Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The community voted, so this Wednesday we'll be airing The Deepest Dive on What Remains of Edith Finch. What we need now is your insight! Leave a comment below with a very specific piece of feedback on the game, like your favorite line, room, sound effect. The more specific your comment is the higher the chances we'll read it during the discussion. Unlike previous Deepest Dives, please don't leave multiple comments. We want to give everybody a chance to have their point read on air, so leave a good one. You're welcome to read the comments as well to make sure you're adding something new to the discussion.

We'll stop collecting comments on Tuesday morning, so the clock's ticking! Thanks for your support, everybody! This should be fun.

Files

Comments

PlusUltra

I have never played this or any other "walking simulator" before, so thank you for giving me a reason to try this. When I started playing this I kept worrying that this was going to have horror elements(not my favorite thing), it turned out to not be a scary game but it does have many emotionally horrifying moments. The moment that got to me the most was the exact moment you start Gregory's story... in the bath tub... in first-person.... I instantly knew where the story was going and I literally put down my controller, wondering for over 10 minutes if it was worth it to continue, knowing that all the gameplay results in the characters death. I did finish the game but its really stayed with me in a lot of ways I wasn't expecting.

Dennis M.

I totally forgot I claimed this game on PS+ last year, dammit! Now I played it on the Switch and the framerate was pretty rough at times. Anyway... Was I the only one taking way too long to realise you had to take a photo of your peeing father Sam during that section with Dawn? I took at least 50 photos of birds, trees and rocks before I decided to look it up online. I honestly thought it was a bug. Turns out I'm just blind. I can't believe I needed help to beat this game.

Doreen Ford

Lewis and his section in the cannery made me think about games that have gamified the mundane aspects of our life such as (for many of us) work. That got me thinking: What's the best video game moment that references the mundane aspects of life? Whether it's political in nature like Papers, Please or bizarre like near the end of Control or of course the scenes with Lewis, and what makes something like that work?

Zach Gileau

Overall, I enjoyed the game. However, I have some issues with the way some of these vignettes are designed. Many times I felt uncertain about what to do or where to go. In Sam's memory, for example, I had multiple instances where I wasn't exactly sure what I should be taking pictures of, so I spent 10 more minutes than I should have taking pictures of everything I could find in frame. In Gus' story, I was flailing the kite around hoping to make the narration progress further for about five minutes straight. For me, the absolute best story in the game (design speaking), is Lewis' story. It is *always* made clear what you should be doing and where you should be going. Not to mention they nail the thematic aspect of his story. The ludonarrative aspect here is really nicely done as well. The monotony of his manual labor job juxtaposed with the elaborate daydreams that slowly take up more and more of the screen just perfectly captures the essence of what this game is all about.

Captainstubs1

Hello everybody, This game was quite the experience to play through. I’m glad the community chose it as I likely would’ve missed it otherwise. I’m a locksmith in real life and as such I’m always looking at locks and keys in video games to see how accurate they are to real life. The key Edith holds in the beginning may be the best looking key I’ve seen in a video game. I feel like I could decode it visually and make a working key. The problem arises when Edith sticks it into the padlock to open the book in the first room Walter if I remember correctly. That kind of key would never work with that style of padlock. They used a Schlage C keyway key and that padlock would only take a Master M1 key. So overall 6.5/10 needs different keys haha

IanTClark

This game was designed for multiple play throughs. There are so many little details you would only notice after you’ve finished the whole game. I’ll only name 2: at the opening of the game when you’re on the ferry and you look down at Edith’s diary, the hands have no gloves. I would have not known you’re seeing this through the eyes of her son had I not completed the full story. Later when you’ve made your way inside the house as Edith, you can see that the stairway railing is fixed rather poorly from when Barbara’s attacker fell in 1960.

Chris Lopez

I love that this game connects to the Unfinished Swan through Milton’s story. That game was a fun little fairy tale to play through, but then to have it just be one small piece of this family’s tragic past puts that game into a whole different perspective. As I reached the Milton story in Edith Finch, I had my mind blown with how they were able to connect the two games so organically. I wasn’t expecting any connection, but it felt completely right and not just like a cheap gimmick.

Jose Gabriel

After all the free games I have claimed, I have finally bought a game off the Epic Game Store thanks to this deepest dive. Really enjoyed the game.

Tyler Carver

One of the things I couldn’t get over about this game was how crazy intricate the environmental designs were. It made the spaces feel truly lived in. It hit home during Gregory’s vignette when you could knock all of the letters of his name off the bathtub into the water, and those same magnets were stuck to a locker in his room after he passed on. Also that whole scene broke me man, my kid was sitting next to me as that sequence was playing out, and I got crazy emotional.

Christian Haines

This game released shortly after my mother passed away from breast cancer. My mother's passing was unexpected. My response to it was to avoid thinking about death, to plunge myself into my work, and to seal off my memory from my consciousness. Playing What Remains of Edith Finch compelled me to work through my grief. The combination of a meditative pace, an absence (for the most part) of fail states, and a series of complex perspectives on death allowed me to dwell on my loss. It was my first "walking simulator," and it allowed me to see that games might be less about progression or leveling up and more about enriching the textures of our emotional life. The lack of many conventional gameplay mechanics is a feature of these kinds of games, because they free up our attention to focus on the essential experience - grief, loss - that the game's trying to convey. I wonder if the criticism of "walking simulators" is a denial of emotional life in the name of a kind of toxic macho gamer culture, but that's another story... Thanks for picking this game, everyone!

DangerZone

I've only played it once but What Remains of Edith Finch has stuck with me more than any grandiose video game story. I believe the length goes a long way in making this story stick. It's stunning how such beautiful stories are told in the little time you have with them.

Ray Aldiar

The cannery level in this game is one of the most powerful depictions of mental illness that I've ever come across in media. The involvement of the player in the story, trying to juggle the two aspects of his life as the monotony gets smaller and the internal world expands, is such a viscerally moving depiction of his struggle, and one that wouldn't have had the same impact in a less interactive medium.

Cade Mead

Where does everyone stand on Barbara's death? All of the other characters are given clear cut answers. With Barb's being from a comic book, it leaves it open to interpretation. The theory I like best is Walter came from under the bed, startling Barbara, who fell through the railing and died. The guilt led to Walter locking himself away. The monster he was afraid of would've been Rick in the bigfoot mask. There likely was never an ear found in the music box, but was made up for the comic.

Sutton

I really appreciate the length of the game.. can we do more deepest dives for games you can finish in one sitting, please? :) I love how the game handles going back through the stories, I was ready to run through the game a second time for the trophy’s I missed but was happy to see the “Replay a story” option in the menu threw me right into the rooms I needed.

Brian Paradis

Hey Ben and Crew, Thank you and the rest of the community for picking this game. I grabbed it on Epic for free and I have been waiting for the right time to play it. I have played other "walking sim" games before, like Gone Home, and I figured that was what I was in for. But then Molly turns into a CAT and my expectations were shattered. I think a great game makes a case for why the story has to be a game and not some other form of media and I think that is where ...Edith Finch really shines. The cannery would not nearly as powerful if you weren't experiencing the monotony along with Lewis. If you didn't live the experiences with Edith and her family members, the story would not have been nearly as compelling. Thank you for giving me the chance to play this amazing game that I probably would never have gotten around to. Brian, Oro Valley

Prestonocron

Hi Ben! I call this style of game a 'what happened here?' game. In games like this you walk around empty houses, towns or islands and read diary entries, notes and other fragments of the lives of the people long gone and try to figure out 'what happened here'? The pacing of these games is often very slow and there is a lot of decorum. This is so the player can focus on the sad narrative and wonder 'what happened here'? Although I like this style of games I have a few improvements I'd like to run past you and the gang. A shift in focus from narrative to combat. Crafting Waves of zombies An online element so you don't feel so lonely when playing All the internal monologues should be voiced by Troy Baker. I'm joking of course. I loved this game. It puts you in someone else's shoes and then takes you on an emotional roller coaster. It tells a story in a way only a video game can. 7 out of 10 (joking again)

Geoff Enright

Hey everyone, I originally played this game a few years back and I loved it. Such a quirky house and the unique setting gives so much variety. This game is great but emotional. The most difficult moment came while realizing in the bathtub Gregory drowns. It is so creative, poignant and completely heartwrenching to experience Gregory's last moments through his imagination, by exploring his underwater world. That absolutely slayed me and I had to stop playing until I regained my composure. Geoff a.k.a Groffles

podbod

I just wanted to point out that the pumpkin man who narrates Barbara's death in the comic book sounds exactly like JeffM doing the Bobo character in the Game Informer Replay episode where they play Falling Stars. Pumpkin man narrator: https://youtu.be/9pOuBkK9hVo?t=11 JeffM doing Bobo's voice: https://youtu.be/1Ht31czPdkM?t=3293 Also, it was great fun to do a Deepest Dive on a short game! Podbod in Yamagata, Japan

Bdun912

When I first played the game at launch I moved the camera around before even taking my first step to get used to the controls—and immediately realized she was pregnant. I think that realization really set the tone for me, the melancholy, understanding who she was talking to and what it meant that he was learning Edith’s story this way. Do you have any thoughts on his cast? Do you think some kind of accident is what prompted him to make the journey? Or is it just meant to be a visual cue that it is not Edith?

Forest Lassman

Hi I like finding out about the developers who worked on a game, so I did some research into the first five developers in the credits (would've done more but it takes a lot of time). Here's brief bios of a few of the people who helped make this game Ian Dallas - Creative Director Dallas worked as a writer for The Onion and a few TV shows before going into game design. After working as a tester and briefly at Telltale as a writer on Sam and Max season 2, he helped found Giant Sparrow in 2009 and has served as creative director for both of their games. Edith Finch is dedicated to his mother Shirley, who died of ovarian cancer in 2013. Joshua Sarfaty - Technical Director Sarfaty first worked at Lockheed Martin where he designed a 3D cruise missile target model viewer and manipulator. After a little over a year Sarfaty went into game development as a programmer for a few different companies, mostly working on sports games like Madden 05/06 and NBA Ballers. He joined Giant Sparrow in 2011 before leaving in 2017 to work as technical director at Annapurna Interactive. Chelsea Hash - Lead Technical Artist Hash first worked at 1st Playable Productions on games like Imagine: Gymnast and Cabbage Patch Kids: The Patch Puppy Rescue. Hash joined Giant Sparrow in 2013, and still works there while also working freelance on games like Outer Wilds and the upcoming Solar Ash Kingdom. Brandon Martynowicz - Lead Artist Martynowicz’s first job in gaming was as an intern at EA working on James Bond 007: From Russia with Love. After graduating college he worked as a matte artist on films including the cancelled Yellow Submarine remake. In 2010 Martynowicz joined Blizzard to work on cinematics before joining Treyarch in 2012 as a senior environmental artist. After working shortly as a professor, Martynowicz joined Giant Sparrow in 2014. Shortly before the release of Edith Finch he left the company and now works at Riot as a senior environmental artist on Valorant. Chris Bell - Lead Designer Bell designed various games at Carnegie Mellon University before joining thatgamecompany as a designer and producer on Journey. After a year, he joined Giant Sparrow before leaving in 2017 to return to thatgamecompany to work as lead designer on Sky. In 2020 Bell founded a new company called Gardens.

Rich McLaughlin

I know most of the feedback is on the story, and it’s wonderfully unique, but I thought I’d share my wife’s experience. She doesn’t play any first-person games but she enjoys puzzle and story-driven games so I’d thought this would be a good entry point. She played maybe thirty minutes before getting nauseous, saying the choppy camera made it hard for her to play. Did anyone else have the same issue or is that just a function of not being used to dual analog sticks?

Anthony Brown

This is so sad! I don't like feeling this sad!

FlaminQueso

Hey howdy hey Hanson and the ‘horts, There is something enjoyable to me about having a game in the first person perspective where you can look down and see your body and feet as you walk. It feels more immersive to me because, ya know, that’s how it is in real life. This game in particular, not only includes the perspective of looking down at your body, but does so in a way that immediately tells a story about the protagonist. The style in clothing and the way it fits leads to the age of Edith (an older teenager girl), the diamond ring hanging on a necklace around her necklace lends some significance to her family ties (probably her mom’s ring), and most importantly, the little baby bump indicating early term pregnancy. I honestly wasn’t confident if her belly was supposed to indicate pregnancy or if it was just animated weirdly, but it sat in the back of my mind for the first hour of the game. Then she finally admitted to her pregnancy during a piece of narration while climbing across a tree. This made that sequence all the more impactful for me and gave a deep sense of meaning to the story and who the story was being narrated to all in one short sentence. I haven’t seen any other game use this first person perspective of looking down at your body as a story telling element before. What do you think? Do yall like when first person games let you look down at your body and feet and are there any games that do this in a way that stick out in your mind? Thanks so much! I loved playing through this game that is both short and extremely thought provoking. Hoping for more choices like this in the future! Queso

Michael Newman

First I just want to say how glad I am you guys chose this game. I know theres a lot of momentum behind covering the latest and biggest games and I really dig that you guys do it but I would love to see more in depth looks at these smaller but still greatly impactful games. I love a lot about this game, I bought it on a whim on Switch about half a year ago after hearing about it for years without knowing what it really was. The thing that really stands out to me with the opening of the game is it gives you the stereotypical "video game choice" of taking the high road or the low road. No matter how many times I play this game I always take the low road (my side questing nature really gets the best of me). But Edith Finch quickly teaches you that all paths lead to the same place which I think is a neat little metaphor for the game as a whole. All of the branches lead to the same place and are equally as important in getting you to the ending. Stay safe out there everyone. -Newman

Taylor Owens

I was so excited for this game I played it the day it came out - and absolutely loathed it. If you make a two hour montage of a bunch of people, many of them children, randomly dying, you better have something to say. I might’ve forgiven the flagrant abuse of similes in the narration, but the deaths stack up so quickly while being so imaginatively morbid it begins to feel obscene. Worse, I have no idea what this game wants me to get out of it. As soon as it ended I started googling what the “real” ending was because I assumed I had done something wrong and missed it. If you want a better version of this game play Everybody’s Gone to the Rapture. It’s a walking sim about experiencing multiple characters’ deaths but it tells the story of their lives so much better. It also has one of the best soundtracks of all time. (and it’s an homage to Where is Everybody? the pilot episode of The Twilight Zone. Twilight Highlight Byelight...)

G-Max Thoeren

Hey Cohorts! I found Lewis's story to be the most interesting and engaging, something I hypothesize will be the case with many MinnMaxers. This is partially because of the unique visual style and the fact that it lets you make choices, but also because I relate strongly to Lewis's experience. Video games are something I use as an escape from the mundanity of real life, just as Lewis did. As a result, I have occasionally had thoughts along the line of; "who really cares what happens to *me* when I can be exploring these fantastic worlds and powerful stories that were created by hundreds of artists." Sometimes it's the case that a game is just so cool that nothing else seems as important... but sometimes life is just so tough or confusing that I don't really want to be me anymore. I really appreciate the way this game was able to get me to be so introspective and to speak to an emotion that I haven't seen expressed anywhere else before! Hope you are all doing well, -Thor

Travis Brinkley

Hey MinnMax, I was pumped this was the Deepest Dive because it’s one my favorite indie games. I specifically want to mention how I would classify Lewis’s sequence as a masterpiece. It is the perfect example of a story that is most effectively told in games. The gameplay of his imagination keeps evolving and filling more and more of the screen, showing that he is slipping into his own mind. Of course, you still have to chop the fish the entire time (sometimes even to progress in his imagination). Also, how incredible is it that a game can have this much complexity and variety where you only press one button outside of movement?

Jimbotron

I absolutely adored this game. I missed it back in 2017 and have been meaning to play it for a while and I’m so glad the community chose it. I loved the different genres, and how playing through each family member was unique and fun, in their own special way. I especially liked the comic book and theme song from Halloween, it was a nice touch and made that part genuinely creepy, and even included a minuscule amount of combat, which was totally unexpected for this “walking sim”. Also, the swing mini game made me super nauseous and captured exactly what it feels like to swing that high (although, admittedly, I myself have failed to make a full revolution). All of this wrapped up in a coherent and, ultimately tragic, story with excellent pacing. Oh, and I loved that I only found myself lost one time, and all without giant arrows or overcomplicated HUD markers telling me where to go, which speaks to the excellent “level” design. Sooo good.

DarkFishDays

In Molly’s story, I love how sudden you switch from the owl to the shark and you just plop on to the mountainside. It’s so perfectly dreamlike, and it’s hilarious to see the shark flop about as it tumbles through trees.

Jon Bockman

I appreciated the sound in this game. Music and sound effects create just the right atmosphere, pair that with perfect narration from Valerie Rose Lohman as Edith and you’ve got the recipe for a moving experience. Just a brilliantly told story, really something special.

Jan Hildebrandt

Two words: "Good luck". What a powerful Moment. It's the last voice line of the game. For the whole game, Edith has been very confident, but just now, when she realizes she will be gone by now and her son is out there alone with the curse, her voice breaks in anxiety for the first time and you just have to feel with her. Edith Finch is the most relatable character I have encountered in a video game. Exceptional writing, exceptional voice acting.

John Richards

Hello everybody! Thanks so much for hosting this Deepest Dive! This game has felt like “mandatory reading” for some time, so this was a great excuse to finally dive in! I have three quick semi-specific insights and experiences from the game! I’ll list them all here: #1) The second I saw the silhouette of the house, my mind immediately drew parallels to Mark Danielewski’s novel, House of Leaves. Throughout the game, the connections only deepened - if you have anyone in the community has not read this book but enjoyed Edith Finch, then House of Leaves is a 10/10, must read! Like Edith Finch, Danielwski really manipulates his medium, and is able to generate unexpected experiential reactions while reading. You are also exploring a weird spooky house in the book, so it’s basically the same thing! #2) Calvin’s story was by far the most amazing experience - they nailed the physicality of swinging, and every pump brought a sincere joy, followed by an immediate wince and cringe when he hit the top of his arc. It felt like an evil little tease, that really paid off in the end. #3) Lewis’s scene may be the most creative storytelling I have experienced in a video game. It was amazing how awkward and awful the split sticks felt in the beginning, but as the narrative had Lewis finding his own confidence, my own clumsiness seemed to be cured as the repetition brought improvement. I don’t know if this was some sort of game play gimmick that forgave clumsy navigation, or if I was actually improving... but either way, just like Calvin’s scene, it was paced so brilliantly - it sincerely enhanced my connection to the character and to his story.

Joshua Duperoy

Hey y’all, This was my first experience playing a game of this ilk or walking simulators as they’re sometimes referred to ( cue Joe Juba of game informer bashing through the wall like the kool aid man to vociferously argue against such a designation) and I enjoyed it much more than I thought I would. Anyways, I’ve been playing on my switch and found myself making ample use of the snapshot/record button especially in some of the more fateful moments of the mini scenarios, but I found myself taken aback in the one involving Dawn’s father, Sam. I managed to take a snapshot just as Sam is startled by the deer and falls off the clip. As quickly as I took the snapshot I immediately deleted it from my album even quicker. It just didn’t feel right and that particular death hit me harder than the rest for some reason, probably the sight of Dawn crying after shooting the buck. What death hit everyone else the toughest?

Bob Buel

The level of tragic detail in this game is what really stuck with me the most. Like the missing posters for Milton everywhere, including gobs of them in the river in the woods before you even get to the house. Or the crutch that belonged to Barbara's boyfriend is now hanging on the wall in Walter's bunker. Or the fact that Sven death date, where it's told he died building the dragon slide, is the same as Walter's birthday, so you can assume he died building the present. But the one that hit me the most emotionally was when you go into the twin's, Sam & Calvin's, room. Before you know their fates or anything that becomes of them, you see their childhood door, with childishly drawn marks showing their heights growing through the years. Sam's goes up and up and up through the years, but Calvin's just stops about a third of the way up the door. This was such a punch to the gut, knowing something awful happened before anything else in the game even hinted at it. This was such a powerful game, and even though I didn't vote for it, I loved this choice for Deepest Dive. Thank you giving me a reason to play through it all!

Joe Dean

Hey Ben and the crew, Did you cry? Everytime I play this game I either cry or get so damn close to it. The soundtrack is amazing and is composed by Jeff Russo who has done a ton of work including recently the Star Trek Picard theme, which is excellent. Lastly I love Edith's gloves. They look so cool and comfy I would wear them all the time if I owned them. Thanks, Joe Dean

Zach Helton

While the stories are pretty different, this feels like a more fun version of Gone Home. Walking around an old house with no one around, but with fun different gameplay chunks here and there. The rooms all remind me of a Wes Anderson movie, they all feel like dioramas. Also, when I was in the graveyard I noticed I share a birth date with the twins, Sam and Calvin!

Matthew Gilbert

I don't think I've cried as much in a game for a long, long time. And it wasn't always tears of sorrow but that of whimsical imagination I haven't felt since I was young, to the relatable feelings of the unknown or the fear of losing my child in a tragic accident. Having lived long enough to be through some of the realities portrayed in this game, I think what stands out is the magnificent way the story unfolds and pulls you further and further into the depths of the family history. In each and every flowing point of the game, you can immediately feel the emotion of the moment. As the stories are shown, you feel like you know the house more... after the comic scene, I went straight to the railing and found the repair points after Barbara smacked the assailant off the landing. I completely missed this in my first wandering of the house! Truly remarkable and a great dive that I'm happy I got to take a part in! Cheers everyone.

James Baldwin

Hey guys! Being one of my favourite games ever, I really hope some of the crew haven't played this before because I'd love to hear your first reactions. Something I always think about and something I feel this game makes a really strong argument for, is the importance on the implementation of mechanics as opposed to the intricacy of the mechanics themselves. There's so many complicated, massive games out there that have complex stories with huge voice casts and set pieces, and yet the only thing that has ever brought me to the verge of tears in a games was playing as a frog in a bathtub. You could call it a walking sim but ironically I feel like it is the BEST use of the medium to tell a story i have ever experienced. Cheers, James

Yarrow

Glad I picked this up for free when it it was an Epic Games store giveaway! I ended up loving it! First off, how much did the Finch house give off vibes of Aerith's house? Being in the forest with the plant life growing all around it, along with the unique structural design immediately made the connection for me. Also a small thing that I enjoyed, the subtitles had lighting that illuminated in the world and bounced off object realistically. As someone who is a sucker for well done text in games (I loved the objectives in Splinter Cell Conviction being put up like it was being shot through a projector) It was nice that they gave even the subtitles life and I wanted to keep them on.

Fred Dinovo

Howdy all, I'm sure people have talked about the similarities to the real life Winchester house so I'll just say the most stressed I've ever been in a game is cutting fish heads as Lewis. Carefully avoiding cutting your own hand even though it's actually impossible in the game to do so. Overall Lewis' story was my favorite vignette seeing the gameplay evolve as he became more obsessed with his imagined world. As well as just how powerless you feel as the player wanting to prevent his inevitable fate at the end. Can't wait for the more lighthearted Deepest Dive - Last of Us Part II!

Patrick H.

I'm sure Im in the minority, but this game wasn't great for me. I got through the whole thing, but it was just so friggin depressing. I know thats what it was going for... but man that wasn't my idea of fun. I know I'm weird, but did anyone else feel like that?

Ozwaldo el Ruso

Im a sucker for text. I have subtitles on for everything, all the time. As soon as the words on screen were sucked up the chimney when I first entered the house, I was hooked and I was never let go. This was such a weird, sad, beautiful game. Excellent choice by the community. I hope we get the opportunity to do shorter games like this between the sprawling epics in the future.

Andrew Bittner

One specific thing I (think) I noticed occurred in Lewis’ story. Towards the end of his marching in his dream world, I noticed his cape jumped/moved whenever he chopped the fish heads. This seemed to tie the real and the imaginary together in a really subtle way that I don’t know if would have consciously noticed if I wasn’t looking for details to talk about. Overall, I loved the game, especially the unique nature of each scene.

betoq92 .

Hi The shark is the best part Ok bye!

Ben

I really enjoyed how dark this game was. I didn’t think I would as our nation is kind of fucked right now, but it ended up being cathartic. Quick question for the crew, what was your favorite sequence? Mine definitely would be the cannery. Close second is the Halloween-esque sequence.

Andrew vala

I immediately felt a sense of dread in this game that never went away. I played the entire game expecting either the house to to be actively trying to murder me or a "missing" family member to be skulking around the premises. Was this intended at all or I was I bringing in external biases against creepy, abandoned houses with secret passages? When I first approached the house, I noticed a knothole in the wooden fence next to the garage door. As I approached, I noticed it was lined up with a vague shape looming in the middle of the water. We later find out it's the original, sunken house. I appreciated this little bit of foreshadowing so early in the game. It immediately sparked my interesting into the mystery of the world before I had even stepped foot into the house.

Mark Miller

I just want to say that the transition and way they handle the fish cannery is maybe the single most impactful bit of interactive storytelling I have ever witnessed and I have played 100's of games. I also think the most impactful thing might be that it's told from such an amazing perspective. He was a man seeking help and it still wasn't enough to help him and I think it's important that those stories are told as someone who just lost his brother to addiction even though he had been in multiple rehabs and treatment programs it struck me a bit differently and even harder than the first time in a way I never expected.

Antonino Laberdee

I will start by saying I love this game. However, I couldn't play it again. I played this years ago and I remember it emotionally impacting me but when I went to replay for this Deepest Dive (TM) I immediately was overwhelmed and anxious. I got as far as the little girls room (where you become the cat) and had to stop. So, I guess my takeaway is the game was effective in what it wanted to do, perhaps too well. My other takeaway from my brief replaythrough is holy shit you can see her pregnant belly if you look down!? How did I go through the whole game without looking down!? Anyway can't wait to listen.

Eric Merrill

Hey I also just commented on chrono trigger way late but this one has but eating at me since I played it. I was absolutely convinced that Calvin on the swings was a suicide. A few quotes from his brother; “Calvin had always wanted to fly”. We promised we wouldn’t be afraid anymore”. “But that day he finally made up his mind to do it” “…. Then maybe he’d still be here, but I doubt it” “ I think he’d already made up his mind.” “The day he made up his mind to fly, and he did” To me this felt like Calvin was depressed and weighed down by the death of siblings and family and it felt like his brother knew the truth. Even if not suicide and just a kids making a dumb choice to swing 360 around a swing, it haunts me still. Love the show hope to hear what you think!