Q&A Session #9 -- ANSWERS September 2017 (Patreon)
Content
I hope that's understandable—I think it will be. Everyone still has their answers and the question prompt for the next one will be up soon.
Before we start, I'd like to give a reminder that the Q&A will be changing to 2 questions each next month. This is to prevent the feature from taking up too much video production time. The length of answers may have to be reduced in future if more people continue to participate.
I know that's lame but the videos have to come first.
Onto the answers!
Stuart H asked:
Hey Joseph, keep being awesome! Only 2 questions below as I thought my second question might require an answer worthy of two questions.
- Do you think games need to be "fun"?
- I hear you often explain your process for making videos as its a question that understandably gets asked a lot. However as you explain these steps you always dismiss 1 critical step as "then I write the script" I was wondering if you could go into more detail about the script writing process? I have thought about attempting something myself but I dont even know how to start putting words on the page...
Hey Stuart! I think you're right. These will need more involved answers.
1—"Fun" is now considered to be a buzzword by some people. I think the root of that change is a matter of definitions. Depending on how you view the meaning of the word, the answer to your question is either yes or no.
To some people, fun simply means "I'm having a good time." So we can take that idea and run it through a bunch of other forms of entertainment that strain the definition: horror movies, rollercoasters, and going out for a really great meal.
Horror movies are meant to make you feel tense and scared. If they're successful, you will be creeped out and uncomfortable. Rollercoasters are far more extreme on the physical side of things but they're milder when it comes to creepiness—although I'm sure there are some horror themed rollercoasters. Dinner at a great restaurant is about being satisfied. You're hungry, the food is good, and you are fulfilling that need in a way that's far above average and acceptable.
None of these examples are "fun" in the sense that many people think of when they hear the word, and yet they can still be extremely enjoyable activities for many people. "The rollercoaster was fun." "Dinner last night was fun." "That movie made me jump, it was a lot of fun."
The other definition that conflicts with the above, is a bit harder to pin down but I think we all inherently understand it. Playing a sport is fun. Playing a game with your friends or kids is fun. Playing most video games is fun. The keyword there seems to be "play" and that's a good partner for it. You're not scared, you're not being thrilled, you're not satisfying any particular essential need.
Let's take this to video games: games need to be "fun" if you take the first meaning as correct. They do not need to be fun if you're going with the second definition, although many games can still be successful if they go that way. Not all games have to.
Horror games are the easy example to point at. There's nothing fun about being startled or scared, but some people enjoy it a lot. It's fun to them under the first definition. Horror games are really obvious though so let's try a different approach.
Games that induce stress are not fun but can still be enjoyable. Puzzle games are mentally taxing and can be seen as a period of mental straining before you finally breakthrough and have that flood of satisfaction from solving it. Although they're very different, you can see the same thing in any sort of challenging game across any genre. Not just action games with combat but even something like a racing game—a difficult time trial on a tough course.
This can also come back to the idea of a game vs an experience, which some people may wish to separate as their own thing—that they shouldn't be considered games at all. Maybe they would argue that games have to be fun under the second definition. That gets muddied with challenging games, however, and calls into question some unconventional control schemes. No matter what kind of game it is, should it always "feel fun" to control? Papers Please would argue otherwise, just as many may argue it's not even a game. Playstation One's Resident Evil and Tomb Raider controls make it a more difficult discussion.
I think for many people games need to be fun like Nintendo games are fun. That's all they want. Run and jump, hack and slash, very little story outside of context, no emotional worth or weight on any sort of experience. And I definitely understand that—for a few years that's all I really wanted out of games too.
Just like books and film can range from mindless action stories to challenging works of art with layers of depth and meaning, video games can be many different things. There always has to be something worthwhile—something you can say you enjoyed on some level. But it doesn't have to be fun.
2) I hear you often explain your process for making videos as its a question that understandably gets asked a lot. However as you explain these steps you always dismiss 1 critical step as "then I write the script" I was wondering if you could go into more detail about the script writing process? I have thought about attempting something myself but I don't even know how to start putting words on the page...
Hmm. I think I've answered this at least once before. Maybe you missed it? Or maybe I didn't go into as much as detail as you'd like. I also spoke a bit about it in the interview I had with Critical Distance.
Alright so a big problem I have with answering part of your question is that I've been writing for years and years. I wrote a lot as a teenager, then there were essays in high school and during the year of university I did—with a lot of creative writing ongoing at the same time. I've written so many long critiques of fiction on the internet. And all of that is before I started writing my novels and now all of these video scripts, which I think may be getting close to overtaking the books in wordcount.
I'm not saying I'm a good writer—I think I'm about average, maybe slightly above average, for the amount of time I've put into it. But I do have so much experience that a lot of it is second nature to me. I rarely have that problem of opening a text file and staring at the blank pages, not knowing what to do. Although it did happen when I first started script writing.
I find I need to hook myself into writing just like a book tries to hook a reader. I need to have some thought process to slip into and just go with it. Sometimes this is knowing what my conclusion is going to be. Othertimes it's only the first paragraph and I just see where it goes—what's the next point that flows naturally from where I ended the previous one?
This isn't the same process I go through with writing fiction on a broad scale. I plan obsessively for that and I always know where a story is going. But on the smaller scale, with each individual scene—yes, I need a good opening line to slide into writing. Or some overarching concept that textures the scene.
My process for script writing is somewhat similar now. I take a lot of notes while I play games. Most of these are kept in a state of juggling in my head because I want to make sure I can link them together as much as possible to make them stronger. So by the time I start writing, I have a road map of chaos of all the things I want to say. I write a few paragraphs—sometimes I get this on the first try, othertimes I have to stop and restart until I feel a hook into a first good point. And from then I write until about that particular point until I see a good way to transition to another one. Even if the first point isn't fully exhausted yet, I will almost always move onto a new point and then come back to the first point later when I can link back to it.
(Did you feel how many times I said "point" in that paragraph? Yeah try to avoid doing that unless there's no other way around it.)
I call this flow. Some people hate it. They say it makes my videos come across as rambling but, at the risk of sounding arrogant as fuck, I think that might be their problem not mine. I'm not saying everyone should be able to enjoy my videos but to dismiss an intentional style as just rambling—well, a lot of work goes into keeping everything moving smoothly from one topic to another. That juggling of points in my head can become strenuous. It's always a relief to finally have a script done because I can let all those balls drop.
Other people may prefer a more structured, firing squad approach. Up first is graphics. Now we're on sound and music. Here's gameplay. Then value and replayability. And for economical reviews that's wonderful. But I want my videos to feel like an accessible conversation that deals with an entire game on a broad scale without sacrificing moments that focus on specific parts of it without it feeling jarring.
I am not always successful with this, but I always try. Even when I split the video into parts, I try to have some bridge to keep it going.
If your question was more about how to actually sit down and write: it's all about discipline and practice. You need to have scheduled writing time, or scheduled work time that can become writing time if that's the part of the project you're on. Or you need to always be ready and willing to work if the opportunity presents itself—that's my life right now with the kids.
If you're going to make videos then I'd suggest starting with a game you already know. Something you like a lot but also think could be better. If you're going to record yourself reading your script then you may want to ask someone you know to sit with you while you tell them everything you want to speak about. Writing can come across as stuffy. Many people default to this scholarly old English voice. You want your writing to sound like you and trying to verbalize all your ideas may help you understand how you should write in order to make that a reality.
Just remember: have "fun" with it!
Alex S asked:
Hi Joseph.
- How do you think your life will change with the extra Patreon funding?
- How would you compare Hollow Knight's world design and storytelling to how it's done in Dark Souls 1?
- After Edith Finch are you planning on reviewing more narrative games? (Such as Firewatch, Begginer's guide, etc).
Hi Alex! Patreon ate this questions so I had to get them through a direct message. I needed to fix the formatting a bit. Hope that's alright.
1—The channel was a big change before the bump because it was just enough to have my wife stay home. Not only that, I wouldn't have been able to get anything done without that happening since the kids would take up all day everyday. Even now, they still take a lot of time during the day. But I also don't want to miss all of it. They grow up so damn fast.
The big increase hasn't changed much yet because it's still so new and we're saving all of it to buy a house. We spent too much time trying to find a new rental and it didn't work out, so we'll be saving it all to move. That'll be a gigantic change that should also be felt on the channel. I should be able to record way more reliably, have a separate work space, and stream—although I'm going to try doing that sooner.
We don't know if we'll be moving this year or in the first half of next year. We expected the patreon support to grow slowly toward finally being able to move—not a sudden increase. So while it's so much more money, it's still too new to cause huge sweeping changes.
For some smaller things: I've been able to buy more games and hardware for videos. A new monitor, a new microphone, a webcam for streaming, and many new steam games to see what I can learn from them. And potential video candidates.
Aside from that, not much. The house and moving is the main priority. After that though? I have no idea.
2) How would you compare Hollow Knight's world design and storytelling to how it's done in Dark Souls 1?
A doubled stacked question! World design and storytelling?
They have many similarities. I spoke about some of them in the video. Dark Souls has that supernatural descent lower and lower from your starting position. Hollow Knight has that plus so many more levels after you think you're close to the end. Both games also have a forsaken city somewhere in their mid-game, after which the world opens up. Neither game directly tells you where to go—both have NPCs to give you hints though. Hollow Knight embraces this more than Dark Souls 1 since there are more chances earlier on to get off the main track of progression. You can also find yourself wandering a lot more from level to level, since they have a lot more connections and paths. Dark Souls 1 only does this a bit, and almost exclusively in its first half.
The big "yeah well duh" difference is that Dark Souls is 3D and Hollow Knight is 2D. This matters a lot, since you'll have a harder time remembering where you are in a 2D space without a map. There are fewer landmarks and ways to feel how everything is put together—at least in the way Dark Souls functions. Some 3D games do this very poorly and make it easy to get lost.
Hollow Knight avoids this being too much of an issue by having each level be visually distinct. Aside from the many hidden cave routes around the place, you can usually immediately tell what area you're in just by looking at the walls and background. The world is also put together approximately to scale too—you can see that when you zoom in from the world map to the level map and pan across it all.
I feel like Hollow Knight has more secrets. Maybe that's not true though. Fake walls and floors also have more clear tells rather than something you feel out via intuition like in Souls.
Storytelling is also similar in a lot of ways: there are minimal cinematics taking away control. I think Hollow Knight only has two, if you don't include the brief introductions that some bosses have. This is harder to see as a "cinematic" since it retains the same player perspective but they are interruptions all the same.
You learn everything from reading things in the world and talking to characters. Hollow Knight has the bestiary information dump that I didn't read much of, but that sets it apart from Souls. The narrative lines following its roaming characters are similar too—there are events you can trigger and conversations to have that make different things happen later. Zote and Cloth especially. It gives that same wonderful impression that Souls has: you're not the only one journeying around this world. A cast of characters is on a similar quest and walking a similar path. It's something I wish was used a bit more, even in Souls.
I don't think Hollow Knight is as vague as Dark Souls 1, but much of it is still left to guesswork. Like I said in the video, this may be something that's fixed in expansions. There are definitely more solid details about the cycle—that it has a cause and solution that's tangible instead of some mystical loop that's baked into the creation of the world.
It's a little interesting but the kicker for me with both of these games is that, even when I go and read what the interpretations are of all of the details, it still doesn't strike me as all that good. It's a lot of work for something that may not be true, may not be intended, and may not be worth it.
3) After Edith Finch are you planning on reviewing more narrative games? (Such as Firewatch, Begginer's guide, etc).
Definitely! I enjoyed making the Edith Finch video. Not only that, they're much easier to make than any other type of content on the channel. There isn't much gameplay to dig into—I love doing that but it's really time intensive to do it right. Examples alone take so much time. The other positive there is that games like Edith Finch are so short that there isn't much footage to sift for what I need to show on the screen.
I don't know which one I'll do next. Anyone have a big request?
Whitelight asked:
Hey, Jessop. Good to see your patreon go nuclear over the past few months. Chris Davis, the first guy who ever posted on your community thing on patreon went from 20 views to around 200,000 now I believe. Can't believe it's been 9 months since I watched the witness video. For fuck's sake. Enter still posts instead of skips a line. Anyway.
- Have you played any of the Crysis games? You seemed surprised when Chris Wagar had Warhead on his top 25 games. If I've asked this before in the turbo edition, then fuck.
- Been demonitized by YT?
Hey WotLight, yeah things have come a long way in a short amount of time. Until then growth on patreon was steady. Youtube had some big bumps too.
I haven't watched many of Chris Davis's videos yet because I haven't played the games he's covered (except Prey). That's probably a good thing though because we can't all cover every game. There are some that I'd still like to do that others have but I'd like for this weird, burgeoning video game criticism community of ours to cover most games going forward.
He's going the hard way about it with long videos on games. 6-7k subs in six months is pretty good though. I think I was only at 4-5k when the channel was six months old.
1—I've played Crysis 1, Crysis 2, and Far Cry 1 and 3. Far Cry 3 probably shouldn't count but Far Cry 1 feels like the proper ancestor to the first Crysis.
I haven't played Warhead, nor Crysis 3 yet.
I like the games a lot. I remember being a bit peeved at the reception Crysis 1 received, since I thought it had a lot more going for it than most shooters did at the time. Open world levels that allow for different approaches, and the nanosuit to provide so many different options. If you get good at switching between modes, there is a ton of flexibility for both stealth and direct combat.
In my memory, much of this was dismissed because the game was incredibly ahead of its time in terms of visuals that how could it possibly have more going for it other than that?
I had a conversation with a friend of mine about a year after its release. He said it was an okay game and the visuals were the best part. I prodded him by saying "well didn't you have fun with the super powers and traveling through the levels in any way you really pleased?" And it slowly dawned on him that he had enjoyed more of the game than he realized while he had been too busy ogling the graphics. Or at least, I badgered him enough to just say that to shut me up, haha.
Crysis 2 had a similar issue, I think. The game looked like a more streamlined (casualized, bad word bad word!) version of Crysis 1. It was still gorgeous. How good could it possibly be? I enjoyed it a lot. Probably more than the first game. And yet it was dismissed by too many at the time. I enjoyed your video on the game a lot for this reason. I thought that you did it justice, while also pointing out its shortcomings.
I liked Far Cry 1 a lot too but the Crysis games were so much better. I'm having trouble thinking of a FPS with a better movement system, really. It's why I used it as my example of a better way in my second Fallout 4 video. It's a great system already and could be even better with some tweaks. Maybe a new mode, too.
I was surprised by Chris including it in his list because I didn't think he went in for many shooters. I think we may have spoken about it on steam once before though and he said he liked it—I didn't realize how much, clearly. Chris has very specific tastes and that game is such a graphical marvel that I figured he'd dismiss it. That's my bad for underestimating him (he's going to love reading that, if he does).
2) Been demonitized by YT?
Yep! I think you mean through their own system, and not a copyright claim. That's happened a few times.
My first Tomb Raider video and one of the Dark Souls 2 videos got demonitized and remained so for about a week. Then they were reviewed and had ads placed back on.
It seems to me like a bot system that's trying to learn, and it's in the early stages of hitting a ton of false positives (or negatives, depending on how you view it). It must be looking for keywords and images, and a team at youtube is tweaking it after reviewing a lot of videos that youtubers bounce back. What's annoying is that isn't everyone going to bounce it back and try their luck at an appeal? I don't know what the goal is with this one. They must be feeling a ton of pressure to fix something with their ad system.
I'm certain I'll have a few more hit from this bot soon. Hollow Knight didn't get copyright claimed though, which is good! It was the best launch of any of my videos yet. It dropped off quick on the second and third days though. Unexpected after such a strong first day.
Adam J asked:
Hey Joseph, hope all the reviews are coming along nicely and the witcher series review isn't causing you too much trouble.
- What is your favorite OST from a video game?
- What is your opinion on the Supergiant games (Bastion Transistor Pyre)?
Hey Adam! The Witcher series is causing me a bit of grief but I'll work through it. It's going to be a while though.
1—This has been asked before and I can't remember my answer. I know the top choice will be the same but I spoke about a few more so you might want to look up the previous Q&As for more of an answer.
I rarely listen to entire soundtracks of anything, and only a few bands have albums that I'll put on instead of a playlist of individual songs. That said, a handful of games are special enough that I've listened to the entire thing.
Chrono Trigger and Final Fantasy 6 would fight for first place; however, this may be cheating because I've replaced most of the original OST with remixes and orchestra versions over the years. OCRemix has an outstanding reimagining of the entire Chrono Trigger album. I think they have one for Final Fantasy 6 now as well? I think it's six hours long so I haven't listened to the whole thing. The Chrono Trigger one was on repeat for so long though. The track "Schala and the Queen"... I must have listened to that hundreds of times while writing. I tend to play songs to death.
Furi's soundtrack is special to me but I listen to mostly the last part of it. The Star's music is possibly my favorite video game track of all time, and that's without going into how it's used to enhance the fight.
Donkey Kong Country's music was amazing. I think even my mother said so while I was playing one time, and she couldn't be bothered with anything to do with games.
I already like Nier Automata's soundtrack before playing much of the game. I've listened to a lot of it on youtube. Turbo Button also linked me some Xenoblade music and that was just gorgeous. Yet another game I haven't played.
Chrono Cross has some beautiful music. Time's Scar could give Danger 7-53/8-02 a run for its money. As could the main theme from Metal Gear Solid 1/2/3 (I think 2 is my favorite but that bit at the end of 3's... damn).
Mario Galaxy has an epic soundtrack but I haven't listened to it as much as I'd like. Everytime I do hear it I'm surprised by how good it is.
Dark Souls and Bloodborne have some great tracks. So does Hollow Knight. Video games have a ton of worthwhile music. I think I asked this last time, but I wonder if it's because composers are given more creative freedom to do what they like with games.
Some other loose tracks: Baba Yetu from Civilization 4, Suicide Mission from Mass Effect 2, Uncharted's main theme (3rd game version is probably best), Metroid Prime 2's Echoes title theme, Halo's theme, and too many from World of Warcraft.
2) What is your opinion on the Supergiant games (Bastion Transistor Pyre)?
Well, related to your last question: they have some great music! I haven't played these games much but I have listened to so many of the songs—less so of Pyre though because it's still new.
I can't give you a good answer to this one because I haven't given these games a fair chance, although from my minimal playtime with all three I think I like Pyre the most so far. I've tried so many times to play Bastion and I put it down after my first play session and never go back. However it's always been with a keyboard and mouse, which I don't think the game is best with. I want to give it another shot with a gamepad, and with a serious enough effort to beat it.
Same for Transistor and, eventually, Pyre. I'm hoping all three will end up as buffer videos to release while I play the Witcher games. Don't hold me to that though!
Justin A asked:
Hi Joseph, many thanks for the awesome videos. I especially want to thank you for the PREY video, as I was really on the fence about the game but your video sold it to me. Now it's one of my favourites this year.
- Have you ever played or considered playing any of the Yakuza games? I've personally gotten into them recently, and they are truly fantastic.
- Have you ever considered doing a video on any of the Resident Evil games? I would particularly enjoy hearing your thoughts on Resident Evil 7, perhaps in the context of a comparison to the previous games in the series.
- Have you considered creating videos focusing on specific concepts across multiple games rather than focusing on a single game? I think it would be interesting to see you talk about the evolution of a particular design style or mechanic that can be found across multiple games, perhaps examining how they have evolved over time. Thanks again Joseph.
Hi Justin. Yeah Prey is great! One of the bangers of the year. (I hate Novacanoo for infecting me with that saying.)
1—I haven't, unfortunately. It's unlikely I will either because most of my game time goes toward stuff for videos. A series with a lot of games that I haven't touched is a big project, because if I don't play the older games I'll eat a lot of shit for it. It's already started happening with Nier Automata since it's my first one.
I might pick up one of the new ones at some point just to see what they're like. I've been trying to play more games lately to have experiences and examples to draw from.
2) Have you ever considered doing a video on any of the Resident Evil games? I would particularly enjoy hearing your thoughts on Resident Evil 7, perhaps in the context of a comparison to the previous games in the series.
Yep! Although this is the same situation as your last question, I've already played most of the games in the main series. I think I'd only need to go through 6 and 7 for the first time. If I'm including Code Veronica and all the spin-offs like that... yeah that'd turn into a big mess.
Resident Evil is one of many "mega projects" I could do. Some of these are larger than others—one on all of the Final Fantasy games or World of Warcraft would probably be impossible.
I liked Resident Evil 1 and Zero a lot. I can't remember 2 or Nemesis that well (I may not have played all of Nemesis). 4 was good, almost great. 5 I played with a friend co-op all the way through my first time so that was a really cool experience. 6 I hear isn't quite as bad as everyone says, and 7 seems to be the horrific black sheep (in a good way) in terms of changes.
I can't promise anything but I may do them one day.
3) Have you considered creating videos focusing on specific concepts across multiple games rather than focusing on a single game? I think it would be interesting to see you talk about the evolution of a particular design style or mechanic that can be found across multiple games, perhaps examining how they have evolved over time. Thanks again Joseph.
All the time. There are so many ideas. There's effectively infinite videos I could make.
My problem is that I've put myself into this routine of doing entire games for the foreseeable future. I do have some broader topics I want to make videos on—and have already done some script writing about—but not like what you're describing here. I think it would be a difficult thing to do but it would be interesting. Definitely worth it.
I feel like I am constantly playing catch-up with releases, with Witcher 3 being the big finish line that keeps getting pulled back whenever a regular release video takes too long to make. Even smaller indie games can spiral out of control if I end up having a lot to say. It's frustrating. I'm really concerned Nier Automata is going to take a full month all by itself.
I think a series on the evolution of 2D platformers could be really interesting. That might have a lot of spillover with Metroidvanias though. Maybe the development of a specific mechanic is too broad to be comprehensive. Smaller scopes on comparisons between individual games or eras could be better.
It would require a lot of time spent playing games. Imagine how many hours it would take to play most open world games to do a proper video analyzing the trends and changes as the years went by. That could take months and months.
It would probably be better to start with something a bit more niche if that was the case. There can still be a lot of examples and games to pull from, but only a dozen or two instead of more than a hundred.
Have any books on game design attempted to do that? Seems like it would be a good fit for a big book.
Erich B asked:
Hi Mr. Anderson!
- (quickie). Did all your friends call you Mr. Anderson (with that specific voice) when the Matrix came out?
- Are you familiar with the Warhammer franchise and have you played any of the multitudes of games set in it? Does the setting do anything for you?
Hi Agent B!
1—Only ever happened to me online. Especially on battlenet since Anderson is on my tag there. More often than not it would be the first thing that was said to me after accepting someone's friend request. It's cute. It never bothered me much but there's no good response to it really.
2) Are you familiar with the Warhammer franchise and have you played any of the multitudes of games set in it? Does the setting do anything for you?
I think this has been asked twice before. Warhammer must still be pretty popular.
Hobbies weren't encouraged when I was growing up. Especially ones that can get as expensive as Warhammer. I did get a couple of models and tried some of it with my friends—they had decently sized collections. But because I couldn't get into the game on my own terms, it stayed at arm's length.
I liked the assembly of the models and painting them. That part interested me more than the game. Same with tabletops themselves. It's something I'd like to try to do with my boys when they're older—or some alternative since I hear Games Workshop isn't the best company to support anymore. Maybe I'm wrong on that though.
The fantasy version always appealed to me slightly more than 40k, although that has its charms too.
The only game I've properly played from the franchise is Dawn of War, but I don't remember it much. I did some multiplayer. It was fun but not all that memorable. I think I played Dawn of War 2 a bit as well. It's weird that I barely remember those games. Huh.
I have Space Marine. Steam says I played it for 48 minutes. It was decent but I couldn't tell you why I stopped.
The history of the franchise is worth some attention if it's used well. There's so much to draw from there that could make some rich video game settings—if not stories. I don't know if I'll ever get to these games. I will say that realtime adaptations interest me far more than strategy games. A fresh perspective in a different medium is a lot more fun.
Would you recommend some games in particular?
Tom B asked:
Hi Joseph! Thanks for answering my questions last month. I have a few more that I was wondering about and thought I'd ask:
- What are the most imaginative boss fights in games you've played, or your favourites for creativity? That can be creative in any way - like in method of defeating them or in the format of the fight.
- You mentioned in one of your answers that you like plot twists if they're done correctly. I find that the older I get the less I'm surprised by narrative twists - are there any in recent memory that have got you completely unawares in a satisfying way?
- What are the funniest games you've played? Can you think of any moments that made you laugh out loud? I'm always fascinated by humour in games. Cheers!
Hi Tom! No problem. Hopefully I can give you some halfway decent answers.
1—There are so many cool bosses in gaming! Especially if creativity is what you're grading it on and not just execution. Like the Dragon God in Demon's Souls. Is it a good boss? Absolutely not. But it's a cool idea. Same for the fights in that series that summon a player to control the boss for you. Super cool idea. Maybe not so great in practice.
I talk about bosses in some series more than others: I already started with Souls, then onto Furi, Shadow of the Colossus, and all the usual suspects. So let's try to avoid them.
I can't resist mentioning World of Warcraft though. Bosses in this game are just a model and a texture slapped onto a rectangular hitbox and some approximate damage cones and other protrusions to estimate how attacks work. And yet there's some great creativity that's wrung out of these in raids. Even in some dungeons!
There was a boss based on time travel that had an hourglass you could use to reset part of the fight without losing progress on the boss. Something I think was originally planned for a raid but was moved to a 5 man fight because it would be too hectic.
Ulduar was full of this stuff: the raid jumps into a siege group of tanks, catapults, and motorcycles. Was it executed all that well? Fuck no, but it was still a big change up and is memorable. Mimiron had different phases that would then fuse together into a giant robot at the end.
There was a boss in Throne of Thunder that created a maze you had to navigate on the fly in order to survive. There was another boss in there too that made you manage a blood-like resource to power evil robots in a room, and you had to strategically kill certain ones in certain locations to not get over run. It was tough on heroic mode—maybe even a bit too hard—but certainly creative.
I miss raiding.
What other games? I think the final boss in Yoshi's Island was cool and surprising. It becomes something 3D-like with the big Bowser in the background of the arena. You had to aim giant eggs and throw them at him as he crept closer to get you.
The Metal Gear Solid series is full of creative bosses that are also mechanically interesting. Most of them also deliver in terms of spectacle too. Psycho Mantis is the first one that most people think of. But fighting a jet, a sniper battle, and then a mech? After mostly doing slow stealth stuff? Same for the Vamp fight in MGS2. The gauntlet of Metal Gear Rays. Metal Gear Solid 3 wasn't quite as good as the first two in this regard but it did have an even more creative sniper fight and that river of death scene.
I thought the bosses in Metroid Prime 3 were unique because of the mixed aiming modes. Staying locked on, with quick movement, and then having to aim further within that lock. I liked that a lot.
The invasion of the Final Fantasy style boss in Mario RPG was cool. The "boss" gameshow of Banjo-Kazooie was awesome my first time through. Some of the fights in A Hat of Time surprised me recently because of how good they were when I wasn't expecting them to. Probably not what you're asking for though.
Oh, and Cuphead! Some of the art in that game was really surprising. Not just in terms of quality but in the transitions the fights go through. Really cool. The candy castle was my favorite change.
2) You mentioned in one of your answers that you like plot twists if they're done correctly. I find that the older I get the less I'm surprised by narrative twists - are there any in recent memory that have got you completely unawares in a satisfying way?
I still enjoy twists but I think they're used a bit too much. Maybe many of the current writers grew up in a time of some amazing plot twists and they're trying to recreate that feeling for others. I know I feel that pull with my own work. A few of my stories have twists.
I can't recall any that got me recently. Aside from the one I mentioned about SOMA in my video. I figured it out before the main character did but I think that's what is meant to happen. There were a couple of parts in Ozark (the Netflix show) that caught me by surprise. And it took me longer than it should have to work out something in The Man from UNCLE.
A recent Doctor Who episode got me really good and I loved it for that. I won't spoil it but it was toward the end of Season 9. I don't know if that counts as a twist though because almost every episode of Doctor Who is about unraveling a mystery. Same goes for something like American Gods, which didn't have any hints or clues that it would even have a twist. Then when it's revealed you don't care really.
For games, the ones that got me the most were Knights of the Old Republic. I didn't see that coming at all. BioShock also got me but I don't think it's a great twist. It leads to a good moment though. There's that big scene in Modern Warfare that I think is really unexpected. And there's a decision in the original Mass Effect that caught me offguard. Braid's ending was good for that too.
Of course there's also what is arguably the biggest twist in all of gaming. The reveal in Metal Gear Solid 2 that you are not going to be playing as Snake. Something that had me saying aloud "any minute now we're going to be switching over to Snake, any minute now!" for every hour of gameplay that I went through. All the way to the end.
God damn it, Metal Gear.
3) What are the funniest games you've played? Can you think of any moments that made you laugh out loud? I'm always fascinated by humour in games. Cheers!
Someone asked this before and I struggled to think of many examples. The Stanley Parable looks funny but I haven't played it.
Portal 1 and 2 are the first that many will point to, and for good reason. The best moments in both of these games are when the humor is also laced with aggression or tension. This building dread that sure, this AI sounds funny and is cracking some great lines but she also might mean most of what she's saying. There's a different kind of dread in the second game when you fully understand what kind of person is now in charge of the facility you're moving through. My favorite part was when Wheatley tries to convince you to jump into a pit. "There are boy bands down there!"
I've played Bulletstorm but I didn't find it funny. More vulgar for the sake of it. Which can be fine, especially when the gameplay is pretty good, but I wasn't laughing. Light amusement maybe? That sounds kind of pretentious.
Dungeon Keeper 1 and 2 have some great funny moments, particularly the monologues at the end of every level. It helps lighten the tone of a game that is otherwise quite brutal with its depiction of death and pillaging. It helps soften the reality that you really are the bad guys. Is Overlord the same way? I haven't played it. I know Evil Genius was and that had some funny parts. I hope the new sequel is good!
No One Lives Forever had me laughing at some parts early on but I never got a chance to finish it. If that level holds up it would have a place on this list. I wish I had kept playing. The dialogue was what got me the most.
Giants: Citizen Kabuto is something that I did finish and at the time I was a young teenage boy. So that game was a fucking riot. My friends loved it too and we quoted it a lot. I have no idea how well it would hold up today—if you can even play it. Has it aged well? Is it on GOG? Shockingly enough that game used to look good! Now it probably looks like a shitty conversion mod for Fallout 3. Not even Fallout 4. But I still remember it fondly.
"The smarties! They're real!" dramatic close up
Kiefer O asked:
Hey man, love your content. I'll only give you 2 since I'm sure you have a lot on your plate. Don't worry about being crazy in-depth, just curious.
- Do you drink alcohol, and if so what are some of your favorites?
- Which of your videos would you consider to be your best, not counting the 2 most recent ones?
Hey Kiefer. One of these will be a bit personal. I hope that's okay.
1—I don't drink. The last time I was drunk was New Year's of 2006 or so. I can't remember. I can't remember the night either. I started drinking in front of my computer in the living room and woke up on the bathroom floor hours later. I was living alone at the time.
When I did drink it was vodka. I don't like beer, and my reasoning was always: if I'm drinking its to get drunk or a buzz, so let's get right to what'll get me there as quick as possible. Not the best outlook.
I've had a beer or two since then just to see if I could find one that I liked—just out of curiosity really. And the New Year's before deciding to have a baby my wife and I drank a bottle of wine but neither of us got drunk.
I come from what I have to imagine is a long line of alcoholics. On both sides of my family. The Scottish side were always drinking. The Welsh side were always drinking. My dad was an unpredictable drunk—sleepy or angry or friendly or too incoherent to be any of those things. He would drink so much so often that he would become a comatose lump wherever he landed at the end of the night. I have lots of horrible stories about what he would do that none of you would find particularly interesting. It's a good lesson that I learned, and it's something that I never ever want to put my kids through.
My outlook now is a bit boring and maybe a bit preachy so forgive me for it: you only have so many days, weeks, months, and years to live. Why waste any of them on a drink that will make you unable to remember it? If you're only going for the enhancing effect of alcohol then that's another thing, but that addiction runs too deep in both sides of my family to risk it.
It's a shame too because I've heard wonderful things about writers and alcohol! It allows them to get shit done. But it'd also be a nightmare when mixed with all the sleep walking I do.
But yeah, straight vodka when I did drink. I think it would fuck my stomach up rotten if I did that today.
2) Which of your videos would you consider to be your best, not counting the 2 most recent ones?
Aw, darn. The new ones are always the favorites! You're almost always proud of whatever you just did.
My top choices right now would be Breath of the Wild, Fallout 4 One Year Later, No Man's Sky, and a toss up between Rise of the Tomb Raider and the Uncharted 4 gameplay critique.
I'm happy with (almost) all of my videos when I watch them back. But those standout.
I think I gave both Breath of the Wild and Fallout 4 a fair, thorough evaluation—of everything they have to offer. There's a lot of good discussion about gameplay, exploration, their core systems, and the story. They're long videos but they don't feel as long as they are, which is a good sign. I was also getting better with more creative transitions with those and I appreciate that looking back.
Joseph Anderson Vs No Man's Sky is like a story told through gaming criticism, and I like it a lot because of that. There's a building narrative that sneaks up on you through this non-stop list of gripes against this terrible game, which shifts suddenly to become the focus in part two. That has the best ending in any of my videos. I will never be able to top it.
Choosing Rise of the Tomb Raider may surprise people but, just like with Breath of the Wild and Fallout 4, I think I did a really thorough, fair job of going through the whole thing. My suggestions for "fixes" aren't usually meant to be taken super seriously—they're more examples of how I, with no game dev experience whatsoever, can see some solutions so proper game devs should have been able to do that too. Therefore someone stopped them from doing it, or some higher up decided it wasn't worth it. My suggestions for Rise are some of my best, however, and I like them a lot.
The Uncharted 4 Gameplay Critique is a well paced video that covers a lot, especially for a series that's criticized for having shallow gameplay. It was a big step up for the series and I think I went through all of its shortcomings in a good way. That video flows well from topic to topic.
If I was allowed to do the recent videos then it would be Hollow Knight and Prey!
Honorable mention to The Villain of Edith Finch, which many people have told me is their favorite of mine. I like my videos to switch between story and gameplay when possible, so that seems a bit lacking since that game was all story. I'm still happy with it though.
Soznyw asked:
Hi again! Thanks for your answers as usual. My questions for this month are:
- What are the common traits or habits or styles of the reviewers you are not really a fan of?
- Do you take any physical notes whenever you're playing something that you're planning to make a review on during the very first playthrough? Thanks a lot! (I'm trying to ask things which are less complicated this month compared to the previous ones since I feel guilty to overwhelm you with my long-ass questions, lol.)
Hi Soznyw!
1—I won't name any names because that would be rude. It also wouldn't be constructive. Plus there isn't one person who is the only one who does some of these problems.
For written stuff on big websites, I dislike how much of each review is dedicated to anecdotes of what happened while playing. These are fine in theory but they're always used as a substitute for discussing gameplay. It's an escape for people who can't discuss controls and mechanics very well—here's something that happened to me while I was playing. Now onto the visuals, sound, story, and value for money.
I use anecdotes too but they're in addition to gameplay discussions, or used to support something. A sharp focus on the end score also bothers me on these websites but that's equally the fault of the audience. Maybe even more so.
My biggest gripe with video creators is talking over irrelevant gameplay footage. Not only does it call into question why you're making a video at all—instead of just a written piece—it's also lazy. Matching examples to what you're saying takes a ton of time. When you skip that, it's easy to see it as a lack of drive to put the work in.
Similarly, not bothering to clean your audio reeks of the same lack of effort. This can be as extreme as leaving ruined takes in, but excessive background noise, coughs, or a general low hum constantly going on are also distracting. These aren't hard to remove. Some of this stuff can be forgivable, especially to someone first starting out. Just like a bad microphone or low video quality—or using let's play footage for everything if you aren't able to record. But if you're a successful creator and you still have issues like this, what message does that send? And why don't you care about fixing it?
I dislike constant attempts to be funny, rapidfire memes, and other "so wacky random" shit. Very few people can pull that off. Even the one who is the most successful with it—I'd argue Dunkey is top of that category right now—still has bits that fall flat. You have to be funny to make a lot of content like that. You can't start making it and hope you become funny along the way. I do enjoy many creators who are more on the entertainment side of things, but that is one of the hardest things to do in writing. You can't just stumble your way through it.
Lastly, the other big for me is when videos have a lot of wasted time with huge introductions and a webcam pointed at a face while the guy talks. If this is matched with small windows of relevant footage it can be okay, but the order should still be reversed—the footage should take the whole screen and your face should be the small box.
It's another way to be lazy. Just set up a camera and talk into it while recording your script. It kills two dragons with one arrow. It doesn't matter how interesting you think your face might be, it's not going to help any of your points. So why are you making a video? If you want it to be more like a presentation at a conference, then record your audio with some slides. Or don't have any visuals at all and go for a podcast format instead—and make sure to account for that and describe what you mean far better since there are no visual examples.
Oh, and you need to be at least average at playing games in order to review them.
2) Do you take any physical notes whenever you're playing something that you're planning to make a review on during the very first playthrough? Thanks a lot! (I'm trying to ask things which are less complicated this month compared to the previous ones since I feel guilty to overwhelm you with my long-ass questions, lol.)
Someone asked something similar above—I think it was one of the first questions. It's also been asked at least once prior to this. It's not a bad question but I can't say too much new about it.
I take a lot of notes while I play games, even on first playthroughs. In the past I tried to not do that and just focus on playing the game for the first run but there would always be observations that I felt were important enough to make a note of. My memory isn't the best so I can't relax until I've written it down. There have been a few story ideas lost forever because I thought I'd remember it.
These notes often become the framework of the script. Ironically, by writing them down I usually remember them. There must be some psychological reason for that quirk but I don't know it.
I've gone through a few notebooks on games now. The first video on Fallout 4 was the most excessive. I tried to go for timestamps of things that happened but it didn't work out that well because shadowplay dates things in a strange way. Maybe OBS does that better?
I have very poor penmanship so my notes are likely illegible to anyone but me. They're not well kept books either. Lots of drink stains and torn pages when my kid gets a hold of them. For Prey and Hollow Knight he tore quite a few out and I had to keep them in a loose stack. It's alright though. No real harm.
So yep. Lots of notes. I always have a text file open too if I think of anything while out of the game so I can type it instead. This usually becomes the script file later.
David S asked:
I'll just give you 2 because i choose to and there is nothing you can do about it. (Also i have trouble with making linebreaks on this patreon comment thing.)
- If you had the power to erase all memory of a game to experience it again with a fresh mind, or to experience something else without context of the chosen game, what memory would you erase?
- If you have played the game, what is your opinion on the Alien-Rulers from XCOM2?
Hello David. I think you need to do shift+enter for linebreaks on patreon's comment box. It's a bit archaic.
1—Cool question. I jumped to a few games as answers and then I had to stop and think about it. Basically the question is: what games were amazing to play blind for the first time? Or with a fair amount of ignorance? That can help a lot when it comes to enjoying a game.
Of course my mind immediately went to my favorites: Dark Souls, Furi, Metal Gear, at least one Zelda, Shadow of the Colossus, and on and on it goes.
But it's more interesting to realize the limitations of the question. Games really do age. Not just in terms of graphics and gameplay, but also more permanent, tangible changes. For instance, if this question was "go back in time with no memory of the game to play it at any point" then this would hands down, no contest, no hesitation whatsoever, be World of Warcraft at vanilla. Vanilla was not the best time in WoW's history but that was the most enthralling it ever was for me as a game and a world.
World of Warcraft really was a world at launch. With so much to do and very few resources for guiding your way. Everything you acquired felt earned. Crafting felt important. Everything I did felt substantial and important and peeling back part of this mystery. Leveling was difficult so all the classes felt like their own separate journeys and perspectives, which was compounded by the different races and starting zones. And places on the map that you could risk exploring but really shouldn't, because they were owned by the opposing faction. Or full of dangerous elites. Dungeons were found in the world. Riding the flight points made it all feel so real. Same for the ferry boats. It was tedious sometimes and I'd hate to go back to it now, today, with all I know already, but back then? Fuck World of Warcraft rightfully earned all the attention it got back then. What a game.
Erasing my memory of it today would leave me playing the new version of WoW, which is better in many ways but it's a lot more standard and sterile—not always a bad thing. But that's not the result I want. It's not taking advantage of this mind wipe you're offering me.
So as boring as it sounds, I think it has to be a Souls, which means Dark Souls. Or even fucking Hollow Knight. It has to be something more recent, unchanged, and not too old. Even something as seemingly timeless as Chrono Trigger would be a bad choice because I think I only enjoy that today due to nostalgia. Although it would be a great experiment to find out if that's true.
To answer the other perspective of your question—to erase a game so there's no comparing it to others—I might go with Factorio. That game has ruined a lot of these builder sim-types for me since I now have an expectation of automating repetitive tasks that just doesn't happen. It's a bit frustrating and hurts games. Even something like Stardew Valley.
Prey and SOMA would be good thematic fits though, yeah?
2) If you have played the game, what is your opinion on the Alien-Rulers from XCOM2?
I haven't sorry, so I can't answer this. Is there something specific about them that makes them worthy of discussion? I just did a google image search and they look cool.
Keaton S asked:
Hey Joseph, I love your content to death.
- What are your opinions on the Halo games?
- Do you think the next Tomb Raider will have fixed the problems with the last two?
Hey Keaton. Thanks!
1—I've played the first three. Halo 1 is my favorite. Halo 3 probably has a better campaign but I played the multiplayer in the first one a ton. PC only. Lots of Blood Gulch and that's the only map I remember. Pistol with scope was overpowered. The noob tube alien weapon was bullshit. Great game.
I don't remember Halo 2 much. Halo 3 was about to come out and it slipped my mind—my 360 was still new. I suddenly wanted to play it right at launch day so I got a copy of Halo 2, played through it just so I knew the context of the third game (because you know that's SO important for Halo). I went to a midnight release for it and it was okay. Hype can get to you like that. A friend of mine helped with that since he was into the games.
Some people have compared my bounty hunter character in my science fiction series to Master Chief. It's not helped that he has an AI companion but the story is very different. This wasn't intentional but things do seep in without your control—some of the star systems in that series have video game names though and that was intentional.
Despite all that I don't find the stories in Halo to be all that good. I think it has some decent characters and settings. The cinematic trailer for the third game is awesome. The main theme is great and for the time, each game was visually impressive. The core gameplay loop in the first game also changed FPS games forever and that deserves some respect. It's more arcade-like than Call of Duty but not as ridiculous as Doom and its sisters. It's a stable middle-ground and I wish we had games that did more with it.
The guns are mostly satisfying—except some of the wet noodle alien weapons. This is fixed in Halo 3 though. There's a good cycle of variety from new encounters, shooting, vehicle sections, setpieces, and some half-bosses. I'm realizing now my memory of the third game is a bit hazy too. The first one has parts that stick out more. Probably because I played it more than once.
Are the new ones worth playing? I heard good things about Reach and I think most people were positive about Halo 4, although not overly so.
2) Do you think the next Tomb Raider will have fixed the problems with the last two?
Let's start by identifying the problems. Broadly speaking:
Combat is standard third person shooting with no real unique elements outside of the occasional bit of interactable environment. The only thing else that's worth speaking about is the "explore an area and then fight in it later now that you know it" bit that it only does once at the beginning.
The tombs are inspired but short. How they function now should be the first of at least three stages of progression on a concept that expands in complexity and challenge. Similar to how a Mario level will introduce a concept and then build on it.
The story is nonsense. Despite some good characters, great voice acting, and decent enough dialogue, none of it makes sense and it feels tacked on. It was done out of obligation and, if that's the thought process behind it, it should remain as context—nothing more. Background noise to justify the gameplay that you're going through. That isn't going to happen though.
So Lara is the star of the show. You don't make a Tomb Raider game without her. From there we know that there has to be some focus on narrative. To fix the story problems of the previous games, you need the game director to also be an accomplished writer or be willing to work closely with one who has the authority to push for changes in gameplay.
If the story is going to be set in a desert, then maybe sand can play some sort of role. Use the setting. Sand dune ambushes. Sand bags on arrows to shoot and pour out to weigh down pressure plates. Ruins that also fit the theme.
If Lara will be returning to past areas, make the story suit that. If there will be more freedom in exploration, that also needs to match.
Following that, core gameplay needs a hook. Either great enemy variety or some complexity on the player's end to standout—preferably both. Lara can become much more resourceful and use the environment in interesting ways to combat tough enemies. Or combat can be all about the bow and different types of arrows and how the levels respond to them. Or there has to be a much more interesting shooting and healing system. Lara is decently acrobatic so something involving that kind of thing with shooting might be best.
Finally there are the tombs that should be mandatory. Link them to the story—the game is called Tomb Raider. If you're going for an open world then they need to have some sort of scaling difficulty and tie into the story in a non-linear, flexible way. If not, make them linear and have them build on prior concepts that are introduced.
It's unclear to me whether the state of the series is due to a lack of attention and creativity, or a decision to commit most of the game's budget toward visuals, setpieces, and some cinematic moments. The games are good. They could be great or even better than that. But maybe they don't want to bother with the trouble and, instead, want to make something a lot safer and flashier. Something that will sell decently well, isn't risky in the slightest, and appeals to the most amount of people. Most won't care about the things I spoke about above, I think.
So maybe to them the series is already a smash success for what they want to do.
John T asked:
Hey man, hope things are well.
- If you had to change how one (fairly significant) historical event is remembered, what would it be and why? To clarify, you aren't actually changing the event, basically, you're just rewriting the history books and changing what people remember/care about.
- What is/was your favorite science based subject (Chemistry, Physics, Biology, etc.). I enjoy almost all sciences to some degree so it's always nice to hear other peoples opinions.
- Yes or no, do you cook at all? If yes, what do you like to make? If no, why not?
- (Short) Have you ever listened to any of Kendrick Lamar's music? Thanks for taking the time to do this, love your stuff and I'm planning on picking up some of your books for a read soon.
Hey John. I'm doing okay tonight. A bit tired. I write these answers over several days so I'm not always in the same place/mood throughout the entire thing.
1—I've been thinking about this answer for a while. It actually caused me to put the Q&A on hold for a day because I wanted to give it a good response since it's a really cool question. Unfortunately I don't think I'm equipped with enough knowledge on history to match the creativity.
So instead I'll give the only answer I can think of: I would change the record of the Lunar Landing. I don't exactly know how I would do this, but the goal would be to make it even more of an impressive accomplishment and an act of all of Earth working together to make it happen. This would lead to an unprecedented level of interest in further developing exploration of space—starting with the solar system, obviously.
Essentially: the space race never ends and we all remain so fervent about reaching farther and father out there. I know enough (it's still little) about space and physics, and the potential pitfalls awaiting our species in the future, to realize how fragile we are while we remain confined to just one planet. We should be spread across the whole star system as soon as possible.
So whether that happens by changing the memory and records of the landing to show some sort of alien presence there to spark some revolution of space tech—I don't know if that would work but hey it sounds cool. Or that the flight and space walk need to be altered in some way to create a deeper sense of community on Earth, or inspire more interest in funding science.
I think people greatly undervalue it. Even those who are otherwise intelligent.
2) What is/was your favorite science based subject (Chemistry, Physics, Biology, etc.). I enjoy almost all sciences to some degree so it's always nice to hear other peoples opinions.
Hey this relates to the previous answer. That's cool.
Physics all the way. I liked all three. Chemistry was my least favorite. Biology was the easiest to understand and, initially, the most useful. Physics took longer to click with me but once it did I looked forward to those classes. I wish I had been able to stay on with that in high school and go to university for that subject instead of English. I've spoken about that in another Q&A so I won't repeat it here.
I had a very good physics teacher in high school. He ran an optional astronomy class which was, I think, the only optional extra course offered in the entire school. And it was a big school. Space interested me a lot back then—it still does but I don't stay as current with it as I'd like. I only have amateur knowledge on these subjects now which is a bit sad. Teenaged me would be disappointed. I said back then I'd love to work for anything like NASA.
Learning about physics can be surprisingly philosophical. Or maybe that's the wrong word. It makes you think about things in a different way, and forces difficult perspectives on you. Have you ever seen something ordinary recorded by a high speed camera? There's a secret, hidden world like that. We can't perceive it without those tools. Physics gets us there. It's a shame most find it boring, but I see why.
I think, maybe, that more schools should be focusing on how subjects are introduced rather than what they'll teach overall. Especially for entry-level classes. No one is going to get hooked studying formulas and seemingly worthless things. You want to grab their attention and show them that this is worth their time. Mathematics is the same way.
I wonder if that physics teacher I had is still alive. He must have been pushing 60 already when I was there. So there's a fair chance he's still trucking along. I hope so.
3) Yes or no, do you cook at all? If yes, what do you like to make? If no, why not?
I do! But not as much as I used to.
I should qualify this answer by saying that to some people, what I do wouldn't count as cooking. I follow recipes. I don't experiment. Sometimes I deviate because some ingredients wreck my stomach—I can't eat onions, for example—but mostly I am following instructions.
The most complicated things I've done are big roast turkey dinners for Christmas and Thanksgiving. And I tried roasting prime rib a few times which isn't that difficult but it's scary because it's so easy to ruin. Even if it doesn't need that much prep and seasoning. Making the little tinfoil tent is about as rough as it gets.
I enjoy making stews—beef and, lately, some chicken stuff. I'd love to try baking some bread. I've never done that before. Same for something a lot more complicated like beef wellington.
Small things can be fun to try to perfect too. It took me a few years of tweaking to be able to make movie-tier popcorn at home. A few years of very casual attempts whenever my wife and I would watch something that went well with popcorn. I think those small machines that can carbonate water so you can make your own soda are real neat too.
I wish I could cook more. When we move and get a bigger kitchen—or an actual kitchen, period, compared to how tiny our current one is—I'll probably look into more cooking projects.
4) (Short) Have you ever listened to any of Kendrick Lamar's music? Thanks for taking the time to do this, love your stuff and I'm planning on picking up some of your books for a read soon.
Only a few songs. They were alright. He seems to have a set pace that he raps to. Any song you'd recommend?
And you're very welcome! Glad you like the videos so much.
Jacob H asked:
Do you have any thoughts on the phrase "intended experience" in games analysis? It's a phrase often used, and your Little Nightmares video touched on this, but what does it actually mean? Take Dark Souls; are sorceries, summons, and other 'easy mode' choices part of the developers' intended experience? They're in the game, but most seem to think that sword-and-board is the intended experience. It feels like a really nebulous term, but still kind of an important one. It's one of game development's truly unique challenges - I think everyone has played some kind of horror game, heard a violin sting or a loud jumpscare noise, but they weren't even looking in the right direction, and the intended experience fell completely flat, because of poor assumptions on the developer's part. The flammable mill in DS2 is another example. I know this is a rather vague question, but it's been bothering me for a while; what do we mean when we (frequently) talk about intentions, and how can we know for certain what the developers intended us to do or feel? Sorry if this has been asked already. P.S. you're a good lad and we're all very proud of you.
Hi Jacob. Lots of thoughts on this topic. It's a massive one. Deserves a video one day. Deserves a book too. Probably not by me though.
Options muddy what people can perceive as intended. Some options can even make some players feel that there is no intended experience. I think this is a shallow way of looking at it. There can be multiple intended experiences, right? Especially if solutions and paths in games are all scripted. They're all intended, one way or another.
There can be happy accidents though.
This may sound like a difficult thing to develop and create, but it's actually one of the strengths of the medium. Your example of a horror game missing the mark with a scary moment is true, but it can also go the other way. You can never be sure if you're seeing or hearing something that's supposed to scare you. A monster can appear without a big strong chord of music to announce it. Things can sneak up on you, or you may start asking yourself: did I really just see that, or was it only my imagination?
I think that difficulty is tied closely to intended experiences. Games that have baked their options into the game have been celebrated lately—hey there's no hard, normal, or easy modes! You get to decide that yourself with choices within the game! I agree that this is a cool thing to do but it also leads to a lot of arguments about intended solutions. Cheat codes are also something that are deliberately added to a game and yet everyone understands that they're not really "beating" something when they use them. Some things outside of cheat codes are on the same level as this.
Your example of the mill in DaS2 is likely something else, but I'm not sure what. Having said that, the boss its tied to... yeah, that would come under intentions. The fact that it's difficult to realize that you can burn the mill would just be poor sign posting? Conveyance? That might be too complicated. The level could have forced you to walk behind the wind mill blades with a path there and had them dripping in oil, or already have one of them on fire, etc. So many things. It's fun to think of solutions like that.
Ultimately I do think that devs do have an intended idea in their heads for most things, and that they might even be disappointed when some players miss it. Embracing creativity is more interesting to me, but that gets into the discussion of linear games vs non-linear. Both can be great. Lately I think I've been mostly interested in a mix of the two instead of a commitment to an extreme.
And thank you for the nice comment at the end!
Patrick S asked:
- I'm not sure if you've answered this already, but what's your favorite tutorial/introduction area in any game, and what about it makes it such a good introduction.
- What's your favorite example of a game that doesn't have a gripping/good introduction but manages to create a compelling experience anyways
Hello Patrick! Hope you're doing well today.
1—The standard answers you'll get are Dark Souls 1 and Mega Man X. The asylum is great: it teaches so much without stopping you in place to lecture, and has a cool experience moment when you realize you really do have to fight and kill the big demon before proceeding. Mega Man X, of course, was famously dissected by Egoraptor in Sequelitis. Which I'm going to safely guess you've seen if you're reading this.
Outside of that, I'll go with two big things that I look for. Either something that is as hands off as possible so you can take things at your own pace the first time or skip it all your second time (replayability is important to me), or a powerful moment that cements your decision to continue playing.
Yoshi's Island has the first type, if I remember right. You can fly through the tutorial level and skip all of the helper boxes and get to playing. Or you can take it slow and experiment with all of the moves that the boxes teach you. It works for different types of players. It's also helped by the unusual health system in that game.
World of Warcraft has the other type, although maybe not anymore since the game is no longer new. The game holds your hand a bit but takes its time giving you abilities and options. So it doesn't qualify for the first type in my eyes. What it does do is keep you confined in an area that feels large enough, before sending you out into a huge world where the scale of everything comes together. This is especially true with the night elf starting zone, but I'd say the cities for the other races also do this.
Breath of the Wild is similar. It's the best beginning of any Zelda game by far. Way better than any other 3D Zelda.
Speaking of Breath of the Wild, it's weird when some games have their best parts right at the start. I'm not sure if BotW is exactly that, but I think the best area in Bloodborne is the first one. Not including DLC. I wonder how that happens? It's the most layered, arguably the most complex (only Nightmare Frontier rivals it, imo) and yet it's the first one. How did that happen?
I should also mention Deus Ex as having a great opening level. You're thrown into a situation right from the start—before you make it to your home base. And it serves as a great way of introducing you to all of the ways it works. Most of them optional.
Strange to remember that it also has an optional tutorial on top of that, which you can select in the main menu. "Training". Another good way to do it, if most people wouldn't skip it.
2) What's your favorite example of a game that doesn't have a gripping/good introduction but manages to create a compelling experience anyways
Ooo, tough question! Let me think. I'll have to go through some of my top games and see.
Here's the list I made a few Q&A's back:
- Chrono Trigger
- Final Fantasy 6
- A Link to the Past
- Majora's Mask
- Half-Life 2
- Portal (1 or 2, I can't decide)
- Shadow of the Colossus
- Dark Souls 1 or Bloodborne (can't decide)
- Super Mario Galaxy
- Fallout New Vegas
- Deus Ex
- Dungeon Keeper
- Furi
- World of Warcraft
- Goldeneye 64
- Devil May Cry
- Metal Gear Solid
- Yoshi's Island
- Mega Man X (can't decide on 1, 2, or 3)
- Civilization IV
- The Last of Us
- Baldur's Gate 2 (maybe Planescape. I'd have to replay)
- Mass Effect 2
- Donkey Kong Country (can't decide 1 or 2)
- Smash Bros Melee
- Total Annihilation
- Banjo Kazooie
- Don't Starve
- Pokemon Silver
- SOMA (solely because I can't think of a better video game story)
From opposite ends of the list: both Chrono Trigger and SOMA open with the main characters sleeping. It's not all that interesting and, directly after this, it's a slow start with not much happening. Both of these games go on to have some of my favorite stories in all of gaming. Funny that.
Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice has a similar dragging start that has you unable to move the main character for what felt like a solid five minutes. It looks great. Sounds great. But many will be bored. I ended up liking it though.
Hollow Knight and Factorio both open at a glacial pace. Especially Factorio. Going back to restart in those games makes me reconsider my decision because of how long they take to go from the simplicity of the early game, to the potential of the endgame.
Half-Life 1's opening tram ride has always been boring to me. I think even on my first playthrough it was boring. Then you walk through a research lab with unskippable conversations and waiting. Not a good opening. Half-Life 2 does this a bit better at the start but still not great.
Conversely The Last of Us opens with a lot of story and hardly any gameplay for longer than most games, and yet it still worked for me because the story grabbed me. So these aren't hard rules.
Oh! All of the big recent Bethesda games. That's a good one to end on because I do like most of them. Oblivion, Skyrim, Fallout 3 (this one I don't like), and Fallout 4. Unskippable, crazy long openings. These are games you mod and want to start fresh in all the time. Why do they have these bloated tutorials and long periods of waiting before you can properly control your character? To hell with that carriage scene at the beginning of Skyrim.
Nasigil asked:
- What are some other video game channels that you like on Youtube (pretty sure you mentioned Superbunnyhop somewhere before)? Would you check out their videos about the same games you are reviewing before you make your videos?
- Is there some aspect in your gamer's soul that hasn't been satisfied by any games yet? If you were to lead a team with world class talent to develop a game of your dreams, what would it look like?
Hello again Nasigil.
1—I don't have a clear answer for this one. It depends on the game. It depends on how I'm feeling about it.
Hearing some opinions on games before I start writing is unavoidable. Especially now that I have an active Discord server and a small twitter presence. I also try to be a bit more careful picking projects so I do more research and consider more games before going with one.
In theory, all my opinions should come right from me and have no outside influences. However I say that and also realize that it's limited, especially when I take longer than virtually everyone else to get my video out. What if I end up saying the same things that have been said so many times before? Or what if there's some really simple observation that I think is unique, and it ends up not being so?
The result is this strange policy I have where I don't actively go to seek out videos other creators have made but if I find myself hearing about them, I don't freak out and try to block it. After writing a script I may skim some reviews and see what the scores are to get a vague idea of what that group thinks of something, but those opinions aren't particularly worth much to me. Rightfully so too, since I don't really review things.
For long videos I definitely do avoid them. Any game that Chris Davis makes a video on, for example, I won't watch until I've played it myself. So maybe there's where the line has to be drawn. Reviews are fine. Other longform critiques are not.
I don't have a list of other channels I like readily available. For now you can check out the people I follow on twitter, or some of those in the Creator role on Discord if you've ever been there. I might have an updated list at some point.
2) Is there some aspect in your gamer's soul that hasn't been satisfied by any games yet? If you were to lead a team with world class talent to develop a game of your dreams, what would it look like?
This is two questions in one—which is fine, because there was still a three question limit for this Q&A. I don't think you intended it to be that way though, it's just that I have to answer it that way because I wouldn't necessarily make the game that my gamer's soul hasn't gotten yet.
No one has made the zombie game that I want to play. Hyper realistic, with a world you can fully interact with and explore, to simulate what an actual zombie apocalypse would be like. It shouldn't be like Minecraft, or Dead Island, or Dead State. Project Zomboid comes the closest but it's hampered heavily by its tension-destroying camera angle and never going to be finished, ever.
I think making this game would be an enormous undertaking. So much so that I wouldn't want to try it—at least, not for the first few games I'd make if I could somehow make games. It needs to be first-person. It should be mostly about planning and decision making, but with a realtime system and the ability to fight if necessary. You shouldn't be able to take down a whole horde of zombies on your own. It shouldn't have PvP. Maybe not even Co-Op but I would consider it. Primarily, it should be an engrossing single player experience.
There have been so many zombie games and it still hasn't been made.
Oh, and something like Starfox 64 still hasn't been given the royal reboot indie treatment? Come on, let's get on with that.
For your second question: if I was starting out as an indie developer with a modest budget, I would make something like A Link to the Past, or Factorio. My version of Factorio would span an entire star system with multiple planets having different conditions, resources, and trade ships needing to be built and fueled by your factories in order to link them all together. There would be an endgame planet—or maybe more than one—which would require products manufactured in space with resources from all of the basic planets. I think Factorio's core gameplay is incredible but it is limited in scope.
My "Link to the Past" game would only be from that perspective and gameplay style. So a 2D top-down game with dungeons, tools, and a world to explore. I have a 3D version of this in my head but that would require a much bigger team. Like my Starfox 64 example above, I'm shocked that more indie games haven't tried to make something like this. Maybe there's a reason? Perhaps it's all tapped out because Nintendo already did a thorough job. Even they struggled to make A Link Between World's interesting, in my opinion.
If I had a large budget and a big team then I would experiment a lot with games that have timelines. I think the idea of Majora's Mask is really compelling. So I'd take that and create different scenarios with games having resets and time limits—characters and events with schedules. But also with gameplay that's worth a damn instead of being just about a narrative. I think there are cool things you can do by embracing the looped nature of gameplay cycles—die, respawn, try again. You can punish players in far more creative ways if there's an even bigger way to reset without losing all progress underneath your typical checkpoint bash upon death.
Also I'd make something like Dark Souls. Because of course I would.
William T asked:
Will you review destiny 2? just yes/no, thanks!
Morning William. Someone asked this same question below so you may want to scroll down for a (slightly) longer answer. You asked for just a yes/no so here we are: no. I'll play it. I won't be reviewing or critiquing it.
Alex T asked:
Hey Joseph. Per usual, if I ask a question that has already been asked then just skip over it.
- Thoughts on the Metal Gear Solid series? If you've played them, which is your favorite? Least favorite?
- What are some games you enjoyed despite knowing the game itself is either bad or has massive flaws?
Hey Alex. I think these are both duplicates but I'll try to give you some new answers anyway. Apologies if I repeat something I've said in the past.
1—I've played the first four, including the Twin Snakes Gamecube remake. I haven't played any of the Peacewalker games, or Metal Gear Solid V.
I like them but only as stories, not really games. The characters are unusual enough that I find them compelling, even if they don't make a whole lot of sense. Having said that I did get deep into a European Extreme run of Metal Gear Solid 2 (added: I just mentioned this on stream) and had... well it wasn't really fun but I stuck with it. The boss fights are interesting. Definitely an experience game with what they demand of you. Psycho Mantis and Vamp are coming to mind.
The visuals are always impressive for the time that they're released. They're like games that are based on imaginary movies and I like that in some sick way.
Maybe I would enjoy them more if I was into stealth games. I've never played a stealth game that has grabbed me. I adore the concept and yet I can't think of a game that had satisfying stealth. Most people seem to agree with that and can only name one or two that worked well.
So great visuals, great music, great voice acting and the characters to go with them. Not so great gameplay but bosses make up for that a lot.
The first one is my favorite. I know many people go in for the third one but I was annoyed that I once again couldn't play as Solid Snake. The fourth one is the most batshit and y'know, after so many of the games, I could even enjoy that too. It is likely my least favorite though.
To me the series felt done after that. If I had played the Peacewalker games I might feel differently. Maybe that's why I've been stalling on playing the fifth one.
2) What are some games you enjoyed despite knowing the game itself is either bad or has massive flaws?
This is different than an outright bad game. "So bad it's good,"—it's not that. This is a good, enjoyable game that has some big mistakes that you have to overlook. That's how I'm taking the question, or else I'll repeat an answer too closely.
Most recently: Breath of the Wild has some huge problems. Bad dungeons. Bad shrines and puzzles. The world is a tad empty. And it runs poorly on the only two systems that it was designed and optimized for. Still a great game despite those problems, but you're probably sick of hearing me speak about it. Haha.
There are more games I could speak about here that I've done videos on but I don't think that would be a good answer.
Dwarf Fortress is a wonderful game that I am consistently surprised exists at all. And yet it looks like a kid's first attempt at using color chalk on a chalkboard, and has a learning curve that you would need a degree in advanced calculus in order to properly chart. After that it's more of a simulation than a game and you need a ton of creativity to fully enjoy it. If you are that person, and can look past those problems, then it may be your favorite game of all time.
New Vegas has combat that is near worthless. It adds context to the conflict you'll encounter. It's not fun to play or adds anything to the experience outside of that. I am grateful it's realtime though. I don't like the forced turnbased stuff in a lot of RPGs as their attempt at combat. It eats up so much time.
System Shock 2 is almost perfect—for the time it was released—even with a big plot hole that's never explained that I think could have been fixed fairly easily (I'm trying to be vague because of spoilers). Yet I can't ignore the ending. I probably bring this up too much but I still can't believe how quickly it all falls apart in the last twenty minutes of that game.
I think the artstyle and difficulty spikes in Stephen's Sausage Roll could be seen as huge flaws but I can't decide. Even after playing it and writing the script. It's strange to remain unsure about something after writing out thoughts. I wonder how I'll feel about it a year from now.
There are a few other games I could list here that are only guilty of being too short but that's petty. Let's leave it at this.
Alex O asked:
Hey Joseph, i'll always look forward to your videos no matter how long it takes for you to make them. Here are my hopefully easy questions to answer.
- Are there any conspiracy theories that you believe in? (Short but the most important question of all)
- Assuming you like steak how do you like it cooked (rare, medium rare etc.) Cheers.
Hey Alex. Most viewers tend to be patient. I guess they learn going in that the videos take so long!
1—I don't think so. I do know that some conspiracy theories in the past have turned out to be true—or partly true. That's a bit unsettling, but there are some really crazy ones. I think most of them can be answered by simply asking "Why would anyone want to do that?" Why would anyone go to so much effort to convince us all that the world isn't flat, and to keep its flatness a secret? To what end and goal? That sort of line of thought.
Although I've heard that the real purpose of the Flat Earth Group/Society/Thing is that it's secretly a debate club. If you can convince anyone of any point of it then you're an accomplished... arguer. Debater. You're good.
Let me google some conspiracy theories and see if there are any I can buy into a little bit.
A secret group of people in control of much of the world is somewhat plausible. But it's mostly a comforting thought if true. Instead of chaos it's controlled and, in a weird way, that makes it almost better.
The assassination of JFK may have some truth. I don't know about that. I listened to Bill Hicks rant about it a bunch and then watched a video explaining how the "magic bullet" could have actually acted the way it did. That's probably the most famous one, right?
Keanu Reeves is secretly immortal? Sure, why not.
The moon landing wasn't faked but would it be better if it had? It would explain how much everything slowed down directly afterward. We, as a species, climbed up the Civilization Tech Tree and managed to get to the moon. Then threw up our hands and went nah that's enough exploring, fuck it, good enough. Looking back at history that's so unlike us, but maybe I'm being naive. The anti-science movement has me more than a bit down if faking that achievement is a better alternative to reality.
That would mean that there must have been a real landing at some point after that. Long after that. I wonder how pissed those real astronauts must have been to not get the credit.
But the moon landing was real. Tupac is, unfortunately, dead. Avril Lavigne didn't die and wasn't replaced by a double. There are no lizard people. Obama can't control the weather. The Earth isn't hollow. Conspiracy theories are weird!
2) Assuming you like steak how do you like it cooked (rare, medium rare etc.) Cheers.
I can't remember if this has been asked before. I think it might have! Cool easy question. Thank you for it.
I like my steaks medium rare. Sometimes we'll get steaks and fry them and it can be tricky to not overcook them—especially since my wife prefers hers medium-well so I have to take them out at different times. I should make steaks again soon.
I've never barbequed before. I should try it after we move.
David S asked:
- Who is your favorite philosopher?
- What game did you like the most out of a philosophical aspect? (i.e. fallout 4's question of what it means to be human and who should be allowed to be reffered as so).
- are you planning on reviewing destiny 2, let alone play it?
Afternoon David! I don't think I have very good answers for you, sorry. I'll try though.
1—I don't have one. I took a philosophy class in university and didn't like it. Mostly because of the professor and her villainous gang of shitty teacher's assistants.
I like some of what they taught, but it's more interesting to think about rather than something I can fully commit to and use everyday. I love the quote "I have gained this from philosophy: that I do without being commanded what others do only from fear of the law." However, I don't know if that's what philosophy truly means anymore and if it's applicable in that way today. Stephen Fry speaks a bit about this in an interview that he did. It's confused a lot with an outlook on life. Something closer to a horoscope.
Plato's idea of the cave really interested me. Aristotle founded logic—which was something I didn't realize until I was in the middle of that class. Thinking back that was one of the most important things I've ever learned. It's a shame the rest of the class was so bad in comparison. After those two—and a bit of the teachings of Socrates, but it was the Socratic method that stuck with me more than anything else which I don't think is applicable to your question—my experience is limited.
Descartes and "I think therefore I am" is something that mostly everyone has heard of. At least it'll sound familiar if they've managed to remain isolated from any discussion about it—which may be for the best. It's a cool saying, along with the brain-in-a-vat theory: that no matter if everything else is an illusion, your thoughts are yours and real and proof that you exist, and so on. It's flawed in a fundamental way—if you think about anything like predetermination (which I do not believe in at all but it can't be ruled out completely) then your thoughts, which you believe are your own and are being created by you and are therefore separate from other senses and experiences that could be brain-in-a-vat illusions, are like a needle going along a record to produce music. The thoughts were already planned and can never be different or "real". You're not thinking. You're following a script.
I think it's fun to mull stuff like that over but that level of philosophy is a bit abstract. It's sort of like thinking about the existence of other dimensions. If they do exist and all other possibilities are out there, then it would follow that there should have been a dimension that could have crossed over to other dimensions and started messing with all of them. Or created some sort of cataclysm that can transcend all realities and destroy them—they are infinite afterall. So that means if there are other dimensions that it's not possible for them to interact in anyway, so what's the point of thinking about them? Unless infinite dimensions would mean that some dimensions are spared from this great cataclysm spawned from one of them—again, there are infinite possibilities. But then that should also mean there are even more cataclysms to spread around and on and on it loops and loops, until you have to question what infinity even means.
I don't know a lot about this stuff so my thoughts are a bit surface level. I should read more non-fiction. That's a flaw of mine.
2) What game did you like the most out of a philosophical aspect? (i.e. fallout 4's question of what it means to be human and who should be allowed to be reffered as so).
I'm going to take this question as a "What game made you think about life and existence the most?" I think it'll be something I can answer better that way.
It's difficult to take stories in games seriously. There have been some good characters and dialogue but very few have made strong points, or have had some substance underneath the surface. I can say that Chrono Trigger made me think about time travel a little more than, uh, Back to the Future? I guess? But it's still a children's game. It has a few cool moments but nothing too deep.
Planescape Torment's famous line "What can change the nature of a man?" is one of the earliest stories in games that I can think of that tried to have a point. It's interesting to think about, and resonates with most people because who hasn't wondered if people ever really change? I think it takes a big life event to stir true change in someone—to alter their core beliefs. Some life threatening situation to themselves or someone they care about. Some sort of shattering event on that level. As for someone's nature, it could be argued that that can never be changed. It's too fundamental and established too early.
You gave Fallout 4 as an example and yeah, it can function in that way. Probably in Far Harbor more than the base game. Both the game and DLC are missed opportunities though—they don't really make you think about the topic or force you to consider the worth of a fabricated person. In fact, through speaking to most synths, the game makes it abundantly clear that it considers them worthy and that you should too. It could been interesting, particularly with Curie, if the game had a moment that it turned that on its head and revealed that they're just mindless robots following a program after all. I think the bits involving DiMA's memory in Far Harbor explored a worthwhile idea way more than anything else. That's a bit sad considering how much the synth stuff is pushed onto you.
On this topic, I could also talk about Edith Finch and SOMA for longer than I did in the videos. I cut quite a bit of my thoughts from SOMA because I didn't want to go too far out there. It was like playing and experiencing an episode of Black Mirror. I don't know how much of it was intentional but that doesn't matter because the game doesn't talk about much of the events that happen outside of the immediate setting. There's no intention to really trample on with speculating how the consciousness copy works. It's something I still think about today, which has led to a lot more thinking on simulations and fabricated realities. It doesn't keep me up at night because I'm usually already up at night, but it helps.
Edith Finch's main point—in my opinion anyway—is a lot more grounded. It's something I think everyone, without exception, has to deal with and acknowledge at some point. We all carry baggage from whatever opinions we were soaked in growing up. That colors our perception of the world. Some are more extreme than others. Some might even be positive. But everyone has them. You'd have to be raised by wolves to avoid this happening and even then—you'd have to shake off whatever wolf-habits that you gained there.
3) are you planning on reviewing destiny 2, let alone play it?
No review, but I will play it.
I bought the game and played the beta on PC, expecting that it would be released in early September. I didn't know the PC version had a special "tax delay" so I was annoyed. A friend of mine loved the first game so I agreed to play the sequel with him since I didn't have a PS4 for the first one. If it wasn't for that I would have refunded the game and not bothered with it, since this "buy it first on console and then buy it again on PC please!" bullshit isn't cool.
I enjoyed the demo. I tried two different classes. It felt close to Halo which is to be expected. It's not a game I'm expecting to love a whole lot by itself, but it's been a while since I've been able to play something with this friend and I'd like to have something that I can do regularly that isn't a stream or a game for a video. It's been too long since I had something like that.
I hope I have enough time to make that happen. Even playing some rounds of PUBG has been tough.
Kirill O asked:
Hey Joseph! Are you still an active Dark Souls player? What are your favorite weapons to use in DS/DS2 and DS3 and why?
Hey Kirill! I'm not active in any Souls game right now. I've never been into PvP in the games either. I enjoy getting invaded but I never seek it out. It's a bit more complicated than that though. I find it hard to nail down my thoughts on PvP in Souls. It can be unfair but maybe that's the point.
I was most active with Souls about a year before I started making videos. I was trying to do No Death Runs of DaS1 and 2. I got pretty far in both games but I still wasn't all that great at them at the time. Maybe I should try again sometime. It might make a funny montage of failures.
For a long time my favorite weapon was the longsword across all games. I like the fast swing speed and that you can roll into a forward poke—I believe the moveset is a bit different after DaS1 but I'm not sure. One of them has R2 as the poke, right? Whereas another has a horizontal swipe.
In DaS2 I also liked the Heide's Knight Sword. It has some lightning damage which is quite good for that game. You can get it early and play the whole game with it, which I think is something of a flaw in all the games outside of NG+. It's more fun to pick a weapon and commit to it early, experiencing the whole game with that moveset.
Recently I did runs with some heavy weapons. I think I did a greatsword run and then an ultra greatsword in Dark Souls 3. I really enjoyed them and, despite many people saying that longswords are overpowered, I found the heavy weapons far stronger in both PvE and PvP invasions. You can make so many more mistakes since when you trade hits you do so much more damage. Not sure why the community thinks the faster weapons are so much better. Maybe it's something tied to experience and knowledge with the enemies and bosses. Could it have been harder like that the first time through?
I've never done a magic run outside of Dark Souls 1. Not a fun time. Like I said in the video, magic turns DaS1 into a third-person shooter in a world where you're the only one with a gun.
I'd like more creative weapons in Souls going forward. Trick weapons in Bloodborne are so much more interesting.
Joseph N asked:
Hi Joseph, Long time viewer first time question asker,
- When you read a book do you have a "narrator" in your head? I've heard this before and I was curious if you had this too.
- This isn't a question but I want to say that I really respect how you tackle a project and that is why I watch you over other YouTubers. For example, I think the way you are going about the witcher series is the best way to handle that series and that doing multiple play throughs of one game does so much in making your thoughts valuable as you have done your hard work and research. I think the idea of hard work in reviews is becoming lost today and I wanted to say this as I want to show that I enjoy and respect your style of your vids and that is why I return to your channel. Just thought I'd let you know why I watch you over other people. Thanks ahead of time for your answers.
Hi fellow Joseph. Thanks for your first round of question(s)!
1—Yep! I think everyone does, right? Maybe this is something I just assume happens? You can have an internal monologue in your head. Speaking without making the sounds, almost. That's different than a narrator in a book but there are some similarities.
Every writer has a voice and that's what comes through. Particularly gifted writers can change this between characters and books, and not just when changing from third to first person perspectives. I'm reading Gone Girl at the moment and it's done wonderfully when switching between the two main characters Amy and Nick. And there's another shift later on that's even better. It changes how you're hearing the story in your head as you read the words.
I think this can only happen if you're immersed in the reading. That semi-magical experience when you're going through words, sentences, paragraphs—entire pages—without realizing. Sometimes even turning pages while barely remembering doing so! If you can't get that way with a book then I'd say that's a sign of some sort of failure: with the book itself or the current conditions you're in. You can't enter that automatic reading mode where your mind takes over and translates it through the tone of the story's narrator.
I'll end here by asking anyone reading this: am I wrong about an internal voice being common? I know it can't be rare because I've discussed it before. But I've just assumed near everyone did this.
2) This isn't a question but I want to say that I really respect how you tackle a project and that is why I watch you over other YouTubers. For example, I think the way you are going about the witcher series is the best way to handle that series and that doing multiple play throughs of one game does so much in making your thoughts valuable as you have done your hard work and research. I think the idea of hard work in reviews is becoming lost today and I wanted to say this as I want to show that I enjoy and respect your style of your vids and that is why I return to your channel. Just thought I'd let you know why I watch you over other people. Thanks ahead of time for your answers.
Oh I was all ready to dive into another answer, haha. Well, thank you! That's all I can say really. I try very hard to make the videos worth the viewer's time and it's been mindblowing how well the response to them has been. I think there are a few more of us out there now that are putting a lot of effort into video game content on YouTube. I hope that the trend continues and, if more talent continues to arrive, that I can keep up with them. Video game criticism is unfortunately still in its infancy—a big delay as far as I'm concerned. Probably because you need visual examples to properly discuss it since so many points require examples, and that wasn't easy to do until fairly recently.
I hope you like the upcoming videos and the ones on Witcher especially. It's a series that deserves the attention.
Sean M asked:
- As you've played games over time, has the way you value the length of a game changed? E.g. Personally, I used to value hours per dollar a lot more than I do, but having spent a lot of time gaming, I now rather value quality of experience per hour - long playtimes are actually a negative.
- How much do you care about being spoiled about games? How much of your enjoyment comes from being surprised, either by plot or by mechanics?
Hello Sean. Looks like you're the last set for this Q&A.
1—Definitely. I think I'm right there with you with the same change, too.
It'll depend on the genre of course, but my minimum hours for the price has gone down in favor of a more quality experience. Having said that, I do wish most games with good gameplay aimed more for 8 hours instead of 4. Most recently: Ruiner, Furi, and Cuphead were slightly too short for what they had made. In terms of cost that becomes a bit more difficult to determine though.
I view things more in regards to how much mileage I think could have been gotten out of the gameplay and, more rarely, the story. So whether the game is 5, 20, or over a 100 hours long, I try to think if it overstayed its welcome with new gameplay or if there could have been a lot more ways to mix it up. Games rarely nail this but that's okay. I think I would prefer something be cut a bit short before it becomes stale. But much of this problem could be avoided if games were willing to become more risky and outlandish toward the end of them—or in an optional endgame stretch where many mechanics can be expanded on for players who want to go that far. Recent 3D Mario games have been good for this.
Longer games tend to become grindy and repetitive. Shorter games don't get creative enough. Stories can be interesting in this way though. Most games don't have stories that are paced well at all—or any sign that they were added with a high amount of care. But there have been a few, like Owlboy, that made me wish they kept going. The story hits a high point which could lead to an interesting final act and, instead, the game is done and the credits are rolling. Little Nightmares was another example of this for me.
For some this will be a problem of development costs. For other games I wonder if it's difficult to match the length of a full story with a series of fresh gameplay mechanics and variety all the way through.
I don't think I can fully agree that long playtimes are a negative—they usually are, yes—but I think some games can still use them. I hope that Nier Automata is one of them. Open world games are also becoming boring for this reason. Even Breath of the Wild outstays its welcome. I wonder if more people will realize that when they return to the game later in the year to finally finish it with the new DLC.
This discussion could also be linked to games that try to be addictive with a grind and drip rewards. But that's a whole other thing.
2) How much do you care about being spoiled about games? How much of your enjoyment comes from being surprised, either by plot or by mechanics?
I'm not quite as concerned with spoilers as I used to be but I still try to avoid them. I try to put myself into the mind of the creator for this type of thing: you can clearly see how there's a build up to a reveal in the story or a cool new enemy or boss. And seeing it already in a trailer or on a forum ruins all that tension and reveal. It's not vital to the experience but stuff like... the introduction to the Gaping Dragon, or even how many bosses/levels are left in a big game with exploration. You're cheating yourself out of some of the enjoyment and mystery which, I think, can make you judge a game less favorably.
These things are hard to measure and acknowledge but think of a boss with really cool music that you're enjoying without realizing for a few attempts—or maybe not even until you play the game again and consciously hear it now that you're not so focused on the fight itself. Or some crazy, intimidating new enemy type that has an explosive arrival in the game and grabs your attention. Those are arguably some of the most important moments in some games. You're not doing yourself or the developers any favors by spoiling it.
What's strange is that I'm noticing a new trend of trailers being separate content. Prey's trailer was like that in some ways. In fact I think watching Prey's trailer helps build up the introduction in that game. Movies are sometimes attempting to be vague or even misleading in their trailers. I like that, but it's also something I can't rely on happening so I try to avoid them unless I need to see the trailer to determine if I should put the game on a list of things I should check out.
I do think gameplay can be spoiled in some ways by watching someone else play. There may be some cool tricks to learn on your own—realizations that you can do certain things. Or maybe the appearance of a character that you're now waiting to show up for the rest of the game. This happens less to me lately so either I'm not paying as much attention anymore, or maybe I've made some subconscious decision to only partly commit parts of trailers to memory. That'd be a cool trick to have.
What's more likely is that I'm just getting older and my memory isn't as sharp as it used to be.
--
That's it! The next prompt should be up in a day or two.