Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Choose What We Stream On New Show Plus - Scary Ghost Edition!

  • Real Ghost Stories That Will Kill You 88
  • The Greatest Pumpkin: Jacob Vs. Haley's Carve-Off 155
  • Bloodthirst Council: Halloween Costumes 179
  • New Show Plus Anniversary Special Clip Show Guessing Game: Episode 2 76
  • 2025-10-27
  • —2025-10-28
  • 498 votes
{'title': 'Choose What We Stream On New Show Plus - Scary Ghost Edition!', 'choices': [{'text': 'Real Ghost Stories That Will Kill You', 'votes': 88}, {'text': "The Greatest Pumpkin: Jacob Vs. Haley's Carve-Off", 'votes': 155}, {'text': 'Bloodthirst Council: Halloween Costumes', 'votes': 179}, {'text': 'New Show Plus Anniversary Special Clip Show Guessing Game: Episode 2', 'votes': 76}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 10, 28, 5, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 10, 27, 18, 12, 58, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 498}

Content

Every week New Show Plus lets supporters at the Backstage Pass tier on Patreon vote to choose a new show for us to create, or to continue an older show from a previous week. You can learn more about the format in this quick video.

But watch out, it's almost Halloween and a scary ghost has taken over this post!! Vote to choose the next episode we create for New Show Plus airing Tuesday on Twitch!

Real Ghost Stories That Will Kill You - Ahhh!!! In this show we'd take community submitted ghost stories (in text and call-ins) and tell real tales of the ghosts that have visited us in this earthly realm!

The Greatest Pumpkin: Jacob Vs. Haley's Carve-Off - Oh no!!! In this yearly option, we'd have two new pumpkin carvers face off to fulfill the same prompt and let chat vote on who made the better pumpkin.

Bloodthirst Council: Halloween Costumes - Fuck!!! We could bring Thirst Council back from the dead and put community-submitted Spirit Halloween costumes on a custom tier list using our patented tier naming system.

New Show Plus Anniversary Special Clip Show Guessing Game: Episode 2 - Help!! I'm serious, Help!!! We could continue last week's anniversary celebration and watch more classic clips from the hundreds of hours of New Show Plus we've farted out over the years. I mean, bled out!!!

Choose wisely, and may the best show win! Remember you can vote on multiple shows if there are a few you're interested in, and the winner will be back on the poll next week for a potential follow-up episode! Don’t be bummed if your choice doesn’t win the poll, if we hit our New Show Overflow sub goal on Twitch we revive a rejected show for a fun one-off!

Depending on what show wins, we’ll be going live at noon Central on Tuesday, so we’ll see you on Twitch. Feel free to shoot a sub on Twitch our way (you have a free one with Amazon Prime) and you’ll get us one step closer to reviving a rejected idea for New Show Overflow.

https://www.twitch.tv/minnmaxshow

Files

Comments

MartyMcFlury

God-tier options this week fr

Rachel Atkins

Thirst Council shall rise again!

BEEFCAKE

You had me at "Fuck!!!"

RynaGoGo

The thirst!!!!

Loud EEL

If thirst wins can we get at least 1 ghost story on the episode?

Koke Kodoro

Those exclamations after the titles really had me rolling. I'd paid you more if I could