Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

What Do You Want From MinnMax In 2022?

  • Previews 96
  • Reviews 183
  • More Retro Gaming Content 212
  • Tabletop Coverage 105
  • Film/TV Coverage 79
  • New Shows From Cohorts 229
  • Video Essays 258
  • 2021-12-30
  • 1162 votes
{'title': 'What Do You Want From MinnMax In 2022?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Previews', 'votes': 96}, {'text': 'Reviews', 'votes': 183}, {'text': 'More Retro Gaming Content', 'votes': 212}, {'text': 'Tabletop Coverage', 'votes': 105}, {'text': 'Film/TV Coverage', 'votes': 79}, {'text': 'New Shows From Cohorts', 'votes': 229}, {'text': 'Video Essays', 'votes': 258}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2021, 12, 30, 15, 32, 34, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1162}

Content

Hello everybody! If you're reading this, then we owe you a big thank you for supporting MinnMax. You're the reason we can keep on rolling. We hope you enjoyed all of our work in 2021. As always, we'd love to hear your feedback to help shape our content in 2022. We want to keep evolving, improving, you know... getting better. I want to thank all of you as well for allowing us to experiment and shake things up moving into the new year.

Let us know in the comments what you want from MinnMax in 2022, what you think would help us grow, and any other advice you have for us as an independent outlet. Critical comments are welcome, just please don't argue in the replies.

Thanks again for your support, we're looking forward to more good times in 2022!

Comments

Zeth Hillman-Johnson

I think more than any specific type of content, I just want to see the cohorts having fun and goofing off. I don't even care if it's video games or whatever, just fun, funny stuff that you guys are interested in. And if that means the podcast becomes entirely viewer questions, so be it.

Mike Lynch

Keeping in mind their time constraints, I'd like to see what show concepts that Janet and Sarah could come up with. They could kick them off, but other cohorts could fill in so they wouldn't have to be the host every week.

Jordan Brown

Yeah, covering retro games is one of your strong suits that I think you don't cover as much. I'd love for you guys to cover Chrono Cross as a follow-up to your Chrono Trigger Deepest Dive.

Thom Blackburn

You are all doing great at this and the new cohorts have been such good adds! Horse girl and horse girl adjacent shows have been lots of fun

Taylor Owens

More retro deepest dives babyyyy

Hunter Sax

Some more podcasts. Minnmax show is one of my favorite podcasts because of the low key nature and the chemistry between the cohorts. If there is any other media or subjects that could warrant long form conversations I'd eat that up. I never complain when I can add a new podcast to my feed. As an example, Easy Allies has the regular podcast and also Frame Trap. I love them both and they both serve different goals.

Michael Gibler

Well since the government's not helping, could you guys send me a stimulus check instead? :P

PhillyYeetSteak

I would love to see you guys do first impressions type videos. Doesnt have to be a complete review or anything, but just have a standalone video focused on a particular game a cohort has been playing and their thoughts about it. Also, it would be cool to have a minnmax award at the end of the year be connected to the idea of "getting better." Maybe something along the lines of "game that made me think about something differently" or something? Just a way to acknowledge how our experiences with games helps us grow as people.

Christopher Reardon

Ya'll are doing great and have so much to be proud of! Also, Jackbox streams are always fun and great.

Leafeonn (Josh K)

Out of just these, retro playthroughs a la replay, but i would really just love more interviews

Donnie

Watch Later Season 2 plz thnx

Jake Z

Great year guys. I would like to hear you talk more about the games you're playing/finishing up after the week they came out. If you got around to finishing a game after a while it'd be nice to hear your thoughts on it before having to cram it in to GOTY discussions.

Jeffrey Rommel

Can we get video essays in podcast form?

Brian W

Interviews weren’t on the poll but that’s probably the secret best content from minnmax to me. My favorite things are your deepest dives, interviews, general impressions/takes from the minnmax show, yearly thanksgiving special and max spoilers. More game focused max spoilers like you’ve done this year would be cool! I will probably never watch your streams or new show plus. It’s too random and unfocused for me in addition to preferring podcasts over watching people play something. There’s also a lot of personal investment needed to care about new show plus, being able to vote, etc. I’m more interested in receiving focused regular audio content. I think you could even publish trivia tower as a podcast. Sure listeners may miss some aspects but currently I have 0 engagement with trivia tower other than hearing about it, liking the idea, and wishing I had the time to take part. If there was a podcast version released after it aired I could at least experience it. I sub to another patreon that does a ton of “better with video” content but also releases it in podcast form. I rarely feel like I’m missing out and still enjoy the content even though I can’t see what’s happening I hear the reactions and fun. Just being aware of audio listeners to describe a few things might be nice. Anyway, that’s my take. Keep it up!

Tyler Sticka

I adore MinnMax and won't be upset at all if you continue delivering the same great content. That said, I just want to profess some extra love for what may seem like "oddball" recommendations among the cohorts. In particular I've found Kyle's love for seemingly all movement- and exploration-heavy games, Sarah's frankness about some triple-A games combined with her openness for simulators and other Steam oddities, and Leo's passion for poorly-covered corners of gaming like VR and even Roblox really helpful for broadening my horizons when it comes to this art form. Also, House Hunter Rise is just the best and I loved seeing it return.

Barry Barrison

My suggestion totally lacks creativity, but I'd just like more of my favourite thing, the MinnMax Show. A longer show or an additional (shorter) one would be great.

Mitch

They’re obviously a little more time intensive, but I LOVE The Deepest Dive, regardless of the game being discussed. That said, whatever you’re all happy creating is fine by me! (Praying that one day we might get ME2 and ME3 Deepest Dives)

Justin Ray

I want more deepest dives on retro games! I am always a little bummed when one is announced for a new game. New games are talked about across all podcast and are in the conversation already. A spoiler cast is generally enough for a new game. I love having deepest dives on older games because it gives us an excuse to go back and play games we missed or have not played in a long time and talk about them. Secondly, just more spoiler content. I love how in Nextlander they will have full spoiler discussions in their podcast if everyone has played the game (with warnings of course). It is nice to be able to hear thoughts about the ending or something that happens later in the game without needing to spend hours talking about the game.

WavingWorld

I would love to see more inclusion of games-adjacent people from around the internet. Jacob Geller is a good example of this kind of person. Someone talking about or playing games not strictly from a journalist perspective. For example, How cool would it be to get someone from the film crew of the Warcraft movie, or maybe a Resident Evil movie? I have no idea how realistic that is but it's for sure an idea. I second Brian W, I think more interviews would be awesome! Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm pretty sure you did a game-focused memoir of Douglas Adams back at GI and its still one of the coolest things that y'all did. I really enjoyed the Oregon Trail documentary, btw and I'm glad it had more legs than just a few views on YouTube. MinnMax is for sure my favorite gaming podcast so thank you for all of the great content! <3

John Bogan

We need more COLUMBO CONTENT! JK but in all seriousness I love the somewhat outside the box stuff you guys do. For example, the LOTR commentary tracks were so much fun. Would love to continue seeing content of that sort sprinkled in throughout the year. Sort of retro tv/movie discussions or watch-alongs I guess? Hats off to a wonderful year, and I'll always continue to support you as my favorite crew. Keep up the great work as always!

Ben Taylor

I’d encourage the team to engage in more constructive criticism of games. I find Hanson often cuts off discussion when he feels it’s getting too negative. I understand the impulse to not devolve into Reddit-esque negativity. But the good kind of criticism—rooted in detail and personal experience—makes shows like these great. Don’t worry about coming across too negatively. The shows are already super upbeat. Hearing 3 different opinions from 3 different hosts is great. Props to Janet for doing this well already. I often disagree with her, but she presents her critiques well and they always give me a new perspective.

Nick from Atlanta

Copied from Twitter, but: MinnMax seems reticent to talk about hard topics, sometimes at all. I get that MM wants to be more positive, but it directly upholds the status quo when these things aren't challenged. It doesn't need to be in depth either. It can be as simple as "We don't want to get into X here, but we do want to bring your attention to it. Here's where you can learn more." Understand that being able to ignore these issues is privilege, and should be recognized as such.

Scott Wilton

I know it’s difficult but more in studio podcasts would be great.

Erin T.

I’d love to see more gameplay focused content - something in between a Deepest Dive and Replay (maybe this could be where preview content comes in?). New Show+ is some of my favorite MM content because it’s often just the cohorts earnestly playing a game and interacting/discussing it in real time rather than in the podcast. I think Hanson has mentioned this, but I also think streaming the deepest dive game (or parts of it, at least), as a way for community members who aren’t playing along to still get in on the fun is a great way to boost engagement. Truthfully though, I adore all of the content y’all make and would be more than happy with a repeat next year!

Josh64

Honestly, I understand why y’all like to shake shows up with things like new show plus, but I really enjoy consistent shows at least once a week, maybe that’s a Quick Look/New Gameplay Today kinda thing, idk, I just like shows that I new will come out week to week.

Jonathan Griffin

You know what we want, HOUSE HUNTER RISE, HOUSE HUNTER RISE(read that as a chant

spelldragon

I'm happy to see so many votes for retro content. I love retro games, but I was afraid to ask because I assumed most people would be more concerned about modern stuff (ie Halo Infinite and It Takes Two). Retro content and interviews are my favorites. And you guys do them well.

RobBobWill

I also voted retro due to personally barely ever playing current games, especially now without a current console. It's fun to hear about that stuff but reminiscing about stuff I've actually been able to play is my usual pipe dream with gaming outlets. Aside from that, one specific question/suggestion I had: I'm a MM noob so I don't know how the Personal Top Ten works, but I am loving the steady drip of tweets showcasing the Friends of the Show Top Tens, and if there's some way you could put together a video with a quick 10-min interview with each contributor about their list I would absolutely love that. For instance I really want to know why Jeff Cork's #1 is Repentance, because I am so here for it.

Phil McKrackup

I agree with Scott Wilton. It’s just better when everyone on the podcast is physically together. But I understand that may not be an option nowadays.

Jaylyn brooks

More streams like u did with suriel,surprising other cohorts with games to play together

Corbin Benn

Can we add House Hunter Rise. I need moreeeeee

Shawn Mills

I would also like to mention the interviews as being a real strength of MinnMax that I would like to see more of. In terms of new content to add the only thing that really feels like its missing is a competitive show with the cohorts, something along the lines of Stress Test or Replay Showdown where the cohorts compete to see who can get farthest in a game in a set amount of time or some sort of tournament with a prize or punishment at the end. Keep up the great work and thanks for a great 2021!

YARF

Hanging out for a movie commentary is so fun, the Lord of the Rings commentary for example, so continuing the occasional treat like that sprinkled in is a darned hoot and a half. If you guys go to a weird game panel or something in Minnesota, game or entertainment related, that’d be fun. Keep trying stuff, see what sticks, pursue the passion, all that, this is the year~ Happy New Years folks!

PoorAndCurly

I think reviews could be cool. We already get some good content on new games in the podcast but a singular voice on one game could be a nice compliment. Definitely go the easy allies route and take your time. I don't think your audience wants a review the second embargos are up, but I'm sure there's pressure to get content out for more potential views etc.

James Pies

Leo Vader's Watch Later series needs a comeback. His LOTR games retrospective and Hitman videos are truly great and got me into MinnMax. Then trivia tower sparked a patronage.

MouseRat

I would love another podcast with a more relaxed format, not even strictly games related. Just a laid back format with 3-4 cohorts talking about what's happening in your lives, what your watching, what your playing. I like the minnmax show format, but it primarily covers games that came out that week, so this could help fill those gaps and also give you space to talk about whatever has got your attention that week. I know there is minnmax council. I just think a more discussion based format, over the Q&A format would be more appealing to a wider audience. At some point you guys did a bonus podcast as a new show plus and that's the kind of format i'd love to see regularly.

Pelicanman

I know you don’t want the Two Tens to be a scientific list, but if the goal is to “measure passion,” I think starting with an averaging of each cohort’s personal list and then having the debate from that baseline to make the final list would be a good way to do that. This year it felt like the list was almost randomly decided and not a great reflection of how each person felt about the year’s games.

Mr Pop

Nearly all of the recommendations that I would have were already posted above but I think I have one more to pop on the pile. 

Every now and then on the Monday Q&A, Ben brings up how the max spoilers for tv/movie content is easy and fun to do but rarely gets the return he’s hoping to see. It’s clear from the poll above that this content might be the least popular of the proposed slate, but there’s still interest in it from both sides. I’m wondering if you could just roll in that content into the core MinnMax show instead? 

There are a few blockers I can already see with this change - Ben is generally spoiler-adverse, so conversations about episode 1 of, say, She-Hulk would have to be more about initial reactions and overall feelings moreso than digging deep (since this discussion would be nested between other topics and I’m betting you’d hate to bamboozle your audience with unwanted reveals). *However*, the people that would turn out for one of those conversations would most likely be watching your core show AND anyone who wouldn’t be (which has to be a sliver of the MinnMax audience, right?) would at least check it out every now and then. At that point, if anyone does fall off with the new integration… that’s like what, a very, very small amount of folks at most? 

 Might make those MinnMax show Youtube titles a little more punchy - “Halo Infinite, Bayonetta 3, God of War Ragnarok, Jurassic World Dominion Impressions - The MinnMax Show”. Flows right into things, keeps something going that you already have a workflow for, and it could potentially fill some time on the show when some weeks look a little light. You could have a spoiler chat after the credits roll on the core show for those that want to stick around. 

 I’ve seen some folks propose a Frame Trap-esque sibling show where the crew could have an additional chance to talk about (potentially more in-depth) some of the games or media they’ve really been passionate about, and I think that idea rocks. Really feeds into the ‘celebrating positivity’ thing MinnMax has going for it. If the movie talk doesn’t fit in the core MinnMax show, why not have it there? In fact, that would be a good gimmick to get folks in the front door of another MinnMax show. 

 I absolutely understand that my take on this is a little simple and ‘easy’ - that there are logistical / budgetary things that may make something like this very complicated depending. But this was something rolling around in the back of my head as I was listening to your Monday Q&As and I figured I’d share. 

 Thank you for all that you do! Looking forward to 2022!

Matthew Roberts

I'd like you to try Giant Bomb esque features like Die Another Friday, Steal My Sunshine, etc.

Anthony Brown

I really liked the work y'all did at gameinformer when y'all talked to developers. Since y'all are smaller now it would be cool if y'all could interview indie devs for those game's y'all really like that don't get a ton of hype like Chicory.

John Ford

I don't have time to listen to all MinnMax's stuff and also listen to other gaming outlets. I have other interests. So if yall don't review new games, I probably just won't hear about games haha

Samuel Hall

Hi Ben and the cohorts! I have really enjoyed Minnmax over 2021. I feel that there is no need for formalized preview/review style content because what I enjoy the most from you guys are the chill longform discussions. I think though, that it would be great to have more cohorts create new shows where they can take the lead and show their personalities as hosts. Looking forward to a great 2022!

Simon M

Most importantly I just want things you all will enjoy doing. When your enjoying what your doing it makes better content. Whether its just looking at houses or doing a documentary on the Oregon trail.

Thomas Hoster

Honestly I feel like this year has been great and Sarah and Janet have been huge additions. Leo has been great and I love that he adds his VR perspective. The only perspective I sometimes I think is lacking is on a shooter focused side of things. There’s a ton in that genre from indie shooters etc that I think is missing. But I know you can’t just add more perspectives on a whim and the crew is honestly doing so well I couldn’t be happier. Hope to continue to see growth! You all deserve it.

LaRay M. Hare

Hey MinnMax, Happy New Year, and I’m personally excited for what’s to come. Candidly, I’d like to see analysis of the Video Game industry as a whole, from Gaming History, to Game Development, to Games Media. I’d like to really dissect the review industrial complex, what has worked in the past and how reviews can be improved to give the Community a better understanding of the products they intend to purchase and enjoy.

Aaron Lennon

Honestly I think you guys already do amazing work, so there is not much more that I want. My only request would be to get Colin Moriarty on Trivia Tower. (I hear Ben going "Heuuu boyyyy" I my head when he reads this lol I feel the gaming industry is inclusive only if you think exactly the same and its time to prove otherwise. You are an independent outlet and could show that coming together in times of divide is exactly what minnmax stands for He's a great, nice, funny and intelligent guy that would make for a fantastic guest, so there is literally no reason for not having him on besides fearing some sort of backlash from other podcasters. I really don't like the political walls the gaming media has built up around itself, I find it obnoxious and Exclusive, furthering divide imo, so it would make my year seeing this kind of content of people just enjoying trivia tower over love of games regardless of who you vote for. It shouldn't, and doesn't matter. Anyways, I really hope you strongly consider this as it would be a boss move. Thanks for 2021, can't wait for whats in 2022

Authoritan

To echo a couple of sentiments already aired. I'd love to see more deep dives on older games and more single player games with colour commentary. Super Mario 64 and Chrono trigger deep dives and The Dirge with Grant and Ronny and Perfect Weapon with Suriel are some of my favourite things you've done. I love long-form hangout vibe, it's about the journey we're taking together! Maybe a topic could be a good addition to the MinnMax show, could encourage more free-form conversation, which you've mentioned you'd like, and it could also help in getting to know the hosts better. If you want to spice it up a bit, Vidjagame Apocalypse has a great twist on the topic idea with their top five X-themed games, where the theme is hitched to a recent release. I'm not saying to do a top five, just an example of a different approach to something tried and true. (That's also one of my favourite podcasts, great hangout vibe, if that's what you're looking for.) Could House Hunter Rise be a good fit for a regular monthly or every-two-months show? It has near universal appeal and everybody loves it, seems a shame not to tap into that. And if anything is eventually going to break through on youtube it seems like that could have a pretty good chance at it. Happy new year, take care!