Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Dear friends,

As you know, there is currently no “rollback” function in the game (i.e., you cannot go back to make different choices or reread dialogue without loading a save). We made that design choice to facilitate full gameplay immersion, encouraging players to save often and think carefully before making choices. If we were to add “rollback” functionality to the game, when you make a choice you don’t end up liking, you’d be able to go back and choose a different option. For one reason or another, we’ve always felt that that would spoil gameplay - that it would be like cheating. 

What do you think about “rollback” functions? Should we add one to the game?

Files

Previews only

Comments

PrecursorDesign

While I understand that some would feel it is cheating, the reason I support a rollback feature is simple. Not everyone likes to replay a game to get every CG, animation, ending, etc. Not everyone likes new game+. Having a rollback available allows for players that don't enjoy replaying story content for 1-2 new lines of dialogue a chance to just see everything without having to grind through everything again.

Anthony Docimo

some games limit the rollback to, say, only to the most recent decision, or to five actions ago (each action being one character saying one thing), or to the most recent change of scene.

Anthony Docimo

maybe save the addition of a rollback, for later in the game's development?

PrecursorDesign

Renpy games come stock with a rollback feature. Devs can just enable or disable it, though I'm sure custom functionality can be added with some light python changes.

HDR

Biggest reason I use the rollback function is to re-read things that I sometimes skim over. I know there is a history tab, but it's very time consuming/inconvenient to keep going to that each time I click or hit space to fast before I'm done reading. Being able to toggle on/off should be available

Anthony Docimo

oh. I always thought it was something that had to be added, programmed into it. thanks

Anthony Docimo

?? I can understand rolling back to see, for example Sister Loura's response to one of MC's actions - as opposed to a different selected action - but there's only *so*far* back one can scroll with rollback. :) so following different paths will require loading a previous saved decision point, not neccessarily a new game

Laserfirelife

Rollback is good for reading something you miss, but I've just save stated at a choice and made split timeliness for the games I play usually. A toggle would be best for those that don't want extra buttons on their screens.

PrecursorDesign

Fun fact, most renpy games just let you use scrollwheel to go back and forth, so the buttons could still be hidden via coding, but scrolls wheel would still go back and forth.

PrecursorDesign

True, you can't roll back indefinitely, but I can choose between 1 and 2, then decide which outcome I prefer. If I'm still concerned, I can make a save before the choice and come back to that later if the choice I went with was actually detrimental to my preferred outcome.

david.hacker

I agree rollback is good, a toggle on/off for those that don't want it.

Anonymous

rollback is better because if you are going to rollback you would just have to save / reload instead which is more of a pain in the ass. All you are doing is allowing people who are going to save / reload to have an easier time to do so which is more player friendly and a better change. If you for some crazy reason want your games to be some kind of iron man painfest then disable saving altogether.