Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Lemme know how this reads, if it encapsulates the spirit of playing tabletop RPGs.

 This’ll be at the start of the Running The Game chapter, just after a “The Role of The Game Master” page I’m workin’ on.

Files

Comments

Nedzilla

Oh, I just so happened to read this the moment it posted. This is a good primer for the start of the book. As written, I'd probably stick this right after the Life/Down/Dead page.

Trevor Foor

Interesting and look fun to play

Rick

This seems... a bit too depressing. As someone who plays TTRPGs for the power fantasy, knowing that it never starts that way but becomes as such, I feel like telling the players that they will start from nothing and are expected to die is more of a turn off than a turn on when inviting people to play the game. This reads like you're not allowed to write your own backstory and aren't allowed to actually do anything but swing a stick until the GM allows you a shiv. On a separate note, the idea of Downtime really rubs me the wrong way, but that may be more of a personal issue. Every game I've played where Downtime was a thing that mattered, I was never able to figure out how to actually use it. Might've just been the DM at the time who didn't know how to present it to me, but when I asked what my options were I was looking for 2, maybe 3 things to choose from and they just gave me the list of activities from the game book. I just wanted to play the game, not worry about what my character does off-screen! There shouldn't be an off-screen! Let me be part of the overall narrative, not go off and create my own until you see fit to have players again! So I feel like linking Downtime and Leveling Up will have to be very specifically focused to avoid that issue, more "Give me a narrative background to your Level Up" than "Tell me what you did in your Downtime".

sUBLIME

There are a lot of RPGs that play differently - maybe this one isn't suited to your play style, but that doesn't mean it should be changed. It seems like a lot of them play the way you want to run things, And it's good to have a variety. I would love to give Vice & Violence a go, and try out the downtime mechanics, and play characters that might get eviscerated.

Vice & Violence

If it helps, Downtime with all it's pageantry stripped off boils down to "choose a skill and/ or roll a dice." It's there largely to encourage the return to towns and cities, put another layer of pressure onto exploring out on the frontier next to maintaining food & drink. V&V has a lot of that Old School Renaissance influence, mainly because those are the kind of RPGs I liked after getting a little tired of 5e. The grimey, dangerous dungeon crawlers. But yeah if you wanted the pure 5e power fantasy a GM could easily say "choose a new skill" during the levelling up process.

Rick

It does help, actually! Sometimes what it takes to make something seem less daunting is to show the goal before discussing how you get there. Phrasing is important!

Sleep

Reminds me of RuneQuest, which absolutely isn't D&D but is fun to play. I am more and more hoping they're going to be a big printed hardcover book of these rules available for purchase.

Noctaceann

This honestly reads pretty damn well to me. I like the fact that for once, you aren’t the main character of the story. Sure the monsters you kill may help you get better gear, but you aren’t the important one. You’re some wannabe adventurer who is likely going to join the rabble who have gone before you. It’s great.

Nedzilla

After reading this through a few times, I think it's comparable to Goblin Quest. It's a slapstick Tabletop were you are encouraged to doodle and draw your characters that most likely will come to a sudden and often silly end doing things that are reckless and stupid, drawing injuries onto the doodles as you go. It's the shared idea that you should make something fun and unique. Something you should already enjoy chatting about right before putting it in a perilous chaotic gauntlet. Your intro also has the feeling of really starting from the bottom of the barrel working up as opposed to being a group of somewhat trained individuals (how DnD tends to feel), which feels narratively at home with the rest of the cynical setting you've written up.

Cheshire Noir

These add a very "OSR" feel to the game. Not my RPG, but a good style to adopt. (I'm an old school Cyberpunk style RPG fan. Mostly here for the boobies :-)

Zarry Underpaw

Probably not the type of feedback you're looking for but there's a typo where Leveling has an extra "L" in the middle. All in all, looks like a good primer for a "start from scratch" game that can be safely put aside once the players and GM are more familiar with the game. It evokes the ideas of older AD&D manuals but with a tongue-in-cheek comedic tone over top of it.