Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

The Nerd³ Awards 2026 - You Choose The Structure!

  • Full Awards Series across December 563
  • One-off Xmas Special Awards 106
  • 2026-11-15
  • —2026-11-16
  • 669 votes
{'title': 'The Nerd³ Awards 2026 - You Choose The Structure!', 'choices': [{'text': 'Full Awards Series across December', 'votes': 563}, {'text': 'One-off Xmas Special Awards', 'votes': 106}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 16, 15, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 15, 13, 47, 58, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 669}

Content

Last week I wrote my Game of the Year Awards list, ready for 25 videos across December showcasing cool games in little videos. Then, just to check, I looked up how many of those games I could confirm used zero AI in the entire process of creating the game.

The answer? Maybe 3 or so.

First of all, anything that used generative AI for anything player facing is out by default. Art, music, models, translations, etc is a no-no. I'm not awarding theft and I won't cover these videos on the channel. Basically, if Tim Sweeney likes it, I don't want to play it.

Secondly, anything that used generative AI in a super limited case that was then removed, I'll allow. Most games that came out this year likely started development before AI was really a thing, and I can see devs testing new tech, moving on from it, but leaving something behind by accident. Or, like in the case of Iron Nest, the dev uses a piece of stock art that hasn’t been disclosed as AI and they don't know. Hell, that last one happened to me this past year.

Thirdly, and this is where I'm struggling, AI use in the code. Look, I'm not naive about this industry, I'm aware that if you're coding for a company, you're being pushed to use AI in that coding or you risk losing your job. I'd bet both my gentlemen grapes that every AAA game releasing this year and beyond has some AI written code in it somewhere, as well as most indies too if I'm honest. Hellscape capitalism demands that everything is faster, endlessly, and if you don't keep up, you can lose that roof over your head. Personally, I'd never touch AI in any of my projects, but that's because I have the immense privilege of not needing too.

So, here's where you come in. I'm torn about my awards this year and have come up with two structures for them. As you are the people who fund this, you get to decided how this award season goes.

Option 1. I do the full awards like normal across December. Silly titles. Cool games. AI code use a question mark throughout.

Option 2. Limit the series to a single awards video on Christmas Day and only feature the games I think are AI free. The question mark is there, but much smaller.

Good luck deciding! I couldn't.

Daniel xx

Comments

Spencer Johnson

Daily awards is my favorite, makes each day super fun to look forward too

Josh Ryan

What do we get/lose if we pick either one? As in, do we still get plays videos either way?

Will Nuessle

Man, that's a hard one. Like you I'm privileged enough that I don't need to use AI – I'm writing a novel using pen and spiral notebook this very minute – but there's so much grey in that area. Could've done without the reference to your gentlemen's grapes while I'm here... 8-p

Dr John Chizzles

I'd go with the daily awards - if games don't disclose AI usage, it's on them, not you. I do have limited sympathy for some use cases such as checking code for errors, as long as it's not being used to generate code, so something like Big Walk should not be penalised as a result. Alternatively, there's the games that actively say they haven't used AI in their development, which should be loudly and enthusiastically cheered at every option!

LucyIsADragon

I also think you do a great job of flagging when you don't know stuff, so if you wanna pop in disclaimer for each video being like "AS FAR AS I KNOW" I think thats the best any of us can do, its a hard time right now but showing us the games you enjoyed I think is always so specials and very HUMAN which goes someone in countering AI! Either way THANK YOU for all the joy youve brought this year ❤️

Forrest

I'm voting for a single video mostly to try to intentially help create spaces that encourage people to limit or eliminate AI use where the point is celebrating the people that make these games. It's not about punishment, it's about knowing that we can all take small steps to encourage one another towards a place where these practices don't have to be the norm just because these massive industries expect us to adopt it en masse for their own profit.

addie

I don't think there's an actual way to properly tell if a game had AI used in the code is the problem. So many games will claim that they didn't use AI coding agents at all because its bad publicity, but its virtually impossible to verify (if its been used "well").

Jason Warrender

I like the daily videos but if it means a more true to you video I can wait for something you are happier with and enjoy it like a little Christmas gift 😅 We've still (i assume) got the advent videos to look forward too! 🤩

Jack Stratton

I know its more work, but I love the daily awards video, because I'll usually watch the advent series in the morning, then the awards video after work and then maybe go revisit that game in the evening!

Jude

For the sake of future planning, sticking to the format this year might be easier to do again next year, and the full awards series will probably drive a lot of traffic to both your YouTube channel and to the games you highlight. I would also be okay with some kind of "Disqualifications due to AI" video where you help raise awareness about the games that are using AI, because if you're doing the research anyway then it's worth sharing. Maybe it could just be a post or short video for Patrons?

Dee Martin

I've voted for a single video. You mentioned on the podcast that you're going to be super busy with plays, GTA, advent calendars and patreon advent already, so maybe not going all out with awards will help mitigate some overworking. The fact that you're asking this question and saying you won't use AI yourself means AI usage clearly irks you, so I'd take the opportunity to cull some awards for games that don't align with your values and focus on one award video that can celebrate the ones that do (to the best of your knowledge.)

Dee Martin

At the time of me casting my vote this is notttttt the popular option

Reece Ashworth

Assuming Ashens isn't an ai creation 😅

UnrulyGoose

I think dragging code into the same category as textures, music, dialogue, scripts etc. is (for me at least) the wrong call. I'm a professional software developer and I use AI all the time for generating code (in fact we are encouraged to), but I still design all of the specification documents that the LLMs use to produce the code. I see this no differently than using any other tool for code-assistance, but this might be because it is accepted standard practice within the software engineering industry to take snippets of code from places like StackOverflow, as well as reusing the gigantic amount of Open Source libraries that are freely published. In that regard, I don't think code is seen in the same way. Most software engineers I know are always happy to share the insane new ways they've found to optimise their code, and love to see other people using the same tricks and even improving on them. Of course, if you are talking about about pure, unadulterated AI slop, then yes, it can get in the bin.

AStupidID

I'd much rather have the one day dedicated to the true art cases of no AI usage. I think it politely but firmly takes a stand against gen-AI use in this industry. If the vote does go the other way though, I think potential AI disclaimers on daily vids would work pretty well too :).

klmns

As a software engineer myself (thankfully at a company that doesn't push for AI use) I have to say AI coding is a bit different than other forms of generative AI. When it comes to source code, most stuff you can find on the internet is actually free to use under a license that allows you to do more or less whatever. Open source software explicitly exists to let others reuse and modify the code. There's still some licensing issues when it comes to code, but many (maybe even most) developers of open source software are fine with their code being used to train LLMs. When it comes to art on the other hand, there's lots of stuff out there you can view for free, but definitely not legally use for anything else. Almost all of that was stolen and used to train AI models and very few artists are fine with that. The tough one IMHO is LLM-use purely for translations. On the one hand, current LLMs are trained on lots and lots of stolen books, sometimes even physical copies that were ripped apart just to make scanning faster. That should not be encouraged in any way. On the other hand, human-made translations are expensive, so expensive that the decision in most cases will just be "no translations" or "AI translations". It's a bit of an accessibility issue. Without LLMs some games just wouldn't be playable for some people, because the developer could never afford to pay humans to translate the game. I think AI translations has to be decided on a case-by-case basis.

Disaidra

I'm of the mind that whilst the environmental and social issues associated with AI use for writing code are still very serious, they are ultimately issues that in the long term can and hopefully will be reduced or negated entirely. The actual deep down morality of it is in my eyes really no different to using online resources like stack overflow to help write code. That's not to say that I don't applaud studios that do make a stand and don't use AI at all.

Beckett

I generally prefer a single video (I find the daily ones hard to keep up with and it usually ends up w me not watching them) but I completely agree that undisclosed AI usage is on the game, not Dan. It shouldn't be up to individual creators to investigate and expose AI usage and they certainly shouldn't be held responsible for it.

Kitty Sam

I feel the daily video structure is the better outcome. You can only do so much to avoid AI use so if you don't 100% know a simple i don't know if it is or isn't disclaimer is more than enough to cover that issue

Diplomatic iocane immunity

While I quite enjoy the daily videos, I voted for a single video this year, because I believe you deserve a break! I know I’m not alone and I’m sure this community will continue to support you either way. Having a nuanced, public-facing view about AI is challenging, but you have already demonstrated your integrity and respect for creators over the years. I look forward to whatever you decide to release.

Lewis Pontremoli

Dan your daily videos are one of the things I really look forward to in a month which I am not particularly fond. As perhaps a bridge between the two, maybe you could add that question mark as a tag somewhere in the video, on the intro frames an AI disclaimer for that game perhaps?

Ákos Rúzsa

As a Software Engineer who started in the field a few years before AI became huge and is still in the business now, I can say that our job looks very different now than a few years back, and not necessarily (just) in a bad way. The skillset required in my day-to-day has shifted more towards that of a technical manager. It's almost as if AI was a pretty stupid developer (with a lot of lexical knowledge) and you were their tech lead. In it's current state I don't feel like AI is replacing us (at least not yet), but it has certainly become a useful tool that makes my work less stressful, makes learning new concepts easier and makes me more productive. On the other hand, I do sometimes miss the raw problem solving that I get to do much less nowadays, and I'm really not happy about the environmental impact of AI, obviously. So yeah, based on my experiences, I doubt you will find any software on the market anymore where the code was never even touched by AI, but there is a big difference between pure AI slop and something that used AI as a tool under deep human supervision. I'd say go ahead with the daily videos, I will have a lot of fun watching them. Thanks for all the laughs, Dan!

Connor Smith

I feel that because you’ve already spent the time to select the games then the daily videos would be the better choice just maybe with a small disclaimer either at the start of each day or just the beginning of the awards mentioning a summary of what you’ve said here. Frankly it’s near impossible to know for certain which games aren’t implementing AI in some capacity so including it in the awards will at least downsize the limitations you have to show off the games you want to.

Etho Burrow

I genuinely really appreciate your dedication to this. But if a game does not declare its AI usage and there's no obvious user-facing generated stuff, then any attempt to figure out whether or not the dev has used LLMs is a doomed pursuit that is mostly vibes-based and will drive you mad. I don't think anyone would blame you for just avoiding any game that declares its AI usage and leaving it at that.

T-jay_HD (Hi Magus!)

I know it might sound selfish and potentially not possible. But is there a chance for both? To both shine a light with a longer video for the games that are AI free and also have the countdown to said single video?

Marvin Kosmider

I would second that. AI is super useful to build little tools that help the development or find a bug in a library where the documentation is outdated. This doesn't mean I endorse every use of AI, but as a Software Dev, a self hosted AI that acts as a coding assistant doesn't seem too bad.

Julian

As someone who writes code, AI can be a very helpful tool if it's used as a tool. Like the whole AI debugging thing with Big Walk, I think that is a good usage of it. AI "art" is horrible there's no excuse for that, but as long as the game is made by people who care and properly maintain their codebase, lightly AI assisted coding is a valid tool to be using. Code is text, and follows predictable patterns, that's like the one thing LLMs are good at.

Mike Jones

Discriminating against AI code usage at this point is borderline impossible, and I think pretty meritless. I completely agree that gen AI should not come into the final product of the creative side of anything, but when it comes to more technical aspects it really doesn't make sense not to use AI anymore. It does what you would do anyway, but faster and quite possibly better. It's not the same as outsourcing your story, characters or artwork. Similarly, would you exclude any game that implements DLSS? It is a form of AI after all.

elke

i think some combination of the two might be the best way to do it? so maybe have the first day highlighting the 3 games that definitely have no ai use (since supporting and highlighting that is imo super important nowadays) then caveat the rest of the series with "as far as i know these dont use ai either but i cant be certain". voted for the first option since its basically just that, only with an extra bit at the start ig

Andy Jennings

I still reckon it's your stage, so it's your shout... but methinks that if I were you, I'd still do the 25 videos with your picks, re-rank them based on their AI usage, and have a percentage of the video dedicated to a big "SHAME OF AI" panel with what they used, accompanied by proportionately-wet-sounding fart noises.

Finn Smith

I prefer the daily videos, but as loge is constantly pushing AI upon me I think restricting things to just one day and celebrating real human creativity is important

Titusz Ban

Also Software Dev - pretty much just seconding what Ákos and Marvin said. When used thoughtfully, it doesn't take (much) away from the technical process, and can help devs out. Fuck anyone forcing AI on their workforce, or trying to replace them, fuck anyone trying to put working artists out of a living. But if a dev can make a great game, and it enabled them to fix bugs, automate some testing, draft boilerplate, etc - there is a productive use of some AI (especially local), and I don't think it is fair or practical to penalise devs if used in a reasonable way.

Mr_Riddleman

In terms of AI in code I'd like to bring up the game Big Walk. They recently got into a ton of drama over Steam not declaring it used AI in the game. It got denied a game award because the judges had this huge issue that is wasn't properly disclosed. What was the use of AI you ask? Fixing a bug... That's it. They ran into a Unity bug that they just couldn't figure out and even talking to Unity got them no where so out of desperation they ask the AI to help fix the bug and it found them the method to fix it. I am not pro stealing art or generating art and calling yourself a artist but the method the developers of Big Walk used to help them solve a problem is exactly what AI should be used for. A TOOL that the professional uses so they can focus on the tasks that really matter.

Little Pink Dragon

The only way to know if a company used ai gen code is if they've said they've used it (or if they've clearly used ai in other as areas in which case there's a very high chance they used ai code). The other side of this is ai can be used in SO many different areas from automated testing to looking through bug reports and build errors. Maybe you could showcase the ones that are proudly against ai in a way that they stand out from the others

Nate

Jaded professional software dev of 15+ years. It is, to my immense horror and anguish, time to accept that AI can actually be wrangled to produce decent code fast IF you already know what you're doing, and are vetting it properly. I HATE that it was trained unethically, (sorry, the ethical models just aren't there yet) but it is useful unfortunately. I think if you're trying to make a living off of making games, you are unnecessarily kneecapping yourself if you don't use it. I think the big players who could afford to do without it should be shamed into the ground, I think that for beginners or passion projects you get more out of it if you hand roll, I think indies should get a bit a leeway. NB: This ONLY applies to code. Asset generation was, is and always will be completely unacceptable in any circumstance, IMHO.

Thomas N Wyndham

I don’t think it is practical to boycott AI, and honestly I see no reason to boycott all AI. It can be a tremendous tool when used appropriately.

Jochem

I voted full series, but I do have a suggestion for beyond the Awards season. As a way to maybe help combat the pervasiveness of AI, can I suggest using some of the new Anti-AI initiatives that are popping up from Indie studios to pick games for regular videos? I don't know if the critical mass is there for _every_ video to be from a No-to-AI studio, or if that's even a sensible / reasonable thing for the health of the channel, but one regular video a month with a guaranteed fully AI free game by a studio that is actively boycotting AI would be nice. Or even just a super short video, some basic gameplay with a voice-over describing the game in 5 sentences, to help actively promote games that have no AI in them? An AI-Free-Game-Friday if you will. There's a lot of negativity about AI in games, and I personally think that is very much deserved... but what is lacking as a balance is positivity and promotion of game studios that don't use AI. If there's anything you're amazing at, Dan, it's being excited and passionate about games. And writing books. And caring for animals. And a lot of other things too, but also the games thing. One of the initiatives I've heard of is https://aftermath.site/video-games-no-ai/, I'm sure there's other initiatives folks on the discord could help find.

T-Fyre

I'd think, highlight in each video whether or not you can confirm if a game uses AI, that way anyone interested in a game can that we know doesn't use AI can be like "oh my god I'm so sold" and if they're kinda interested and it may use AI, they can look into it further if they care