Q&A Session #5 -- ANSWERS May 2017 (Patreon)
Content
Brandyn S asked:
Hey Joseph! I'm a huge fan of your videos and this is my first time participating in the QNA session.
- What do you think of dishonored? It's got some of my favorite gameplay of most games in recent memory, with the multiple ways to tackle every situation and was just wondering if you have ever played them and what you thought of them!
- On a similar note, have you ever played Pillars of Eternity? I have just started playing it and have been blown away by the quality of the dialogue, writing and lore. Wanted to know if you have tried it and what you though, and if you have maybe played anything similar you could recommend me as this is my first “proper rpg” (in the same vein as baldurs gate, fallout 1/2 as opposed to a Bethesda rpg) and was wondering what other games you may have played that are similar and you would recommend.
- Finally, I am interested in what subjects you found the most interesting during your school days. Did you always have an affiliation for English literature and similar critiquing? Did you follow this pattern through uni as well? I am currently studying psychology at uni and did a level English lit and your videos really tap into a certain level of casual/approachable analysis and critique of games that I hugely appreciate and utterly adore, and it’s why I decided to become a patron. I feel like your videos have inspired me a little to become more in tune with these analytical perspectives when playing games, and it’s been an eye-opening experience, so thank you so much for making these amazing videos, they’re easily my favourite things on youtube to watch. I hope none of these questions have been answered before as a passing remark in one of your youtube vids, as I haven’t watched all of them (specifically for games I haven’t played yet) and would love to know what you think. Thanks again Joseph, you’re the best?
Hey Brandyn. I can't give you long answers to some of these questions but I'll do my best. I haven't played some of these games extensively yet.
1—I've only played the first Dishonored. I think I was still playing WoW at the time and I remember rushing through the last half of that game so I could be done in time for a raid week or something? All I know is that I rushed a good chunk of it.
Overall I liked the game. The superpowers were given enough focus that it felt like I was meant to use them, even if they can break the game. Not so sure how I feel about the stealth and the combat, but I liked the setting and the level design a lot more than anything else. The story was a bit poor in the second half but a lot more work went into world building.
It felt like a looser, more creative take on the Deus Ex type game. Good exploration, and everyone raves about that one dinner party level even though I barely remember it.
The telltale heart item is what sticks in my memory the most. I thought that was a cool feature that didn't have to be in the game but was anyway, even if some of it doesn't make much sense.
Sorry I can't speak more about it. I might do a video on the series at some point. I'd like to do a more thoughtful run of the first game and then look at the sequel. I can't recall any good videos I've seen on the series either so I can't point you toward some discussion on it.
2) On a similar note, have you ever played Pillars of Eternity? I have just started playing it and have been blown away by the quality of the dialogue, writing and lore. Wanted to know if you have tried it and what you though, and if you have maybe played anything similar you could recommend me as this is my first “proper rpg” (in the same vein as baldurs gate, fallout 1/2 as opposed to a Bethesda rpg) and was wondering what other games you may have played that are similar and you would recommend.
Steam tells me I have played Pillars of Eternity for 9 hours, but that seems really high to me. I don't remember playing it that much. I got through the starting dungeon, the big shock after that, and then explored the first village and met some of the characters.
I enjoyed it a lot and then never went back after turning it off that night.
I think about this more often than I probably should. I love Baldur's Gate 2. I played that game to death, multiple times, and lost myself to it for what must have been near 200 hours when I was a teenager. Same for Planescape Torment—thoroughly immersed in that story, just like a good book can drag you in.
But Pillars? Tyranny? Wasteland 2? Fallout 2? I don't know why, but I don't feel the same attraction. Maybe it's a time thing. Those games require a big commitment, especially since you have to meet them halfway on a lot of things because the combat is mostly shit. It's not strictly a problem with the isometric perspective either, because I have the same issue with Neverwinter Nights 2. I've played it a fair amount, enjoyed what I did, and yet felt no big draw to go back to it.
Maybe it's the density of the game's story and characters, mixed with a bunch of janky cinematics and a lot of reading. I love reading but not on a screen. Maybe my tastes have changed but I don't think I'm lying to myself when I say I enjoyed what I saw. Maybe it's just a coincidence and, while trying to play these games, I had a lot of distractions from other things so I couldn't connect with them. I'm not sure.
The only other games I can think of that are like this are the old Planescape game and the new Planescape game. Tyranny and Wasteland 2 I mentioned before. Shadowrun Returns and UnderRail (not to be confused with UnderTale) are big ones that I hear are good but I haven't played them.
Dragon Age Origins is also pretty good. And you can play Neverwinter Nights 2 without the first one. They're not connected if I remember right. I've heard great things about NWN2's expansion Mask of the Betrayer so it might be worth checking out. But that game is really old and is early 3D, so it hasn't aged nearly as elegantly as the late 2D stuff.
3) Finally, I am interested in what subjects you found the most interesting during your school days. Did you always have an affiliation for English literature and similar critiquing? Did you follow this pattern through uni as well?
I cut the rest of the question so there are fewer repeated words on the page. It was a lot of nice comments! Thank you for them. I hope the new videos stay at the same level of quality for you. I'll continue to try my best.
So it may surprise you to know that I was more into math and science in school. For almost all of it. I did really well in school and the only subjects I struggled in were other languages, but that's a whole other question. So even though I got high marks in English class, I was mostly about science. For a long time I was moving toward a career in something along the lines of engineering. My dream for most of my teenage years was anything to do with space. I don't know what I specifically would have ended up going for but obviously that didn't happen, so it doesn't matter. Fun to think about though.
When I was around four we moved from the UK to Canada. When I was around nine we moved back to the UK. Then at about sixteen we moved back to Canada again after I finished high school in Britain. The way school works is different in these countries. You're mostly done at sixteen in Britain with an option to continue. In Canada there was still two years left that aren't as optional.
The problem was deeper than that because the way subjects are taught is also vastly different. I was ahead in some areas. Behind in others. Science and math were especially awful because the teachers couldn't understand this difficulty and, to be fair, most of the burden was on me to adapt. Why should they have to go through so much trouble just for one odd student that has the equivalent of high school completed already?
Unfortunately for me this was not a good time to have a massive challenge and a shake up in education to adapt to. I had lost all of my friends in this move, and was staying in a small house that we shared with my mother's brother's family. We were all crammed into one small room. I'll spare you the mopey details but I think it's understandable that I was miserable.
English became something that was easy to slip back on, especially since high school here was so much more specialized than in the UK. I had always done well in history so that was something else I pursued since science and math were no longer options. I had always written stories my entire life, loved reading, and took a creative writing class in high school as well. I learned next to nothing in that class because the teacher was terrible but the idea to pursue something as a writer became more real there, so it was still a good experience for me.
For a while I had a lot of regret about not pushing more to adapt to the change. I had a lot of interest in math and science and I should have kept at it even out of school. I'd say the move was the big culprit and less so the different school system—you shouldn't force that big of a change on a teenager at such a crucial time.
I don't regret it anymore because I didn't know I was narcoleptic back then, which would have killed my chances at so many of those jobs right off the bat. So maybe it was a corrupted blessing. I still have other regrets about education—not exploring computers and programming especially. I was a really smart kid but I also had no real direction outside of vague goals. Probably my own fault, and it's getting difficult to really remember all those years now. More than half of my life has gone by since then.
I didn't finish university for reasons similar to those above about my parents. Again, another topic and probably not that interesting. When I was going it was for English and a bit of History. My view on that type of academia is quite negative. I've answered at least two questions about it in prior Q&As if I remember right. If you're really curious you might want to do some CTRL+F searches for them.
Despite saying that, I do think it was a good thing I went through those classes. I learned a lot, even if it wasn't exactly the way I should have been learning, and I'm very happy to be in the place I am now. Who knows what would have happened if we had stayed in the UK, or any other virtually infinite changes that could have happened. You can lose a lot of time thinking about stuff like that.
Ramiz G asked:
Hi! I'll be a little wordy. Sorry for that in advance, it's just me being bad with words. Anyway, first I want to say thank you for the videos. I enjoy long-form analysis format you employ, reminds me a lot of encyclopedias about sciences I've read as a kid. I really do love that format. I’m kinda tempted to do something similar with some older games, no one talks now (Gothic, Jedi Knight, NOLF). It was quite timely, to find your channel, because I’ve recently bought a ps4pro (hence U 1-4 and LoU) and last half of the year I spent on DS 1/3 and BB. And playing and after that listening to analysis and comparing it to my thoughts – it is fun. Or may be a sign that I need more friends? Who cares. So, I have some questions. While I know that they’re probably not from your area of expertise, I guess I hope to see outsider’s perspective. If that makes sense?
- First question is probably a bit personal for me. I love playing stealth games (at least from time to time), and I prefer older Splinter Cell and Thief games to recent stealth games (with exception of Hitman). They’re probably slower, but it feels more… deliberate? I guess. Personally, I think it’s more about atmosphere and how such slow gameplay work with it, not unlike Souls games. But, that preference of mine leaves me quite puzzled when I hear things like “I don’t like stealth games for long times when I must wait long time for perfect moment; so, that’s why I think, say, Dishonored is much better, because I can do things way faster or just engage with the enemy”. Usually, if there’s a sentiment that I don’t agree with, I can understand where it comes from (for example, people love their MOBAs or MMOs, I can see the appeal, even if I don’t personally enjoy them; good for them!). But that one, for some reason I just don’t get it. Like, Dishonored, Blacklist, MGS V aren’t bad games, they’re flashy, with good level design, and allow for many approaches, but as a stealth game, they’re rather easy and not that challenging, even if I go for perfect scores with no tools/magic. And yes, they don’t waste my time, but is it a good thing? Do we lose something with that level of streamlining? So, the question is, what’s your stance on stealth genre, and why do you think there’s such divide in impressions? And do I make sense with such question and ramblings?
- I played a little new Prey (and then I returned to finish DaS3 with dlc), and one of the things that surprised me, was how old-school controls felt. Comparing it to Dishonored 2, it’s strange. Prey could be as well be released in 2002, while Dishonored 2 is, definitely, product of our time (even if you downgrade graphics). I wondered a little why it is. Probably, it goes with some imperfections with how weapons handled (spread, recoil, etc), and combined with weakness of the player it becomes easier to use other means of facing enemies (outwitting them and cheesing them out), and lack of many flashy custom animations (like all the finishers in DH2). And to be honest, I find that classic old-school feel very… refreshing. I wonder, if that relative lack of polish in how character controlled and felt, does improve the game, or is it just my nostalgia speaks. What’s your take on that?
- Ok, just quick, fun question. Star Wars or Star Trek?
Hey Ramiz. The videos are a lot of work and older games don't typically do that well, so only go for it if it's a passion project that you'd like to do regardless of how much exposure they get. People WILL watch them and enjoy them, so they won't fizzle into nothing, but definitely know what you're getting into ahead of time and manage expectations.
1—I think you make sense. Or at least I think I've understood enough to try an answer.
I haven't played many stealth games but then there are also not many stealth games, period. The big ones missing for me are Splinter Cell and Thief. I tried Splinter Cell and couldn't get into it. Thief I just missed, unfortunately.
Despite having so few games devoted to just stealth, it's a feature in many games now. I enjoy the concept a lot but many games do it badly. I think a lot of the reason for that is tied to what you spoke about here.
Waiting is boring. It's always boring. No exceptions. Right? Well, yes, but it's the amount of waiting that's important. The idea of a stealth gauntlet is that you have to avoid detection from enemy sentries by staying quiet, or out of their line of sight, or being clever about alternate routes that avoid them. This almost always means learning patrol routes and slipping through them when there are openings.
There's also the more involved side with killing or subduing all enemies within an area while remaining undetected, but we'll leave that alone for this conversation. It's worth saying that some games are harder like this, but others are also easier. Removing a patrol can be difficult but then it's a piece of the enemy's coverage that's now free for you to roam. This can make stealth sections become puzzles more than anything else: identify the first guard you can safely remove, and then peel them away after that.
But waiting is boring. How much waiting? I'd say anything over 10 seconds. Maybe even less than that. A second or two of waiting can be exhilarating in this system though, because it can feel like anticipation—at least it can the first few times. This is wrapped tightly with success and failure though. Fuck up a part even a few times and even that second or two will become infuriating, and might lead the player to explosively ignoring stealth and trying to go guns blazing instead—something most games support since pure stealth is so rare.
Think also about games that aren't pure stealth that DO have forced stealth sections with no other option, like some sequences in Zelda. Think of how frustrating they are in comparison to other stealth games, even those devoted to it.
I think it's a matter of patience. Some people love the tension of slipping through enemy patrols and being right in the middle of them all, still undetected, and feeling like they're some great infiltrator. I think it can also appeal to the hunter instincts in a lot of people, especially in an action game. But true patience is a rare quality and, even with it present, a high difficulty level can ruin it with too many restarts through the same thing.
Could be a problem solved by some mild randomization on enemies and available paths. But typically it means the game is very easy or the player is given supernatural tools to help like a radar minimap, or you can see through walls, or the basic third-person camera perspective to peak around corners with no danger.
I think if you're going for a puzzle approach then some time-powers would be great so you can fastforward or rewind for a few seconds, on a cooldown like Prince of Persia, so the player can feel like they're actively playing this "waiting" time rather than being idle.
Stealth is a niche type of game that deserves a really great title, which I don't think exists yet. Does anyone know if I'm wrong?
2) I played a little new Prey (and then I returned to finish DaS3 with dlc), and one of the things that surprised me, was how old-school controls felt. Comparing it to Dishonored 2, it’s strange. Prey could be as well be released in 2002, while Dishonored 2 is, definitely, product of our time (even if you downgrade graphics). I wondered a little why it is. Probably, it goes with some imperfections with how weapons handled (spread, recoil, etc), and combined with weakness of the player it becomes easier to use other means of facing enemies (outwitting them and cheesing them out), and lack of many flashy custom animations (like all the finishers in DH2). And to be honest, I find that classic old-school feel very… refreshing. I wonder, if that relative lack of polish in how character controlled and felt, does improve the game, or is it just my nostalgia speaks. What’s your take on that?
Hm. Okay, so this will be a little awkward because I disagree. Prey felt pretty modern to me. Closer to the latest Doom game than anything else I can think of right now, especially with the ledge grabbing. The sliding sets it apart too from older games. I've gone through Prey twice now and I'm in the middle of System Shock 2 as of writing this.
That's in terms of controls though, whereas what you say here sounds more like gameplay. That's definitely closer to some of the older games, especially System Shock and Deus Ex. I can't agree about a lack of polish in controls though. Aside from the zero-gravity sections, which may be awkward on purpose, I thought it was great. Maybe we're talking about different things.
I haven't nailed my thoughts down on Prey yet because it'll be an upcoming video. I agree with what you're saying about gameplay because it's more about thinking about encounters, learning from deaths, and preparing for next time. It's a game about "bring the right tool for the job" which is likely a line that'll make it into the video. Whether that's a good thing or not is debatable, and I think the combat is on the weaker side of things in that game. Overall I enjoyed Prey though.
As for nostalgia and making things feel old: there's definitely a market for that in visuals. Even some of the shitty early 3D games have gotten homages lately. I think Strafe is one of them right? Gameplay can be brought back from that too. But controls, not so much. Some flaws can be recreated with great effect, like the visual tearing in Mega Man 10 even though it came out in 2010, if I'm remembering correctly. But poor controls age and stay aged in my opinion. I'd hate to have to return to what Deus Ex felt like, and I have to tolerate a lot of jank in System Shock 2 right now. Especially when it comes to jumping on things and hit detection on melee weapons.
Could a game pull it off? I think so. But mostly for people who have already been exposed to those games. A controversial example would be Super Mario 64. Wonderful controls for the time. Not so hot today compared to the improvements brought in later 3D games. It's still accurate and precise enough to be enjoyable, but it's ever so slightly off in a way that I think could alienate people who are playing it for the first time today.
3) Ok, just quick, fun question. Star Wars or Star Trek?
Your quick fun question is going to piss a lot of people off, haha. It's fine though. It's a good question.
The honest answer is neither. It's a tiny bit complicated though.
I like Star Wars. I don't love it. I watched the original trilogy when I was a kid. I thought they were good, but I didn't obsess over it. I had friends who did though and they ruined it for me. I hated the endless quoting and reciting of it, especially when they watched them again and repeated lines as they happened or spoke them before a character could.
That's going to make me sound like a hipster who hates it because it's popular. That's not what's happening here. I think they're good movies (well the first two are) and I will happily watch them with my kids when they get older since now those friends aren't there to spoil them for me. But the damage has been done permanently to the series and I am incapable of adoring those movies like others do. I do not think the prequels are nearly as bad as everyone else seems to think, but mostly because the original trilogy isn't exactly pristine and a bastion of logical plot points either. The prequels are definitely the weaker movies, but they have some positives, if only for some of the action scenes at the time. Especially the final light saber duels in Phantom Menace and Revenge of the Whatever.
I didn't love The Force Awakens. It felt like they made A New Hope all over again only with even more batshit plotholes that make the prequels look tame. I genuinely do not understand the fervor this movie has garnered from the same people who hate the prequels. If you like all the movies then great! Makes sense! Star Wars is your thing.
I think I've enjoyed the Star Wars video games more than the movies.
My opinions on Star Trek are a bit more tame, simply because I haven't watched enough of them. The new movies don't count—they're part of the routine action movies that are being made right now that have the Star Trek logo as flavoring, like they're a packet of chips. They're entertaining but nothing special. Some fun visuals.
The television series is where I have some experience. I've watched nothing of the original series, probably 20 or 30 episodes of The Next Generation, a lot of Voyager, next to nothing of Deep Space Nine, and nothing at all of the one that came after that. Enterprise?
I liked Voyager a lot because it was so exotic compared to the rest of the series, but I was really young when I watched that show so who knows. I think I'd like TNG a lot but the first episodes are really really REALLY fucking bad. And I'd like to watch them in order, since that's what stopped me from enjoying a lot of it when I was younger. I would catch them on tv while changing channels and be a bit lost, even though I liked it.
I hear Deep Space Nine is fantastic if you watch it in order like that, but I was too young to appreciate it. It was boring as hell as a kid. This is the one I'd like to watch the most.
To loop it back to Voyager, I thought the characters in that series were the most human because they were separate from the rest of the Federation. People in the Star Trek universe are so robotic. Everyone is half vulcan. It's all so sterilized and clean, like everyone had their baser instincts lobotomized for the sake of progress. I know that makes the emotion that does appear feel a lot more impactful, but it's strange to realize that Data is one of the most relatable people on that show, and his whole plot arc is about a robot slowly becoming human.
Voyager avoids that problem because they're stranded and desperate and forged an unlikely alliance with another ship of rebels out of necessity. There's an undercurrent of tension there that I remember, but we're talking about almost 20 years ago now so maybe I'm wrong.
Brendan L M asked:
Hello, Joseph! This is my second time typing these do to an unfortunate misclick. But, I digress.
- Are there any sponsorships that you have been offered that have tempted you? Any brands you would like to work with?
- Do you avoid making videos on games that you have thoughts on but doubt there is an audience for? Which ones? Does covering recent releases boost viewership when you aren't posting reviews or at release?
- Is there any parent company you would consider working for if you could maintain production rate and creative freedom? (As in doing what you do for Polygon, IGN, Kotaku, etc. What conditions would you have if you did?
Bonus Short Question: Why do you think simulator games are so overwhelmingly loved on steam? (ie: euro truck, farming, etc.)
Hi Brendan. Sorry to hear about the misclick. I think Patreon's comment system is a bit finnicky. Might be better to type questions in a word file and then paste it over. That's what I do for answers.
1—This will be a short answer, sorry. I've received very few offers for sponsorship. I can only remember two right now, that's how rare it's been. The first was for bean bag chairs? Sumolounge? I think that's them. They asked twice. I emailed them back asking why they think a video game analysis channel is a good fit and I never got a response.
More recently I got an email proposing that I plug some unspillable cup or something which is again weird. I didn't answer that one.
I get regular emails for youtube network partnerships. These are so numerous I don't bother replying. The one and only time I did saying no I got another email back asking for reasons why, which would overwhelmingly likely lead to another email asking why until they can establish a dialogue and try to convince me to give them part of my ad revenue for nothing. Mildly annoying, those emails.
I've had a few offers to promote a game. No solid figures for money though. Maybe that's for the best because I may have been tempted at the start when things were more financially rocky. I doubt I'll ever do any sort of promotion on the channel. I would have to be desperate, or it would have to be an absolutely absurd sum of money with a contract that I am allowed to publically release so there are no questions about bias, and total freedom on what I'm allowed to say.
Unlikely.
2) Do you avoid making videos on games that you have thoughts on but doubt there is an audience for? Which ones? Does covering recent releases boost viewership when you aren't posting reviews or at release?
Yes and no. This is complex. The issue is that so much is based on luck. How things are voted on social media within the first 10 minutes. The first few comments—whether they spur interest or not since many people check the comments before the post. Big releases can fail because of this, whereas relatively unknown games can do really well. SOMA was a surprise hit. Definitely the best return on time investment in a project for the channel. Whereas Uncharted 4 fizzled. Same with Rise of the Tomb Raider. Dark Souls DLC doesn't do very well either. I think a lot of people skip that extra content.
The games matter a lot. So do the titles. But there's the big luck factor. Of my last four videos, two of them have been on mega huge games—Fallout 4 and Breath of the Wild. Before that things are difficult to properly judge, especially given that big views can come much later like with The Witness. Typically though, videos have their biggest bump in views in the first 48 hours.
I spoke a bit about this in a previous Q&A. I think you can find it with a search for controversy and how I sometimes picked projects. There's no real solid method I'm set on at the moment, although chasing big titles does seem to help a lot.
I'd love to have the freedom to do quick looks on new indie games, but I don't have the time and "diluting" the channel with non-review/critique/analysis videos is something I take very seriously. I could pull a Shammy and launch a Second Channel for that but it's still so close to video games that I don't know. I'm unsure about that, since it's splitting views and youtube's suggestion detection too, from how I understand it.
There are a bunch of old games I'd like to do that I think wouldn't be popular. From the SNES era especially. I still might do some of them when I'm building a buffer for The Witcher Series since I've already played them and don't have to learn a game from nowhere going back.
The Little Nightmares video makes me a bit cautious about doing general gaming topics, but it's very likely that video didn't do well because reddit was still pissed that I dared criticize Breath of the Wild. That video was posted twice on the major game hub there and the one with my name in the title got heavily downvoted, whereas the other one got a lot of upvotes. Of course the one with more upvotes got deleted so the video didn't get as much exposure as it might have. I like that video a lot so I'll probably make more of them, but I think I get more consistent success with big releases.
I'm trying really hard to weave in smaller games right now though. It's quite stressful.
3) Is there any parent company you would consider working for if you could maintain production rate and creative freedom? (As in doing what you do for Polygon, IGN, Kotaku, etc. What conditions would you have if you did?)
Maybe at the start of the channel but not anymore. Growth is stable and consistent. Even with long gaps between video releases the channel grows itself now. You can see the same with other guys who go months and months and months without videos and still get new subs, once they've reached a certain size.
The only thing that could make it worth it would be a massive amount of exposure, which I don't think would happen. Or a big payout for making a video that they could have on their own site for ad hits. Maybe that would be a good partnership, as long as I could have the video on my own channel a little later, but I think it would be a lot of hassle for very little gain. Unless it's a large enough sum of money that it would help make more videos for myself in the long run.
I don't have anything against those websites and I would strongly consider doing written reviews for games if I was approached, but I'm already too busy with my current projects so I don't know how I would find the time. It would depend on how much they'd be paying. Kind of lame for it to depend so much on money right?
To answer your question in a hypothetical way, I'd have to have total creative freedom and under no circumstances would my script be allowed to be changed without my approval. This would also extend to anything that would change my style and how I present myself, even if there are a few subjectively poor parts for that. Ray Bradbury mentions this in a good essay about how strict editing rules can lead to all writers sounding the same. Sometimes there's something to be gained from the little oddities that some people have. They should be embraced—perhaps not celebrated—but they should survive.
Bonus Short Question: Why do you think simulator games are so overwhelmingly loved on steam? (ie: euro truck, farming, etc.)
Some people might play them ironically. Others might do so out of curiosity—or with the goal to play it in order to make fun of it—and end up getting looped in by a progression system. I should try some of these games for an upcoming video on Cookie Clicker (hopefully sometime this year, it's been on my to do list for a while). We're so easily ensnared by simple rewards and rising numbers.
I think there's also something to be said about a simple mindless game you can do while listening to music or a podcast, or checking out something a bit more realistic and learning how some jobs sort of work. I know they're not truly accurate but you get a new EXPERIENCE.
Ooo, shameful plug to that video there.
Whitelight asked:
- You said on the discord or maybe twitter that you really like Darksiders 2's combat system. I couldn't tell if you were being serious because it seemed everyone in that thread was acting strangely, but I for one fucking love the game. It might be my favourite of all time. I wondered if you had any other thoughts on the combat or on the game otherwise.
- Your book answer in the last Q and A was really fascinating. You broke the top 500? That's awesome. I wondered how you wrote your books. Do you start from the middle and expand out? Wing it with the major plot points set? The snowflake method what ever the fuck that is? Or something else?
- Were you introverted when you were young? Or did you "do the road" and go out tagging office buildings, eating cocaine sandwiches, picking up dragon chicks and dabbing. P.S. I'm glad you found my picasso killing thumbnail artwork funny. It was an online sketchpad rather than paint actually. I'm just a classy artist.
Hey again Whitelight.
1—I don't even own Darksider's 2, so either it wasn't me or we were shitposting for Turbo Button's video. Discord can get stupid sometimes.
I know next to nothing about the game so I can't talk about it. So let's talk about your video instead since this answer will suck otherwise.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFXxP2ELPkk
I watched it the other night. You did a good job and not just for a first attempt at the video game analysis thing. Your shifting microphones weren't as noticeable as you think. Consistency is great but it wasn't that bad. Your visuals typically matched what you were talking about and I know how much work that takes. I won't speak much about the content itself because I've already said my piece on the DLC in my video. And you spent a decent chunk talking about the lore and storytelling, which doesn't interest me in Souls.
Having said that, I think Ringed City may have been a poor place to start since you're assuming a lot on the part of the viewer—both knowing what's come before now and that you're all on the same page with interpretations. I know there are a few lore channels already but it might be worth going back and filling in some of that information in another video. My guess is it would be a big time commitment though.
Your speaking voice was a bit dry—and I know full well that's fucking RICH coming from me. It's not a bad thing but if it's NOT intentional you may want to work on your delivery. If it IS intentional then stick with it. You sound a little on the quiet side too so you might want to look into boosting the recording volume a little.
You should try promoting the video a bit more on reddit. The videogameanalysis subreddit was a great place to start for me. Obviously r/gaming is the giant one but critique videos rarely catch there, so r/games is the defacto big community. I'd ask around in the discord for someone who is willing to post it for you since you can't post it yourself, and see if you get lucky with some hits and subs.
The early days of a channel can be demoralizing when you've spent so much time on something and no one is watching it. A lot of it is based on luck and perseverance, and hoping something gets picked up somewhere and gets a few views. Then next time more views, and then more views, until your audience starts to grow itself.
I highly recommend some shorter videos with some quick production times before you go for long ones. Even when you do have a big audience, it's uncommon for new viewers to go back and watch all of your old videos. Some of them will, definitely, but new content is always what new subscribers come for. I also got through the early period of the channel by treating each video as an opportunity to experiment and learn something, rather than just going for new subscribers and views. Although that helped of course.
More than anything though, ignore me and anyone else if there's something you feel passionate about, that you feel you have to do. Being excited about a project is better than anything else you might be working on for a more strategic way to gain an audience.
2) Your book answer in the last Q and A was really fascinating. You broke the top 500? That's awesome. I wondered how you wrote your books. Do you start from the middle and expand out? Wing it with the major plot points set? The snowflake method what ever the fuck that is? Or something else?
Many writers are different. I'm big on planning. I can't start writing a book, or even a series, unless I know how it's going to end. Endings are very important to me as a reader as well, so I want them to be satisfying and, above all else, actually make sense and not feel like I made it up out of nowhere to close something off.
Along the way through that planning I will have notes about scene ideas, major character arcs, scribbled lines that I want to find a way to include or snippets of dialogue. Sometimes I'll think of a good simile and have it ready to use when it's appropriate. I plan just as much as I write. I scrap very little because of this method, and it's usually beginnings I change the most before settling on a good place to slip the reader into the story that's happening. Like the videos, I find it's best to just go with it and not worry too much about grand introductions.
That's not to say I don't make things up as I'm writing. I'd say even most of it is created in the moment, especially dialogue and the prose. Big plot developments can change and the plan has to change along with it, but the ending is mostly set in stone. If a change is so big that it effects that ending, I either spend a lot of time making sure that everything makes logical sense after that (I think that's only happened once), or I let the idea go in favor of keeping the story on track with the plan.
It is excruciatingly obvious to me now when a story isn't following a plan. Some writers are talented and lucky enough to pull it off, but luck runs out eventually. Most start incredibly strong and then flounder when they have interweaving plot threads and too many characters. The whole thing starts to fizzle and either gets really vague, or they embrace a ton of plotholes by not explaining mysteries introduced early on in the story and an ending that just... stops.
Sort of like the answer to this question.
3) Were you introverted when you were young? Or did you "do the road" and go out tagging office buildings, eating cocaine sandwiches, picking up dragon chicks and dabbing. P.S. I'm glad you found my picasso killing thumbnail artwork funny. It was an online sketchpad rather than paint actually. I'm just a classy artist.
Mostly introverted. I think the introvert/extrovert labels are a bit limited but if we're abiding by them definitely more on the introvert side. Even now, despite having a public speaking type of job. If I was asked to give a talk live I'd probably pass. Probably.
I value alone time but I went through phases in my life when I had a large group of friends that I went out with a lot. I never felt hassled to keep up with them and that's a reason why I don't like the labels so much. My guess is most will feel that way and it's just an easy way to talk about things. Online communities can blur that even further because you're technically alone while in contact with other people. I've had so many great nights in voice chat while playing games with friends. I don't know if that counts as an introvert activity or extrovert.
I'm a private person who doesn't mind talking about himself if someone wants to hear it, but I prefer to listen more than speak when it comes to discussions. Or talk about topics that aren't specifically related to myself and the other person. I think I come across as reserved sometimes because I don't want to bother anyone. I do this with twitter a lot even though people follow me specifically to receive messages—I type tweets and then delete them because I think "Is this REALLY worth someone's time?"
Maybe it comes back to how your parents humored you as a child. My interests were often seen as borderline embarrassing (video games more than anything), and that neither of my parents did well in school so they couldn't relate to success there. My dad even resented it which is a mindblowing level of pettiness looking back. I kept my mouth shut more than I didn't. Anything extracurricular was viewed as a huge chore in order to accommodate it—driving to the place, or spending any amount of money on it whatsoever, came with a guilt trip and a lecture. Not good.
My parents weren't awful. I think so far when I've brought them up here I've been overwhelmingly negative because that's how it relates to the topic. I think the bad moments stick out more than the good too. I'm struggling to even think of a good one right now.
Michael C asked:
Hi, just a single question here. Do you have any thoughts on board games or tabletop games? I’m speaking from the perspective of someone who started gaming on the PC and the PS2, shifted to indie couch multiplayers and eventually gravitated to board games completely. I just don’t find the same appeal in solitary experiences or in competing against strangers or have the patience for grind or for giant open world time sinks like I used to. That said, I found myself fascinated by your analyses of games that I had no intention of playing any time soon and your channel is the only source of video game related content I subscribe to. It would be great to hear your opinions on digital vs analog gaming if you had any.
Hello Michael! I love board games. This sort of relates to the question directly above yours because I was really interested in them as a kid, but my family never wanted to spend any time with them.
Fortunately my wife is also into board games so we've played a little. We joke that the real reason we had kids is so we have more than two players for Monopoly, Clue, and some of the new games that are out that we want to try.
Because of that limitation I can't comment too much on them but I definitely agree with how appealing the social aspect of games can be. Some multiplayer games—when they're focused on co-op—can work that way online, but there's something unique about being in a room together. Doubly so when it's at a table instead of a screen. There's something romantic about the physical nature of the games. Something solid both literally and mentally. It's more elegant, maybe? I think that's the word I'd go with.
The only tabletop game I ever played was a short dabbling in Warhammer. The game itself didn't interest me nearly as much as assembling and painting the models, but a big reason for that is how expensive a full army was to acquire (impossible for me at the time), and how rude the workers were at the only Game's Workshop we had in our city. Not a good atmosphere, but looking back I wish I had pursued it a bit more with friends at the time. I know they managed to get games going outside of the official store. I think I was embarrassed that I couldn't afford my own army.
I tried to get into Magic as well but again it was more the collection aspect than playing the actual game. Same for the Pokemon TCG. I've never played Dungeons & Dragons. For some reason it's never appealed to me. Even now, I'm just not interested in it.
I don't know if chess counts but I was big into that for a few years. I played competitively for a while too. I think chess is something everyone should learn and play at least a little bit. You teach yourself a lot about problem solving and planning. Simple game yet it can get so complex as it goes on.
Thinking about this now, I wonder if something like a board game stream might be a good idea for the future. I've seen Totalbiscuit host those on twitch in the past. I think they could be a lot of fun but I wouldn't know where to start. I can't stream at all right now regardless but in a year or two that might change.
What are your favorite three board games, Michael? Or anyone else reading this if they're into it.
Jordan R asked:
- Games Done Quick is one of my favorite video game events. Do you ever watch speedruns or explore the speedrunning community?
- Are there any game/miscellaneous streamers you enjoy watching?
- Have you ever pulled an all-nighter to finally finish a game? Final Fantasy X-2 was one of my earliest memories of doing so, sneaking downstairs to play and finishing about 2 hours before having to wake up for school. The volume was off the whole time but I was so engrossed in it and HAD to finish it.
Hey Jordan. Some short questions! Thank you.
1—I love speedrunning. For a while I was really into Super Mario 64 specifically. But I watched some Zelda and Souls stuff as well. Cosmo/Narcissa, Puncayshun, and more than a few Souls guys. There's something surprisingly tense about watching a run that could break a record. You can feel it from the streamer too, as they get nervous and start making mistakes toward the end. It's very entertaining, and you can start to become invested in their success and root for them.
Unfortunately I don't have the time to watch them anymore. Or watch much of anything for that matter. I have a ton of tv shows to catch up on if I ever get to take a break. I really like watching people play some old SNES games. There's a guy on Twitch who is a god at Yoshi's Island. It's like watching a different game in his hands.
I think you can learn a lot about what "depth" means in video games by watching no-glitch speed runs. Although the glitched versions are fun too.
Games Done Quick is a good time and I usually check it out for a few hours each time it's running. It's fun to watch even games you're not familiar with, and often the runners will have a ton of trivia to share as they play. Sometimes it's cringy (I'd really prefer if you would be quiet) but even that can be entertaining. They can also function as really focused Let's Plays.
I'm really positive on them. They can be a great way to feed your nostalgia for an old game. I caught the Star Tropics run once and loved the whole thing. It was a great mix of my childhood and something new. It's also an awesome way for an old game to have a momentary return to the spotlight.
2) Are there any game/miscellaneous streamers you enjoy watching?
Very similar to your first question: yes, but I don't have the time anymore. Going back to twitch now can be awkward, since it's become infested with all of these distracting "production values" with floating text and icons and shit. I remember watching some guy—I think it was MANvsGame—and he seemed charismatic and fun enough to be entertaining, but he spent more time saying thank you to subscriber notifications and donations or whatever it was than anything else. The last few times I've went to twitch I've seen a hell of a lot of that.
I watched a lot of Hearthstone streamers for a while. StrifeCro, Kibler, Trump, Hafu, Reynad, Forzen, and of course Kripp. Hearthstone is a game I enjoy much more as a spectator and that's the games biggest strength and weakness tied together.
We went through some of the speedrunners already. I can't think of any others to add to the list.
Aside from that I usually pick games and see who's streaming that for a preview of what it's about, rather than attaching to a specific variety streamer and watching them regardless of the game. For a little while I watched LethalFrag like that—this was so many years ago now when he was just starting out—and I thought his Binding of Isaac races were a cool idea and something a bit unique to streaming. But he got a bit too preachy about things after a while and that turned me off. There was also a shitty Diablo 3 streamer I followed for a while because it was like watching a trainwreck live. I think it was intentional too so it was weirdly entertaining.
Oh and our guild in WoW became obsessed with a raider's stream on the horde side on our server. We would hang out and watch his guild progress. He was so salty about wipes that it was a lot of fun. Kind of weird that we did that, looking back.
3) Have you ever pulled an all-nighter to finally finish a game? Final Fantasy X-2 was one of my earliest memories of doing so, sneaking downstairs to play and finishing about 2 hours before having to wake up for school. The volume was off the whole time but I was so engrossed in it and HAD to finish it.
Plenty of times. All-nighters are a regular part of my life though, for many reasons. I didn't know I had a sleep disorder until I was in my twenties, but I always had it regardless of my knowledge. Just like any lifelong disorder. There are some nights that I simply just cannot sleep no matter what. When I was younger I would read a lot into the night. Then later it would be video games, or some movies, or just general puttering on the internet. In some ways getting a computer was destructive for me as a teenager because it can be so engrossing, but in other ways it's been one of the best things that ever happened. There were so many fucking awful nights before that spent staring at the ceiling for six hours.
Obviously this doesn't quite answer your question though. Same for games I've stayed up to finish for videos—or just kept playing hoping they'd be done soon like No Man's Sky. That's always awkward too, when you think you're in the final hour of a game so you keep playing into the night and slowly realize there's a whole other part to go yet, and you don't know whether you should stop or not. Probably an underrated part of video games there too—in a movie you can see the duration ahead of time, and you always know how many pages are left in a book because you're holding it. Games are a mystery and that can lead to to some great surprises.
This just happened with my first playthrough of Prey. I kept thinking I was near the end but nope. It keeps going with some final tasks and I ended up going well over my bed time. Not a great day with the kids after that, haha.
I think it's really cool when something grabs you that much that you feel compelled to finish it above other things. Do you ever forget to eat because you're so into something too? Happens to me a lot.
Alex S asked:
Hi Joseph! Since last month i could have done so much better with my questions i feel like i have to step my game up for this one (by the way enter is broken so i'm just gonna have to space real hard):
- Your top ten dragons in media (with a brief explanation).
- I would like to know what tips would you give to someone trying to write a fantasy level who is really interested in world building.
- Are you interested in other game reviewers in Youtube? If so, could you link a handful of game videos from other content creators which you think are worthwhile? Please :3
Fix your enter key, Alex!
1—Oh fuck this question. I read them ahead of time. I've been thinking about it. You even got a tweet about Gyarados because of this. I don't know if I can even think of ten that I consider important without naming multiples from the same series.
Let's try, in no particular order:
Smaug from The Hobbit.
Onyxia from World of Warcraft.
Icefyre from Fool's Fate by Robin Hobb.
Sinh from Dark Souls 2.
Red Gyarados in Pokemon Silver/Gold.
Yeah I'm really struggling now. I could fill the list up with other dragons from World of Warcraft and Dark Souls. Some of those fights are incredible, but that's cheating I think. Or we're scraping the bottom of the barrel and have to consider stuff like the flying dog from the Neverending Story as a dragon, or the big flying serpent in Shadow of the Colossus.
OR MY OWN DRAGON IN MY BOOK.
I haven't seen The Hobbit movies but I've read the book. Smaug was described as this immense force of nature that's become my standard for dragons ever since. I also adore the idea of a dragon having a treasure trove that they guard. There was a lot of tension in that first scene when Bilbo sneaks in, but it's been almost twenty years since I read that book.
Onyxia was my first raid kill in World of Warcraft and it's one of the most memorable. I've spoken about it in another answer before. We only barely killed her and it felt like such a fucking struggle that I felt pure relief after she died. It was a real rush to see her finally go down. The third phase feels so desperate with all of the whelps that spawn, and the lava bursting through the cracks on the floor. Positioning mattered so much—for the time, at least. That fight is very simple compared to what came afterwards.
Icefyre is probably one that hardly anyone will know even though Robin Hobb's books are quite popular. I don't know if that series sold nearly as much as her first Farseer trilogy though. I don't like most fantasy books despite writing some myself. Hobb is the exception and I've probably taken more from her style than I realize, even though I'd say John Irving is easily the writer I look up to the most for that sort of thing. This dragon in Fool's Fate isn't particularly interesting, but the concept is something I love: he's frozen like a fossil in a massive iceberg, and is being excavated by a group that wants to kill him, I think. There's another group that wants to free him. I like that image a lot and how it was written—there's slightly more to it than that but I won't spoil it. They're good books, Brent. (look I'm memeing)
Sinh I went into detail on in the Dark Souls 2 DLC video. When I first fought him, no other boss in a game had ever felt more like fighting an actual dragon. He's fast, strong, breathes fire, and actually flies to do divebomb attacks that aren't just shitty canned animations like in Skyrim. Darkeater Midir also qualifies for that in a different way and I wonder if I would like that fight more if I fought him before Sinh. Great fights, both of them. Kalameet too!
Red Gyarados may seem like an odd choice but this guy was my shiny rock for a huge chunk of that game, especially when returning to Kanto. I had a Gyarados in the first game which I treasured more than others because of the investment made leveling a crappy Magikarp. The red version felt even more special with the fancy sparkle animation. I can't even remember who else I had on my team—or what my starter was (probably the fire one though)--because that red dragon overshadows all in my memory.
Oh! The dragons in Baldur's Gate 2 were really intimidating. One of those might count. The red one especially, when you go through the load screen, enter the lair, and it takes up SO MUCH SPACE. It's SO MUCH bigger than your party! That was cool.
Honorable mention to the smaller dragon/drakes in Dragon's Dogma. Climbing on them to attack their hearts, even with the flaws that combat system has, was fun.
2) I would like to know what tips would you give to someone trying to write a fantasy level who is really interested in world building.
Fantasy level? Do you mean novel?
Characters and plot have to come first, no matter how much you enjoy world building. I'll speak about this a bit more in response to the question about Lord of the Rings. Basically, a common trap is that you'll do a crap ton of work on the setting that it takes over everything else in your mind and becomes the story, when the setting should very rarely be the story. It can work, and when it's pulled off it can be wonderful, but it's incredibly difficult.
Characters and plot should be your focus, until you're really experienced and know how to properly break convention. People want reasonable characters (not necessarily ones they relate to on a personal level, but that can help), and plots that are exciting and unpredictable. This does NOT mean having a ton of twists and turns just for the sake of it, just that no one should be able to guess the entire plot of your story after a few pages, unless you're writing a book for beautiful prose more than anything else. A simple story to facilitate your wonderful use of language. Many writers go for shocking revelations more than anything else and that can work, but it can get ridiculous and tiresome without a lot of planning—even then, if everything is a twist, then nothing is.
Something I've said in a previous answer is to build your plot and characters first, and then tailor the world to that end. The world should not revolve around your characters, but it should be built in service of the story that you want to tell and not the other way around. What are the important things you want to happen to these characters, their struggles, and the major conflicts that lead to character development? Set that down, and then go nuts on world building while keeping in mind the goals of your story. When you think things complement each other then expand on that. You'll likely find that planning one side leads to ideas and inspiration to improve the other, and you can enter a feedback loop of enhancing these sides of your story.
Just remember to actually start writing it, and to not get lost in those details. World building is a great way to procrastinate without realizing that you're procrastinating. It still feels like work.
As always, feel free to ignore writing advice if you think you know better. My way is not the only way, and writers far more successful than I would give very different suggestions.
3) Are you interested in other game reviewers in Youtube? If so, could you link a handful of game videos from other content creators which you think are worthwhile? Please :3
My safe answer for this is to just link the r/VideoGameAnalysis subreddit.
A long answer runs the danger of insulting someone via omission. So I'm just going to link some review-ish videos I've enjoyed recently and nothing else.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wvwlt4FqmS0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7MlatxLP-xs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQw4w9WgXcQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vnh0l_Ecpx4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N_-jyF987MQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AHf_EUxfAtw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=razDYQzPdSM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5wIIwBL784
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DU9EI1WIKUM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WrQs9ugQiOA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ST7iDT4Z_SY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzgSzbMryFY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HcSMm2FWgLU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ygchZzqfgzw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rB84uBc68QE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NXI9PPJjiWg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=He8Y-Y5Dx9Q
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8S6myWz3Kzg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o908SWJ8ulc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dfEOis8xVP0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JgcgeZHECDg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t5OhPhAkEBo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zp5hNL5v54U
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=891-nJWxJGY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DI3zWni8N5A
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SaGnes5uIf4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=evprGzIcwxM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nh5H_E7TDHg
Henrik S asked:
Hey again Joseph. Thanks for the answer to my third question last time, was a bit unsure if it was appropriate to bring up a relatively political topic.
- Now I don't know for certain that you've even read them or watched the movies but given that you're a writer and that the books are considered to be, to put it mildly, kind of important, I'd like to know what you think of the Lord of the Rings books and, if you've watched them, Jacksons adaptations?
- What are some games that you consider to be overrated?
- What are some of your favourite villains (in any media)?
Hi Henrik. Sometime topics can get a bit dicey. I hope my answer was enough despite that. I think it's important to discuss virtually anything but a patreon Q&A from a guy who makes video game reviews isn't always the place. If I made political videos, on the other hand...
1—I've read The Hobbit but I haven't seen the movies. I haven't read all of the Lord of Rings, but I have seen the movies.
Awkward typing that out there.
I read up to the end of Fellowship and I gave up, because I am a bad fantasy nerd and couldn't take anymore. Keep in mind I was quite young but that shouldn't be a real excuse: I found them boring. Too many pointless details about worldbuilding and history.
I don't know why I enjoyed The Hobbit so much when I couldn't get pulled in by Lord of the Rings. Maybe it's a more focused story, or has fewer of these worldbuilding bits, but it's been too long for me to remember. I should sit down and force myself to read them all just so I can say I did. And I'd like to read The Hobbit to my boys.
I'm not a massive fan of the movies either but it comes back to the answer I wrote above about Star Wars. Almost exactly the same scenario, actually, because it was the same obsessive friends who would go on and on non-stop about it. Now this makes me sound like a salty-stick-in-the-mud but I swear to you, you have no idea how relentless the circlejerk was over these movies. They're good. They're enjoyable. The scale of them is fantastic. But they're not The Best Thing Ever that's worthy of hours of daily conversations about the same thing.
I've only watched them once because of that. I think I'd enjoy them a lot more now, without those friends in my life to ruin them for me. Aside from the magical plot ghosts that show up near the end. Those are always going to bad, I think.
Apologies that I can't speak more about them.
2) What are some games that you consider to be overrated?
Truly: none of them. If people like something then they like it. Trying to figure out how much someone's opinion is influenced by hype or public perception is very difficult. It definitely exists because that can change—sometimes quite rapidly—but I don't know if that's "overrated". More that some people don't really think about why they like something and that when confronted by an opposing argument, they don't know how to fight against it.
But that's a shitty answer to your question because I, and everyone else, know exactly what you mean. And you could probably make a better proposal that things can be overrated by some bad reviewers that don't really know what they're doing, or insist on putting scores on things that are too complicated to really be represented by a simple number.
It's more complex than that, but not your question.
I think all of the Shock games are overrated, except for maybe System Shock 1, because I haven't played it. I enjoy these titles but they score staggeringly high for games that I consider to be only good. System Shock 2 is harder to judge because it's so old but the game falls apart at the end, which is enough right there to question its quality. I'll speak about this in the Prey video because I think that game is having a bad time just because it doesn't have the word "Shock" in its title.
We should avoid games I've already looked at in videos, like BotW, Uncharted, Dark Souls 1, Fallout 4, etc.
Having mentioned Zelda, I think A Link Between Worlds is only okay. It was fun to return to that setting but I don't get the adoration the game has received. The combat had nothing new added. The dungeons were small, only two bosses were memorable, and the formula wasn't subverted at all by the change to purchasing equipment. Dungeons are still built around limited items. It's a step in the right direction but having all the equipment at the start should have opened up the possibilities for item interaction. Instead, it's usually one item plus the 2D flattening ability, which admittedly was a good one.
I've spoken about this one in past Q&As so I won't go into too much detail: I don't see what all the fuss is about with Super Metroid. I like the Prime games a lot. I liked Ori. I'm enjoying Hollow Knight right now. But I've tried so many times to get through Super Metroid and I can't do it, including once as a kid when it was new. At least I think so. I'm sure we rented it one weekend.
Halo is fun but I don't consider it a classic even if it is an important game. The multiplayer was great but that's not what I hear people praising it for when they talk about it. There's something unsatisfying about the weapons in that game that I'd have to go back to pin my finger on. The movement and hit-and-run tactics were fun though. Good game. Not amazing.
Some quicker examples now:
Try as I might I can't get into Bastion. Same for Transistor but I've only attempted that one twice.
On paper I should love Binding of Isaac, but I find it dull with too many items. So you have to play it with a wiki.
The New Super Mario Bros 2.5D games were kind of dull. Nowhere near the same quality as the old 2D ones. I love the full 3D ones too so it's not "new is bad" either.
Overwatch is a game primarily played in character select, as confirmed by Jeff Kaplan himself. I don't get it.
And finally to wrap this up: whatever game is your favorite, because I've already pissed off enough people with this list and you should be included too, whoever is reading this.
3) What are some of your favourite villains (in any media)?
So what makes a good villain? If you asked people that today, I think many would answer that they need to be sympathetic, even relatable in some way. There's a push away from conflicts that are black and white, and closer to something that's grey. But is that really the case?
Along comes Dolores Umbridge in Harry Potter, one of the most successful villains in modern literature. And she's just an asshole. That's her whole character. She's a slimy, unwashed asshole. And you hate! Holy FUCK do you hate hate hate hate HATE this character. Which is a resounding success for a villain.
Along comes Darth Vader, one of the most successful villains in all of film. His prime characteristic is that he's sinister. Not so much scary. Just imposing and deadly. You know, just by looking at him, that you don't want to fuck with this guy. Compare that to Kylo Ren—who is more powerful than Darth Vader—and you don't see the same response even though he's purposefully a newer version of him. It's even built into the story. Kylo wants to be Vader. Yet he's nowhere near as imposing or effective.
Is he a worse villain though?
Sympathetic characters can work no matter what role they play. I think what's most important with villains is that their goals make sense. It doesn't have to be something you agree with—although that can help make things interesting—but their actions have to be understandable in some way. Even if that reason is simply "they're just a fucking asshole and want to be as cruel as possible." In that case, it has to seep down to infect every part of their character.
Look at the recent Daredevil series on Netflix. You have two villains: Kingpin, and the Punisher. Kingpin has goals very similar to the protagonist, but his methods couldn't be more different. So he's relatable in some way, and even has a sympathetic back story, but you still want Daredevil to come out on top. You want Kingpin to be taken down, and that he's a human being underneath that helps make it more interesting and believable. You understand how he became the villain he is, and that makes you more invested in the story even if you want him to fail.
Punisher, on the other hand, has a story that is so sympathetic and understandable that my wife and I wished he'd become the main character and we didn't have to bother with Daredevil anymore. A villain can cross over the line and become an anti-hero, even if the story didn't intend for that to happen. I think they did, eventually, in this case. But we were rooting for Punisher way before that point.
A great example of this done arguably a little better in a video game is with Jon Irenicus in Baldur's Gate 2. He's intelligent, cunning, and driven to achieve his goals. Goals that make a lot of sense when you learn more about him toward the end of the game. You don't root for him, but you end up wishing that he would resolve the conflict inside of himself, get his shit together, and become an ally instead of an opponent. I think a villain like that can work wonderfully in some stories.
Then you have Joffrey Barantheon. He's an asshole. He's an Umbridge villain. You hate him. Hate hate hate hate HATE, etc. That's effective too. Great villain. It makes you feel something in your gut.
I think the sinister type might be the hardest to pull off without it coming across as forced, or half-assed. A monster can be sinister, but is that really as effective as something so focused as Darth Vader or Hannibal Lecter? Is Jaws—the actual shark—on the same level? I'd say no. Neither is Voldemort, even though it's an attempt at the same thing. Umbridge, despite being a different type, steals the show from him.
There's more to it than this of course, and not every villain will fit into these three categories. But it's a fun way to think about it off the top of my head right now. Another type would be a mirror image of the protagonist, or a response to them like the Joker in the Dark Knight.
RoyB asked:
Whoops, looks like I waited until the last minute to do these questions. I'll try to be quick.
- Have you played Horizon, or are you planning to do a video? Some of the best open world combat I've played in a game. Good story too. One thing that stuck out to me is how great battling one enemy or 5 enemies can be.
- An expansion on the first question: What does it take for a game to be good at both single and multiple enemy combat? Shadow of Mordor was good at multiple, but single was kinda boring. And Zelda was good at single, but shit at multiple. Is it too much to ask to have both? (I hope you get to play Horizon)
. - Seriously? You didn't mention the wolves in the Zelda video? I could have sworn you were going to point that out. Unless I'm the only one where every single wolf encounter turned into: Howl -> "Here, check this bomb out." I also thought you were going to talk more about the elemental mechanics too (weaknesses are OP, shock has no opposite). I guess what I really wanted was a 4 hour long Zelda video. My real question is: anything you wanted to put in the video but weren't able to?
Hello again Roy.
1—I can't give you a long answer for this one even though I have played the game for a little bit. About three or four hours if I remember right, just before BotW came out.
I liked what I saw so far. It's very pretty. Feels good to play. I liked the combat and the enemy variety so early on in the game. I did the Hunger Games part and got out of the starting zone.
I think I'll do a video on it after Nier Automata, so sometime in August or September is most likely for it being on the channel and viewable, but I suck at estimates so don't take that as a good date for it. My guess is that I'll end up making some comparisons to BotW—Horizon has better combat, better graphics, better story, but weaker exploration and world design. But who knows maybe I'll be pleasantly surprised and like it better in every area.
2) An expansion on the first question: What does it take for a game to be good at both single and multiple enemy combat? Shadow of Mordor was good at multiple, but single was kinda boring. And Zelda was good at single, but shit at multiple. Is it too much to ask to have both? (I hope you get to play Horizon)
Difficult question. There's a lot to consider.
The three big ones are the player moveset, the design of the enemies, and the camera.
If enemies are typically simple and mostly fodder, then group fights can be great. One-on-one will be boring because they're meant to be fought in a swarm. I haven't played Shadow of Mordor so I can't comment on how that works specifically. I know that Assassin's Creed is sort of shit all around in group combat because the enemies make a circle and take turns coming at you. That said, if they come at you fast enough that you need to make a series of really quick reactions then that can be okay. I've heard the Batman and Mad Max games work the same way with enemies pretty much lining up to be destroyed one at a time.
So solutions to these problems would be a much more freer combat system that allows more than one enemy to attack at once, and a lot more avoidance options for you to control that. Or AoE sweeping attacks to get back at them. This can get too complicated for most players to handle though. Let's say you had to aim a shot with the right stick for one enemy, while also timing a parry with another button for another enemy. I doubt many people are going to be able to do that and, if they do, find it fun. But I might be wrong. It depends on how it's presented to you—right now I'm picturing the Assassin's Creed fighting ring and thinking it's awful. But in Furi?
For the problem with fodder enemies, you need more variety. A bigger opponent that requires more of your attention while also dealing with smaller ones—and to be sure to never have just one of those fodder guys coming at you because it'll be boring.
From there you can escalate this system with more than one of the bigger types, with attacks designed to zone you out and make you play cleverly about your dodges or sprints as a most basic idea. It'll depend on the combat system. But your question also wanted to know about single enemy combat. Well when enemies die they could empower others around them, highlander-style, so that you always end up with a strong opponent left to fight against. One that can incorporate similar moves as multiple enemies, but with the safety of having your full attention so the difficulty can be ramped up.
The conclusion I'm working toward here is that a good combat system will naturally be able to do this, as long as the work is put into adapting for the difference between single and multiple enemies. The player needs options no matter what. If they have them, then challenges can be built around those tools, with a sharp focus on making sure it's possible to actually see what's happening when there's more than one opponent, or at least teach the player that it's their responsibility to use their tools to make that happen for themselves (don't stay locked on or, far more commonly, have your thumb on the camera stick and make that a part of your experience. Actually look around).
The more taxing way would be two different engagement modes for multiples and singles. Sort of like the phases Furi moves between, or the way the camera shifts to different perspectives in Automata. This can work well but it's essentially giving up on a unified combat system and making two games in one.
The problem with more examples is that most games don't have great single AND multiple combat, because most games don't have good combat, period. I think we're seeing more attempts at creative stuff outside of shooters now though. And there are a ton of games I still need to go back and play to fill out my experience. The Platinum ones especially.
3) Seriously? You didn't mention the wolves in the Zelda video? I could have sworn you were going to point that out. Unless I'm the only one where every single wolf encounter turned into: Howl -> "Here, check this bomb out." I also thought you were going to talk more about the elemental mechanics too (weaknesses are OP, shock has no opposite). I guess what I really wanted was a 4 hour long Zelda video. My real question is: anything you wanted to put in the video but weren't able to?
Wolves weren't a big enough thing to mention, sorry! They would howl. I would run up to them and hit them. End of wolf. They were barely more significant than many of the wildlife in that game.
Despite what some of my most, uh, passionate, critics say, I do cut a lot and leave a ton of stuff out of every video. Breath of the Wild was no different but I have a very "fire and forget" mentality with games I do videos on it. I go through so much that I have to clear it all out afterward. That sounds very computer-like but that's how I work. It would come back to me if I thought about it for long enough but I think I'd have to play the game again to remember everything.
I wanted to do a more thorough deconstruction of the divine beasts and really show how simple they were. But to also show what good they do too, since they weren't all bad. I think they're a good inclusion if the game also had proper dungeons as well. Being able to look outside of them and see the land around you was neat. At first I thought they were in remote locations to limit that—the lake and the volcano were the first ones I did. But then the flying one and the giraffe one let you see really far around you so that was impressive. I didn't go into great detail on the lead up to them in each of those areas as well, just a summary to compare how the Rito one was lacking. That could have used some more detail.
For combat, I could have spoken more about how it works one-on-one. You can cancel attacks into a dodge at any time and I even had the footage saved to show that, but it ended up being left out of the script. Instead I went with the biggest problems that I saw. Believe it or not I originally wanted even more time on shrines to really prove how lacking they are. I wish I had pulled the trigger there because some people argue with that part despite what I consider to be overwhelming evidence. You can LIKE how simple they are, but I don't think you can DENY how simple they are.
There was a cool idea I had about climbing stamina management: to use the quick timing time in Nioh after each jump as a way to regain used stamina at the same rate that you would have lost it if you slow climbed instead. So you can't climb farther if you get good at it so it's not required, but you can cut down on the time spent climbing with this simple mini-game. I struggled to find a way to match a visual to that so I left it out.
The only other thing I can think of right now were some comments on how good the game looks. There's a lot more going on in BotW than something like Skyrim and Fallout 4. Especially all the grass that you can clear away, the trees you can cut down—stuff like that. Yet it ran quite well despite a few problem areas. For technical stuff like that I usually drop it because I don't know enough specifics to really know if it's impressive or not, and can only compare to other games like it. Which can be a lazy sort of criticism on a game that's not even the focus of the video. Might have been worth finding a way to include it though.
Riccardo B asked:
Hey Joseph! Just a single question this time. Have you practiced meditation in the past, and with what purpose in mind? What was your experience of it?
The celestial man himself, with only one question this time! Hey again, Riccardo.
I've tried meditation a few times. At first just out of curiosity to see what it would be like, which wasn't a serious attempt. The second proper time was multiple attempts at finding a way to trigger sleep. I thought it would be a good way to fight through insomnia and get on a good schedule.
It didn't work, but I think I'm the problem. I can't clear my mind. It's just not possible. I try to focus on my breathing, or some vague empty feeling, or nothing at all, and my mind wanders within a few seconds to any possible topic. I had a moderate amount of success pooling all of my focus onto one of my big toes for a while—sounds weird but I read it somewhere. That got me into a "clear state" for the longest amount of time but we're still talking tens of seconds here. I'd become aware of an itch I had, or a dull ache in my side or, the biggest one for me, restless leg syndrome would kick (haha) in and that would be the end of any chance of meditating. I think it's a narcolepsy thing—really bad restless legs. It's been happening a lot lately and I hate it.
Mostly I found it unsettling, which probably means I wasn't doing it right. I don't do well without something to occupy myself. I'm always doing something—reading, watching, talking, listening, or playing a game, or doing something with the kids. It's almost always more than one thing and, when it isn't, I usually fidget or find something annoying to play with on my desk or wherever we are. A sugar packet at a restaurant, or spinning a coin on a table. I've gotten better at controlling these urges to have my hands do something but that's the kind of annoying monster I am when I don't have enough to do.
In the same vein as meditation, I found much more success in ASMR. I had a bunch of the audio from those videos on my phone and I'd listen to it when I was trying to sleep. The problem with narcolepsy is that sleep isn't as direct as it should be. The body can fall asleep before the mind (sleep paralysis). Or the mind can fall asleep before the body (sleep walking plus other scary stuff). I would listen to ASMR for half an hour, try to move to turn my phone off, and realize that most of me had fallen asleep. It was disconcerting enough that I stopped doing it after a few more tries. It wasn't fullblown sleep paralysis, but that scares me enough that I didn't want to risk it anymore.
The video part of ASMR is also important for me, and that was missing. I think I might try it again with a small dimmed screen at some point and see if that makes it easier to fall asleep. The other problem is that it had to be just noises, not any whispering or speech, unless it was in another language. If it was English I'd get too distracted and listen instead of drifting off. There was this one channel that was in Greek that did it best for me. I hope it's still around.
Yuval M asked:
Well, I am probably too late at this point but I was on a trip and I have to try at least. I only have one question though: you've shown footage of Oxygen Not Included in your last video, so assuming it was yours, what are your thoughts about the game thus far?
Hey Yuval. You're a little late but we didn't get as many questions as we usually do, so let's go with it. It's all good.
I love Oxygen Not Included. I want to do a video on it after the next update, similar to the video I did on Factorio. ONI is currently my goto game that I can play when I can't commit too much attention or time to something else. It has a lot of planning and waiting for your guys to finish orders, just like Dwarf Fortress.
But it's not really Dwarf Fortress, even if that's the closest thing that I know. It reminds me of the Bullfrog games as well—a more colorful, friendly version than them anyway.
What impresses me the most is that the title isn't just some lame thing you have to micromanage and then forget about: it's a massive part of the game. It's not just a sim-builder type thing, but a gas and fluid management simulator. Temperature too, but that's less important so far. It has this rolling puzzle element to it that has problems that lead to solutions that produce more problems, with the electrolyzers solving the oxygen issue but then creating a hydrogen one. More dupes solving the lack of a workforce but requiring way more food and producing so much CO2. I strongly advise against reading guides and instead figure things out yourself, because there's a surprising amount of complexity in the limited options that are currently in the game.
It's still early access and nowhere near finished. I hope it has another 10 or so big updates left, and a few massive ones amongst those that add huge changes like Don't Starve received. If that doesn't happen then I hope it gets mod support, because this is an exciting foundation already. There's a lot here that can be done.
Thanks for asking about ONI, because I've put in a lot of hours now and I'm eager to talk about it. I check the subreddit every day for update news. It's my pet indie game at the moment.
And that wraps it up! As always if I missed a question please let me know and I'll get to it. I'm considering a "rapid fire" Q&A round for next time, with an unlimited amount of questions that only receive short answers so I can catch up and loop back around to a better schedule on these. I think that's a good idea and would allow me to catch up without skipping a month, because I am so busy with videos on top of this right now.
I think we'll go with that. So I'll put that up and have the answers a few days later, and then July's Q&A can start really soon into that month and I can actually have them answered in the same month they're asked.
Thanks for reading!