Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

About a month ago, 26-year-old John Allen Chau illegally visited the North Sentinel Island to convert it's uncontacted indigenous population to Christianity. The tribe killed him for it. What is this aggressive tribe, and why is missionary work so problematic?

Files

Previews only

Who Killed an American Missionary in the Indian Ocean?

About a month ago, 26-year-old John Allen Chau illegally visited the North Sentinel Island to convert it's uncontacted indigenous population to Christianity. The tribe killed him for it. What is this aggressive tribe, and why is missionary work so problematic? SUBSCRIBE and join us! https://goo.gl/7vUgh0 Step Back is made possible by the generous contributions of viewers like you, consider helping at https://www.patreon.com/stepbackhistory If you liked this video and want to leave a one-time tip: http://paypal.me/StepBackHistory Check out a collection of books that are either Tristan's favourites or used to research Step Back videos at: https://www.amazon.com/shop/influencer20170928253 Submit video ideas: http://stepbackhistory.idea.informer.com/ I have a curious cat account for anonymous questions for me: https://curiouscat.me/TristanPEJ YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: Did Columbus Really Discover America? https://youtu.be/PfcOf7-elRs Connect with Step Back: Discord: https://discord.gg/MQSZPXu Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/StepBackChannel/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/TristanPEJ Sub-Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/stepback/ Slack: https://join.slack.com/t/stepbackhistory/shared_invite/enQtMzA5NDkyNDA1MzE4LWRlNjAzNDVhY2Q5ZTY2YWM2MTIzZGUyNzdmNDRjNDQ4MDI4ZTE2MjY4N2QzNTAxMWM0M2M0OTJiYTliOTAwYWU

Comments

Quinlan Vuong

I'm pretty concerned that his body carries a bunch or yuppie western diseases that these poor people don't have an immunity against. There aren't very many Sentinelese to begin with and he just introduced a whole new host of bacteria

Shawn MacIntyre

I don't think it's sad at all. I think it is Justice. Missionary work is an unequivocally bad thing; it is cultural genocide. I spent much of my teen years in a remote part of Papua New Guinea where my parents were working for the local Catholic mission. Missionary work is probably the best example of the horrible term "virtue signalling" out there. It's all talk about how they are going to help the people, but what it really boils down to who can get the most converts: like a heavenly score board. With different sects competing against each other and offering incentives to communities to switch "sides". Arrogance, paternalism, and western supremacism are how missionaries treat the people they are supposedly there to help. Missionary work destroys and impoverishes communities; these are the same people who push "traditional values" back home but see nothing inconsistent with trying to replace a 60,000 year old culture with a 2,000 year old one. As for a "right time" to contact "uncontacted" tribes, it has to be completely on the tribe's time table. There has to be a right to not be contacted or to drop out of societal "progress". In short, missionary work can only be understood as a hate crime and should be a criminal offence.