Q&A Session #7 -- ANSWERS July 2017 (Patreon)
Content
Timothy B
Hi Joseph, very happy to be able to support you again.
- Do you immediately analyze a game during your first playthrough?
- Are you still able to enjoy playing when you're analyzing a game?
- Are you happy with your current daily routine?
Hey Timothy. Thanks! You're kicking us off this time.
1—Yes but not always intentionally. Someone asked a question similar to this a few sessions ago. Or it might have been the last one. All the questions are blurring together in my memory now. There have been a lot of them!
I'm playing more games lately to find some potential candidates for Witcher-Project videos—games to do and then not release the video until I have enough to play all of the Witcher games as a buffer. I don't always actively go into a game trying to pull it apart, but I find it impossible to completely turn off. I played WoW for a bit during the Legion launch because those are the most important times for the game, and I wanted to make sure I experienced it if I ever do a video on it. And even knowing that any possible video would be years away, I was still considering things and how they worked far more seriously than I used to.
Some games I go into knowing almost for certain that I'll be doing a video right after I'm done. I make notes during my first playthrough, and start to collect a lot of thoughts and observations, but it's not until my second playthrough that it starts to properly come together into something coherent. There have been many times that I thought I didn't need to do a second run of a game and, for whatever reason, I made myself do it anyway. I have never regretted it because I always notice my thoughts maturing and changing on the game. A lot of my notes end up being changed—not all of them, but enough that I'm concerned about how much I'll be able to say during streams of games if I ever do that. Maybe that'll be part of it for viewers though? Comparing early thoughts to later ones and how they evolve. I tend to have a lot of kneejerk reactions the first time through that I temper later on.
Having said that, some games I refuse to play twice no matter what. Long grinding/progression games, and puzzle games. If there's a ton of repetition in the core gameplay then I have, in a way, already played it multiple times right? Puzzle games may occasionally be worth a second go but I think once you've seen that you've seen it. Unless there's a story along with it, which is rare.
So yes, the "analysis" definitely starts immediately, but I also need a lot of time afterwards to think and digest what I see, and then a second run to solidify my thoughts. That's not to say all my thoughts are always fantastic or anything! But that's my process.
2) Are you still able to enjoy playing when you're analyzing a game?
Yep, absolutely. Reading is the same way for me too. Every book I read is an opportunity to harvest new terms, words, and ways to say things. And also ways to avoid doing something. It may sound arrogant as all hell but I often read something and think of how I would have done it differently—not because I think my way would have been better (it almost always would not be) but because it's a fun experiment to work through while reading. It's like writing without the full effort. And writers hate writing, haha.
I don't make games but analyzing them is like the other side of that coin. It's a deconstruction instead of construction. So there are many thoughts about hey how does this really work and become an interesting mechanic/system. Or what alterations could be made here that could add depth and make a boring part of gameplay interesting. Is there any missed potential in what the game is doing and, even if that's the case, would adding complexity really be an improvement?
There are a lot of things like this to think about and I really enjoy it. Again, like the answer to your first question, that's not to say that everything I think of is done particularly well or worthy of speaking about in a video—I know full well that I'm not a game designer. But I do think I can break down games fairly well now and it's an interesting thing to go through for me.
But this is sort of mangling your question, isn't it? "Of course I still enjoy playing games while analyzing them, because analyzing them is enjoyable!" So to answer the other way: yes, I can still have fun with games even while studying them in the same way that most do.
I'm surprised this is the case but I often find myself immersed in a game just like I was before the channel. It's the with same books, still, today—there are different levels/meanings of immersion. You know how you can read a book and not realize that you've turned a page, or have been sitting for so long? That's immersion. And it's different than what most people mean when they speak about a world being immersive. Video games can do that, and it's when I tend to enjoy them the most.
Sometimes analyzing the games can get in the way of that. It's funny admitting this, but there have been a few times that I haven't wanted to pause the game to make some notes because I've been so into it. 99 times out of a 100 I'll still pause, or I'll just remember to make the note later, but I'm sure I must have forgotten to make at least a note or three over the past two years because of that.
Even bad games can be fun. There's always something to like. There hasn't been a single game I've done for the channel so far that hasn't had at least one thing going for it. Even No Man's Sky had some nice visuals and that transition between planets. The scale is worth admiring there.
3) Are you happy with your current daily routine?
I've mentioned in a couple of answers now that I have narcolepsy. It's not like it's portrayed in popular culture, but it's disruptive enough that I have a lot of trouble keeping a daily routine at all, never mind enjoying one.
The kids help with that. I can usually stay on something close to a set schedule for a few weeks at a time as long as I get up early. Normally I wake up around 4 AM, and then I'm close to passing out around 9 PM when it's bed time for the older kid. This was different when we had newborns that required feeding in the night but that's not the case anymore.
When I'm on this schedule I mostly like it. Our apartment is tiny with both the kids so it's difficult to get any work done during the day. Especially writing. I can play games, do audio editing, and video editing. But I can't do any recording and I can't write reliably. I still try but it's not an efficient use of my time.
The issues crop up when I have to switch to a recording phase, or when the older boy is such a terror during the day that I have to stay up late to finish playing a game or do some writing. Then I'm on the night schedule and everything turns into chaos. I don't sleep until I'm close to falling over—which isn't good with two dogs to walk before bed—and insomnia can prevent sleep even when I'm in that state. Then I'm also sleeping during the day which means the kids are screaming and waking me up, and that my wife has to deal with them on her own which isn't fair.
However I have to go on this schedule to record so it's unavoidable. The biggest problem is that to get back on the day schedule I have to do a full loop around and stay up for a full day. This was fine when I was younger—I've done it hundreds of times because I've always been narcoleptic and employers don't give a shit—but now that I have so much going on and I'm into my thirties I find it very difficult. So I'll have days that I'm stranded on the bad schedule because I try to stay up late and I can't do it. I fall asleep and have to try again. I get a lot of work done during these days because I'm up late by myself. If you ever see me chatting on Discord after 2 AM then chances are that's the schedule I'm on, or I had a bad night terror and I woke up. That's always a wild card with nightmares coming to ruin the good schedule. A problem my older boy seems to have gotten from me if these past few weeks are any indicator. He's woken up screaming every night this month.
Eventually I'll manage to loop around and be on the preferred day schedule.
Moving will help with this a lot. Separate recording space means no more late night schedule so it'll only be uncommon times caused by nightmares that'll get me on it. Or a severe bout of sleep attacks. Narcolepsy is far from the worst disability out there, but I think a lot of people take regular sleep for granted. Or at least the ability to fall asleep normally. The new place will help a lot, which is suddenly possible now thanks to you guys here on patreon.
This sounds a bit like whining now that I've read it back. I've long since come to terms with narcolepsy and, if presented with a magical cure tomorrow, I would hesitate before taking it. It's part of my identity and isn't without some positives. I think I would still take the cure but it means a lot to me to realize that it wouldn't be an easy decision.
Raviolli Warrior
G'day Joseph
- Having critiqued games for a while, do you feel like you'd be in a position to design a "good game"? Have you ever considered writing for a game or would you be interested in doing so?
- How important is a good story for a game? Can a game with a simple story and premise still be great?
- How do you feel about tabletop wargames and have you ever considered getting into one?
G'day Italian Fighter.
1—This is a two part question. The answer to the first part is "absolutely not". The answer to the second part is "definitely yes". So a strong flip from one side to the other there.
Being able to criticize something does have some amount of transferable knowledge to making the same type of something. The opposite is also true in my experience: having written a book will make it easier to look at another book with a critical eye. However this isn't the case for all things, or all people. Some people can create but can't criticize. Some can criticize but can't create.
Solo projects are rare in video games. You have to be a supremely talented person in multiple areas to make that work and, even then, it's highly unlikely you won't have to hire or outsource at least some part of the process—art or music is my guess, since if you're trying to make a game yourself you'll probably be doing the coding. Or else you wouldn't be able to start.
So if we push aside that scenario—especially since I have no musical ability whatsoever, and very low experience with drawing—then making a game would involve a team. Which is a very different thing than writing or coding. It's organization. It's coordination. It's running a business and handling people, disagreements, being an employer, and on and on and on.
I would love to be able to try this and I have some very lofty, very long-term aspirations for trying, but it'll probably be a tough learning experience that will hopefully lead to later success, rather than a dream coming true: making a game! I have a lot of ideas. Most of them my own. Some of them are more like pulling a Shakespeare and taking something that already exists and doing it better. Not as successfully as Shakespeare though of course, haha.
For a long time, while playing games, I thought I was only interested in doing the writing for the story parts. I even applied to do that job at BioWare a long time ago. I have more ideas for gameplay now and trying to mix them both together. I'm interested in telling stories in a way unique to games, although not always strictly through gameplay. I think you'd be hard pressed to find a definition for that right now that even makes sense, never mind a concept that can be purposefully built on. I think most games that have achieved that have done so accidentally. Or are limited in scope in terms of gameplay mechanics so that the story was really the focus all along—Edith Finch and SOMA come to mind.
As for joining an already existing team, I don't think that's a good idea. Writing for a team would be a cool learning experience so I think I'd be interested in doing it at least once or twice, but it would be more to see how it works rather than being excited about creating something. Although with the right team that might change. Like I said in answer to the previous question though, my schedule is a hot mess at the best of times so it would be difficult to coordinate. If I ever tried making a game it would probably mean the end of YouTube videos for a little while since it would take up so much time. Although the channel could be incorporated in some way. A dev blog or an in-depth documentary of the process. Not sure. This at least ten years from now though and unlikely to ever happen.
So no, I don't think I'm in a good place to design a game because of the videos. But yes, I would still love to try regardless.
2) How important is a good story for a game? Can a game with a simple story and premise still be great?
A story is only important to a game when it decides that it's important. I know that sounds stupid but think about Super Mario—most Nintendo games really. There's some background information about a villain, a crashed spaceship, a kingdom in peril or a kidnapped princess. Then you're off to do some gameplay segments. Great. The story isn't important. It's only context. Context can be simple. It can even be effective. But it's not really important. The game could probably survive without it and still be just as good for a lot of people.
Then you have Metal Gear Solid. Kingdom Hearts. Fallout. And so on. Not necessarily RPGs but games where the story is a capital-b Big Deal. Now it matters a lot and is suddenly very important. It needs to be done well to justify a lot of things: the development time, the writing time, and above all else the time it takes for the player to go through it. If you're going to interrupt gameplay then your story better be getting enough attention to justify that. I think we went through a period during the last decade or so when a lot of games just included these story scenes out of obligation because that's what a lot of successful story-driven games were doing before that. So you have so many games with truly shit stories interrupting gameplay. But also know I haven't studied this or anything. These Q&As are a chance for me to speak and speculate a bit more casually than in videos.
The fundamental idea behind all of this is that if something is going to be included in a game, then it has to done well. It should be exciting for the devs and necessary for whoever is in charge of the project to realize the end experience they have in their minds. Never include anything out of obligation—and, in the few cases that something like it may be truly necessary, go the Nintendo route and have it provide context instead with minimal interruptions. Even Nintendo can mess this up sometimes though. Even some of their games take so long to get going.
The more games I play with bad stories the more I'm relieved when games don't bother. Or have it in the background. I think this is the appeal of stuff like Dark Souls or most recently Dead Cells and Hollow Knight. I can criticize these stories for being vague but I also say that I love that they're unobtrusive. I can just play. Even skippable cinematics can ruin the flow of playing a game.
But when a game can combine the two, or tells a really great story, then I think that's wonderful. It's probably my favorite thing a game can achieve. Maybe many people agree and that's why there are so many attempts—by developers in charge of a project who have always wanted to tell a story but simply don't know how. I think everyone secretly fancies themselves as a writer, or thinks they have one story in them to tell. It's easy to look at it and think "Well I know how to write. I learned that in school. And I read/watch so many stories! How hard can it be."
Turns out, it's really fucking hard.
3) How do you feel about tabletop wargames and have you ever considered getting into one?
I think I like the idea of collecting and painting the models more than playing the game, but I never had a chance to. Someone asked this question in the May Q&A if I remember right. I don't have much to say about them, sorry. I never had a chance to get into them much. My friends did and it seemed fun but I couldn't afford to keep up with them
Maybe in a few years, after we move, I might look into some of them as a fun hobby to do with the kids. I'm trying to get into board games at the moment.
Do you have some recommendations outside of the typical Warhammer stuff?
efekt
I thought I won't have any questions ever and I don't really want to bother you when you'd probably want to focus on making videos - but after skimming through that Google doc of the previously answered questions, I do have one which comes to mind: Did you ever play "The Talos Principle"?
Hey Efekt. This whole feature is meant to be a way to message me without risking interrupting something—or to definitely get a reply. So don't worry about asking questions. That's what this is all about.
Unfortunately I can't give you much of an answer here. I haven't played The Talos Principle. It's on my list for games to try to make videos on for the Witcher-Buffer. Funnily enough I just installed it the other night. Haven't played it yet. I'll probably try it soon.
I've heard good things. I hope I enjoy it! It's pretty long for a puzzle game, right?
Bayard B
Hi Joseph, in your previous answers you've shared some of your favorite books, but the only science fiction book that I noticed in those responses was one by Vonnegut.
- Do you have any other favorite science fiction books and/or ones you would recommend?
- Secondly (and lastly), are there any authors that you think are criminally underrated and that you’d want to bring to our attention? Thanks for all your hard work.
Hi Bayard. I replied to your comment saying I probably couldn't give you good answers to these but I'll do my best on the first one. There's not much I can do about the second one, unfortunately.
1—There are a bunch of important sci-fi books that I still need to read. I haven't gotten around to Hitchhiker's Guide, Neuromancer, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep, or Dune. Most of the books I've read have been literary classics and I'm not sure if they count.
1984 and Fahrenheit 451 are technically science fiction. But they're more political dystopias. Both of them are hardly that advanced compared to our current world either—but they were science fiction at the time. I've spoken about Fahrenheit 451 a bunch in these Q&As lately because I recently reread it and was shocked by how relevant it is for many discussions happening today. As long as you can remember that it's not about censorship. The author's note at the end of the text also went a long way to improve how I looked at the book.
Similar to that, does The Road count as science fiction because it's post-apocalyptic? There was an unnamed calamity that destroyed civilization but it's more a reason that the world is in its current state, rather than an active part of the plot. Books that good tend to transcend their genres in my mind and instead become "a book you should read no matter what".
Is The Stand by Stephen King science fiction? There's a man-made illness that kills 99% of the population, but then it becomes something closer to dark fantasy horror. The Stand might be the longest book I've read. I think it's about half a million words all on its own? The complete edition I read was anyway. I think it's impressive that the book doesn't feel as long as it is, but there are some parts toward the middle that make me want to stop. Once they get into the dark Christian magic stuff I lose some interest. What comes after that is great though, so you have to power through it.
Is it science fiction though? I'm reading American Gods at the moment and even Neil Gaiman, in his introduction to the book, struggles to answer that question. Pretty good book so far. I would call it urban fantasy not science fiction.
For some stories that are firmly science fiction you have stuff like Ender's Game, which is a strange book for something that's so popular. It's a kids book for adults, in a way. "The enemy gate is down" is something that will be stuck in my head forever and I almost quoted it in the Prey video. I still might. Strangely I have no interest whatsoever in reading the next books in the series. Maybe I'll force myself just for the sake of it one day but yeah. I like the story as it is. The dream sections are so weird.
I'd say Zombies are science fiction, not horror. Although it depends on how it's written. I thoroughly enjoyed World War Z and I'd like to see some other books written in that format. Maybe a huge galactic war told through separate stories of different characters and battles. World War Z feels like the most authentic, realistic zombie story ever because of that style, even when some of the stories didn't have many zombies. The submarine shanty town sticks out to me every time I think back to that book.
I thought the movie was okay after I just pretended it had a different name.
The laundry room in our apartment building used to have this "dumping ground" where people would leave things they were going to throw out. There would often be a lot of books left there. One of them was Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency which I started reading without realizing it was by Douglas Adams. So that ended up being the first thing of his that I read and I loved it. Absolutely wonderful. Such a twisted story that I can barely talk about without spoiling it. Endings are really important to me in stories and that book has a great one. Reminded me a little bit of Good Omens but I couldn't say why.
Speaking of Pratchett, we'll end with his book Only You Can Save Mankind. Which is about a kid who gets caught up in an alternate reality inside a video game. Some quasi-MMO type thing about defending an alien invasion. I read this book when I was about 11 years old and it was a big deal. Not because of the video game part—although that helped catch my interest—but because of the background plot outside of the game. The main character is living with parents that are constantly fighting and, at the time, that was very close to my life. I know it may sound silly now that we're all adults and know how common it is for parents to have massive fights—and broken marriages in my parents's generation are particularly bad—but at the time I didn't know all that. I didn't want to talk to anyone about how my parents treated each other, so reading that book and realizing that this is a thing, and it is so well known that someone wrote about it was an important revelation. It made me feel a lot better, even if the fighting carried on.
I should read some more of Pratchett's books. So it goes.
2) Secondly (and lastly), are there any authors that you think are criminally underrated and that you’d want to bring to our attention? Thanks for all your hard work.
I haven't read as many books as you probably think I have, considering that I've written a bunch for myself. I would say I've probably read as much unpublished, amateur fiction as I have proper books. There's always something that I'm reading but for a few years there I was deep into discussing prose with beginners and intermediates. It became a big hobby for me and still helps today when it comes to looking at video games. Just the practice at trying to explain things alone is part of it, since if you're going to be critical about someone's work in a direct conversation with the person who made it then you want to back-up your claims so you don't come across as needlessly insulting them.
When it comes to published books, I don't go digging for unknown writers. I have more big classic books to read than I have time to read them. That's probably bad of me considering that I am an unknown writer myself, but when I read a book it's always one that you've probably heard of, so I can't give you a good answer to this one. For a while contemporary fiction wasn't high on my list, period. Most books I read were from writers who were long dead.
Have you heard of this guy called Charles Dickens? He's pretty good. If you hated him when you were forced to read his books in school, you should give him another chance now. I found that a few years later I could enjoy his stories so much more.
Shockwave1211
- Hi Joseph, I've been following the channel ever since the Hearthstone video, I was wondering if you've ever gone back and played it and if so what did you think of some of the changes?
- Since that was 2 questions, my final one is, Have you ever played any amusement park sim games (RollerCoaster Tycoon/Planet Coaster) and what do you think of the genre? Thanks!
1—My greetings, Shockwave.
I've played Hearthstone a little since the video, but only when there's a new update. It's one of a few games that I keep my eye on to see if they're worth doing another video on later. But also because I really do want Hearthstone to be a game I enjoy. It's perfect for playing on a tablet while I'm hamstering it up on an exercise bike.
Unfortunately, when it comes to the changes to the game, mistakes were made. I don't want to disrespect Blizzard anymore because I do think my early videos crossed a line. But Hearthstone reeks of exploiting their fanbase. They can use "free-to-play" as a shield to justify some absurd prices on digital cards, when the game would be far cheaper in the longrun if there was a standard entry fee for all the cards. A few people are capable of staying relevant with free-to-play accounts by playing a crazy amount of games everyday, but that's spending time instead of money. Spending it poorly too as far as I'm concerned since it's not a lot of money saved per hour for that game... not quite what was planned.
Changing the game to a format system should have been the perfect time to open up card allocation. I wanted to include something like this in the video but I couldn't get it to work quite right. For now I'll say that Blizzard could give every account a free pack every day for just logging in and you still wouldn't be able to get every card with close a hundred dollars spent every expansion. Things have gotten worse with the legendary quests—which are a wonderful idea—because they require a huge investment to make the deck work. If Blizzard cared about players having options and the ability to build these decks, they would have made the quest cards part of the new standard rotation and available to everyone so there could be many tweaks built on that. More cards could have modified the quest too since they know everyone has them. Hello!
Instead they're more interested in squeezing as much money as they can from every player. It takes a long time for new cards to come out—probably so people are more likely to buy early and often to get some variety out of the long seasons. Small content packs and tweaks between big expansions would be great but there's no money in it so, with their current design philosophy, it won't happen. Same with regular, substantial balance changes. They happen a little more now but not enough. Oops.
The game is still as pretty and accessible as ever. And I adore how connected it is to WoW—it's a lot of fun to see how Hearthstone interprets those characters and raid bosses. I want to love it. So it's quite frustrating. But it seems to be working for Blizzard regardless. The game must pull in massive profits for how cheap it is to produce compared to their other titles. So why would they change when people are still buying the cards? Well played.
2) Since that was 2 questions, my final one is, Have you ever played any amusement park sim games (RollerCoaster Tycoon/Planet Coaster) and what do you think of the genre? Thanks!
I used to like management games a lot. In theory I still do but it's not something I'm still excited about. I played Theme Park a lot when I was a kid. I missed out on RollerCoaster Tycoon but I've heard good things.
After my second son was born, I got a few simulation games on steam since I was looking for stuff to do that wouldn't be interrupted by a waking baby. Pausing action games ruins the fun—I also had to stop playing Nioh at this time because it didn't have a pause function at all back then. Planet Coaster was one of the management games I got. Same with Oxygen Not Included.
What I learned playing Planet Coaster is that these games might not be for me anymore. At first I thought it was the waiting: the gameplay is essentially build some stuff, wait for the new income stream to settle from those new attractions, and then build some more once money is saved. Do some maintenance stuff in the meantime, but that also costs money and pushes back when you'll be able to make your next big purchase.
I didn't play Planet Coaster for long because of this issue. It's possible there's some clever tricks you can do to avoid all of this waiting but I was too bored to find out. Plus there was the really unintuitive system around building rollercoasters which, I admit, had enough complexity that it might be the point. Some people might love it. I was confused more than anything trying to put them all together.
A lot of work went into that game and I'd like to give it another shot. Maybe I'll look up some guides this time since I didn't have the patience to find tricks if any exist—maybe there aren't any. It seems like it has enough to it that it might be a big deal for simulation enthusiasts. I think my tastes have changed and drifted away. I want things more like Factorio and Oxygen Not Included now. There's still waiting, but I can be a lot more active and have many short-term decisions that are separate from the economy/resource game that fuels long-term decisions. The mix is what I think I need. It's why I love Dungeon Keeper so much.
Robert W
Hey Joe, first off congrats on the recent Patreon success, I know I've said it before but it really is nice to see a genuine and hard working guy get somewhere on such a saturated platform as YouTube.
- Have you played the Jak and Daxter games? If so, short thoughts?
- I read that you have jumped around between Canada and the UK a few times, I am an Englishman myself and have always wanted to go to Canada, was there any cultural differences you found strange or difficult to adapt to, and...
- In response to the Edith Finch video, it made me wonder, as an author do you think you are somewhat inspired by elements of video game story telling? Even games with barely any real story like No Man's Sky? I know the medium's are quite different from each other and could be an entire discussion itself, I'm wondering from an author's perspective if anything sticks out as clever or inspiring. Again; loving the content, you deserve every bit of success you get. -Rizzles
Thanks Robert! It's been incredible to see how many people love the videos so much. It's been overwhelming. We never expected this level of a response. I hope the new content continues to meet everyone's expectations. There's more pressure now!
1—I haven't sorry. All I can do is point you in the direction of Novacanoo's videos on the series. I have no experience with them at all.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZF5aHYD1FcE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HcSMm2FWgLU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-srRwNwvEPE
2) I read that you have jumped around between Canada and the UK a few times, I am an Englishman myself and have always wanted to go to Canada, was there any cultural differences you found strange or difficult to adapt to?
Oh a ton. Keep in mind that my exposure to both countries has been limited. We stayed in the same small area for the most part. We did travel a bit but I was young—especially when we went far west in Canada. I've been to Calgary but I couldn't tell you anything about it.
Language is a big one. I've been criticized for my accent my entire life. I say some words wrong in Canada. Some wrong in the UK. Now I have this mixed accent that most people don't like. Or at least they find some words and pronunciations to pick apart. You'd think with the internet being a global thing that it wouldn't matter, but since I sound American it throws people when I say something like a Brit, but still with the western accent.
Food is another major difference. There are a lot more small business places in the UK that offer a lot of variety. There is some of that in parts of Toronto but where we live are mostly big chains. This could be a difference caused by street sizes though. Roads are tiny and narrow for the most part in the UK. The wide lanes in Canada and America are closer to some British highways—or motorways, as they would say. Everything is built on a grid here since the streets were put down first. In the UK there are many twisty paths and streets everywhere. Lots of alleys and shops. Much easier to get lost. But it has more character when you get used to it.
There are a lot more gas stations here in my experience too. Or petrol stations. People also want you to take your shoes off when you go into their houses here. That wasn't expected in Wales but maybe that was only for that city. Not sure. In Canada's defense, the winters make it necessary so my guess is that it's a habit that continues into the other seasons.
This may be a surprise to anyone reading this, but I find Canadians to be more standoffish than the British. The Brits have a reputation for being stuck-up and—yeah, maybe a few, maybe sometimes, but I think they're a lot warmer early on. Canadians are, I think, more friendly but after you get to know them and have repeated exposure. Maybe it's simply because of the size of the city we live in. There's less sense of community. Everyone lives more in isolation and rarely sees the same person more than once on the street, save for those that live around them. Apartment living can also promote that since you're rarely outside in your garden or front lawn or anything like that.
Or maybe it's a sign of the cultures of both countries shifting to more withdrawn people. I've read that recently too. Maybe I wouldn't recognize much of Wales anymore either.
3) In response to the Edith Finch video, it made me wonder, as an author do you think you are somewhat inspired by elements of video game story telling? Even games with barely any real story like No Man's Sky? I know the medium's are quite different from each other and could be an entire discussion itself, I'm wondering from an author's perspective if anything sticks out as clever or inspiring. Again; loving the content, you deserve every bit of success you get. -Rizzles
This can go one of two ways as I'm considering the question now. It's how video games can influence what I write in books. Or how I would write a story if it was for a video game. There's how gameplay can become a part of that, but also just baseline interactivity and choice. Video games can fully realize the potential in those "choose your own adventure" books. Or they allow players to influence the direction of a story in multiple ways without being railroaded into the same ending. So far it's been done in mostly minor ways that don't change much because it's so expensive to make real divergent paths. Maybe there's some game that's successfully done it that I haven't played yet. The biggest example I can think of right now is the second act of Witcher 2.
I've heard Nier Automata does things with storytelling that are unique to video games. I have no idea what it is aside from some sort of cycle. I'm interested in finding out.
To answer the other way: yes, video games have influenced my books. Most of my stories have fight scenes, and I'm sure some video game playing has bled into those. Action scenes are difficult to write and I think I do them fairly well, especially in later books. You can tie a lot of emotion and get into the character's heads during fights. It can be a struggle on more levels than just physical.
There have also been a few scenes that I've written like they're a first-person shooter. On purpose. I thought it would be a fun exercise and I enjoyed them. Most of the experiences I've had in video games have to be built upon a lot though. Many of them are too shallow to make work in a medium where all you have are words on a page. I'm sure they have been the source of many ideas but it's essential to speak about things that you have a good handle on. This can get messy since no one knows what being in a flying armored suit is really like. No one knows what fighting a dragon would be like. So video games can be a really cool way to experience otherworldly things and to get some ideas for that.
As for stories and characters themselves? Very little is deliberately taken from games. My characters Burke and Cass might be similar to Master Chief and Cortana at first but the story quickly moves on to be nothing like that. Same for Kate, who I realized later is a lot like Geralt. I don't think I had properly played any of the Witcher games then so I'll chalk that up to coincidence. Again, though, the story quickly becomes its own thing. I do wonder sometimes how my books would translate into video games. I wonder if that's been done before? Has any author overseen the adaptation of their own stories into a video game?
Isak E
Hey Joseph! Grats on reaching your 3k goal! I'm a long-time fan and first-time Patreon supporter. Fitting it should be for my favourite YouTuber. My first question might be a little personal, so I don't mind if you ignore it.
- How did you and your wife meet?
- A lot of the people I've asked have strong opinions on this one, so I wanted to hear your thoughts: Which of the Portal games (provided you've played both), do you think is better, and why?
- Top 3 movies?
Thanks Isak! I'm glad to be someone's favorite YouTuber!
1—We met at a walk-in clinic. Turns out we had the same STD. It was a real good icebreaker.
No—we met in high school. My family had just moved back to Canada. I had to do one last year. We had one class together. I was interesting to her and her friends because I still had a bit of a British accent. We became friends and started dating soon after that. We've been together for thirteen years.
Not a fun story, sorry! But I guess it's uncommon that we met so early and stayed together for so long. We went to the same university after that. Had similar problems with our respective parent(s). We moved out together early. And now our oldest kid is about to turn 2. She's always been the best part of my life since we met.
2) A lot of the people I've asked have strong opinions on this one, so I wanted to hear your thoughts: Which of the Portal games (provided you've played both), do you think is better, and why?
Oh fuck that's a tough one to call.
Portal 2 is way more fun. There's more variety. It's longer so the story gets to have more characters and stretch its legs. You could argue it might even be a little too long, especially during the old facility part. I wasn't as taken by Cave Johnson as many others, and I think the twist weakens the most important character instead of being interesting. But that game might be the funniest story in all of gaming so it scores major points for that.
Portal 1 is a much darker comedy. It was fun in a different way: it was such a surprise. Even the trailer had that wow-factor. The mechanic felt so fresh and defied logic. I remember wondering how they even got portals working. But then I played it and it had GLADOS! And all of the sharp dark humor that comes with her. All of those biting, perfectly delivered lines. On top of this mechanic that is unique enough to really grab you.
Portal 2 didn't have that, yet Portal 1 was so strong I felt quite intimidated by GLADOS in the opening of the second game. And it is a much better opening if I recall it correctly. It's difficult to remember your first time through after a few years, and that's the most important run as far as I'm concerned.
The second game may have more variety and larger puzzles but it does suffer from "find the white panel" in order to solve some of them. So right now I'm leaning toward the first game; however, if we include the Co-Op campaign, which I played with my best friend and had an absolute blast, then the sequel takes the lead.
3) Top 3 movies?
I think this has been asked before. I wonder if I'll give the same answer. I think I change my mind a lot when I think about things like this.
Fight Club deserves a spot because of how important it was at the time. Aside from some movies I watched over and over as a kid, I've seen Fight Club more than any other film. When I was a teenager the social commentary stuck with me while I was in my edgy adolescent phase. But even back then, when I first watched it expecting it to be some dumb boxing movie, it was the way the story was told that grabbed me the most. This mix of narration, breaking the fourth wall, and jumping all over the place. It's likely influenced my own stories more than I realize. Any movie or tv show that does it—House of Cards springs to mind—immediately becomes more interesting. I think it's a cool part of movies.
Fury Road should also be in the top three because it is the most I have ever enjoyed a movie in the theater. It is the only film I have ever seen that I thought afterward "this wouldn't have been the same if I watched it for the first time at home". The story doesn't matter in Fury Road. It's like a video game that uses it as context for the action. The sheer spectacle, the music, all of the sounds—god damn that movie was like a glorious assault on my senses. I hope they do some special return runs of it in theaters years from now. Especially for people who didn't get a chance to see it like that the first time.
Cloud Atlas would probably be number three but I've only seen it once so I don't feel comfortable putting it on the list. I loved it so much when I watched it but maybe I was in a really good mood that night or something. I doubt it. It's probably still fantastic—I even have the book to read later—but let's go with another movie instead.
Charlie Kaufman is one of the best screen writers around right now. I'm going to go with Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind as my top pick but Adaptation comes close. Eternal Sunshine has that really creative use of scenes breaking apart. Crumbling and smashing together. It matches the story. It's a representation of the plot. I love it for that. It may be a bit sappy—or really dark, depending on if you read about the first version of the ending. But I adore that movie. I've written scenes like it in books and it's only now that I'm writing this answer that I realize how influential Eternal Sunshine was for me.
Honorable mentions: Mr Nobody, Primer, Gladiator, Jurassic Park, Django Unchained, Inglorious Bastards, The Lion King, Emperor's New Groove, The Fountain, Oldboy, Watchmen.
Craig
Hey, Joe! 'grats on reaching your goal. Thanks for being so great.
- Have you ever considered doing any kind of streaming, maybe of your editing process or something like that?
- I found your Little Nightmares video really interesting; given that the majority of your reviews focus on gameplay and you talked about Little Nightmares more as a way to nail down the broad, intangible "experience" umbrella, are there any games that you've enjoyed specifically because of their story or characters, even if the graphics, gameplay, etc. don't necessarily hold up all that well?
- You've mentioned liking John Irving. Have you read A Widow For One Year and, if you have, have you seen the 2004 film adaptation The Door In The Floor?
Cheers Craig! I'll try to keep being great. It doesn't come naturally to me.
1—I've thought about it a lot. I actually did my first stream ever recently. We played some Xia and then Secret Hitler. We didn't announce it ahead of time because we weren't sure how it would go. I'd like to do it again but it's very difficult to schedule.
As for streaming solo, I'll almost certainly try it after we've moved to a bigger place. It's so difficult to get some quiet time here and impossible for it to also match when most people will be awake to watch it—most of my audience is in Canada and the United States. I don't know if I'll be a good streamer and the games usually take so much of my attention that it's unlikely I'll be really into viewer engagement. But who knows. It could be fun.
As for streaming editing, I'm not sure. I have considered it already. I've seen some game devs do something similar as they work. I don't know if anyone would find it interesting. At worst it may slow me down while working. But it's worth a try.
It'll be months before we can move though.
2) I found your Little Nightmares video really interesting; given that the majority of your reviews focus on gameplay and you talked about Little Nightmares more as a way to nail down the broad, intangible "experience" umbrella, are there any games that you've enjoyed specifically because of their story or characters, even if the graphics, gameplay, etc. don't necessarily hold up all that well?
It was good to finally put all that into words. There are a few experience games I've enjoyed. I think Skyrim falls under that category for a lot of people.
When it comes to story and characters though—yes, absolutely. Quite a few games. There were a few years that I wanted story and characters more than anything else in games. Then that flipped over to the other way for a while too, haha.
Most RPGs have poor gameplay. I'm thinking of the old Baldur's Gate style games. But even slightly more recent ones like the first Mass Effect, Dragon Age, and Witcher 1. Then there are "games" that don't try to have gameplay at all like What Remains of Edith Finch. They use interactivity in another way. I spoke a bit about how this can succeed or fail in my SOMA video as well. Which is another game that I think has an incredible story, and would recommend playing it only for that.
Some people say that playing a game for a story would be like watching a movie for the subtitles. I don't agree with that but it might have a bit of validity. I think everyone enjoys a good story. It's part of what makes us human. And exploring those in the interactive medium—no matter how much that interactivity is or isn't tied up in something like puzzles or combat—is still worthwhile.
For games that try harder to do both: I enjoy the story a lot in Fallout New Vegas even though the gameplay is terrible. I've heard that Automata's gameplay isn't bad but that it isn't good either. The story is the main draw.
Games like Uncharted and the new Tomb Raider also have inconsistent gameplay, bad stories, but great characters. Most of the cast in all of the Uncharted games are interesting and/or charming. And the new Lara Croft is arguably the best female protagonist in an ongoing gaming series. It's a shame these great characters don't get great stories to match. Uncharted 4 came pretty close though—didn't quite stick the landing.
Some of Blizzard's characters are great too, despite not having worthwhile stories to support them. I wonder if making good characters is easier than a good story? Something to think about.
3) You've mentioned liking John Irving. Have you read A Widow For One Year and, if you have, have you seen the 2004 film adaptation The Door In The Floor?
I haven't read it, nor watched the film. I'm quite a slow reader when it's a book that I think is worth my full attention, which is almost always. John Irving's novels are so dense and packed with important details that I have to take them slowly. Time to think afterwards is essential. I'm still thinking about The World According to Garp and I think I read that almost ten years ago. There are very few superfluous details in Irving's stories. Even the bits you think are just there for flavor come back. Sometimes for some joke or a simple link. Sometimes with some deeply menacing consequences.
So there are a lot of his books that I haven't gotten to yet. We just ordered A Widow For One Year though, funnily enough. I'll be going with that or Owen Meany next. My wife's already read that one so we can talk about it.
I haven't seen any of the movies based on his books. A lot of people hate those adaptations but in my experience it's always fun to see what survives the transition. And to see who's shitting on it just to feel superior: the best recent example being the Great Gatsby movie which aside from some atmospheric tweaks was near fucking identical to the book, and yet people still whined that it was too big of a departure.
Alex O
Hello, Joe gz on getting 3k+
- Excluding Onyxia do you have any other really memorable moments from WoW that stick out in your mind?
- What was your main in WoW? Did you stick with one class for most of your time in the game or did you jump around and play a lot of different classes/specs?
- (Short Answer) Do you have one or two non gaming youtubers that you enjoy watching and would recommend to others? If you couldn't tell I like WoW quite a bit. Cheers
Hi Alex. Thanks for helping me get there! It's been a mad month.
1—Too many. I wonder if I'll include most of them if I ever do a video. A lot of them aren't specifically about the game either, but the people I met. I ran a guild for years and we must have gone through at least a couple hundred raiders during that time. 25 man raids will do that. There was a lot less turnover in the MoP years with 10-man raids. We kept the roster around 12 for that, instead of the 33+ to make sure we had backups for when people missed nights.
I'll go through the game and write a few of them:
Playing the open beta for vanilla—it was a promotion they did to drum up interest of the game. I remember the first time I got out of Teldrassil and took the flight path to Darkshore. It was a seamless flight and I felt the world click in proportion. God the map in WoW has to be up there among the best in all of gaming. Such a great feature. It acts as a guideline and then you enjoy filling it in.
My first raid through Blackrock Depths so we could get into Molten Core. Being a part of this huge train of people getting to this instance, wrecking everything on the way. And then being put in our place by the molten giants. For a first raid, I always thought the way mobs were tied to certain bosses—and stopped spawning when they were killed—was a really cool idea. It wouldn't fly now but I like it. Maybe it could work in a single player open game to remove some enemies from a spawn pool.
Arriving at Desolace for the first time was amazing. It was so different and far more open than any other zone so far. Same for when they finally added weather effects! And then turned them off shortly after for a reason I never found.
Going through the Dark Portal at the Burning Crusade launch was a great moment. You turn around after loading in and the sister gate on the other side is SO MUCH BIGGER than the one in Blasted Lands. BC had some of the most creative zones so far. Zangarmarsh is still one of my favorites. Nagrand is so vibrant too. Warlords didn't recapture that enough for me, although it was fun to see some of the connections between the zones.
First run of Karazhan was incredible. That was one of the best raids Blizzard ever made. I haven't played WoW since they "remastered" it for Legion. I hope it's just as good. The Opera and Chess events standout, even though Chess is a pain to solo now for pets and transmogs.
The gauntlet before Flame Leviathan, and the tank's entrance, was cool for a few reasons. That was the first new raid that came out after I was properly leading a guild. Naxxramas was a retooled version of a vanilla raid. That's where we got started. Although finally getting Malygos down—and watching comprehension dawn on everyone with how to control the drakes—was fun too.
That's the great thing about running the guild is that you have a whole other game to play and enjoy by gearing up your raiders. The awful thing is how much time it eats up, and how you often have to deal with assholes. I think I learned a lot of diplomacy doing all that. It sounds ridiculous because it's an MMO but I think dealing with people in any capacity is going to teach you something. Being firm isn't always best, although for some people it's the only way to do it.
For a long time the guild was full of bad players. We had no reputation to attract people with so we took whoever we could find on PUG runs of Naxx until we built up a roster. Then the game became about finding better raiders to replace bad players who were only there for some easy loot and weren't interested in learning encounters. Which is far more common than you'd think.
Sometimes it was the good players that were the most outrageous with what they said though.
I remember we had this one guy, who we'll call Paul because I don't want to use his real name, who would always talk in chat about how much he was into selling drugs and a big "gangster" lifestyle, and how much his mom just didn't understand it. He would say the most ridiculous shit like "Yeah I'm real into selling drugs but I don't use them myself y'know, I have to stay focused because I street race."
For a while we weren't sure if he was a troll. Sometimes I still wonder but I think he was too committed. It went on for too long. One night he DM'd before the raid and said "I hope we have enough people to raid tonight. One of my friends just got stabbed and I'm so pissed. I need to raid to keep busy or else I don't know what trouble I'm going to get into."
Then there are the excuses for people who want to bail on a raid. You know, someone actually saying on ventrilo "I have to go, I just lost internet." Or "my computer just crashed! I'm on a blue screen." - "How are you still talking then?" - "Oh it's one of those Vista blue screens that still lets you use vent."
People bickering over loot. I had a grown man, ex-military, get so pissed that someone else won a roll for an epic ring that he left for the whole night and was still pissy about it the next day. Or there was the guy who we had to ask sit during a MoP raid. Again, an actual adult. Who responded by saying, in the most dejected, dramatic voice you can imagine "This was the only boss I needed..." and then he toggles on the slow RP walk to leave the instance instead of hearthstoning out.
Some guy's dad had a stroke. He got the call during the raid. "But it's cool let's finish this up first before I go to the hospital." I had to force the guy to leave. Hopefully he was just in shock and just defaulted to going back to the routine he was in before the call.
When asked why he died during a fight, I had a raider once tell me "Oh there was this guy coming from my left, and another guy coming from my right. I couldn't do anything to stop it, it was an oxymoron."
MoP was so good though. I had such a good time with that group. Mostly friends at that point, and the Throne of Thunder content was amazing. Hardmode Lei Shen is a masterpiece of a fight. I'm curious how Final Fantasy 14's raids compare. In my experience, raids are a unique thing to WoW. Or at least the way they function. I know there were large boss fights in Everquest. WoW has so much development time devoted to something that very few people actually see. It's strange. Some of my best times spent with games though, that's for certain. Still, though, maybe not quite worth all the time it took up.
2) What was your main in WoW? Did you stick with one class for most of your time in the game or did you jump around and play a lot of different classes/specs?
At the launch of Legion I had a max level of every class, but I got most of them up during one night that I couldn't sleep and there was an exp glitch tied to pet battles. I watched a few episodes of House of Cards and got a lot of classes to 85 or 90, I think that was the max then. I can't remember. Before that I already had 4 or 5 max level guys though. I played WoW a lot.
In vanilla I was a DPS hunter and a tank warrior. In BC I switched over to tanking exclusively, and stuck with that until halfway through WotLK with my own guild. I made the switch to paladin around the release of ICC because warriors were purposefully nerfed by Blizzard to encourage tanks to switch over to other classes—until WotLK, warriors were the only real tanking class. That changed with that expansion.
I continued being a paladin tank for main raids into heroic ICC, but kept current with my warrior tank on PUGs I ran on the weekend. I really wanted a Shadowmourne and that was my way to get it on my warrior.
During Cataclysm I was still a paladin tank until my guild fell apart. I made the switch to mage dps and joined a high-end raiding guild on another server. That was shortlived because my mom died so I quit the game for while. That's a whole other story though and one that's not worth telling.
I started playing MoP casually at launch as a return to the game. Monks seemed fun so I leveled one of those but I didn't like them. I ended up sticking to the mage, who I transferred back to my original server, and raided as that for the whole expansion. Because "playing casually" didn't last long since raids could be done with 10 people, and there were enough of the great raiders still hanging out on that server. We were pretty successful and that's the best time I had with the game. Very little drama. Lots of fun times. It was often more worth it to show up for the raids to hang out with everyone than the raids themselves. We had this tank and healer couple that were just consistently hilarious to interact with. I still talk to them sometimes. I also met my best friend in that game and we talk almost everyday.
I barely did anything in WoD—some light raiding on the mage. I quit early into that expansion. And Legion I only played a little to get an idea for how the launch period was if I ever do a video on it. I liked Demon Hunters a lot. And I flipped between one of those, a fire mage, and my warrior. WoW takes up way too much time to play to stick with it though, even casually.
3) (Short Answer) Do you have one or two non gaming youtubers that you enjoy watching and would recommend to others? If you couldn't tell I like WoW quite a bit. Cheers
Primitive Technology is a big favorite of mine. Someone should hire him as a consultant to make the ultimate survival crafting game.
Miniature Space has this effect on me that makes me so enthralled that I feel hypnotized. Very relaxing.
ASMR used to do that for me, so there are some channels I used to follow for that. I think most of them are gone now though. That community could get some obsessive fans.
There's CGP Grey of course. Gordon Ramsay for cooking guides that usually have two steps that are too complicated for me so I skip them—it usually works out. I was really into TedTalks for a while too. And the channel Sixty Symbols. They explain some scientific concepts in a very simple way. Usually, haha.
Eoghan C
Hi Joseph, I love your reviews and just picked up a couple of your books on Amazon. Keep up the fantastic work!
I don't think this is a question so I'll just say thank you, Eoghan! I hope you like the books. Some of them start a little rough but they pick up as they go along. Just like the videos, I got better. I hope!
Andrew K
Hi Joe, still really enjoy this feature! It's a nice way for your rapidly expanding number of patrons to get an exchange with you without feeling like we're totally wasting your time.
- Do you think that a game that has very finely tuned and carefully designed combat design, for argument's sake we'll say something like Souls, can ever ALSO have a well crafted story and characters? Does focusing on the one necessarily counteract the other, or is it just a foible of From and their imitators? (I would personally point to TW3 on the hardest difficulty as an example of something which tries to do both, but I know A LOT of people disagree with me passionately there)
- Regarding WoW, I was surprised to see that you seem to rate a lot of the post-Cata content like MoP pretty highly, though I think you said Wrath was your favourite. How do you personally feel about WoW's changes over the years? I kinda feel that this dovetails with a lot of what you say in your Souls videos about the extent to which inconvenience is a legitimate challenge. For me, Vanilla and BC were the best precisely because solo play was so disincentivised, and co-operation encouraged, often with inconvenience which I regard as legitimate. I'm guessing you see it a little differently, so I'd love to hear more about that.
- Since you're an author and now also a respected games critic, have you thought about writing a book analyzing video games? I'm currently following/ helping crowdfund a couple of these sorts of projects, and in my view the interest is huge. Gaming is young, and it's been underserved by print media. You've also got a ready made digital/kindle audience in place. Some such projects, like the CRPG Book Project which I've been following for some time, are polished up to a very high standard, and with your undoubted levels of conscientiousness it might be a good way to re-use the research you've done for your videos. Just a thought.
Hi Andrew. I like this feature too but it's becoming something that takes a lot of time. If next month's is the same size as this one I might have to drop the question limit down to 2 so it doesn't delay videos. We'll see. I don't want to scrap it completely. I think some people like to read it without asking questions, too.
1—There's nothing that makes this impossible. I think we can use a video game analogy to try to think of why it's so rare.
In an RPG character creation, you typically have stats or skill points to allocate to build your character. Points are in limited supply. You can't be good at everything. I think some people also view real, actual people in the same way. If someone is fit and clearly works out a lot, then they obviously can't be intelligent! Same for someone who is really, naturally good looking. They must have some "stat points" missing because of that. Reality doesn't work that way. Things aren't quite that balanced.
If we superimpose that idea onto game development, then the points we have to allocate become money and time. Great gameplay takes a lot of that. So does a story. Having them both work in harmony will require a ton of coordination—which likely means a lot of planning. A lot of time. Some AAA games do have enough resources to do both, but they almost always focus on one first and then shove the other in afterwards. So you end up with conflicts and things not making sense. Or lots of cutscenes where the game stops being a game for a while and is a movie story time instead.
What I'm noticing more lately in indie games is that some sort of gameplay hook is given priority, and the story and characters are either background noise or a lot of text on the screen. It's cheap. Doesn't take much time. And can easily be changed later on—voice acting can't. My guess is that big games can't do this as easily because cinematics have to be worked on throughout the whole of game development. It might come down to writing there—a really good planner who can sort out all of the potential problems from the start so there's minimal editing at the end. But I am a writer so that's my area of expertise, so I'm biased to feel a pull toward that being important. The game director should definitely have some writing experience though.
The other side of this issue are players—or the game's audience. Deep gameplay requires a commitment. So does an engrossing story. If you're interrupting gameplay to tell a good story then many players will find switching back and forth between these two dense halves of the game awkward. The player's attention is like a cup, and everything you have demanding their attention is like water being poured into it. Have too much story and gameplay being poured in too fast, and the cup runneth over.
So with enough money to develop both sides, I think this would become an issue of pacing. Which isn't something discussed much in video games. Hollow Knight, for example, has very poor pacing in combat. It's too simple for too long. Then when it finally does get good and has enough mechanics, it's almost over. It would be an even tougher problem to solve in a true open world, but those already struggle to find a story that properly fits them at all.
If you take things slow so players have time to digest gameplay and story, then you run the risk of more experienced players getting bored and leaving before it gets good. I also get annoyed when a game starts with a massive dumping of story. I'm way more interested in seeing how it plays, how it feels. So maybe the answer, if you're doing both, is to begin with a long stretch of gameplay and then slowly introduce your story, and quickly ramp up the complexity. I'm unsure where cinematics fit in games though. But that's a whole other question.
I hope that's the sort of thing you were looking for.
2) Regarding WoW, I was surprised to see that you seem to rate a lot of the post-Cata content like MoP pretty highly, though I think you said Wrath was your favourite. How do you personally feel about WoW's changes over the years? I kinda feel that this dovetails with a lot of what you say in your Souls videos about the extent to which inconvenience is a legitimate challenge. For me, Vanilla and BC were the best precisely because solo play was so disincentivised, and co-operation encouraged, often with inconvenience which I regard as legitimate. I'm guessing you see it a little differently, so I'd love to hear more about that.
That's a big question! I know it may be surprising because a lot of WoW "veterans" prefer the older content. For me it comes down to the raids, and they've continually gotten better with each expansion. There have been some stumbles, yes, and a lot of reused content and tiers that went on for far too long. But anyone who says to you "raids were so much better and harder in vanilla" is a liar, or is misremembering things. Or they didn't play in vanilla at all and just want to say they did.
It was way more difficult to get 40 people together, and that's the only thing. By the time Icecrown Citadel was released, encounters were so much more complex and fleshed out. And now when you look at those fights, even they look simple compared to some of the recent stuff. With Lich King being the possible exception, because holy shit that one had a lot going on in each phase, and even between phases.
Outside of raids things get harder to judge. I would say the only two other things that have "objectively" improved are the visuals, and solo play. But as you say here, you could make a strong argument that solo play should never be the point of an MMO.
Things get dicey when you look at things like attunements or stuff like resist gear in BC. It was very annoying to try to get a group together only to suddenly have to do a bunch of other shit just because someone wasn't attuned yet—and could not change that on their own. Same for getting my tank ready for Serpentshrine Cavern. I needed nature resist? I think? So I spent a lot of time farming the bog lords in Zangarmarsh. That sucked. I didn't want to do it. But understandably no one else wanted to either, even though you're probably meant to have a guild helping you.
Even in vanilla you had some reputation grinds you could do solo though, and that slowly became the basis for solo adventuring. They may try to put a different coat of paint and name on it now, but there's a lot of filling up bars by doing quests and killing mobs. You're limited via dailies—sometimes only with a soft cap on each day though—so that even if you do everything in a group a solo player can still stay relevant on their own. Which is good and bad. I think it's vital to remember that WoW is a game that greatly benefits from stringing into playing for as long as possible, without you realizing that. It's a thin line they walk on with each patch and I don't envy them.
PvP, dungeons, and server communities have suffered the most over the years in my opinion. Maybe I'm more positive on later expansions because over time I stopped caring about this. Sometimes I'll look at modern WoW and see it as a different game rather than a better one.
LFD killed a lot of dungeons and server communities. I used to have a list of good healers, good dps, and good tanks (when I wasn't tanking myself). When they were on I knew I could pull a group together. Get someone to meet me at the summoning stone, and off we went pulling. If you were a dick then you got a reputation for being a dick. You weren't invited back. You could warn people of others on the server—who's a scrub, who ninjas loot (back when that was a thing), and who bails a lot in the middle of dungeons. You could inspect someone's gear and know you weren't going to have to carry them through the place. However this also took up a lot of time organizing things.
Today you just queue into LFD. It's fast, teleports you there automatically, and you pull with a bunch of strangers. I loved this feature when it first went into the game. I was a tank. I lived in LFD. I did so many dungeons because I genuinely enjoyed it. As time went on, more and more people realized they could get away with half-assing it because everyone is effectively anonymous with cross-server parties. No one will ever see you again. There were more bots. More AFKers. More assholes too. More people queuing in with horrible gear and specs unfinished, because the majority of the group will be able to carry them through it.
The dungeons themselves became more simple around this time too. More straight lines with a lot of monsters. They can be fun, but there was nothing like Blackrock Depths, Blackrock Spire, Maraudon, Diremaul—a lot of the vanilla ones are immediately coming to mind. They became a lot easier too, with the only exception being the brutally hard Cataclysm heroics at launch. Something that was nerfed if I remember correctly, and never done again because people complained about it.
There have also been fewer and fewer 5 mans in each expansion since Burning Crusade. I'd have to look at the numbers to be sure though. Some of them have been good! The train one in Warlords was fun. The challenge modes in MoP were a cool idea that I hear has gotten better in Legion. But they're a lot more disposable, and forgettable to me, compared to the early days of WoW.
PvP is the same. Battlegrounds were fantastic when they first went in. AV was incredible. The rivalries and infamous players you saw in world PvP were also present in the battlegrounds. You learned to recognize names. It was too much of a grind even for me back then but the idea was great. I can see the same issue with the battlegrounds as I do with dungeons. More cross-realm. Less creativity in new instances. And fewer of them.
Wintergrasp was fun but they never did a world pvp zone better than that since. Does Legion even have one? I don't think the Dalaran sewers count. Of course PvP leads us to balance issues which is a whole other thing that Blizzard regularly struggles with, even in raider DPS.
I could talk for hours about WoW—and, believe me, I have in the past. It's not something I feel too comfortable with anymore though since I've been out of the game for so long. And I probably will be forever now. I doubt I'll ever be able to raid again now that I'm a father and, without raiding, I don't see much point in the game.
Outside of finally getting Mimiron's Head.
3) Since you're an author and now also a respected games critic, have you thought about writing a book analyzing video games? I'm currently following/ helping crowdfund a couple of these sorts of projects, and in my view the interest is huge. Gaming is young, and it's been underserved by print media. You've also got a ready made digital/kindle audience in place. Some such projects, like the CRPG Book Project which I've been following for some time, are polished up to a very high standard, and with your undoubted levels of conscientiousness it might be a good way to re-use the research you've done for your videos. Just a thought.
"Respected games critic" haha. Well I am a games critic now! Not sure how widely respected I am.
I've kicked around the idea of doing a book. Right now I have too much going on to truly consider it but I think it would be a cool idea. An easy one would be to release all of the scripts I've written in a big book, with some added notes and "making of" features looking back. Even that might get hectic though because I'd probably want to include a few pictures. Maybe I'd have to keep the scope of the project down.
There are some broad topics I think I'd enjoy writing about, but I also like the video format so I can use examples. So maybe there would have to be a video accompanying it as a reference guide. At which point just making a video essay might be easier. There has to be something that would benefit more from the written format though. I'll think about it some more and see what happens. You guys will all know about it ahead of time if I come up with a good idea.
Łukasz R
Hi, Joseph! I've been following your channel since the Darkest Dungeon video, but was on the fence of becoming a patreon up until the latest info video. Sorry for being so late! Now, for the questions:
- In your latest video you’ve mentioned Nier: Automata. Have you played (or plan to play) the first Nier? I think that this game is a criminally underrated masterpiece, even today a lot of people just shrug it off as a bad game that happened to get a better sequel. If you did play it – what are your thoughts about it?
- Do you like to discover and play lesser-known indie games or do you prefer ones that are more popular, „safe bets”(for example: Hollow Knight, Stardew Valley etc.) ? I think that’s all. Keep up the good work! I hope that your channel will continue to grow even more!
Hi Lukasz. Darkest Dungeon was a while ago now! You've been watching for well over a year—that's always a big compliment. Thank you.
1—I haven't played Nier. Originally, when Automata first caught my eye a while before it came out, I considered playing the first game(s) but I knew I wouldn't have time. I dropped Automata from my list of games to play but it was requested so much that I put it back on, with the caveat that I would only be able to do Automata. People still voted for it and want to see a video. I still might go back and play Nier and Drakengard? That's the same series right? But that'll be after the Automata video.
Hopefully I'll still understand everything. Or have a different but still valid perspective only playing Automata. Nier looks like a weird game. Maybe I'd like it.
2) Do you like to discover and play lesser-known indie games or do you prefer ones that are more popular, „safe bets”(for example: Hollow Knight, Stardew Valley etc.) ? I think that’s all. Keep up the good work! I hope that your channel will continue to grow even more!
Until recently it was "safe bets". Safe is actually a good term for it. There are a few things to consider. I don't play games that I don't think I can enjoy. It wouldn't be fair to go into a critique on a game I'm going to trash because it's not my thing. Even Darkest Dungeon—I thought I'd like it. And I did for the first 10 hours or so! After that it also has to be a game that people are going to want to hear about, because channel growth was so important. Finally, the cost of the game was a significant factor. I'm not always going to be able to find enough to talk about, so every purchase will be a risk and could waste money.
The channel has grown very quickly this year. With the huge, recent spike on patreon (thank you all again) I've been able to take more risks on steam games. Especially searching for those videos to make for the Witcher months. So it should be a mix of both from now on. I can take a gamble on buying a game I end up unable to speak about, and I think I have a large enough audience now that enough people will enjoy me speaking on many unknown games. Not everyone, but fans that want more content will enjoy it. At least I hope so!
I was thinking about doing some "First Impression" videos too. Picking a new, unknown game and doing something close to what TotalBiscuit does. That would have to be part of a second channel though, and would have to wait until after we move so I can record more reliably. Even tonight I had to stop recording the Prey script because the traffic outside was too loud. Not good.
A podcast would be a good fit for another channel as well. So what features would that be? Streams, podcasts, and first impression videos? Anyone have any other suggestions?
Whitelight
Andersone Josehp is best Josehp?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E781QE7ZQK8
Context: https://twitter.com/TheLightIsWhite/status/863850957498658821
David S
I truuuuly recommend Sapiens regarding the last QnA.
- What are your opinions on competitive games? You haven't talked about competitive games as a whole as far as I'm concerned and in your HS video you don't even mention it. Are you a fan of games like LoL Dota and CSGO?
- Will you read the Witcher books before playing the series? Have you even started reading the Witcher books? What are your thoughts on them? I am reading them now AFTER having played the games and I kinda regret that, mostly because Geralt's appearance sounds SO unique on paper that I can't even imagine now how he would've looked like in my head if I HADNT played the games.
- I just saw your what remains video and was thinking "could this be a movie instead?" Of course this isn't a controversial question one might ask himself and I quickly gave myself an answer "the experience of YOU navigating the visuals is what matters". Now having had this thought another question came to mind. There is a movie called "enter the void" and it's a masterpiece (although i doubt anyone here has seen it, but i recommend it for answering this last question if you want joseph). what is crazy about this movie is that its a 3 hour long journey through the main character's eyes while he is having an out of body experience, and that is why after answering the question i asked myself this question came up directly after. Could movies be turned into videogames? If you were to see "enter the void" I would love to know your answers before and after you saw it because it certainly would give another perspective on it. In your previous QnA you said you weren't sure about doing audiobooks. I think I can speak for a lot of people but a HUGE reason I come to your channel and have ONLY payed your channel monthly is because of your calming voice. Audiobooks would be a great success IMO. Maybe you should do a poll??
1—Hey David! Sorry to do this but this question has been asked at least two times already and I don't think I have anything original left to say on it. So I'll paste a link to the previous times I answered it below. In summary: I enjoy them a lot. I've been into a few multiplayer games heavily in the past. But I don't have the time to commit to them right now, and it's near impossible to do so for a video since I would have to get really, really good at them in order to judge them properly.
https://www.patreon.com/posts/q-session-1-2017-7950683
Ctrl + F "multiplayer" asked by Stephen S, and Korey B.
https://www.patreon.com/posts/q-session-3-2017-9302673
And again here Ctrl + F "multiplayer" asked by Adam H.
I could have sworn it was asked another time too. Maybe it was in the Turbo Q&A.
2) Will you read the Witcher books before playing the series? Have you even started reading the Witcher books? What are your thoughts on them? I am reading them now AFTER having played the games and I kinda regret that, mostly because Geralt's appearance sounds SO unique on paper that I can't even imagine now how he would've looked like in my head if I HADN'T played the games.
I have the books stacked on my dresser right now. Six of them, I think? I read the first pages of a few of them but my plan is to play the games first. Geralt has amnesia so I "should" too. What I haven't decided yet is whether or not I'll pause the games and read the books when he regains his memory (which I believe is Witcher 3?), or if I'll continue to finish the games and then read the books.
I plan on doing two playthroughs of each game in order. So Witcher 1 > 2 > 3 > DLC. Then read the books. Then 1 > 2 > 3 > DLC again.
I also haven't decided if the books will have their own video or be included with the games. Having a visual representation of the books will be tough. Maybe I'll have to buy a camera to record the pages and highlight some paragraphs. Hm. Does anyone know of any book review channels that do something like that?
3) I just saw your What Remains video and was thinking "could this be a movie instead?" Of course this isn't a controversial question one might ask himself and I quickly gave myself an answer "the experience of YOU navigating the visuals is what matters" ... that is why after answering the question I asked myself this question came up directly after. Could movies be turned into videogames?
Stories are the point of discussion here I think, since movies can't have gameplay. There are four states that I can see:
- A story works better as a movie than a game.
- A story works the same as either a movie or a game. (I think people forget this can happen)
- A story works better as a video game than a movie.
- A story only works as a video game, and could not be done in a movie.
Some examples for these in order would be something like The Last Guardian, which I think would be better as a movie (you may disagree). The Last of Us works just as well as a game as it would a movie (again you may disagree). I think SOMA and What Remains of Edith Finch are better as games than they would be movies. And something like Fallout New Vegas wouldn't be possible in a movie format.
But let's not stop there. Let's go into why and throw some more examples.
Video games have a few strengths that movies do not. They can have gameplay segments to strengthen the narrative if they're linked, but to also act as beats in the story between big moments. There's also the increased running time of video games which allows stories to be longer and, occasionally, more complex. People don't expect to finish most games in one sitting—they can take a break and come back, just like a book. Whereas most people sit down to watch a movie and finish it right then and there. Not many people pause a movie halfway and then resume it the next day. Although I'm sure some busy people might have to, it's not standard practice.
Of course you also have interactivity. The easy one to jump to here are choices. You can influence and direct the story, if the developers put that work into the game for that to be possible. But by interacting with something, you also have the ability to feel like you're connecting to some characters more than you might in a movie since you are one of them, potentially on equal footing. You might feel more resentment toward enemies. You may feel a building grudge toward one of them. I've said in the past that this is a reason that so many games have a story with a big betrayal as a twist. Because you feel tricked and angry when it happens, not a character on a screen.
There are also opportunities to stop and take parts of a game in at your own pace. When I reached the beach scene in What Remains of Edith Finch, I lingered at the water and thought a bit about what just happened. I got to dictate the pacing there, as I saw fit. A movie doesn't do that. Which is arguably a strength that movies can have in the opposite way—a far more directed, focused experience. The ability to stop and think, without physically having to pause the video—the game is still going, with ambient noise and music and all!--is closer to the experience of reading a book than a movie. Which is a comparison that I don't think people make often enough.
Having mentioned books, we should bring up cinematics. A video game becoming a movie for a little bit would be like a movie showing the script instead of a visual representation of it. Or it would be narrated subtitles. Sort of like the opening to The Fellowship of the Ring. Is this a failure of movies? I don't think so. Is it a failure of video games? Well actually maybe. But probably not. I think these are all tools that can be shared across a lot of mediums, but they should be used sparingly. Even though some people will argue that any time a game takes control away from the player, unless your character is physically incapacitated in someway, is a failure.
Some people think that The Last Guardian uses its interactivity and extra length in a way to make players bond with Trico the griffin. I didn't feel that way, so to me I would have greatly preferred a much shorter, more directed experience to enjoy the wonderful visuals that game has. Instead of having to force myself through a lot of boring gameplay and bad "combat". Like with most things, that's going to be subjective. Some people will say what I just said in regards to Uncharted.
The Last of Us has many cinematics that take away control. There's a lot of back and forth between gameplay and story sequences. They're produced at such a high quality, with great voice acting and animations, that they were very enjoyable to watch. I would have—and still would—watch an entire movie of this game done this way. The gameplay did not detract from that experience for me. I thought that part was good too, even if it rarely added to what was happening to the story. Sometimes it did, but not in a significant enough way in my opinion. This is also where "movie" can get a bit blurred since The Last of Us would be too long to be a movie. But movies can be broken into parts, and there are also television series. So even though I'll give this score to video games for added length, it's not a unique thing for that medium.
Edith Finch and SOMA both have moments that I won't spoil that are dramatically improved by having the player have to make something happen. These moments would not have the same potency if you were watching another character do them in a movie. Any time a game makes you feel something—you feel something in regards to yourself as the character you're playing—is a sign that the medium is being used in a significant way. The added length of the story also helps SOMA since you have that extra time to really sink into the character of Simon and the situation he's gotten into. We should also throw in environmental storytelling, which is linked to the ability to stop whenever you like and take in your surroundings.
Finally we have Fallout New Vegas. And probably something like Undertale from what I've heard about it. New Vegas could never be a movie and still have the branching choices. Parts of the world react to your decisions. Some other games do this in a way that could probably be simulated, or at least addressed in a minor way, by a movie. But not all of the different paths and outcomes in New Vegas. It isn't just the endings that change—your journey there is different. So that would be my answer for a truly unique thing that video games do. It shouldn't be surprising that interactivity is what it comes down to.
As for gameplay, I struggle to think of a clearly defined example for that. Some might say Dark Souls. I'm not sure. A game where you're growing in power maybe? Mega Man X is cited as that. You want to get stronger for the story. So do you as a player to make gameplay more fun. A lot of games have that basic idea. Some ignore it though and don't really acknowledge how much more powerful you're becoming. Not sure on that one. Cool question though. Might be a video one day.
(Short) In your previous QnA you said you weren't sure about doing audiobooks. I think I can speak for a lot of people but a HUGE reason I come to your channel and have ONLY payed your channel monthly is because of your calming voice. Audiobooks would be a great success IMO. Maybe you should do a poll??
I think it could work but I don't have the time, nor the willpower, to do what would be hundreds of hours of audio editing. I struggle enough getting scripts recorded. It's possible if I get better at it—or if a new recording area works so well that I can record more often without having to reset my schedule to late at night when it's quiet.
Soznyw
- If you can give a single piece of advice to aspiring writers, what would it be? It doesn't have to be concise.
- Which game(s) do you think are highly underrated and clearly deserve some love?
- Do you think that one day video games would be regarded as artistically and culturally significant as movies?
Hey Soznyw. Some short and tough questions here. I'll do my best.
1—A single piece of advice may be too limited. If that's all I can give then it would simply be: write. Sounds stupid but most writers don't write. Even famous successful ones go through long periods of inactivity. Rare is the author who writes every single day and only releases one book every few years—they exist, but most writers who have massive gaps between books simply aren't writing for the majority of that time.
So keep writing. It's like exercising. It's not going to happen unless you do it. But this is too limited a way of dispensing this advice, so let's build on it.
Writing isn't enough. You also have to be doing two other things: reading, and allowing others to read what you're writing. If you're too embarrassed to let someone read your work then you're not ready to be a writer. That's fine. Give it time. Continue to write. But you need feedback. Understanding and processing feedback is a skill all on its own and could fill another topic. Unless you're writing only for yourself—in which case, never let anyone else read it anyway—then you have to accept that other people will have their eyes on your words as an inevitability.
Reading other work is just as vital as writing. There are so few skills or paths to walk in life that haven't been trodded down by tens of thousands that have come before you. Sometimes a fresh perspective can change things. But there will always, always be something to learn by studying what people have already done. Or you will be making the same mistakes that they did—or you will be straining yourself to make innovative leaps on your own, only to discover that someone already did it decades ago and no one is impressed with your take. This isn't limited to writing either. Virtually everything people can do sits under this umbrella. Only the bleeding edge pioneer work is exempt and, even then, it's debatable.
It's also near impossible to think that anyone who wants to be a writer hasn't already read a ton of books. Or been exposed to countless stories—from movies, tv, video games, or just people in their lives telling stories. Everyone can be a storyteller, even if it's just something that they're recounting. Some funny thing that happened to them on their way to the shops that day. There's at least a little bit of style and artistry in that. It's been influenced by what they're been exposed to. And that is now influencing you.
Read as much as you possibly can. A writer can never waste their time with a book. Unpublished fan fiction? There are things to learn there to avoid—and probably at least one cool thing to take from it. A classic from hundreds of years ago that's barely English anymore? There's something there too. Badly written genre fiction. A contemporary masterpiece of literary fiction. Read it. Acknowledge what you like and don't like. Figure out why. Avoid/steal it for your own work, but bring your own style to it. Don't be afraid of a unique voice—embrace it.
Read as much as you possibly can and then write. Write, and then let as many people as you possibly can read it.
There are a few other questions I've had about writing if you want to look back at the prior Q&As and search through them. The link in the question prompt has them all in a list for easy searches.
2) Which game(s) do you think are highly underrated and clearly deserve some love?
The only legitimate way I can think to answer this is to consider games that benefitted from a lot of hype and, maybe, fear from a huge following of fans. So stuff like Call of Duty usually gets scored quite highly because if reviews go too low, then they have to deal with a lot of complaints. Same for Fallout 4, which we saw happen to Giant Bomb even from other reviewers if I remember right. I don't know if this is truly what happens but it seems to be the case.
There will be games in a similar style, and a similar quality, that do not benefit from this even though they may be better games. Prey is the first example that comes to mind because I just got done playing it. It doesn't have the privilege of a name with a fanatical history like the Shock and Deus Ex games—and any connection to the previous Prey might work against it. It also may have pissed off a lot of review sites by not having early copies distributed.
I'm not saying that Prey deserves a higher score on a lot of these sites. It's that, if you look at the other BioShock and Deus Ex games, it has too low of a score. So are those games simply scored too highly? I'm not sure. I think many people have ignored Prey because of this when, if they loved the Shock games so much, they would thoroughly enjoy Prey even more. Most of them, at least. But then you also have to consider if maybe the hype and big reviews also contribute to how much a person enjoys a game. This proposal is on unstable ground though. Do you ever feel more justified in liking something when you already know it's critically acclaimed? When you play an unknown game and like it a lot, do you ever doubt that your enjoyment is legitimate? These are difficult questions to answer.
Someone asked a similar question to this before and I brought up Enter the Gungeon, which I considered underrated compared to Binding of Isaac. Turns out Gungeon has sold over a million copies. That's still a lot less than Isaac but it's also a newer game, and didn't get the huge boost that early streaming did for Isaac. So I don't think I can say that's underrated. I do think it's a better game though and deserves a bit more attention.
I think Dungeon Keeper 1 is better than Dungeon Keeper 2, even though the sequel gets more attention and brought up more often as far as I can tell.
Infinifactory is one of the best puzzles games I've ever played and I rarely if ever see it brought up anywhere. Not sure how much it sold though.
Judging by the response the video got, What Remains of Edith Finch was passed over by many people. Which is a shame. One commenter even said I didn't give a good enough spoiler warning and they missed out.
Obligatory Dark Souls 2 mention. Plus most of the Obsidian games that went unfinished. Whether that was their fault or not I'm unsure about, but they're among only a few games that push for interactive storytelling, or really good writing within a game.
Furi didn't sell well from what I can see. It also was victim to at least one reviewer proclaiming it was too hard, but also that easy mode was too easy. So I don't know how that works. It is something of a niche game though so it makes sense.
Maybe that's the best answer to go with: niche games in general. Many of them go unsung because they only appeal to a small group, but they're usually intensely loved by those who do enjoy them. I wish more people were willing to take the plunge and try to meet games like that halfway. There are some wonderful experiences available if you can tolerate a rough transition period while you adapt to it.
3) Do you think that one day video games would be regarded as artistically and culturally significant as movies?
The cheat answer here is to say that they already are.
Not quite true though, is it?
So this question is heavily tied with the dreaded "are games art?" debate. My answer to that is always to first agree on what art even is, and then to go from there. Which usually stops the conversation dead and moves it to people not knowing what art is. Which is the whole point. The definition is blurred, I'd rather not choose at all, etc, etc.
But you also said culturally significant. Which I think we can answer with yes. Video games are already a huge part of our culture. The generation that had video games as children are now grown up. Look at the recent phenomenal success of Pokemon Go. That was quite a "sensation" as some news outlets said. Nintendo is deeply significant to a lot of people. I read recently that Mario is as universally recognizable as Mickey Mouse? Not sure if it's true but I'd believe it. Fallout 4 was a massive thing for a lot of people. Tens of millions have played Skyrim. More have played Diablo. World of Warcraft has been on multiple television shows and attracted many people who never played games before then.
I think a few years ago that video games took over the film industry in terms of revenue too, but that might not be true anymore. Reliable sales numbers for games are hard to find as well. I hope that changes soon. Some big publishers would have to lead the way with that.
Video games still have to shake some baggage off though. They're regarded as the same as toys by many. Even some people who grew up with them like to put the hobby down. I think you can see the medium's adolescent phase as the grimdark, bloody, violent shooters of recent years. We seem to be at the end of that now and, when it is done, it's with a nudge and a wink or wearing the ridiculousness of it on its sleeve. We need more mature stories like The Witcher, New Vegas, and some of the stuff in Walking Simulators to push things forward—hopefully with more gameplay though, since I think that's important. SOMA is the closest thing I've seen that matches some of the best stuff movies can do while still also feeling like a game. Unfortunately it's kind of a bad game. Great story though. Bad might be too harsh looking back. It's serviceable.
Maybe the Witcher 3 is already it. Mature themes don't mean blood and nudity, although some seem to think so. Some even seem to equate their presence, if tastefully done, as a way to elevate something. Not sure I agree on that. When I think about this sort of stuff, it comes back to the issue that science fiction and fantasy books still have today. They're the "video games" of the literary world. Sometimes movies too. Many of them are looked down upon, and authors often have to push a lot of boundaries within those genres to be recognized as worth it by the cultural elite that tend to make these judgements on what gets to be classified as high literature.
These genres are a natural fit for video games because they come with a pre-packaged reason to have combat, or a lot of exploration, or—you know, gameplay. They're also genres that are enjoyed by the same people who grew up with games. So maybe that's a double handicap that video games have to overcome.
Or we could stop letting a lot of elitist snobs determine what gets to be considered art and, instead, begin a new discussion on what art can even be.
Edward M
Hey Joe, very glad to hear things are continuing to go up and up for you, gives me a warm fuzzy feeling seeing the real quality of life improvement for you and your family. I dunno if these questions are a bit out of scope, but all well.
- Post your recent enlightenment regarding "The Experience" when it comes to video games, as you described in your Little Nightmares video, has this changed how you think about any other games previously reviewed, other than Inside and Limbo, where the experience might not have been the sole aim of the game, but still a big part of it? Perhaps you have become more forgiving of The Witness for example?
- I've been thinking about your stealth game idea regarding implementing some sort of time manipulation to combat the impatience a lot of players feel, especially replaying the same bit over and over. I can definitely see the place for a fast forward, but is there any place for a rewind mechanic in a stealth game that doesn't just remove the challenge from the game? And I know you aren't a game designer, but you seem to have a knack for solutions.
- Out of ideas for questions now, so... What are you wearing? No worries if these questions are duds with short answers and feel free to skip that last one. Cheers!
Hey Edward! Thank you—and I wouldn't worry too much about scope. Sometimes short questions get long answers. And you asked about my clothes so hey, anything goes.
1—I don't know if it's made me reevaluate anything I've previously done a video on. I do know The Witness did have that quality and that I felt it while I played. I chose not to include it in the video because I couldn't quite articulate it properly. There's something very appealing about exploring that island and coming to the slow realization about its origins. All of the different perspective tricks it has makes it feel alive and haunted. I mention them in the video but not as much as they deserved. There's always something I have to leave out though. Even with the long videos.
Dark Souls is another big one. I even mentioned it in the Little Nightmares video. There have been a few good conversations about that on the Discord server—about the experience of the first game. It is firmly something that is somehow separated from visuals, gameplay, and atmosphere, and yet complements them all. The "experience" of Dark Souls 1 is the best in that series.
Some have spoken a bit about Darkest Dungeon and proposed it has a similar quality. I'm not sure I agree but I think the perspective is a valid one. Some people definitely got more out of that part of the game than I did. Dragon's Dogma might be the same too? I don't know if people grew attached to their pawns and became proud of them? I'm not sure if that really fits because, like I say in the video, it's difficult to gauge this sort of thing when it doesn't work on you.
Strong feelings are difficult to quantify at the best of times. It's made even worse when the targeted experience is specific. I think quite a few remain unconvinced after my video but that's okay. Focusing on how intangible it is may have been a mistake, but I do think that art forms have this ability to hook into some people more if they can relate to it. I think almost everyone would agree it can happen with music, some parts of film, and definitely when it comes to food—or the type of humor a person has would be another good one. Yet there's resistance when it comes to video games.
2) I've been thinking about your stealth game idea regarding implementing some sort of time manipulation to combat the impatience a lot of players feel, especially replaying the same bit over and over. I can definitely see the place for a fast forward, but is there any place for a rewind mechanic in a stealth game that doesn't just remove the challenge from the game? And I know you aren't a game designer, but you seem to have a knack for solutions.
The easiest games to look at are the 3D Prince of Persia ones. They have a rewind to help with some precise platforming parts. This wasn't always easy to judge back then so the rewind helps soften the frustration you might feel because of the camera, or bad depth perception from certain angles. In order to prevent the game from being too easy, you had limited charges of the rewind that you had to collect sand to refill. So something like that could work.
I don't know if the time manipulation would work though. It could ruin the game by making it something you play too much in the fastforward mode. If the stealth part of the game is something you have to wait around for regardless then it's probably a decent idea but a better one might exist. More mechanics around distracting guards, or really dense environments with a lot of hiding space, or interactable objects to draw attention away. The hacking system in Watch Dogs always looked underutilized to me—I haven't played them though so maybe in the sequel it gets more attention. Some sort of magical power in a fantasy game could allow you to project your form, or knock stuff over far from your location, or lure guards to some areas.
The idea being to create ways to interact and break the patrol routes they have, instead of being forced to wait for the right moment to strike to come around again. This can be especially tedious if the guard's routes are slightly out of sync and it's only every other time that one comes near you that you have a chance to get them. If that's the only way then yeah, time manipulation would be great. Maybe a mix of both would be best?
You could also have rewind be tied to souls of enemies you've killed so that if you use the ability you're out of danger, but a guard you previously killed comes back to life under the same rewind—their soul is released back to them. Or it spawns a new enemy that joins the others. That might be too punishing though. The line you have to walk with this is that if a temporary setback is more punishing than death, then players might choose to die and restart at a checkpoint instead.
I should play Mark of the Ninja. I hear that has a wonderfully focused stealth system. It must gain a lot from being 2D though. The fixed camera angle goes a long way to inform players.
3) Out of ideas for questions now, so... What are you wearing? No worries if these questions are duds with short answers and feel free to skip that last one. Cheers!
Black shorts and white socks. Maybe some Frozen-themed boxers underneath. Too hot for a shirt right now even at night. Thanks for the fun question!
Chosen Code
Can't wait for your Nier: Automata video <3
- Have you played any of the other Yoko Taro games, if so did you enjoy any?
- Have you considered hiring an editor for basic things like editing your audio (the hated aspect of your production)?
- Do you think that games are relying on cut-scenes too heavily and should rather focus on the strength of games, being able to interact with the player?
Evening Chosen! I'm excited to get to that game too.
1—I haven't, sorry. Aside from Time Crisis 2 in the arcade, if wikipedia is accurate with the list of games he's made. I'm afraid I can't give you a good answer to this one so hopefully the video on Automata will be enough somewhat soon. Since Prey ended up being over an hour, Automata will probably be out sometime in September. I have Hollow Knight to do in August first.
2) Have you considered hiring an editor for basic things like editing your audio (the hated aspect of your production)?
Yes, and it might happen depending on how the next year goes. I don't know how much it would cost or how I would feel passing over that bad part of work onto someone else, but it is the only way I could step up video production. It would free up time for other things. If it's too expensive then it may not be worth it no matter how much time it saves, but if audio continues to be a problem after we move I'll do some research on it. I'm not expecting it to be cheap.
3) Do you think that games are relying on cut-scenes too heavily and should rather focus on the strength of games, being able to interact with the player?
Someone asked a question similar to this above. I think more than one person, actually. I said something along the lines that some people may consider it a failure whenever a video game takes control away from the player, unless your character is rendered immobile in some way.
I think your question is more specifically about story and how it's delivered and presented to its audience.
The issue comes back to the problems of interactivity rather than the potential it brings. Every story sequence, if you given the player free control, can be broken. So think of scenes in Half-Life 2 when control isn't taken away but you still can't interact with anything really. At the start you don't have any weapons, and later on in scenes the game doesn't let you use them if I remember right.
Other games allow you to shoot NPCs during story parts but immediately trigger a failstate if you do. Or warn you that the story will break in some way, or they'll make important NPCs immortal like in Skyrim. Is that better than a cut-scene? Honestly it might be. Another problem is that cut-scenes can be skipped on later playthroughs. Interactable story scenes like this usually can't, even though it should be possible to include the option.
Another problem is that letting the player control their position and camera may make them miss important information, or ruin the performance of some of the story parts. Again this still may be preferable to the alternative since you're still in control, but it won't be for everyone. Maybe not even most people.
Ultimately I think it comes down to this: if there isn't going to be any meaningful interactivity in these sequences, then is a cut-scene really the lesser option? It can be given a better camera angle, presumably improved visuals like in The Last of Us, and developers can direct how the information is given to you. It's easier to skip, and there's no temptation for the player to try to screw around and potentially glitch out the sequence by jumping all over NPCs or trying to kill them when they're not allowed.
However, there's also something to be gained by having a seamless transition from normal gameplay to conversations. Speaking to NPCs in Dark Souls doesn't take control away from you. You can choose to walk away from them while they're talking. Some NPCs even get pissed at you if you walk away without saying goodbye. Yet even that game uses cut-scenes to make sure you see something it deems important.
They're not always used for story. Some are to introduce bosses, or to give a hint to players on where they should be going next. Or to show off some of game's visuals. So while I think I do agree that some games use cut-scenes too often, my closing thoughts are that it's a tool like any other that can be used well or poorly by developers. And many people enjoy "interactable movies" like the Metal Gear Solid series.
I have a feeling I'll be returning to think about this over the years and that my mind will change back and forth.
Gareth F
Aha here we are again!
- So to build on my questions from last month, how important is a boss arena to a boss fight? Especially in the Soulsborne games!
- Have you lived in Wales at all as an adult, I know you were born here. How much of the country do you know?
- What are some things you're excited for in Bloodborne 2, if/when it is released. Changes you'd like to see, things you'd like to carry over from previous entries.
Morning Gareth!
1—I remember those questions.
Let's approach this in two ways. A boss arena can have a passive impact, or an active impact.
Passive would mean how well it functions as a space to actually fight. You want there to be room for both the player and the boss to move around, use all of their moves, without it feeling cramped—unless that restriction is in some way part of the intended challenge like with Taurus Demon. I think a much more important thing to consider is that the camera is never hampered by the arena. So nothing like the bridge problems in the Cleric Beast fight. Nor the way Aldrich can get lost in the walls during his fight.
Some arenas can also cause bugs. The same room as Aldrich can cause issues for Ornstein's rapid dash. Same for some bosses in World of Warcraft bugging out if they have knockback effects that land a player out of bounds, causing them to go immune and heal up rapidly because the server thinks you're trying to exploit the fight with the terrain in some way.
How interesting an arena is to look at would also fall under the passive quality, I think. Does it match the theme of the boss? Is a contrast something that was intended? That sort of thing. I think visuals are something a lot of critics tend to think is beneath them. I don't talk about them much simply because I don't think I'm qualified to. Whereas others think gameplay and story are more worth their time. Maybe I'm wrong on that though.
Active impact is potentially a lot more exciting. So this means parts are used in the fight some way. So if a boss had a lightning ability and there's water nearby, maybe you have to stay out of the water. Or find some high ground that's sticking out of it. Same for lava that the boss can traverse but you cannot—think something like the Centipede Demon.
The Surge has at least one boss that has things in the arena that you can use to change the fight. Unfortunately it doesn't tell you this and it's so difficult to work out on your own that I beat the boss the usual way. Very similar to my experience with the Snake Lady in Dark Souls 2 and her poison room. Does that count as an active impact? More of a shitty puzzle I think. Anyway it's a cool idea on The Surge's part and I think it's worth exploring.
An arena could have pillars that cause parts of the ceiling to collapse if they're broken. Maybe even more levels could fall and open for you to get to as this happens. This matters a lot more in games with complex movement systems and more acrobatic player characters, since these arenas will determine what moves you have available. Especially in something like Mega Man X or Hollow Knight where you need walls to do your jumps around. The absence of those is a simple way to fundamentally change how the fight feels.
I can't think of a fight in the Souls series that does this well, or really does it at all. Aside from Bed of Chaos and arguably the Dragon God in Demon's Souls. Both of these bosses aren't very good so that likely shows, even though it's a compelling idea, there needs to be more than just that to make it work. Oh the Chariot boss in Dark Souls 2 is a good example! That does it well. Same for the first boss in Heide's with the platforms you can choose not to raise as you move through the level to make it harder for yourself. The Flexile Sentry also has water that slowly fills the arena during the fight that can slow you down. Ruin Sentinels has the option to fight them on the small elevated platform at the start. The scorpion boss burrows and you need to find a safe place to stand. Guardian dragon jumps onto the side of the cage in order to charge an attack. You can destroy the pillar one of the dragon knights is standing on during the double version of the fight.
Then there's the healing radiators for Fume Knight, and destroying the portals summoning enemies during Burnt Ivory King, right?
That's kind of cool to realize. Dark Souls 2 has a lot of instances of active use of arenas, or things within the boss fight. Maybe there's more in the other games I'm forgetting since I'm clearly biased toward Dark Souls 2. Using the central pillar for cover in the Living Failures fight for Bloodborne? Ludwig jumping on the ceiling probably shouldn't count. But then neither should the guardian dragon jumping onto the side of his cage. You visually see that though whereas Ludwig's feels like he's hovering in the air with a long jump.
I don't think Dark Souls 2 goes as far with this concept as it could. I don't want to sound like I just pointed out all those examples as great boss design. Some of them are neat touches but not all of them are compelling. Especially the scorpion one and the Ruin Sentinels. It's fun to notice it though, and to think of how it could be done better.
World of Warcraft is probably the best at it. There are a ton of raids that have creative arenas. Some fights wouldn't function at all without them, especially later raids. Blackwing Descent immediately comes to mind with a blind dragon having gongs around the arena to disrupt his acute sense of hearing. Then there was another boss that had capsules of monsters on his walls that he would open. Then there was Nefarian and Onyxia that has this big coordinated dance phase with lava, pillars, and bombs on players that you would need to jump away from others to keep from killing them.
Even the first Onyxia fight, way back in vanilla, has cracks on the floor that burst open with lava. You needed to position yourself carefully not to run into them and die when she used her raid-wide fear mechanic.
WoW is full of this stuff really. Lots of active ways the arena matters and is included. I'd say that it's not something a fight needs to have in order to make it exciting, especially in combat heavy games like the Souls Series, but as FROM runs out of ideas for twists on the core mechanics, it can be a wonderful way to increase complexity on the encounter side without resorting to throwing more enemies at you. The problem might arise from how the games try to tell you as little as possible. Like The Surge example, there may be a lot of players that don't realize there are things to interact with through the boss's mechanics. Just like there may be some people that didn't realize you could choose to fight that first knight in Heide's without raising some parts of the floor, or that the water rises during Flexile.
2) Have you lived in Wales at all as an adult, I know you were born here. How much of the country do you know?
Very little of it, I'm afraid. I was 15 or 16 when I last lived there. I visited a year or two later. I think I was 18. But it was only for two weeks. I've only been around Cardiff really. I never went to North Wales. I think I'd still know my way around the part of the city that I lived in but apart from that I was quite sheltered. I'd be a tourist anywhere else in the country.
I think my accent would come back quickly though, I do.
3) What are some things you're excited for in Bloodborne 2, if/when it is released. Changes you'd like to see, things you'd like to carry over from previous entries.
Oh that's a hard one to think about.
We had a discussion on Discord a few weeks back about how Bloodborne is more focused on offense, while Dark Souls is about defense. At least the first Dark Souls, anyway. Shields are important in those games, and we talked about how requiring shields in Dark Souls 4—building the entire game around them—might be a good way to up the complexity. Some attacks can only be dodged through. Others can only be blocked. So you'd have to respond and pick the appropriate move.
If I was to make a Soulslike game I would have a dodge, a shield, and a jump. I would build a lot of attacks around those three responses in ways that test the player to recognize which is the correct move. Then you could start on offensive complexity, which Bloodborne already has quite a bit of.
There are a lot of different moves tied to trick weapons. Dodging then attacking. Sprinting into an attack. Transforming a weapon between attacks. Then there are three different attack buttons for directional attacks, sweeps, etc. There's quite a lot available to you and these choices usually matter, especially when you're fighting groups. The gun is a bit limited though so maybe that's a way to expand the scope of the combat system.
Bosses could have more weakpoints that require quick attacks to stagger them. The gun could be used for some of these. Or maybe Bloodborne should use its different name as an excuse to shed an important part of Souls, and allow attack canceling—so the game can become faster and require better reactions from players when a boss attacks faster than your attack can complete. Perfect dodges could also restore stamina similar to the Nioh system, but more in time with enemy attacks so you can keep on hitting them as long as you're good at dodging while being aggressive. Nioh, at least early on, was about keeping enemies locked down with its stamina regain mechanic. Flux.
The other way to go would be more enemy variety and more mechanics on their end, rather than what Nioh did by making the player's options grow. This was also a part of the Discord conversation. I think JoacimT brought up some good points about that and they've stuck with me.
Aside from combat, I'd simply like to see more content. More bosses. More varied locations. I'm okay with it being based in Yharnam again since Bloodborne suits a city setting, but I'd like to see more levels around the city. A good way to have an open, interconnected would would be a ring of levels around the central city section, with lots of cross-routes going to and from those central levels. Sort of like a wheel with the spokes going from the middle, with levels also linked on the outside of the circle. It could also be layered with underground paths, which would depend on how much development time they have to flesh that out.
A greatly improved Chalice Dungeon system would also be very welcome. More variety. More enemy types. I'd like this to also be a separate mode with some rogue-like elements but that might be asking for too much, since FROM likes to have everything be linked to the lore in some way.
One exception I would love to see is a boss rush mode. I am very disappointed that hasn't happened yet.
Sean M
- What has been your favorite memory since starting your channel?
- How do you combat fatigue while writing?
- I'm looking forward to a paperback edition of your books. Is there any chance that I could get you to sign the copy I buy?
1—Afternoon, Sean.
Well this month has been pretty great! But we're still living this so it's not quite a memory just yet.
I'll give you two, since just one might be a short answer.
The first is when the Hearthstone video went up. It was the same day as my son's "meet the family" party that my wife's parents arranged. We didn't want to do it but they insisted and we didn't want to ruin too much of the relationship with them. It just so happened I finished that video the night before and it was done uploading an hour or so before we left. This was my first son, of course, and he wasn't even three months old yet.
So the video goes up. I publish it. A few people watch it. I only had a couple hundred subs back then, I think. Nothing I made had gotten a lot of attention. We leave, walk about an hour to the restaurant. We go through the meet and greet with my wife's massive family. We're there all day. Then we have an hour to walk home again. Mostly we've forgotten about the video by now.
We come home and it's been posted on the Hearthstone subreddit. The channel's subscriber count has gone up by several hundred hundred—which was a huge deal. It's gotten so many more views than anything else. Compared to today it was quite tame but it was the first time a video had done something. It had been posted on r/games too. Some streamers had watched it. There were so many comments. It was incredible, really.
It was also the first time I thought the channel could be something that could be big on its own. It had potential.
Which brings us to the second memory: the night after Joseph Anderson Vs No Man's Sky was released.
My wife was still working back then. She was already pregnant with our second boy. I wasn't expecting the video to do well since so much time had passed since the game was released. The channel was growing steadily but a lot of the recent videos hadn't done that well. Dark Souls 3 got posted on reddit a bit and that was good, but the Uncharted and Inside videos hadn't gotten much attention. Still, things were looking good because growth was never stopping completely. I think we were at about 14,000 subscribers.
The video goes live. It gets posted around. It quickly hits the top spot on r/games and is locked in there for well over 24 hours. I think I have a screen cap of that somewhere. I remember seeing it on my front page, not just r/games. Which is different for everyone, but still. So this day turned into gawking at how many views and subscribers were coming in. And it just kept increasing and increasing, as more people saw the ending, upvoted it because of that, and then shared it. I think I said this in another answer for the first Q&A: that video, save meeting my wife and us having kids, is the luckiest things that's ever happened to me. So much had to line up for that video to do that well.
But the memory linked to that video was of the night afterwards. My wife came home. We watched the video together because she hadn't seen it yet. It got late, we went to bed, and of course I couldn't sleep. The comments and views were still coming in and I wanted to see them all. Finally I did fall asleep only to wake up a few hours later. So I decide to be weak and go to the computer to check. And I see that Notch had watched the video and tweeted out about the channel.
My wife also wakes up and we sat together, in the middle of the night, talking about what might happen next. The channel had close to doubled in subscribers already. Throughout that month it quadrupled because the video kept getting passed around. Going from an absolute obscure nobody, to having one of the most famous people on the planet suddenly knowing who you are, is a very hard thing to process. I still don't think I've come to terms with it. When someone big mentions me on twitter, or direct messages me, or leaves a comment saying they love my stuff—it happened recently with TotalBiscuit. It's like a hand is being reached out from this world of media that you've only been a spectator in for your whole life. And I know that may sound ridiculous, or overly dramatic, but that's how it feels. Who the fuck am I, really? That's what I keep asking myself.
Despite all that, the memory is still strongest of sitting in the dark, only the monitor lighting the room, talking to my wife about what might happen next. And how this youtube thing might have just gone from potentially being a job, to actually being one. And there have been so many other moments—a funny comment, or an angry comment that I've dramatically performed for her, or going back and watching an old video and realizing how far they've come since then—but that night after No Man's Sky was the purest feeling of professional success I think I've ever had.
Until this month at least. But like I said, that's not quite a memory yet.
2) How do you combat fatigue while writing?
Practice. Not just for the writing itself, but practicing returning to it after taking a break.
These Q&As are a long exercise in writing. A handful of answers in each session take over an hour to write. And I don't mean a set of questions either. Just one question. I enjoy them because it's like returning to writing for me and it's liberating to know I can put words on a page and not have to read them aloud into a microphone later. But it's still a lot of writing.
What I typically do is take a break after each long answer. I go check youtube, twitter, Discord, or do some google searches on stuff. I don't play a game because I'll get hooked into it. Then I come back, having "recharged" a bit. I'll read the next question and, sometimes, I'll get right to it. Othertimes I'll go back to the break while I think about the question. I need to recharge a bit more. Let my fingers have a break.
The important thing is to actually come back. At first you may not do that. You'll get caught up in reading something, watching something, and you'll procrastinate. That's okay, as long as you try to do better next time. Discipline can be self-taught. It's difficult, but it can work.
For creative writing I will always advocate structured writing time. Have a minimum amount of hours on writing per day, not a desired wordcount. Be at the computer, or notepad, or typewriter, and put in those hours everyday. Take some breaks between writing if you need to, but even if nothing happens while you're there you need to form the habit of having daily writing time.
Then, having done your time, you can do whatever you like for the rest of the day. Guilt-free. Some days you'll write barely anything. Other days you'll go over your scheduled time and not realize it, because you'll be so invested.
Fatigue can be tricky sometimes. You need to be honest and know when it's legitimate, or if it's that you simply don't want to work. If it's the latter, you need to accept that and decide if you can risk ruining your writing habit to take some time off. If it's the former and genuine fatigue, take a break and try again that same day when you're feeling better. Even if you only write 500 words that day—multiply that by a year's worth of days and see how many novels/articles it equals.
3) I'm looking forward to a paperback edition of your books. Is there any chance that I could get you to sign the copy I buy?
I'm not sure if that's going to be possible. I think I would have to sell those copies directly myself. So I'd have to have a paypal thing set up, buy a limited amount of my own book to be mailed to me, then collect addresses from people who go via paypal. Then I'd sign them and ship them out right?
If people are willing to go through paypal I could do it that way. It would delay you getting them though. How much extra would that cost? Shipping might add up a bit, but if enough people are interested I'll do it.
If anyone reading this has some advice I'd love to hear it. If not, when the release of the book gets closer, I'll do a poll to gauge interest. Or I'll open a paypal thing for people to order them ahead of time. I have no idea how well the book is going to sell. I'm a little nervous about it. The new cover looks really good so far though.
Stuart H
What's your secret? How do you make such great analysis videos consistently, what advice would you give to others wanting to make similar videos?
Hi Stuart. I don't think I have a secret. I don't know why I'm good at making these videos—many would say that I'm not. Years of critiquing stories for other writers has certainly helped in some way. I know that I'm good at explaining things so that helps. Coming up with strategies for bosses in WoW helped me learn how to pick video game mechanics apart a little bit. Then there was watching a lot of youtube videos. I have a lot of writing experience to help with scripts and creating content quickly. And I love learning new things and figuring things out by messing around—so getting audio and video editing programs to work, while sometimes frustrating, was fun enough that I wasn't scared off.
Advice is tricky because it implies that I know what I'm doing. I really don't. This isn't just imposter syndrome. My bet is that I make a lot of mistakes and do some things inefficiently. My flawed process works for me though and, with a lot of luck, I've been successful. That doesn't mean you should listen to me; however, you asked, so I'll do my best.
If I was to restart my channel now, today, with a reset back to no one knowing who I was but I kept all of my experience so far, then I would make primarily short videos on small games and broad topics. I would do this to have weekly releases. Every new video is a chance to get posted somewhere and to gain new subscribers—to gain an audience. I would continue with this for the first 10-20,000 subscribers, with most videos being things that people like but typically don't do that well when they're shared. Only a few would kick off and attract a lot of new people. Then I would transition into longer videos and in-depth looks at newer games, now that I have a decently sized audience to justify it.
I would still put a lot of effort into these short videos, but I know that I shouldn't do long ones right from the start for two reasons: you need regular chances to reach people, and that new subscribers usually want new content. Some people will discover you and watch everything you make, but the new exciting videos always bring the most people back. So before you commit a lot of time to long projects you'll already want to have an audience around to be worth that time. And it'll be best for your viewers too since more of them will have that content to enjoy.
I'd also make sure I didn't have clipping in my audio—that I was more picky with sound quality overall. There's an option in audacity that shows clipping that I wish I had found sooner. Video quality might not be something I could improve on right away because the hardware for high-end video production is quite expensive. So that would come later as the channel grows and I could invest more income from it into better hardware.
On the other side of things, I would advise that you try not to take criticism too much to heart. If many people are saying the same thing then they likely have a point. If not, only listen to people who are being constructive and are giving you clear examples of what they think you could be doing better. Some people, no matter how courteous you are, will hate you. Forever. They will follow you on twitter just to hate you. They will subscribe to you on youtube so they have quick notifications in order to dislike your videos. They will leave horrible comments. Find some humor in them. Remember that, while art and video games are important, they're not life or death topics. Someone who hates you because you didn't like a video game as much as they did isn't worth your anger. Sympathy maybe. Try to be understanding with people and remember a time that you were invested in a game that you may have been defensive about it. And that it's hard to tell someone's age or emotional state through text.
Also know that the first video will be the toughest to make. The first hundred subs will be the hardest to get. Same for the first thousand. And at first, you may not want to be in it for money. That chance might come later but, as I said at the start, I think I got very very lucky. Making these types of videos should be like writing: unless there's a burning need inside of you to create, then maybe you shouldn't be doing it. But if you're unsure about that, there's no harm in taking the plunge and trying to write something before buying all the special equipment. You may surprise yourself by how motivated you become to finish something once you begin.
Tom M
- How do you narrate so fluidly, I'm supposed to start an analysis series on an online game but I don't have much confidence in presenting a solid flow of information, how do you prepare for a recording session?
- How do you structure your scripts?
Hello Tom!
1—Well this is similar to the last question I just answered above: I don't think I narrate so fluidly. In fact this is a part of the video creation process that I find quite frustrating. I've gotten better at it, but most other video game youtubers are much better than me.
Some things that help me through it are reading the script aloud once before recording, so I learn where I'm likely to stumble. Speak louder than you think you have to, but also do a quick test sentence at the start at that volume and then listen to it back to make sure it's not too loud—or too quiet if your microphone sensitivity is turned down.
I read that you should pretend someone else is in the room with you, so you speak more naturally. You may actually want to have someone listen to you recite the script first if they're available to help you, or to sit in the room and speak to them with the microphone on if it helps. I don't do this but it could work.
You should try to open your mouth wider than you usually do. With practice you'll also learn what parts of sentences you should emphasize, and also where you should pause, to avoid sounding like you're reading in monotone. For a few videos I would force myself to smile while reading to sound happier, but I ended up disliking this because it sounded like I was close to laughing too much. Sometimes this still happens when I really am close to laughing from a part in the script. And that's okay when it only happens here and there.
I usually have my right hand raised, doing a circular motion as I read as a way to control my pacing. I read along with the bobbing of my hand so I don't go too fast. That was a big problem before.
As for preparation: I don't eat or drink anything hot a few hours before recording because it can make me sound congested. Especially during winter. I make sure all the windows are closed, that it's late at night—often meaning I had to change my sleep schedule—and that the traffic isn't too bad outside. The kids need to be asleep. The animals needs to be closed in one of the rooms. And for a while I had to unplug the fridge because it was too loud. Then it broke completely and we had to get a new one that's a lot quieter. In summer I have to turn off the AC and take it out of the window. So you might get a bit hot while recording.
I have a soft limit of an hour for recording sessions. And a hard limit of an hour and a half unless I only have one page left to do. Your voice will become drained as you go on and you may become quieter without realizing it. Sometimes I do this poorly and you can hear that I obviously stopped recording and started again later, because my voice deepens between sections. It's pretty bad in the Edith Finch video. You can likely avoid this by talking aloud for a bit before you start. Or not recording within an hour of waking up like I did that time.
Audio editing comes next but that's a whole other thing. Try to remember that your voice will always sound awful to you because you're used to hearing it from within your own head. It's just different, not bad. You'll get used to it.
2) How do you structure your scripts?
I have to have a hook to start. When I write fiction I have to know the ending. That's not true for script writing—for me, at least. But I still need to have a good opening that gets me into the script as much as I hope it'll grab viewers. Sometimes I go back and ruin this with some opening statement about spoilers or a warning about the video being too long. I've drifted away from that now, and go with introductory hooks that speak about the game and then end with a spoiler warning.
I'd love to say that I have guidelines that I follow, and a big checklist of things to speak about. Or that I always have a rigid structure of different parts to go along. Instead things are always a lot more flexible. I prioritize flow above all other things. What I say should sound at least a little conversational and, if I do it well, you should rarely notice that we've moved from one topic to another. When a video is so long that I need to have breaks between parts, I try to have a statement that bleeds from one to the other so there's some continuation. I think I did this best in the Breath of the Wild video.
Flow means that I speak about things whenever they feel relevant. I choose an important topic and just start writing, keeping in mind all of the big discussion points I want to address. When my thoughts naturally fit shifting to one of those topics then I do so. Then when that line of thought matches to a new topic I shift again. If I'm not quite finished exhausting a topic I'll either go back to an early part and see if I can slip it in somewhere, or I make a note to return to later on when there's a relevant moment in the script. That can make all of the points feel interconnected and working toward a consensus, even if that isn't the case.
For longer scripts this process can be hell. It's like juggling. The more words, the more ideas, the more points—they're all more balls you have to juggle. I can feel very stressed out in the early part of long scripts because of this. There are a lot of decisions to make on when it's right to jump to a new topic, and sometimes it can feel that there may never be a good time at all, or that I'm moving through some of them too quickly. Often I'll try to give story its own section, with important bits poking through the gameplay part. And then the opposite will also be true, with some final points on gameplay seeping into the story section. It's a good way to mop up any lingering points I missed out.
Some people hate this format. It's understandable. But I think most people like it. You may want to go with something closer to ACG's style, where there are set discussion points—graphics, sound, gameplay, story—and they're all exhausted in order. That's a good way of doing reviews, but I can sometimes find it a bit jarring. No offense meant toward ACG either he does good work.
So flow comes first. It's my most natural way of writing now. I even do it for it some of the answers in these Q&A sessions. A non-linear approach to essay writing.
Ethan O
- Have you ever played the Hitman games and if so how did you feel about the disguise mechanic the first time you used it/found out about it.
- Have you ever thought about talking about the Hitman games?
Hi Ethan. I should have replied to your comment and asked for different questions, but I didn't see this one until I was already answering them. I haven't played any of the Hitman games for more than a few minutes so I can't give you any good answers. I can link you to some videos by Writing On Games and thinreaper though:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZaO0ujcFwKg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nh5H_E7TDHg
The idea behind the games appeals to me but I'm not sold on the execution. I need to give them another shot so a video series may be possible in the future. It won't be for a long time though. If you take part in the next Q&A feel free to add some extra questions since I couldn't give you answers this time around. Like I said I should have replied to you and let you know ahead of time. Sorry about that.
Nasigil
Looks like everything I wanna ask now has already been asked, so why don't you tell me how is your progress on Witcher project now? Any current thoughts? How do you like the first 2 games? Have you started on TW3 yet? Anything. I am gonna ask this every month because I am dying to see your Witcher videos
Sorry Nasigil. I don't have much more to say that I didn't already go into for The Lion, The Witcher, and the Patreon. It's going to be a while before I have enough videos made in advance to start.
I can tell you that I've already played Witcher 1 in the past and a good chunk of Witcher 2. I like the second game more because it has a much more interesting combat system but I don't know if I'd say it's better. It's quite awkward but I was playing with a keyboard and mouse back then. We're also talking about years and years ago well before the enhanced edition came out.
Witcher 1 has glorified QTE rhythm combat. I wouldn't call it awful but it's not good either. The animations are stiff during dialogue. The eyes on a lot of the models are terrible. Not all of the voice acting is good, and it suffers from a lot of jank. But the story is still great despite a rough opening. It took me about three different attempts before I got past that initial hurdle and kept playing past the first area. And trying before the enhanced edition was a huge chore because of how long the loading screens were for that version. I'll give that to CD Projekt, they know how to improve their games after release.
Witcher 2 is an improvement in every way. Visuals are the most obvious though and holy shit was that game a looker upon release. I remember gawking at the scale of the forest in the area after the tutorial. And it continues the first game's standards with story and characterization, only with improvements on animations and voice acting. It looks a bit dated now—especially compared to the third game—but it's not really fair to judge it like that.
I'm looking forward to playing them all. You can continue to ask if you like but I'll warn you that I'll have nothing new to say for a long time. So you'll get a pass until then. Try some other questions for a few months so you don't waste them!
Devin S
How do you decide on what game you are going to cover next?
Hey there Devin. There's three main criteria:
- Whether or not I'll enjoy the game in some way.
- If I think I'll be able to write a script about it.
- Will the game be something people want to hear about.
The first one may surprise some people. I don't go into a game that I expect I'll hate. Not even No Man's Sky. I don't like turn-based combat but I thought I'd enjoy Darkest Dungeon's take on it and, like I said in another answer above, I did for a little while. If the game had better pacing and some more variety in encounters and level design, I think I would have liked it a lot more.
So my first step is often doing a tiny bit of research to see if the game is something I'll like. Sometimes it might be more accurate to say "something I think I won't hate." I had my doubts about enjoying No Man's Sky but I didn't know for sure that I'd hate it. I try to avoid almost everything I can after doing that first bit of surveying to see if I'll be able to get with the game or not. So I figure I'll sometimes miss a bit of information that tells me I won't like it, but that's sort of my job right? It's my opinion that people want. Not the regurgitated one of others.
The second thing on the list is very difficult to tell ahead of time so maybe it shouldn't be on there, but I do consider it sometimes. I don't play fighting games for this reason. Same for multiplayer and sports games. I don't think I'm qualified to speak about them and, if I was going to try to change that, it would take too long for a video to be worth it. For other games it's always a risk. Sometimes there won't be enough to say. I got this game on steam this month called Yonder and I don't think I could make a video on it because there's just not enough to it. I can't even criticize or praise it. It's more relaxing and lazy—maybe in a good way—than Stardew Valley, a game I enjoyed specifically because it was so relaxing.
Lastly the game has to be a topic that I think my subscribers will want to hear about. However I am going to start easing this rule a little bit to do some games and topics that I'm excited about. I think I have a lot of viewers now that are interested in whatever I make and not just content on the hottest, newest games. They want that too, but I think there's enough interest to have a few indulgent projects here and there. More like Dungeon Keeper and ActRaiser. I'm less worried now about every video being something that has to grow the channel, which was vital until recently. I still want to do big new games because I enjoy them and they're exciting projects, but it's not that crucial anymore.
Some people would also include "controversy" on this list but I don't try to go for that. Except for maybe the follow-up I did for No Man's Sky, which I feel a bit bad about now. It works for some viewers but I need to be truly invested in a project to see it to the end, especially on longer videos.
Oh, also I take requests too. If enough people tweet at me saying "will you do this game?" then it's more likely I'll consider it. Maybe I'll regret saying that here but it's probably obvious after what happened with Automata. Some games I'll never do regardless of how many people ask but for others—yeah, I can be persuaded as long as I think I'll enjoy it. (that's what she said)
Liam M
After watching the Edith Finch video, I looked back at the title of the game and wondered which Edith it really refers to. If the theory you pose, where the "curse" is perpetrated due to the actions of Edith Finch sr. is what the writers were aiming at then the title would make more sense in reference to her, with the curse (her legacy) being the thing referred to. Thoughts?
Hello Liam! I think that's a valid interpretation. I don't know if I agree. I don't disagree either. It's something I've been mulling over still—I made notes about it and I couldn't decide, so I left it out of the video. "Joseph Anderson is conflicted" is dangerously close to becoming a meme so I decided not to include it. Maybe I still should have.
So there are three ways I can see the title going: What Remains is simply the book you're reading. Edith Jr wrote it. She's dead. This is all that's left. The second is that her son is What Remains and, since we were technically playing as him the whole time—reading the book—then it's a perspective that fits.
The third way to go is that it's Edith Sr, as you propose. This fits very nicely with the What Remains being the house itself, and all of the memories. A place that we see the boy ready to explore at the end since he's at the cemetery outside.
Your comment here about the curse or legacy is really interesting to me. We know next to nothing about the boy at the end so it's easy to imagine him as not there at all. He may be important. But for us all of the Finches are dead. So the house has finally finished its transformation into something like a museum. The curse is, in a way, real now. Legitimate and haunting every room since every Finch that was told about it is now dead. It's quite a sorrowful ending, but Edith's name is also there in the title. She got what she wanted: the status of a legend. At the cost of every branch on the family tree.
I was going to propose a different ending in the video but, like being conflicted, I'm trying to drift away from doing changes like that. I have no problems writing them here though away from most people who only watch videos. I liked the idea of making the ending more hopeful instead. That the opening scene would be different—a boy going through a closet in a house. Finding the book. And opening it. Then, the rest of the game is the same including the speech while Edith is in labor. The final scene would be Edith, not dead after all, interrupting her son reading the book just like Dawn did with her. Edith survived despite her own doubts and, even though there's some tension that her son just exposed himself to all of the stories, she still managed to live on and didn't succumb to the curse after all.
Is it a better ending? Probably not. It's also not as powerful. But it turns the message of the story into a hopeful one instead of depressing. That it's possible to shake off the baggage of older generations and, while you may not be able to keep it hidden forever, you can begin to move past it and toward something better.
Bobby F
Your "Lion, Witcher, Patreon" video didn't make it clear: do you still plan to cover The Witcher series at some point?
Hey Bobby. My current plans may not work so I'm being careful about what I promise when it comes to the Witcher. Because of the length of the games and the four hour estimate I have for the final video, I'll need to prepare a lot of videos in advance to release while I'm looking at the series. Or else people might get annoyed by a lack of content, and that it might kill the channel after so long with nothing to show for it. There's also the fear I didn't say in the video: what if the Witcher stuff I make ends up being bad? That would be a huge blow to the channel's future.
I've already started making some of these buffer videos. I have a list of games. A few of them I've already played.. If I can make them reliably enough then I'll start with the Witcher as soon as they're finished—I think I'll need about 12 of them because they'll be short. Then I'll play Witcher 1, 2, 3, the DLC. Somewhere in that order I'll read the books. And then I'll do the games again.
Hope that clarifies everything about the Witcher plans. I can not currently give any guarantee that I will be successful with this plan, nor can I guess on when I'll be finished even if I am successful. Like I said in the video, I regret making the poll. Most people have understood though.
-
Thanks for reading everyone—to the people who make it all the way down here. There are DOZENS of you! The next Q&A prompt will be up a few days into August and answers will be at the end of next month.
I want to repeat my warning that this feature may have to be trimmed a bit in the future. Prey was delayed by a few days because of this and I don't know if that's acceptable or not. I think the next Q&A might have even more questions so I may have to drop down to 2 questions each.
Thanks again. Prey will be up soon.