Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I fuckin’ love this faction. I know Alignment’s an outdated concept but if we were doing it, these guys are pretty Lawful Good, if you ask me.

Files

Comments

Petter Wäss

D&D Alignments aren't outdated, merely incredibly dumbs and have been for decades. They simply don't make sense as commonly described. Also, love how sensibly they dress, a true rarity in this setting1

Sella

I think there's a typo in the perk, should say something like "You can *sell* thieves guild..."

Commissar Doggo

My brain can't resist the idea of an on-the-nose mario reference. Hell, the dwarves have the height and build for it.

Chaos Possum

I love the idea of militarized municipal workers 😂

Khajiithaswares

I've always thought they make a great starting point for characters, especially if someone is having trouble with the character creation part. It's when people don't let the evolve and pigeon hole them into one way of acting is when it becomes bothersome.

Dark Kuno

Yeah sadly a lot of players don't actually understand what the alignments mean. Chaotic Neutral for example is automatically thought of as insane, instead of just the flat out ultra-selfish and/or amoral that it actually is, (which might include insane characters).

Petter Wäss

That's a problem from the game writers as much as from the players.

Petter Wäss

For example, a True Neutral character during WWII, as they were written in 2nd Ed, might have thought for the Allies up until D-day and then turned and thought for the nazis the rest of the war. Because apparently "upholding the balance" means having no allegiance and behaving like a insane person. Or changing sides and joining the evil Necromancer against their own adventuring party halfway through the fight. And this mind you, was the recommended alignment for player Druids... Not to mention how the alignments were never integrated in the settings in ways that made any sense.

Petter Wäss

Alignments are deliberately pigeonholey by design. Much better starting points would be a set of personality traits. Telling me that my character is say "fastidious, tidy, and wrathful" is much more useful when it comes to portraying them than telling me that they're a cop (Lawful Evil). It just does not add anything, does not make sense in the game world and actively leads players to pigeonhole their characters by design.

AFrickinDwarf

And that’s what the Personality Traits, Bonds, Ideals and Flaws section of the character sheet is for

Petter Wäss

And that's why Alignment should not exist, because it is either superflous or pigeonholey. Especially since traditionally, D&D character sheets do not have those things you mention.

Nedzilla

Shovel Knights. It's a perfect fit here, of course.