuff

Etho Burrow

Reviews, but without the review scores!

Peter Barrett

I think Recommends will be more sustainable in the long run. You run the risk of upsetting fandoms and going viral for the wrong reasons on reviews, that I think just isn't worth the faff 🤷

Joe Bailey

So far its 50/50, you're welcome Dan

Sophie Wyllie

I vote for Option C: "Recommends with the occasional 'Nerd³ DOESN'T Recommend' special for when something desperately needs shitting on". All the benefits of option A, and you can shit on things, plus making the negatives a special "bit" allows you to be very funny with how and when you use them.

Ben Anderson

You wouldn't have to release a video every Friday. Just because the series title has Friday in it, doesn't mean it has to be every Friday

Freek Jansen

I prefer a majority of recommends, with the occasional (bad) review thrown in.

Gavin Bouchard

Reviews seem easier to sustain, plus then you can just go back to games of historical interest to you or played in your youth without it being outright endorsed if it's aged poorly. Also just drop review scores and give a little "You should play this if: you like blah" style thing at the end.

Jack Robertson

Love the idea of more Recommends, and as much as I love your more critical videos (often they lead to hilarity when the game is really crap), I think keeping a positive space will be/do better! The world is negative enough, I want to hear people babble on about things they love!

Harry Franklin

You could space “Recommends” out by filling the gaps where you haven’t a newer game to recommend with an older game that you love that can be picked up for £3 on Steam, or £0 on the high seas (á la Driver San Francisco)? I’m picturing those really popular “powerful websites that you need to know part #69” videos where they’re really blasted through. Maybe shorter ones work better for older games, rather than newer deep review-style things?? :)

Codey Miller

the benefit of giving us the choice is, if it all goes wrong, you can blame all of us 😄

Scroggy

Dude i loved seeing you more active on all socials, it really felt great seein you thrive on tiktok aswell.

Brad

Prefer reviews Loving seeing games get shit on and angry dan is who I aspire to be

Gavin Bouchard

I'm in favor of dropping the review scores entirely and just have a little "You'd enjoy this if: /Avoid this if you:" at the end

Tailmartian

Reviews! Because I like the idea of a wider scope and it's been to long since we've heard you in pure anger about a game ;-)

Andrew Poor

I voted Recommends. I'm not sure what value I'd get from a 3 minute video of Dan going "this game exists, but I don't think you should play it".

Nathan Kirby

Reviews, but with thumb up/down.

Reece

I come here for Dan uploading to Dan’s channel Dan’s opinions on games that Dan has chosen to be opinionated about; I will watch literally either or both of these

Kelbi

That is not a bad idea at all honestly!

Max Tal

Reviews because it's more fair, you'll get more content and (it's icky but) reviews that make people argue get more attention on the internet

Lauren Clarke

... por qué no los dos? but for real, I love the idea of quick little reviews, they sound brilliant! and for games you like it's essentially just the recommends concept with a rating (you could always go the way of Liam @theplantslant and not give an actual rating, eg beans out of ten, just for fun)

Jack Stratton

Recommends! Although bad reviews can be funny, I think the format works better as a joyful celebration of games! And if no games release that week, there's gotta be an older game you can shine a spotlight on!

Jay350

I voted for Reviews but don't worry about the score. We just want to hear your opinions and ramblings on games

AStupidID

I vote for Reviews cause I've been missing NerdCubed's Hell and I think we could get a few shorter videos with that vibe with the Reviews.

Kemot

Scores are too restrictive, plus it's much nicer to hear about a handful of good/interesting games, than a bunch of semi-interesting, or bad games. Although I would welcome the occasional Hell video if you come across something truly horrible.

Harige Knolraap

I kind of would like both, but reviews are more interesting than a short demo. As for the review scores, I would recommend considering the Yahtzee tactic: not assigning a score. Concluding what your final verdict is in a few words rather than comparing it to other properties makes it harder for random internet weirdos to point at a number and complain that you didn't score a game high/low/mid enough. Or rather than stars, you could give some other meaningless number that's harder to compare to others (giving a game a "NER" out of "NERD3" or a "Shadow" out of "Sonic")

BreadThatIsBread

Good morning Dan, I am literally just waking up for work. I gave my vote but I'll watch either way. Anyway, off to take my shower.

PurpleZERO72

Reviews would be great but without scores. I think mixing in some ‘hells’ level games with the recommends would be a cool combo to mix things up a bit.

Mr. H.

The old Nerdcubed hell was always fun.

TheEvilHatter

I feel like recommends is a much stronger idea when it comes to shortform content. Providing a curated list of good games is generally what the channel is about anyway, and just a series of short form recommendations is much easier to scroll through than a mixed bag I think.

niamh.muffin

I'd say combine the two, 'Nerd³ Recommends... You Play *game* / You DON'T Play *game*'. "this week I played *game* and think you should too..." or "this week I played *game* and think you should avoid it AT ALL COSTS..." etc. Allows you to go with the flow, it can be positive or negative. I think it would be nice to have more positive stuff on the feed but some well placed, scathing take downs of certain games are delightful too (thinking of the 'Nerd³ Show' episode where you talk about Six Days in Fallujah).

James Tann

The spiritual successor to the Loves and Hates series if you will

Triplestaff

Either is great, but remember that you can use older games too, they might as well be new to most people!

Texta 217

Reviews are probably the way to go for longevity, but agreed with lots of others here that star rating my not work as well as hoped. Thumbs up or down could be fun but sure you could also come up with some witty and nuanced way to at least showcase the art form you enjoy (even if the game is a bit shit)

jelly time

reminds me of the old 'three free game friday' series that introduced me to a bunch of stuff, or the videos recommending kickstarters like planetary annihilation lol, recommends would be an excellent return to form I say but either one sounds neat

Chandler Heatley

Going reviews here as I think sticking to just good games is a little limiting. Sometimes a game is bad and we need to see why that game is bad, sometimes a game is almost good, and those games deserve to be talked about too. Besides, I like hearing your thoughts on stuff!

James Tann

I really like both options, though I'm not a fan of increased toxicity because of review scores. Personally I'd be more on board with something like a pros and cons breakdown rather than a star rating. There's also nothing stopping you from doing "Nerd³ Recommends [you play something else]" when you feel the need to shit on something. edit: I have just realised how close to Z̶e̶r̶o̶ ̶P̶u̶n̶c̶t̶u̶a̶t̶i̶o̶n̶ Fully Ramblomatic "Nerd³ Reviews" could be and I am absolutely here for it!

Darksquall

Can we get an occasional one from mr_rebecca too? Any time they mention a game theu are playing i lose twenty hours to it over the next few days. Thrifty business as mentioned on the recent podcast nearly killed me because I was trying to play in the heat last week.

Aaron Norman

Honestly a mixture would work. Maybe occasional clips taken out of a new full length video too? Might just be me but my youtube recommended page sucks at... well recommending and the new "most relevant tab" in the subscription tab is equally as frustrating. Could be a nice way to be like "DAN'S UPLOADED" ... This could all be a me issue though

Finn Smith

Obviously you're primarily a gaming channel, but does it have to be limited to games? I'd personally enjoy quick thoughts on books, films, TV - whatever it is you're enjoying at the minute! Although, I don't know how TikTok would respond to a 3 minute review of old Doctor Who episodes

Milz Bowden

I selected reviews, but I'm recommending to use good/ mediocre/bad scoring system. A channel I watch, Rollitreviewit, uses that system and it seems to work.

Narmatonia

Maybe do Recommends if you have something to recommend, if not then do a Review

midnight_mountain

I'm in the small camp where I'm not arsed if I like something someone else doesn't/vice versa, so seeing you review stuff that might be a bit shit sounds interesting to me! But also i get why people would get upset by it 🤷

Mitchel van Ham

I went reviews mostly because I think the recommends, especially with the knowledge that you have less material, might actually end up either having you skip weeks (and consistency is key on social media) or have you recommend stuff you don't fully support, which just sound completely against your ethos.

Alex

Personally I'd love to see some game reviews from you, I love the positive ones and I'd say those should be the main focus just because the games industry could really use a lift right now. But a short form video of you breaking the physics in a shitty simulator would probably do amazingly well.

Javier Cabral

Hard agree with people saying recommends with the occasional review/doesn't recommend, and without an actual numbered score!

mxEzriRobyn

I think reviews is a much more interesting format for ME, but I also think unless you're trying to get on Metacritic, just drop scoring the games. I think scores for things should go the way of the dodo for the reasons others have stated.

Rob

This is the way.

Rob

I feel the internets need more positivity, so I voted for 'Recommends'. But reviews would probably get more views. If you go the reviews route, I'd like to have you either give just thumbs up or thumbs down rather than a score or something like that.

Ashley Doherty

I voted reviews. I do think having a broader scope would be helpful. I have always loved your recommends type videos, though. so it's a. hard choice.

Cosmoneq

Personally would like joyous Reccomends more than any number of really negative reviews (0/1 stars), as they don't really do much other than tell you to not buy a game (speaking purely on the review rather than your sense of humour which would make it funny regardless of the game). But, I do love your honest and critically thought out reviews of any game you think worth reviewing. Just think that the negative ones need to be far and few between, and it be mostly positive (or middling) if going for reviews, as negativity is everywhere on the internet atm.

ashesbyrm

what are your thoughts on a combo of both? i remember the 'recommendation' series' in the past causing stress with upkeep, and i think people benefit from your review knowledge!! perhaps 2 reviews to 1 recommend (or different ratio) and keep a monthly schedule for shorts instead of weekly?

Nathan (Mixter_Chestnut)

This is exactly my thoughts aswell, everywhere else on YouTube has negative reviews of games, i don't really see the point for the nerdcubed channel to do that also

Morgan Kenning

It may be good to do something like "little tiny baby video essay". So if you don't have anything to recommend, you don't have to, but if something in gaming news has particularly excised you, you can do a quick 2 minutes on "why I love X game series", "why X company's latest decision is shit" etc. that could pad things out when you're not doing a recommends.

Nathan Malaney

I miss the weird shit. You were in a shower clothed and I think it was sepia toned. Bring back the weird shit

That Other Person

I personally prefer videos that tend more towards positivity, but the games industry does need shitting on frequently, so, maybe keep things generally positive, but don't feel bound to it and on occasion, say "hey fuck this game". And scores don't feel necessary to me personally, you can make your feelings on something clear without needing to quantify it.

Michael

For reviews: instead of a star rating, you could go with something silly. For instance, you could do a funny sentence potentially followed by "out of five" or whatever.

Bailey Newsham

I think I agree with a lot people on reviews but without the score, maybe just a would or wouldn't recommend

lastjjune

I’m here to hear your opinions on as many games as possible, so I voted reviews. If you feel like you need to assign a score, I’m willing to tolerate that; otherwise, don’t bother with them. Describing a games strengths and weaknesses is enough for me to get an impression of the opinion I’ll form when I play the game. The score isn’t helpful for me personally. Gavin Bouchard mentioned doing a “This is for you if…/This isn’t for you if…” system which I think is an excellent alternative.

Henry

I'd like it to focus on good games, I got bored of youtubers crapping on shitty games ten years ago.

Thomas N Wyndham

A recommendation doesn’t have to be ‘I recommend you play this’, it can also be ‘I recommend you don’t play this’.

AsYouWes

I am always in favor of "whatever is easiest and least stressful for you", but I also tend to lean towards Recommends over Review--because I believe positivity is easier to maintain, at least personally. Something that is joyful in nature is easier to produce long term. Even if it means there isn't something every week. It also leaves room for occasional sub-ins of games Rebecca has Recommended (which I always love as well).

Finn McCool

Petition to call the series: Fuck Yeah Video Games. But seriously, one of the things I really love about Dan & the channel is the unapologetic love of games and I think the book titles just sums it up & so does this series (even with some odd or terrible games).

Tigerbattle

Love the nonsensical ratings idea, gives a general idea while not pinning a number to it.

Jack

Option C: Nerd Hell returns! Serious answer: Reviews! You’re more than qualified at this stage to provide quality reviews, I’d thoroughly enjoy them!

Lewis

Why not a mix of both, depending on what you feel like (or what game you discover)?

Wynter

I like the reviews, but I think agree with a lot of people here when I say it doesn’t need to have a proper score at the end. Maybe just mention a similar game and whether you or Rebecca will play it later

CrohTheDragon

Love the idea for the reviews but not the review scores, because not only are they devisive but as you've said in the past they don't really work as they're not universal. A simple do/don't recommend like on steam would probably work better. (^_^)

Daniel Bennett

I prefer Dan doing games he likes over shit ones, but I like the 10 minute mark, maybe a mix, maybe a 3 minute version for tiktok and then an extended one for youtube with unscripted gameplay?