Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

 

Introduction


Hello again everyone. Shorter introduction this time since we'll be jumping right to the questions. The format is the same as last time. A few people got some shorter answers because I don't want to bullshit the length of some just for the sake of it. If you want some more depth next time try to think of some broader topics, with maybe a specific thing about it that I can dig into. I feel bad when some people get multiple pages and then someone else only gets a few paragraphs.

Also apologies that this is so late. I think we're still within a month since the questions went up so I'm still in the minimum time but I do want these to be up faster. Baby is keeping me busy. The next Question prompt should be up in about a week.

Thank you again for everyone who took part in this.



Riccardo B asked:

  1. Favourite vacation locations? Archetypes are fine (like sea/snow mountains), also either lived or dreamed about.
  2. Favourite time of year?
  3. Favourite animal?

Hey again Riccardo. Fun questions.

1--So many! I've been to a fair amount of countries—most of the United Kingdom, France, Spain, Canada, and the United States. I was young for most of the trips though. I used to live in Britain so these trips to Europe weren't extravagant or anything. A trip to the US from Canada wasn't a big deal back then either after we moved here.

France was kind of shitty in the cities but some of those cathedrals are something everyone should experience in person at some point in their life. Or at least some building like it. The sense of scale when you're in one of those lives up to the word "awesome". It makes you not want to waste the word on lesser things after that. But you still do because it's been diluted so much by now.

I'd like to go back there with my wife. I was so young the first time. That would be part of a larger trip through Europe. There are so many cities and places I'd like to go. Greece and Italy are near the top of the list. But I've also never been to Ireland despite spending so much time in Wales, Scotland, and a little bit in England. Generally any place with a lot of water and rolling fields is something I'd like to see.

There are some places within Canada I'd like to go. The US as well. Anything like this:

https://crmr.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/img-banner8.jpg

https://c1.staticflickr.com/9/8170/8037284730_01fed4d46c_b.jpg

(just googled real quick for those)

Visiting Alaska appeals to me but I don't think I'd like to stay. I like colder climates but living somewhere that cold might be pushing it. But then the stereotypical choice of seeing the Pyramids appeals to me just as much so who knows. Traveling is so expensive but it's also romantic and exciting. The big, never-going-to-happen dream would be some sort of train-based tour through a lot of places, where you're on the train so long between countries that it's like a cruise-on-rails where you have your own room to sleep in. I love trains too. Any game with a train level gains extra points from me.


2) Favourite time of year?

Here in Canada it's the transition seasons. Autumn and Spring are great temperatures—never too hot or too cold. I love thunderstorms and we get a lot of them in Toronto during these seasons. The city looks great when all of the leaves are browning, and same for Spring when everything is growing back after Winter.

I love the snow. Winter would be my favorite season if it wasn't for all of the ice that comes with it. Plus the streets get all slushy and polluted from all of the cars. It doesn't stay that serene white for long. I actually got into a bit of trouble with the ice when Nioh came out recently. There was a huge rainstorm while I was out at the mall (the local place didn't have the game) and all of the water froze on the streets really suddenly. I've never seen anything like it before and I've been in Canada for a long time now. You couldn't really see the ice on the streets but it was so widespread that entire sidewalks were slippery for whole blocks. I took the bus home and I had to stand at the stop, not in the shelter, because the ice was so bad I didn't think I'd make it from the shelter to the stop in time after seeing the bus.

Saw a lot of people fall. It was really bad.

For some more specific times of year: Halloween is great. I'm looking forward to when our boys get older to take them out. Same for Christmas. The oldest didn't understand what was happening last time. I know it's a cliche but Christmas is so wonderful when you're a kid. I want to make sure our kids have the same experience.


3) Favourite animal?

Dog. Easy answer. We have two. All my life I wanted a dog. My parents kept giving me endless excuses for why we couldn't get one instead of saying no outright. We'd be moving soon, or I wasn't old enough, or I wouldn't like it as much as I thought, etc, etc, on and on, with how bad having a dog would really be.

I moved out at 19 and got a dog my first year. My wife has one now too. One of the best decisions we ever made. Border Collie and an Aussie Shepherd. Great dogs. The Collie is smart as hell. The Aussie is a bit derpy but she's adorable.

For some more exotic answers: bears and wolves. There's something noble about them, even though they're likely far from it in reality. Lots of wildlife really does fascinate me though. I used to spend a lot of time watching nature documentaries. You get to see a lot of the almost-alien looking places on Earth in some of them too. I wish I had more time to get into them again.

Oh I also went through a dinosaur phase like every other kid that grew up with Jurassic Park. But I think that's cheating by stretching your question. It still blows my mind that they're considered to have feathers now.



Chris H asked:

Quick side note before I ask you my questions: I absolutely love everything that you have done for this channel so far. Your analysis brings up points that I would have never even thought about and you mix that in with the perfect amount of humor that add a nice breather to your discussions. I'm always excited to see anything and everything you post and enjoy rewatching your stuff. Also, I feel as though I should let you know that I just bought Catch-22 per your suggestion and I am going to start reading it when I finish writing this. Anyways, just thought I should remind you once again that what you do is fantastic and I just get hyped seeing your stuff. On to the questions:

  1. Would you ever do a video on a video game that was based on a book? For example, Metro 2033 was a game that was adapted from the novel of the same name. It has some major differences in the adaptation that made it more suitable for playing, but still conveyed the same kind of story/message. On the flipside would be The Witcher where the developers kept as close to the source material as they could and, when they ran out, try to extrapolate everything from there.
  2. Would you ever consider outsourcing some of your work? Like hiring an editor or an audio engineer?
  3. What is your biggest pet peeve? Both in video games and real life.


Hey Chris. Thanks a lot! I try very hard to keep a balance with humor. The channel should be mostly serious, so I end up cutting a lot of stupid jokes. Which might be a good thing in more ways than one because my sense of humor can be juvenile. And punny. Let me know what you think about Catch-22. Shoot me a private message here or mention it in the next Q&A if you're going to be taking part in that.

1—I think I already knew about Metro 2033 being based on a book but I had forgotten it. Written in Russian. Released in 2005? More recent than I would have guessed. I liked what I played of that series. I suppose I should read the books when I do those games. I think it'll add some good points.

And that sort of answers your question. I don't think there are many video game adaptations of books, but that makes it very appealing to me. You can make some comparisons and debate whether they stayed true to the source material, or if the deviations they did make were worth it. Thinking about it now, I wonder if it's better to go from Book-to-Game, rather than Movie-to-Game. Ideas come a lot more clearly through books, with a lot more depth and nuance. Games are sort of in between since they don't have rigid runtimes and have the freedom to explore things more than movies, but movies are more focused. You can't really watch a movie wrong, unless you fastforward. But you can play a game wrong. You can read a book wrong too

I also wonder if the visuals in a movie dictate too much about what a game can do. There's already this visual experience people expect. Even down to some video game adaptations using the same actors as models in the game, often with uncanny valley results. This is fun to think about. I've also done it to my own books if we're being totally, embarrassingly honest. My books have "fight scenes" and I wrote some of the plots in a way that I think could translate to a game particularly well. Especially Burke's power armor in Bounty Hunter. I miss writing those stories a lot. I hope I can get back to it by the end of the year.

Anyway, we'll soon see how this ends up with the video(s) on The Witcher series. Maybe reading the books won't add as much as I expect. Or maybe it'll make them a lot better. I'm really curious. Those videos are still a ways off if anyone is wondering. I'll be speaking about it in the 100k subscriber video that should come after Zelda. Having the second baby ended up being far more disruptive than I thought.


2) Would you ever consider outsourcing some of your work? Like hiring an editor or an audio engineer?

Yes and no. Just like the answers last time, I really hate to say stuff like this because this is Patreon and you guys are all giving me money but I really can't afford it. Editors for writing have rates so high that it would be like entering a partnership with someone. I'm going to guess that video editing would cost even more.

I've had a few offers to help with audio for free but I don't like that for two reasons—I don't think people SHOULD work for free. And if I'm not paying them then I would feel like I couldn't ask them to do a lot of work or make a deadline for a video. I know that there's a lot of time between videos but I actually work very quickly. Waiting for someone else to finish the audio would kill any momentum I had in a project.

That said, audio is the one area that I would be happy doing this in the future, but only once I can afford it so I can discuss deadlines with whoever the engineer is. Editing audio is the only part of this job that I'm beginning to hate. It's so time consuming and I end up loathing the sound of my own voice partway through, which deadens a lot of my confidence when it comes to recording audio for the next video. I'm also pretty bad at it too so having someone who knows what they're doing would go a long way. I've gotten a LOT better, but it's still not good enough.

There's also some other one-time work I'd be interested in getting done but I'm too busy playing catch-up with projects to investigate right now. The channel needs a new logo. I'd like custom thumbnails for almost all of my videos. Depending on how much it cost, I would like to hire an animator for specific parts in a video that I think would benefit from some more fancy visual examples.

My guess is that this would be expensive. It's looking likely that I'll be releasing my books in a physical format myself soon and I'd like to commission some covers for them—my current covers are from stock images that I made myself because, like a professional editor, they would have cost too much money otherwise. Cover art can range from a few hundred dollars to close to two thousand. So my guess is that hiring someone to regularly do this sort of thing is years in the future, if ever.


3) What is your biggest pet peeve? Both in video games and real life.

First let's decide what "pet peeve" means. To me, it's like a Seinfeld Problem. A pet peeve is something that irritates you, but it's ultimately unimportant. It's still infuriating—like someone chewing with their mouth open—but isn't a huge thing antagonizing the world like, say, racism.

Does that make sense?

My biggest pet peeve are people who are unaware that other people exist. This sounds broad so here are some examples: two people standing in the middle of the aisle in the supermarket having a 20 minute conversation during which no one can pass. People smoking outside the entrance of a restaurant/hospital so you have to walk through to go in.

When my wife and I go out with the kids we're like a roaming caravan tribe now with our big ass stroller for both kids. And I am constantly looking around, like a dog hearing a new noise, for people who might want to pass us. Because we take up the whole sidewalk. There are so many people who are oblivious to us and other groups. They stand in the way and don't let us pass. Or stay in a crowd at a bus stop or at a street crossing. They don't give a fuck. I notice this stuff all the time since becoming a father because it's not just me and my two feet anymore. We took the new baby to the doctor and one of the big two telecommunication companies were doing work on the street, and they decided to just drive up and park in the middle of the sidewalk. So fuck us and our stroller on the way to the * doctor * I guess.

I know I'm ranting and I hope it's at least a little amusing but fuck it makes me mad. Your time is not more important than anyone else's. Let people get OFF the subway car before you try to get ON. If you're retired and you still do your shopping on the weekend when the place is at its busiest then you're an asshole. Don't let your kids stampede freely up and down the hall in an apartment building. And don't give me stinkeye when I ask them nicely not to do it anymore. Other people have kids trying to sleep. Or dogs that freak out when they hear stuff like that. Or hell, some people work nights and are asleep during the day.

For video games it's inventory management. Or specifically, strict limits on inventory when the game isn't built around it. Loot in Diablo 3, items in Stardew Valley, weight limits in Skyrim and almost every other open world game. If you're trying to be realistic then it has to be realistic. If you have a limitation for the sake of challenge—say, healing items that take up a lot of space—then that's fine as long as you're successful with it. But if the game has a limit for no reason other than to send me to my home base then it's padding that's wasting my time. This will be a future video because it bothers me so much. Imagine a game that doesn't have this limitation. Now ADD it. Think of any game ever. Does it make ANY of them better? Chances are high that the answer is no.

I hate it so much.



Teostra asked:

Just recently upped my pledge from 2$ to 6$ because I freakin love your videos Joseph. Here are my 3 Questions for the next Q&A:

  1. Your 3 favorite Bands/Musicians/Singers?
  2. A statement and a question in one: I read your response to a question about Monster Hunter. You should definitly give it another chance. The controls are actually not that bad once you get the hang of it and it`s my favorite franchise besides the souls-series. I love it for the same reason I love the from software games: it`s combat. It has kinda slow attack-animations and this "punch" to it that makes it really satisfying to play. And it also has a lot of depth with it`s 13 different weapon types and different armor-sets and skills. I played the MH-Series for over 1000 hours by now because it`s such an addiciting concept. Now my question: Would you do an review, or something like this, of MH4U or MHGenerations if you like it?
  3. Did you actually study literature? Well... since you`re writing books and stuff ;) as already mentioned I really love your stuff and keep up the good work. I think my money is in good hands ;)


Morning Teostra. Thanks so much! I hope my answers are worth it.

1—That's a tough one. To narrow is down that much.

I don't listen to much music since I committed a lot of time to the channel. I can't have it on in the background anymore since it'll be picked up in the recording of the games. My wife plays a lot of pop music on her laptop so that isn't picked up by my computer recording. It's mostly catchy stuff that's shitty but I like it. Anything with an infectious beat or chorus and I'm good. I have horrible taste for that. I'm too easy.

My embarrassing "early teens" band was Linkin Park. I don't think I understood why so many people liked music until then. After that I used the tv like a radio to watch MTV, VH1, and probably another channel or two that I'm forgetting. Rock music wasn't popular where I grew up—which probably sounds fucking weird to you but it was a small city in Britain—so I thought I was so damn cool for having this alternative taste that was so mainstream in the US and Canada, haha.

I was big into Tool a few years later. I know that carries a lot of pretentiousness with it but I was never a mega fan who analyzed their songs and thought I was hot shit for liking them—I got over that early on with music. I still like their songs and they're probably the most important band in my life for how much I've listened to them. Lateralus is my favorite album by them. 10,000 days is alright but I like it mostly for the joke that it was also their announcement for how long it'll be until their next album.

If I don't want to have a big conversation about it, I tell people my favorite song is Bohemian Rhapsody by Queen. In reality it's a song by a more obscure band: Arriving Somewhere But Not Here by Porcupine Tree. Sort of similar to Tool. Maybe even more pretentious, I have no idea. I'm not big into music like I am into games, movies, or books. And I like that a lot. You can ruin your enjoyment of some things by analyzing them. Porcupine Tree has a lot of great songs but they're very long. And there are some bloated stinkers on some albums too. Some of them sound too similar but when they hit something good I don't think there's anything else I enjoy more.

More recently, my favorite current band is Twenty One Pilots. Holding Onto You is probably the best song I've heard in the past five years. The only other ones that compete with it are Hero by Elizaveta, Flesh Without Blood by Grimes, or Which Witch by Florence and the Machine. Twenty One Pilots has a ton of other songs that I love though which I can't say for those others, although they have some good stuff too. I can listen to the entirety of Vessel by Twenty One Pilots and enjoy the whole thing. And I can mostly say the same for Blurryface. Lane Boy is fantastic.


2) Would you do a review, or something like this, of MH4U or MHGenerations if you like it?

The problem with the controls I had were using the touchscreen as a camera. It was only the demo I tried and it was right after I got my 3DS years ago for Pokemon X. I remember it being so awkward. I know there's an extension thing now with another stick for the camera. Does that work with Monster Hunter? I also have a Wii U now so I should pick them up.

If I like them, and I think I will, then I'll definitely do a video on them at some point. I can't say when but that's not the only Wii U game I'd like to look at.


3) Did you actually study literature? Well... since you`re writing books and stuff ;) as already mentioned I really love your stuff and keep up the good work. I think my money is in good hands ;)

I did a year of university studying just that and then had to leave after exams for reasons that are too complicated for this answer. Probably too personal as well but I have trouble drawing that line.

I dislike a lot of academia that surrounds books. It's a big reason why I'm against doing the same sort of thing to games—not just myself, but even praising others that go about it all wrong. There's so much opinion and interpretation. There's so much bullshit. I've gotten an A on many essays by just regurgitating the perspective of the professor because that's how terrible the system has become. Some interpretations are apparently better than others.

A lot of writers hate this too. James Joyce is a great source for confidence in many ways and this is one of them. Learning about writer's lives should do little to enhance their work and I think it's a flawed way of studying. But it can be a big deal for a creator of things because you're left with the impression that they were just people. Same as you. Their names got big but they still had bad habits, weird kinks, ate too much, drank too much, shat their pants, and everything else that you'd never attribute to giants of literature or art.

Despite saying that I still struggle with this. At the beginning, with both my books and the channel, there was this tall hurdle that I call "Who The Fuck Am I, Really?". Why would people want to read my book? Why would people want to hear what I have to say about Dark Souls? Who the fuck am I, really? Yet here we are. Confidence is important but it can go both ways. And it can get surprisingly complicated, with some of the most boisterous, egotistical people in the world acting that way to hide how fragile they are underneath. A couple of times a year I still bite the inside of my cheek while I'm eating, yet I'm supposed to be a "leading critic" on video games. Who the fuck am I, really?

Well I'm human. Just like everyone else who has a famous name that you know. That's the biggest benefit I've gotten from studying the lives of writers. Never think you're the best of the best, but don't stamp on your own feet. I think I'm still too far into the latter category.

As for writing I've gained far more from reading books and thinking about them myself. Amateur work is also fantastic for learning what not to do, and finding pieces that work so well that they stick out so clearly through the rest. I don't read enough though. I'm a slow reader. Not just sentence-to-sentence, but also in the time it takes for me to digest each book. I like to think about it all for a while and reading another book so soon can ruin that. Meanwhile my wife is so much better than I am at that. She can read and understand a book a week.

And thank you for the comment here. I hope you like the future videos just as much. I wish I could be faster making them.



Stephen S asked:

  1. If I'm remembering correctly, you're playing/have played through the Witcher series for a future video. Do you have any plans to read the Witcher books as well? I fell in love with the Witcher series and ended up reading all the novels which is the first time a video game has ever done that. I highly recommend them assuming the Witcher universe interests you as much as it did me. Really looking forward to that video by the way, even if you end up disliking it somehow.
  2. Somewhat related to the Witcher games, how important do you find having to play earlier games in a series before playing the most recent one? Is it fair to judge a game without playing its predecessors? I couldn't sit through playing Witcher 1 or 2 myself and I feel somewhat guilty about it.
  3. Has making this channel your job changed how you view/play games in any way? Do you find yourself analyzing things when you would otherwise ignore them? More importantly do you still find games fun? That's all I got for now. Thanks for the Q&A, thanks for the videos, and just thanks man. I wish you all the best with what's going to undoubtedly be a very busy time for you.


Hi Stephen. I'm seeing a lot of repeated names in the Q&A. Pretty cool.

1—I bought the books a few months ago. They're sitting on top of my computer tower right now! I've read some of the openings and they seem decent.

My plan for The Witcher is to play all of the games as amnesiac Geralt. Then read all of the books. And then play the games again making different choices, and seeing what I understand better after reading the books. I don't know if I'll do ALL of Witcher 3 again since it's such a huge game, but if there are a lot of decisions then I'll have to.

I've played Witcher 1 already. And most of Witcher 2. I haven't fully committed to that series yet since I have a lot of plans to have some smaller videos to drip out while I do it, so there isn't a long content drought. Right now it's been a while between videos because of the second baby. If I had planned better I would have already had some small videos made, but Fallout 4 One Year Later ended up being much larger than I thought. Now I'm playing catch-up and maybe I should have let some games go instead of trying to do them.

Now I'm wondering how Witcher 3 the first time will be like after playing Breath of the Wild first.


2) Somewhat related to the Witcher games, how important do you find having to play earlier games in a series before playing the most recent one? Is it fair to judge a game without playing its predecessors? I couldn't sit through playing Witcher 1 or 2 myself and I feel somewhat guilty about it.

It changes from series to series. If the games have a lot of focus on a continuing story, then it's important to play the earlier ones. It would be like watching movies out of order otherwise.

Games like Mario though? Or even Zelda? I don't know about those. Zelda does have a story but each one is more of a spiritual progression or a remake of what came before, rather than a continuation. Even though people speak about timelines and stuff in that game, I doubt they were planned. Nintendo has spoken about them but I'd wager it was more of a "hey these fan theories kind of fit, let's roll with it."

On the other hand, it may not be necessary to know the history of a series to judge it but it can still provide a lot of opportunities to make comparisons. The more information you have, the more interesting points you can make. And seeing mechanics develop over time can help you better understand them. Which means you can better speak about them.

I don't have a rigid rule about this but my own guidelines are that I generally try to play all of the games in a series first. And, if possible, include them in the video. The Last Guardian script grew to include Ico and Shadow of the Colossus for these reasons (although it's not finished yet). I played all three games again, recorded my time, and had a ton of notes comparing them. It was beneficial for writing, yet would a script on JUST The Last Guardian have been so much weaker? Probably not by that much. It would have just been different.

Sometimes this isn't realistic though. I'm playing Breath of the Wild right now and, even though I've played almost every other Zelda game, it would be a giant undertaking to go back and do all of them for a video on this game. I can make some comparisons from memory but I wouldn't be comfortable doing that for a lot of things because what if I'm remembering it wrong? Looking at a game in a series and treating it as its own isolated thing can be interesting too. Especially if it's a dramatic departure from the other games.

In a way, one review/critique/analysis isn't going to cover everything then. Which is a good thing. There should be discussions and disagreement. Look at Fallout 4. I genuinely believe it's a good game on its own, but a bad game in its series.


3) Has making this channel your job changed how you view/play games in any way? Do you find yourself analyzing things when you would otherwise ignore them? More importantly do you still find games fun? That's all I got for now. Thanks for the Q&A, thanks for the videos, and just thanks man. I wish you all the best with what's going to undoubtedly be a very busy time for you.

Thanks! Yeah this past month has been the most difficult in my life so far. It's difficult in a good way since it's a new baby, and I love this job, but with so little sleep and so much going on, it's been a huge challenge. One that's still ongoing too. I think I could be handling it better. Or maybe I just need more sleep.

The two biggest things that have changed in video games for me now are that I can't switch the "analysis" off, and that I find it difficult to play some games just for myself. I feel like I should always be working toward a video. It wasn't like this at first so maybe it'll change again in the future. But even something like returning to Stardew Valley for the new patch, or the new DLC for Furi, becomes "well maybe I should find a way to make some content out of it..."

This is honestly exhausting and it's a problem I hope goes away soon.

Despite saying that, I still enjoy most of the games that I play. I receive a lot of comments from people after I criticize a game that they love. Usually they're backhanded compliments like: "you make a lot of good points but you can't appreciate the game for what it is. I feel so sad for you that you're so cynical." Or they're outright hostile that HOW DARE I CRITICIZE THIS PERFECT MASTERPIECE GIFTED TO US BY BETHESDA.

I love games. But I'm not an entertainer. I'm not a journalist or even a reviewer really. I'm a critic. And more games fail at bringing their pieces together than succeed, so that's what I see and find the best topics to talk about. There's also the other end where I'm speaking about games that are fantastic. I think I'm quite positive on a lot of these games but the flaws stick out a lot more BECAUSE of how successful the rest of the game is. Just like great moments in an otherwise bad game similarly shine through as potential. So I walk this strange line sometimes—not always—of finding great things to speak about in bad games, and horrible parts in wonderful ones.

I try to see the intention in a lot of games, and I think that lets me appreciate it more than many other people. But it also exposes flaws that might make me come across as harsh. I think I touched on this in the last Q&A. It's really not fair for me to do it because the developers go through hell putting games together. And I'm not sure if what I do has any value whatsoever to them. But people seem to enjoy the deconstruction so it must be worth something at least.

But not being able to turn the "analysis" view off does hamper some of my enjoyment when I'm playing just for myself. Not because I'm seeing flaws, but because I feel like I should be collecting information for a script. That part gets in the way.



Marcin D asked:

I just recently become a patron, but I've been watching your videos since your monster of a video about Uncharted and The Last of Us. First of all I want to thank you for making these videos, they really changed my outlook on storytelling in games and gameplay.

  1. What was the first videogame that you fell in love with? Why did you like it so much? Was it story, gameplay or both?
  2. What do you think about the modern trend of locking important pieces of story behind paywall? By that I mean releasing Day 1 DLC with a character like Javik with Day 1 DLC from Mass Effect 3.
  3. Do you have any guilty pleasures, and if you do - what are they?


Hi Marcin. I try really hard to make gameplay and story the core of my videos so it means a lot that you're enjoying those parts. And so much so that you want to help make more of them happen. It means a lot.

1—The first game I ever played on a console was Mario Brothers for the NES. But my memory is a bit jumbled on what came before that. I remember having some handheld games like the Game and Watch ones. There was a Zelda one that I still have, but other ones like a three track racing game I think. They were very simple.

Mario Brothers hooked me and I've been playing games ever since. I'm not sure if that's the first one I fell in love with though. I'd be happy to never play Mario Brothers again because it's not as good as most of the other Marios. Whereas I can play Super Mario World today and have a great time. So maybe it's that game?

Or maybe I should go with the first thing that popped into my head when I read your question: Chrono Trigger. The story and characters grabbed me and I played and replayed that game for years, even though it's fairly short. As an adult the story and characters are overly simple now but I still love it. Maybe because as a child it was the opposite sort of experience: it can be quite complicated to understand with time travel, altering the past, and seeing different versions of the future. So maybe it instilled some sort of reverence from that.

Chrono Trigger also has arguably the best gameplay in any JRPG I've ever played—which, to be clear here, might show how few JRPGs I've played in recent years. The tech system is standard for each character but that they can mix and interact with dual and triple techs is still something I haven't seen another game attempt, never mind do it better. I think I Am Setsuna might have tried it but I haven't played it. Party and enemy positions matter a little bit in Chrono Trigger, and there's a switch up in gameplay toward the end that makes you feel weakened in combat, just like the story wants the characters to feel at the same time.

Then there's the music that I still listen to regularly. Mostly remixes though. The visuals were incredible for the time and still hold up if you're into pixel art. It has one of the most appealing overworlds of any SNES RPG.

It's probably my favorite game even though turn-based gameplay isn't my favorite. It's not a mechanically-heavy game which is what I go for now. I'd love to see someone attempt a mature version of Chrono Trigger aimed at adults. While I think Final Fantasy 6 falls just short of equality to Chrono Trigger—and it has the same problems with being aimed at children with its characters—that game has some surprisingly dark events and themes.


2) What do you think about the modern trend of locking important pieces of story behind paywall? By that I mean releasing Day 1 DLC with a character like Javik with Day 1 DLC from Mass Effect 3.

I don't know. It's complicated.

You have to think about what makes a game. When is it complete? How many hours per dollar? But also how much quality matters over quantity? Fewer, better hours vs more but worse. The only people that can judge if the game is a complete package are those who made it, or reviewers who play the game and can decide if the Day 1 DLC is required to make the experience complete.

It's easy to see, in your example, that they made the game with all of the companions and then chopped one off to sell at a higher price. They're holding it ransom. Games are, apparently, far more expensive to make today so this could also be an incentive for "real fans" to give the developers more money for a better game, without the cost being too high for "new fans" who aren't invested enough to pay a higher price.

Either way this is bad in my opinion. If games are too cheap then the prices need to be raised so these practices don't have to happen. Or developers should be looking at ways to reduce development costs. I'm hesitant to say this but let's roll with it anyway: if Eric Barone can make Stardew Valley all by himself, then perhaps the problem isn't that Triple-A games are too expensive. Maybe it's that the developers have bloated teams and are SHOCKINGLY inefficient at organizing their employees. From what I've read, most big developers aren't places in which most people enjoy working. Unhappy workers typically don't give it their all, which would lead to these huge expensive teams to make up for that. But please know that I am talking out of my ass here. I could be right—probably not though. I know little about business.

The alternative goes like this. Consider:

BioWare has five years to make a game. They make their deadlines. The game is finished. But then the decision is made to hold off on release for a few months because they think the game will do better around the holidays, or that another similar game came out and they don't want the competition, or they simply want more time to do bugfixes and polish.

There's now a huge part of the development team that has nothing to do. Instead of laying everyone off, BioWare commits their workers to making some more content. Because it's a smaller project, they get it done before the base game is released. They can even fit it on the discs so people don't have to download it if they buy it.

This is extra content, made after the game was finished, with the sole purpose of keeping developers in the company. This is great to me. Nothing wrong with this. But the issue is still complicated. Maybe they should wait a month before releasing this extra stuff so it doesn't look so shady? Well then people who will only play the game once are missing out on stuff that's already done... But it makes BioWare look bad because you just have to take their word for it that it wasn't content already included in the game that was removed to be sold separately.

Even I've accused developers of doing this. More than once if I'm remembering right. In Dark Souls 3 and I think Rise of the Tomb Raider? It's hard to measure this and no developer is ever going to come out and say "oh yeah totally, we just trimmed that fat off and want you to give us more money for it."

So yeah. It's complicated.


3) Do you have any guilty pleasures, and if you do - what are they?

Oh god a lot of bad music. Taylor Swift. Nicki Minaj. I used to know all the words to Super Bass and could sing along. Ignition Remix by R Kelly. I find these popular songs and I will listen to them 500 times on repeat until I'm sick of them. At least I used to when I had the time. With the kids, putting on a headset at all isn't an option very often.

My wife and I are casual-perverts and talk about hot celebrities all the time. That's a pretty guilty pleasure. Miranda Kerr, Kate Beckinsale, and Jessica Alba are usually our top picks. I'm a little embarrassed to admit we do that, haha.

I've always liked Disney movies. I never outgrew them and I'm looking forward to watching them all—and having an excuse to watch the new ones!--with my boys. Same for all the cool new toys that came out since I was a kid. Who knows what amazing shit is out there now.

I drink too much soda. I don't drink or smoke or do any drugs. So soda is my big vice. How uncool is that. I hate coffee. I don't know I think I'm pretty boring in this area. My wife and I are solitary. Are really bad jokes to make her laugh a guilty pleasure? She laughs at them so maybe it's one of hers, not mine.

For video games I have no idea. Probably World of Warcraft, but I haven't played it seriously since Mists of Pandaria. I was hopelessly addicted to WoW for a long time so I'd say that counts.



Michael L asked:

3 short and sweeties.

  1. Do you play an instrument?
  2. Have you ever considered making shorter form reviews?
  3. What do you think of the Shin Megami Tensei games? (Review maybe, maybe not? No one else has done a good dissection IMO.)


Hey there Michael. I only have some short answers for you. Sorry about that. Some questions can't become this big thing. I think you knew that already with the "short and sweeties" though.

1—Nope! I wish I could though. But it's the sort of half-assed "I wish I could do..." which leads to watching Netflix or something. I wish I could draw. I wish I could speak another language. Apparently I don't wish hard enough.

I was learning how to play piano and guitar when I was a teenager—same with learning to draw and another language, funnily enough—but the problem I've always faced in life is that if I'm not immediately great at something I give up. To my credit I did put in quite a few hours in all of those, and I made some quick progress at the start, but as soon as it gets a little tough I give up.

That was teenaged-me. I've gotten better at dealing with this as I've grown up. Maybe I should try again at some point. French would be a good one to learn for Canada. And yeah, piano or guitar would still be my top picks for an instrument.


2) Have you ever considered making shorter form reviews?

All the time. I'm currently debating whether I should scrap all of my current projects and dive into a few months of short videos that are more manageable while I adjust to life with the second baby. I don't know if you follow me on twitter but I just announced that I'm priotizing Breath of the Wild for the channel. That's sort of in the same line of thought: I have so many open projects and so many scripts and game footage recorded since I lost about a month to the new baby (even the weeks leading up to the birth were really crazy), that I need to "reset" and have just one thing to focus on.

If I did this I would lose my work on Last Guardian / Ico / SotC, which is something I think a lot of people want to see. And that's where I get stuck with wanting to do the longer videos for the channel but not really having the time. The more time passes the more I think people want the longer stuff.

Short videos have to happen for The Witcher regardless. And the situation isn't as bad as this sounds now that I just read it back. Really the issue right now has been all of February and much of March just past for me like someone snapped their fingers three times. It's been pregnancy, hospital, birth, baby baby baby, visits, doctors, baby, no sleep, cry cry baby cry (he's actually crying right now), and with each passing day I can spend a few more minutes playing a game or answering messages or emails or script writing. Even this Q&A has been difficult to find time to finish.

Things are finally settling now and, after Zelda, I don't know if I'm going to do short reviews for a while or go back to the Fumito Ueda games. There's Nioh, Horizon, the Dark Souls 3 DLC, and who knows what else that I'm forgetting. People seemed interested in an Automata video and that was a game I wanted to play too.

But I have so many games like SOMA—which I can play, write, and make the video in about two weeks. Maybe even shorter if it's the ONLY thing I'm doing.

It's a bad place to be in because I think I already produce a lot more content than most channels like mine, but that's not good enough for me. I shouldn't ever compare myself to others. It should be what I'm happy with for myself, and I don't like the time between releases currently. I just hope it's purely baby-related.


3) What do you think of the Shin Megami Tensei games? (Review maybe, maybe not? No one else has done a good dissection IMO.)

Well I had to google them just now after reading this so I think that says most of what I think. I've heard of them but I know little about them. On wikipedia is says Persona is a spin-off from the series? I didn't know that. No Persona 5 spoilers, please.

I have a friend who loves the Persona games and I've always wanted to try them. I'm not big on Japanese culture but a good game is a good game. Sorry for the weak answer but I know nothing about this series. Maybe sometime in the future I'll play them and make an outsider-perspective review.



RoyBatty asked:

  1. Have you been playing Nioh? What do you think?
  2. I've been thinking about something you said in the Bloodborne video. You said that some levels don't do an effective job at preparing you for the bosses. I thought that was real interesting, and shed a lot of light on Boss fights I've had and continue to have. My question is, should that always be the case? Can a boss fight be fitting and appropriate while bringing a new idea? I guess I would just like to hear you elaborate on that idea.
  3. In the lead up to Zelda and Horizon, I've been reading a lot about systems-driven open world design and theme park style open world design. MGSV being an example of the former, and Fallout/Far Cry being an example of the latter. What are your thoughts?


1—Evening Roy. I have Nioh and love it. Unfortunately I haven't had a chance to finish it. The game doesn't have a pause function so it's impossible for me to commit any time to it with the new baby. I'm mentioning the new kid a lot in this Q&A. Sorry about that everyone, it's dominating our lives right now.

Without the ability to pause, I can't relax and get into the game because I'll constantly be worried I'll have to leave it during a boss or even in a hostile area. The game is difficult enough, and crammed with enough enemies, that redoing it over and over because I got interrupted would ruin it for me. And I want to enjoy the game as much as possible.

So even though I love it, I can't tell you how I feel about it because I haven't finished it. My guess is, from seeing the first quarter of the game, that if the quality keeps up it'll be up there with Bloodborne and the best of Dark Souls. The combat is better. The level design, in terms of its construction (not theme, I hate the theme), is about the same maybe a little worse. Some of the bosses have been great. And there's a bit of cheap bullshit moments but they're in the Souls games too.

Mission select instead of a connected world is fine to me, and I might even prefer it in the Souls games if they're not going to bother with a world design like in Dark Souls 1. I've brought up Souls a lot now but it's unavoidable—the game is clearly building on that formula. Amrita are souls, the shrines are bonfires. You die, respawn, and fight through the level again. You have a bloodstain. It's a more complicated version of it.

Turbo Button has a good video on the combat if you haven't seen it:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dXea0FNvk3c

I don't like the gear system in the game. I don't like how gear-dependent much of the progression is. I had the same problem in the beta, when I was too low a level and had too shit a weapon for one of the optional bosses. But those are problems I can learn to live with. There's a hell of a lot of menu clutter and navigation that I don't like. The UI is something I tolerate. I wish it was cleaner. And like I said, the game's theme isn't something I enjoy but it's not quite as bad as I expected it to be. The colorful spirit animals are neat too.

I want to do a video on it but I don't know when. These types of games are an incredible time commitment even if the videos aren't that long. There's so much to speak about and fact check before going through it all, and they can be extremely heavy on specific visual examples to reinforce what's being said. But I do want to do something eventually.

Man all that dodging, stance switching, and Gears of War-like reload timing... I hope the game stays good all the way through. It's so creative with different modes as well. Twilight levels. I wish FROM exercised this much freedom in their games.


2) I've been thinking about something you said in the Bloodborne video. You said that some levels don't do an effective job at preparing you for the bosses. I thought that was real interesting, and shed a lot of light on Boss fights I've had and continue to have. My question is, should that always be the case? Can a boss fight be fitting and appropriate while bringing a new idea? I guess I would just like to hear you elaborate on that idea.

It's such a small part of games as a whole and yet you could think about this for days. It's complex right? Games are awesome like that. There are so many ways to approach this little thing. Some games don't even have boss fights.

I think it's going to depend on what kind of game it is. Specifically, how it punishes failure and how much it expects of you to get back to the boss again. For a game like Bloodborne, you could die quite quickly. Then you have a potentially long run to get back to do another attempt, with the added possibility of clearing more "trash" mobs to do so on the way. It's like raiding in World of Warcraft. Or at least how it used to work in the earlier expansions. Trash doesn't really reset all that quickly anymore.

Molten Core was hell though.

So, in a game like this, I think that it can be cheap if the boss is a drastic shift away from what you've had to do so far. It's why I don't really like Cleric Beast or Gascoigne. Like I said in the video, Yharnam wants you to be careful and methodical about killing the packs of enemies—to the point that you can get yourself killed if you overextend and pull too many of them at once. You're meant to wait for openings and exploit them. But with the bosses... you CAN kill them doing this, but they do so much damage that you're going to die a lot learning all of these patterns if you're new to the series. Whereas you can just stay in and attack like crazy to win. Rallying can do a surprising amount of healing. And I'm still on the fence on whether this was intentional or not. Maybe it was an oversight and they weren't expecting players to be able to be so aggressive and still win. Yet so many of the bosses can be killed like that.

Gascoigne is also really easy to parry if you're willing to put in a few attempts on the timing. And you can afford to waste a lot of bullets getting him vulnerable because he doesn't have that much health. But that comes back to the issue in your question: Yharnam didn't set you up to learn how to parry. In fact, I'd go as far as saying that any new player to the series won't even know what parrying is at this point in the game, even if they saw the weird cluster of messages in the Dream explaining how to do it. There's no way to test it RIGHT THEN AND THERE, which led to information overload for me, and I was familiar with the series.

Father will shoot at you though, which might be a hint to get you to try it back at him. I think I said that in the video as well? I can't remember now. Which is great if FROM intended for that. But it's still something that's new to the boss and had no set up in the area leading up to him. So in these cases, I'd say it's a flaw. And from the comments I've gotten from people on the video confirming that these two bosses were some of, if not THE HARDEST, bosses in the game for them, I think this is a huge misstep. My guess is that there are many players who got Bloodborne after hearing about it and never made it past Yharnam. There are tens of thousands of these unfinished games from people who hit this wall and never scaled it.

Because everytime they were asked to try again, they had to spend minutes running back to the wall, potentially dying on the way, before they could even think about trying to climb it again.

Does this mean that every boss in Souls should prepare you ahead of time? I don't think so. I think that would be boring. But for bosses that are really different—how about a checkpoint in front of the door? Maybe even a hidden one to reward exploration. I like the run from bonfire to boss door in almost every case, so I don't think there should always be a lampfire nearby, but in these cases there should be.

For other games, that have less punishing death systems, things can be different. A boss that's so different than everything else can be exciting and a fresh challenge. But it still needs to be done within reason. My go to example of a boss that subverts its entire game in a terrible way is the Simon-Says monster in Super Meat Boy. The game has been about careful timing, judging jumps and obstacles, and even past bosses have kept with that. But here's this boss that's all about trial-and-error. Learn the pattern. Die everytime. Memorize it and do it again. It's awful.

Looks cool though.

Mario 64 might do this well. I'd have to play it again. Bowser's levels are the best parts of the game for me. And I love that Super Mario 3D Land and World used them as a template for every level—tight obstacle courses. This is already different than the other levels in Mario 64 but it's still obeying the same rules, and there's no time limit. Lots of lives too. Then the boss at the end requires dodging some fireballs and then grabbing his tail to spin him around, which isn't something you do at any other point in the game if I remember right. You have to release the throw at the right time to send Bowser into bombs around the platform.

This is very different from everything else. It's memorable to me for that reason. And nothing in the game has prepared you for it—except maybe getting behind the bomb boss in the first painting, but that didn't require you to spin him in place and aim a throw, so I don't think it's all that similar. If you die to Bowser, you don't have to redo the level before him as long as you have some lives. So the game can be really different without expecting too much.

In closing I think variety should win. A boss that builds on ideas in the level that precedes him can be a beautiful example of teaching and then testing the player. But one that introduces many new concepts and expects you to learn right then and there can be thrilling and challenging. Strangely, I think the former way can lead to more difficult fights if done properly because there can be high expectations on the player. Whereas the latter—if the fight "clicks" for the player quickly then they can overcome them without much trouble. Some people have told me that it was EITHER Cleric Beast or Gascoigne they had trouble with. One clicked with them early on. The other didn't.

I love video games man. This stuff is so cool.


3) In the lead up to Zelda and Horizon, I've been reading a lot about systems-driven open world design and theme park style open world design. MGSV being an example of the former, and Fallout/Far Cry being an example of the latter. What are your thoughts?

Just to make sure I'm understanding correctly, systems-driven would be giving the player a bunch of fun mechanics and the freedom to be creative with them, and a theme park open world would be mechanically shallow but a lot of locations/dungeons/quests to find and complete with those basic mechanics? So something like Just Cause would be systems-driven because of all of the wacky physics-based tools you have. And Fallout 4 would be a theme park because the gameplay is simple, and you're basically walking from quest to place to NPC, who are like "attractions" or "rides" in a theme park.

I'm assuming Just Cause is like that by the way. I have it but I haven't played it. There are quite a few open world games I haven't played yet. I've never properly played a Grand Theft Auto either. For some reason it's never appealed to me.

I think that both versions have their merits, and I'm not sure which one I like more. New Vegas is a theme park and that's one of my favorite games. I also like Skyrim but I don't think the "attractions" are great in that game. I like seeing the world instead.

New Vegas could be vastly improved with more gameplay features. It's only good at what it set out to do: tell a good, non-linear story with a decent amount of player freedom. But the gameplay is terrible. Yet for some reason the bare bones attempt at improving the combat makes me less inclined to be critical of it. Because they didn't make it a priority, I feel justified in ignoring it. I don't know if it's right for me to do that. Probably not.

Meanwhile I'm playing Breath of the Wild right now which is a mix of both of these types. Horizon is too funnily enough, albeit to a lesser degree than BotW. Horizon is very exploration and combat focused. It has some crafting and gathering resources, but they clearly put more time in enemy variety and combat options. And from the little I've played (several hours) I think it's pretty good!

Breath of the Wild gives you SO MUCH MORE freedom in getting around its world. And so many more tools to do so. Stasis a block, whack it a few times, and then go flying on it. Inflate balloon sacks to float a boat in the air (not really viable mind you but still possible). EVERYTHING is climbable! Glide down from high places. Increase stamina for tangible, real results in where you're capable of going. Prepare expeditions into hostile areas. Weather effects aren't just visual tweaks. They matter and modify what you're capable of it.

But there are also towns, quests, NPCs, boring Fallout 4 style fetch quests, mini-dungeons in the form of shrines that sit behind load screens just like "rides" in theme park open worlds. This is the part of the game that I really don't like so maybe that shows where Nintendo focused its attention.

Combat also suffers but it's still a huge step up from Skyrim and Fallout 4, so I'm learning to like it. But it's unfortunately coming at me after playing a bunch of Bloodborne, Souls, and Nioh for fucks sake, so it makes sense I had to manage expectations with Zelda.

I don't know what the conclusion to all of this should be. I will say that I am a strong supporter of games not including something unless they want to put in the time to make it worthwhile. Which is why almost every shrine in Breath of the Wild has been a huge disappointment to me so far. I've done more than half of them (65 or so as of writing this) and I think only 12 of them have been mildly amusing, and only 5 of those 12 felt truly worth interrupting the fantastic exploration of the open world to do.

If you could have a New Vegas style story, quests, and NPCs, with Breath of the Wild's type of world plus freedom in exploration, and a Souls bonfire system with combat that isn't QUITE that deep but somewhere close, then that's my near-perfect, imaginary unicorn-never-going-to-happen tier open world game.

I think games that try to be a theme park but have shitty quests and "attractions" end up being too boring to justify their worlds. Traveling between these locations becomes bloated load screens for the combat system instead. I liked Far Cry 3 when I first played it but it's becoming less favorable in my memory over time. And I should really play MGSV.

I hope this is the kind of answer you were looking for.



Jared L asked:

1. What's your favorite "shitty" video game? By that, I mean a game with strengths that you can play off of, but has some big flaws in it that keep it from being great. It doesn't need to be overly popular/unpopular. Why do you like it?


Hey Jared. The games that come to mind are Management Sims. I feel that if you asked this question again a year from now you might get a different answer though. It's hard to remember all the games I've played. Some of them must have been bad but I liked them anyway.

Management games are, in theory, terrible. There's no challenge or solutions to find. So the game is all about making decisions but there are no wrong ones really. If you do mess up, all that means is you wait around for a really long time to build up more resources/money. Sometimes, if the game has a research feature, waiting around for better tech might be the BEST way to play the game in the long run.

These games are best played with total creative freedom then. Which many of them don't provide because they want to "gamify" the process. This is almost always a mistake because it leads to those long waiting periods. Even on the highest speed setting, Planet Coaster is really boring in these sections. Cities Skylines and Tropico were too if I'm remembering right.

They also feel binary in terms of success. Either you're making progress at a snail's pace, or your city/park is BOOMING and there's only small tweaks to do. The game is only good if you have the creativity and drive to make something look nice or interesting for yourself, which means all of the "gamification" parts get in the way instead.

Yet I enjoy these games a lot. There's something about this progress that appeals to me. Planet Coaster makes it easy to be make "artistic" choices with decorations as well. And I've lost hundreds of hours of my life to city builders. Yet I think they're shitty. Go figure that out because I can't.

I think Management Sims could learn a lesson from Factorio. Not only in that the player has an avatar to center the experience around, but also that the problems you're solving have tangible effects on how quickly or slowly you can progress. You CAN wait around for resources and research—and I'd argue the endgame does get bogged down with just that—but instead you should be making more factories. There's no currency, just resources that you can use to acquire more resources, so you can decide how much expansion you want to do. You can't do that in city builders and theme park simulators. Or even stuff like Theme Hospital.

I think there's a fantastic, new version of Magic Carpet that is waiting to be made by someone. That's a similar style to Factorio even though they look so different. You're killing monsters and fighting over mana instead of raw materials. Eh maybe they're not so similar but I feel a connection there somewhere. Same goes for Dungeon Keeper which, during moments of long waiting, allowed you to increase time to "ludicrous speed" or even "plaid" if you wanted to skip a lot of tedium. Your creatures could go from level 1 to 10 in about 15 seconds if you knew you had the resources and could risk the time skip.

If you want the king of examples for your question: Evil Genius. It's like Dungeon Keeper without a lot of the control. It had insane amounts of waiting for gold to trickle in. First from the campaign map, to your boat, then you had to wait for a worker to run to the dock to pick up the briefcase, then carry it AAAALLLLL the way into your vault inside your mountain lair. And it really was a trickle. Just so you had the resources to build rooms and train more underlings to send out to make that trickle move a little faster.

And yet I played the shit out of that game. It was such a cool concept and it was so much fun to steal big pieces of loot—like shrinking the Eiffel Tower and putting it on display in your base. It was charming. And a much better version of it is aching for the "Stardew Valley" treatment.

Pokemon is too in my opinion. Game Freak is squandering that idea.



Brendan L M asked:

Keeping it basic.

  1. What was your first job?
  2. What would be some of the games that would make the imaginary "top ten games" list that you have but haven't ever created? (I believe you alluded to it in your Uncharted/Last of Us video)
  3. What are your thoughts on handheld gaming? Is there still a place for it today as gaming advances and these systems remain underpowered?(3ds/PSP as opposed to phones). Thanks


Hi Brendan. I'm not sure how involved my answers can be to these questions but I'll give it my best.

1—I had a handful of brief jobs as a teenager that aren't worth mentioning. I worked at Wendy's for a single day when I was 18. There's a cult around that Dave guy let me tell you.

My first "real" job was working for a doctor in Toronto. She was insane. Totally batshit. It's funny now but I was there for months and it was not funny then. Not even a little bit.

She was a medical doctor. I got this job through an agency and I was desperate for work. I couldn't turn anything down. I thought it would be respectable work considering it was a doctor's office. And it was cool because it was based in a house instead of a building. The doctor didn't live in the house it was a proper office, with extra space she rented out to a handful of other... uh... practitioners let's say.

This woman was so insane that I don't even want to use her real name. Let's call her Martha. She'll also be a character in a book one day because that's how much this experience stuck with me throughout my whole life. I was hired to do computer work for the office—not really IT, but more transcribing notes and, initially, there was talk about sending me to training so I could make pamphlets and flyers for potential customers. Now you might be saying "Joe, don't you mean patients? Why did you say customers?" No. Customers.

Martha was an M.D., graduated from University of Toronto, and was pushing 60 when I was hired. She was obsessed with money and wringing as much as she possibly could from her "patients", her staff, and anyone stupid enough to buy her alternative medicine. She pushed homeopathic remedies on all of her patients, while simultaneously confiding in me that it was all bullshit. Without a word of a lie or exaggeration, she had a big fucking wall in her office with bottled extracts of everything in it. One of them was "Tarantula". Fucking TARANTULA extract. She was like a fucking alchemist with this shit.

Homeopathy is based on the idea that water has some sort of memory. If you dilute the extract of something in water, and then take a drop of that solution and then dilute it again in more water, then you can somehow use the essence of it in a safe way to cure... anything. Cancer. Herpes. Tummy ache. Bad back. Anything. Name a thing that's wrong with you? WELL DO I HAVE THE DILUTED CURE FOR YOU!

I had to go to seminars with this woman on this stuff and take notes for her because she was terrible at typing. She must have been one of the only "real" doctors in this ocean of homeopathic con artists in the lecture hall, and she would scoff to herself at the absurdity of it and then sell this stuff to patients the next day because—SURPRISE!--it isn't covered by Canada's healthcare so she can charge a ridiculous amount of money for it.

Any sort of alternative treatment that wasn't covered by the government was catnip to this monster. The top floor of the office was like an opium den for lunatics that preferred her over a regular doctor, because they felt like they "were more involved in their treatment, and could make decisions for themselves instead of being told what to do." Yeah, because you want to argue with doctors who went through insane amounts of school to know what's best for you. No, YOU want to have some input.

To be clear you should definitely explore options and doctors and discuss the risks of each, but if you went to this doctor and said "I hear that putting my feet in lightly electrified water can cure me of my hemorrhoids" she would already have the machine set up and ready to affirm that you're right... for a "modest" fee.

This opium den was full of comfortable chairs, a few bean bags, was the best looking room in the house—like a cabin lodge really—and was for people to get IV treatment. Because a drip bag of Vitamin C cures EVERYTHING. Regular treatment! Come and get it as much as possible! She would do it to herself too so it would all appear more legitimate. Some cocktail drip into her arm of god knows fucking what (probably just saline to be honest) and she would sit like a homeopathic drug lord or queen pin in the room. One time the needle got stuck in her arm and I had to yank it out of her. Just imagine having to do that with no training. It was like pulling a stick out of the tightest clump of cobwebs you can imagine.

She was horrible at drawing blood. If the nurses weren't around then she'd just YOLO an attempt. Patients would pass out. Once she instructed me to "hold this girl down" while she took blood and I told her no. Which was the first of many dominoes that resulted in my being fired.

Listen I could write a book on this woman. She would hold staff meetings in the fucking bathroom. I never did any of that pamphlet work because I become her bitch instead. Just a general "do this for me today" kind of thing. Go get me lunch. Go across the city and get X for me. One time I helped her clean her house for Christmas before her sons came to visit. There was the week the sewage system beneath the office backed up and it overflowed in the basement. This was so bad that even the plumber threw up when he came to fix it. Guess who had to coordinate fixing that? I remember having to drive with this plumber to go get some stuff or something and I'm sitting in the passenger seat next to him of this big giant van (which, if I remember correctly, he said was technically illegal or something but we did it anyway), and he randomly whips out his phone to show me topless pictures of this woman he banged the night before.

You know typical stuff. Here's the office. Here's the lake of shit that's bubbling up around all of the centrifuge and the rest of the equipment kept in the staff kitchen (????) in the basement. Oh it's so bad you're vomiting. Let's go for a drive for some stuff I can't even remember. Here are some titty pics.

And this sounds pathetic right? I was THAT desperate for the money. I learned so much from that job but I still can't say I'm happy I went through it. I've barely scratched the surface on the illegal shit that woman pulled. What a fucking nightmare.


2) What would be some of the games that would make the imaginary "top ten games" list that you have but haven't ever created? (I believe you alluded to it in your Uncharted/Last of Us video).

Alright so I started this answer by listing out my favorite games for each system and it's turning into this huge giant mess of a thing with almost a hundred games so let's be more selective. Let's boil it down to a top 30. Some of these games are only good because I played them when they first came out. Played today they might not be all that great. They're also not in any real order even though I'm numbering them.

  1. Chrono Trigger
  2. Final Fantasy 6
  3. A Link to the Past
  4. Majora's Mask
  5. Half-Life 2
  6. Portal (1 or 2, I can't decide)
  7. Shadow of the Colossus
  8. Dark Souls 1 or Bloodborne (can't decide)
  9. Super Mario Galaxy
  10. Fallout New Vegas
  11. Deus Ex
  12. Dungeon Keeper
  13. Furi
  14. World of Warcraft
  15. Goldeneye 64
  16. Devil May Cry
  17. Metal Gear Solid
  18. Yoshi's Island
  19. Mega Man X (can't decide on 1, 2, or 3)
  20. Civilization IV
  21. The Last of Us
  22. Baldur's Gate 2 (maybe Planescape. I'd have to replay)
  23. Mass Effect 2
  24. Donkey Kong Country (can't decide 1 or 2)
  25. Smash Bros Melee
  26. Total Annihilation
  27. Banjo Kazooie
  28. Don't Starve
  29. Pokemon Silver
  30. SOMA (solely because I can't think of a better video game story)

Some potential new challengers I have to play more or think about:

  1. Enter the Gungeon
  2. Nioh
  3. Breath of the Wild
  4. Doom 4
  5. Factorio (I really like Factorio! It needs to be finished)

There might be some games I'm missing. I think I played my first game around 4 or 5 and I'm approaching 30 years of this stuff so it's hard to remember them all. I wasn't big on Sega games as you can see from the list. And there are some PlayStation classics that I missed out on too. Narrowing this down to 20 would be fairly easy. Getting it to 10 after that? I don't know if I could do it.


3) What are your thoughts on handheld gaming? Is there still a place for it today as gaming advances and these systems remain underpowered?(3ds/PSP as opposed to phones). Thanks.

I have no idea, sorry. I judge games not consoles. Everyone is talking about the Switch right now and even though I have one, it's just a vehicle to play Zelda for me.

I had a Gameboy Color, then a DS, and now a 3DS XL thing. I treat them like normal consoles. I don't get them to play something while I'm out. They sit at home like portable consoles for the apartment. I got the 3DS specifically for Pokemon X (which turned out to be not so great). So I'm not a good person to ask.

I will say that I hate playing games on my phone. The touchscreen is so limited that I can't see it ever making gaming handhelds obsolete but who can say for sure. A lot of games could work well with a simple touchscreen—even some complicated games like Civilization don't need precise, timing-based inputs. And simplified controls like Mario Run also make sense. You can use limitations like that to your advantage in games or even writing—self-imposed restrictions can work wonders for creativity, even though it sounds counterintuitive.

I got my Switch so I could play Zelda for the channel. If it was just for myself I wouldn't have bothered. It's too expensive for what it is, even if it does get a lot more great games. Which I don't think it will.



Henrik S asked:

Hi, Joseph.

  1. What is the funniest game you've ever played?
  2. Assuming you've played them, which of the Half-Life games do you think is the best and why?
  3. I remember there being a debate about game length not too long ago, when The Order 1886 was released to a not so great reception. How long to you think a full price, 60 bucks game has to last in order to be worth it? I know it depends a great deal on the quality of the game but is there a minimum amount of time you feel is necessary? Most people I've talked to seem to put their minimum at 8 to 10 hours.


Afternoon Henrik!

1—Either Portal 1 or Portal 2. No other game that I've played comes close to those two. Some other games can have funny moments but they're the exception to mostly serious character interactions. Other games that go out of their way to be funny end up being cringe-inducing instead. Either with overly juvenile toilet humor (which can work if it's a parody or intentional exaggeration), or non-stop references to pop culture, which is something I'm starting to hate as I get older. It's a cheap way to get laughs.

The Uncharted games have some funny moments too. Those would probably be in second place to the Portals. I've heard good things about The Stick of Truth, and the E3 preview for The Fractured But Whole was really funny too. People have said The Stanley Parable is funny but I haven't played it.

Oh! No, Giants Citizen Kabuto would be second place. That game was fucking funny. But I was a teenager at the time so maybe it doesn't hold up.

The Portals do it so well because all of the jokes have a sinister sub-layer to them. There are some lines that are funny just for the sake of it, but most of them bring some heavy context—how much power GLaDOS has under her control and how ruthless she really is, and then the same thing for another character in Portal 2, but with how incompetent he is. I didn't care as much for Cave Johnson in the second game for this reason—he was a vehicle for some fantastic one liners that are really funny and quotable, but there's nothing really to him underneath that. I guess he does have another function though so maybe that's the reason. I'm trying my best to avoid spoilers here because these are two of the greatest games ever made. Anyone reading this who hasn't played them should do so. They're not long.


2) Assuming you've played them, which of the Half-Life games do you think is the best and why?

If you include Portal 1 and 2, then it would be one of them. But even though they're in the same universe, I don't think this is what you mean.

I've played Half-Life 1 a bunch of times. I've only played Half-Life 2 from start to finish twice. I haven't played Opposing Force or Blue Shift. I don't know if you're counting those.

Despite playing it less, I think Half-Life 2 is the better game of the two main entries in the series. Half-Life 1 was fantastic when I first played it—and it still mostly holds up today as a fun time, it's just not mindblowing anymore—but the second game has more variety in its enemies, locations, mechanics, and all of those physics puzzles. Plus the gravity gun.

Half-Life 1 does have the alien section at the end though which I remember liking a lot. I know other people don't but I thought it was a neat way to have a twist for the finale. Maybe I'd feel differently if I went back and played it though. It's been years and I really don't want to do them again.

And that right there is the biggest problem both games have. Half-Life 1 has that introduction that goes on forever. It's great the first time. Somewhat cool the second time since you notice stuff you didn't understand before. Everytime after that it's terrible. Boring. Same for Half-Life 2. Those long conversations in the lab at the start, being "interrogated", and every single conversation you have with the resistance leaders as you make your way through all of the levels... these are unskippable cut scenes and it makes me want to avoid playing the game again.

Half-Life 2 is way worse than Half-Life 1 in this way. But you can't ignore all the ways it improves on the first game. The shooting is just as good—arguably it's better. The level design is still fantastic with lots of secrets and this strangely fun feeling of finding paths through chaos and destruction—the crumbling lab, the crumbling city. But Half-Life 2 has the vehicle sections which I enjoyed a lot. And Ravenholm is one of the most memorable levels in any shooter I've played. Parts of the highway stick out to me too. The bridge in particular.

Both of these games are still enjoyable today but they're showing their age. I don't think they're timeless classics but, if you played them when they first released then you know how big of a deal they were for the time. It's just like Ocarina of Time and Super Mario 64. They're still good today. But anyone who plays them for the first time and is all "Oh my god the hype was real, so good! SO GOOD!!!!" is just trying to fit in. The later games in the series do everything better, it's just that they weren't RELATIVELY huge improvements over those first 3D games, as they were to the jump from the 2D ones that came before it.

Except for the castle in Mario 64. That "hub world" still hasn't been done better. Same for the map in Super Mario World. Both of those are so creative and are my favorite parts of those games. And Nintendo never did it again.


3) I remember there being a debate about game length not too long ago, when The Order 1886 was released to a not so great reception. How long to you think a full price, 60 bucks game has to last in order to be worth it? I know it depends a great deal on the quality of the game but is there a minimum amount of time you feel is necessary? Most people I've talked to seem to put their minimum at 8 to 10 hours.

Another tough question. I feel like there were more substantial questions for this Q&A. Or maybe some of them were bunched together in the order they came in this time.

Let's try to break this down because I'd like to give a proper answer to this. I just don't know if I'm able to.

Enter the Gungeon is a $15 game that you can beat in about an hour if you are actually capable of beating it. That might not make sense if you haven't played it.

Gungeon is about "runs" through the dungeon that the game takes its name from. It has five floors (spoiler: there might be more than that), and each one has a boss at the end of it. The floors are randomly generated but not in an intense sort of way. It's like Don't Starve in that the generation is there to make everything feel just a little different and fresh for each "run". Because the most important thing about Gungeon is that you will be replaying it a lot.

Gungeon is difficult. It's highly unlikely someone will beat it their first time. There's a lot of enemy variety, weapon variety, tons of items, and a good selection of bosses. You have a lot to learn to get through it. I've beaten the game dozens of times now, including the big secrets, and managed to find over a hundred hours of worthwhile gaming time out of this system that, at its core, is only "one hour long". Each successful run is about that time.

Knowing this, would I have been happy to pay more for Gungeon? Honestly, yes. I think $30 would be a fair price. But a lot of people aren't going to love the game as much as I did. They're not going to become so enthralled with its systems to play it for over a hundred hours. They may only put in 10 or 20. $15 is more inline with that sort of engagement.

However the big point I want to make is that many AAA Games only provide about 10 or 20 hours for $60 and, because of the production values in those games, sometimes they're worth it. And yet, if Gungeon was $60 despite providing over a hundred hours of enjoyment, I think it would be overpriced.

I think I made this point much better in my Diablo 3 video. The amount of hours you can wring out of a game doesn't equate to value. If so, something like Windows Solitaire or Tetris should be some of the most expensive games to buy.

Quality matters far more than quantity. And quality is SO MUCH harder to assess. It's going to vary from person to person. I think the quality in Gungeon is insanely good after a hundred hours, and yet SuperBunnyHop was sick of it after 15 hours or so. He got a dollar an hour of "good" on his purchase. My rate was way better.

But it's not quite as clear cut as this either because quantity still does matter a little. If I paid sixty dollars for a game and it was some of the best gameplay ever—it was like playing my favorite game for the first time all over again!--but it was only an hour long with no replay value? I would feel cheated. So I guess there is a minimum length somewhere in there for each price point.

I'm trying to think of what the cutoff would be for $60 and it's deeply intertwined with quality. "Best game ever" gameplay? I'd say four hours. "Really good"? Maybe six? "Just above average?" Eight. Then it flips over to just average gameplay and I'd argue it'd be detrimental for games to go longer than that. If the game is plain then I wouldn't want to have more than ten hours of stuff to do. Do you know what I mean? Yet this is only judging a game on whether I'd feel ripped off or not. The better the gameplay the longer I would want it to go on.

Heavily scripted, highly linear games can be a hell of a lot of fun. But these are the ones I'm thinking of when I don't want them to go on for too long unless they're interesting to play. With more open systems—I'm playing Breath of the Wild right now—I think you need more content to explore all the possibilities they have. Exploration-based games need actual space for you to do that. That means more playtime. Yet a lot of open world games have too much dead pointless space.

So even there it's a conflict between quality and quantity. There's no straight answer to this. And games like Gungeon that are built to be played and replayed over and over blur those definitions even more.

Maybe a good definition would be: for every ten dollars, you should get at least one hour of good, scripted-level content, or the equivalent level of work that goes into making that translated into whatever sort of game you're playing. A management game can't have a scripted train sequence from Uncharted 2.

Or could it...



Adam H asked:

  1. I find game feel to be a major factor, and sometimes I find the benefits of modern gaming refinements (Even year to year) heavily slant my view/feel when playing a game. An example of this for me is Dark Souls 2. I played it after DeS, DS1, Bloodborne and Dark Souls 3. Regardless of anything else in that game I cannot get over how 'slippery' the combat feels in terms of weight. When you hit an enemy it feels, at least to me, that my weapon just slides across enemies, taking away HP but not really having that feedback I want/expect. This takes me out of the game so much I pretty much stopped playing after the Giant boss. This is entirely a subjective problem, and despite not having played enough of DS2 to really understand what I would like/hate with it because of this. With that example out of the way, what games have you found that you instantly could not 'click' with, that a majority of other players like?
  2. You mentioned in your last Q&A that the Bloodborne series didn't do as well for your channel as you thought it would. I personally enjoyed your Uncharted series despite not liking any of them (I've played 1, 2 and 3, as well as TLOU. I've tried to give them all a chance), but you said that video was a mess, with a slow return at first on the videoes, Have these experiences made you reconsider games you would cover in the future? Or is it more a "Oh this game interests me, lemme make a video about that"?
  3. Do you have any favourite games that are pretty much universally considered mediocre/bad? (Don't say DS2! The internet hates anything new, most people have nothing but good things to say about it now DS3 has been released). For example, I love Alpha Protocol, despite that game being a huge pile of steaming shit, it holds a special place in my heart as the only game to do the whole "Choices" thing well. That game allows your actions to actually shape what happens, and despite all the terribleness that the rest of the game is, I replay it pretty much every year.


Hey Adam. More tough questions. I'll do my best.

1—Game Feel might be the "camera work" of videos games, even though most games also have a camera. In a movie, it doesn't matter how good the story is or the acting or the special effects, if the camera work is so bad that you can't properly see anything then the movie is fucked. This is so important that I don't think I could even name a film that messes this up, although I'm sure a bunch of amateur stuff does. Maybe porn! A lot of porn has horrible camera work.

Game Feel is so heavily connected with a game's controls that maybe they should be lumped together. Chris Wagar has recommended a book on Game Feel to me a few times and I should really buy it already. There was a web version of a lot of points but if I remember right some of the example links weren't working anymore. I think that it might be worth it for a group to make a few "games" to show off some of these concepts. A lot of the language in video games isn't nailed down. Some people don't even know what "Game Feel" means at all. Hell even I might consider it to be a little different than what you think.

Yet it really is so important. What you're describing doesn't bother me in Dark Souls 2. In fact I think DaS2 has a better combat system than DaS1. You're in no ways wrong to feel that way though because it is subjective. And I feel the exact same way about combat in Skyrim. There's no proper response to enemies getting hit and, in both first person and third person perspective, it often doesn't even look like your weapons ever connect with enemy models. Ever. It's this sliding through the air between both of you. There's no depth to it. It's so strange.

I think the last line of my Breath of the Wild video might be something like "If I was Todd Howard, I would be shitting myself right now." BotW is a MUCH better version of Skyrim. I don't know if I can get that line in though. We'll see.

As for games that are usually praised that I can't get into...

Uncharted is the first one that comes to mind. It took me a long time to figure out why everyone loved those games but I didn't. I didn't even like them at first. Especially the first one. I had to meet the game more than halfway to finally understand. I had friends that RAVED about the series and then I played it and felt so much like an outsider.

Fallout 3 would be another. I ended up playing it a lot but it was more like... I had bought an expensive meal so god fucking damn it I'm going to finish it. You know what I mean? I ended up finding a lot of stuff to like in the world but there were long stretches of that game that I forced myself to get through.

Obvious answers are Darkest Dungeon and INSIDE. I don't think I need to repeat the videos here though.

Dota 2 and, to some extent, League of Legends. I don't understand the appeal of Dota 2 at all. It's so awkward to play. League of Legends is so much smoother and yet even then, there's this huge barrier to getting into the game that you have to scale. The community is like a bunch of bitter tribesmen standing on top of that barrier throwing piles of shit at you as you try to climb. You more or less have to have a friend who's already in the game to guide you through that, which might make it so you never fully grasp some of the basics. I often wonder if the only reason it's so popular is because it's free. I've played it a bunch because of that friend and I don't get it. You play for 20 minutes in separate lanes until a big team battle that's like two teenagers dry humping each other's legs in mid-lane until someone lands a spear or a grab or makes a mistake, and then the battle is over in 5 seconds. Often so fast you can't tell what even happened.

I've tried four times to play Bastion and each time I get about 20 minutes further than the time before it. I don't know why but, as you say here, it didn't click with me.

The original BioShock has always felt awkward to me. I understand the acclaim it received for its story (although I still disagree with parts of that), but for its gameplay...

I played FEZ for 50 minutes and then never played it again. I couldn't tell you why. I should give it another chance.

I've tried so many times to get into Terraria and Starbound. I can never get a hook into the game. It feels so wrong to play. In Starbound, I don't know if I'm meant to be digging down as far as I can or just walking along the planet's surface. Both of these feel equally boring. I don't know, maybe I'm playing them wrong.

ICO and The Last Guardian. But that'd be spoilers for the video on them.

There are probably a few more I'm forgetting. Oh! Super Metroid! That's a big one to end on. I've never been able to enjoy it. I got really far on my latest attempt too—like Fallout 3, forcing myself to play it. I love those classic 2D platformers too. I wish I liked it.


2) You mentioned in your last Q&A that the Bloodborne series didn't do as well for your channel as you thought it would. I personally enjoyed your Uncharted series despite not liking any of them (I've played 1, 2 and 3, as well as TLOU. I've tried to give them all a chance), but you said that video was a mess, with a slow return at first on the videoes, Have these experiences made you reconsider games you would cover in the future? Or is it more a "Oh this game interests me, lemme make a video about that"?

It hasn't. But it probably should have. There have been a bunch of Big Games that I've gone out of my way to do for the channel because I think that huge sales = huge playerbase = huge potential viewership. In practice this hasn't worked. It's been controversy that brings in views. Not controversy that I make myself, but a video on a game that's already getting a lot of attention after release. So Fallout 4, how Bethesda made the game, and the disagreement between players, fans, and critics. No Man's Sky speaks for itself. And Hearthstone (which was HUGE for the channel at the time!) was going through a tumultuous period when my video was finished. I got really lucky with that one.

You can sort of see something similar on other channels. The disagreement between fans and reviewers on BioShock Infinite and Dark Souls 2 for Matthewmatosis. The controversy that BunnyHop ended up central to with Konami. And the mess of Mass Effect 3 that MrBTongue made a video on.

My biggest video is The Witness, but that's an outlier. I have no idea why YouTube chose to recommend that one to so many people. And I have no idea why so many people clicked on it. Is it the title? The game? Or just the pretty thumbnail? I have no clue. But usually it's some "drama" around the game that gets a big audience.

I hope I'll never try to chase this. It may appear like I already did with my Three Games To Refund No Man's Sky for, but really I got a lot of requests to talk about those three games and I just wanted to make a video on them. The title was chasing it though and I regret calling it that.

My video on INSIDE didn't do very well even though my opinion was against most reviewers, probably because most people who played it also agree with those reviews. So "self-made" controversy doesn't work the same way. Just like my video response to Breath of the Wild likely won't hit it big either, because most people agree with the review scores. I think the game is great but it's nowhere near 10/10.

I don't go looking for this stuff. I have never tried to have an "edgy" opinion or specifically go out of my way to hipster something. I love a lot of popular games. And I actually get more shit for agreeing with common opinion than I do for disagreeing with it. I've gotten a lot of messages saying LOL YOU LIKE THE LAST OF US, FUCKING DROPPED. Or the same thing because in One Year Later, I said that I still like Fallout 4. Or that I liked BioShock Infinite. I don't love those two games, but apparently just LIKING them is enough to invalidate my entire existence for some people.

A lot of gamers want extreme opinions. It explains why a lot of reviewers only use the top 4 points on their Out of Ten Scale.

Anyway, so going for the popular games isn't always going to be good for attracting new viewers. It didn't work for Bloodborne, Uncharted 4, or even smaller popular games like Darkest Dungeon or Stardew Valley. And of course, it could just be plain luck that my big hit videos got that attention and it could have nothing to do with that controversy. But I can only go with the information I have.

Still, here I am with a Nintendo Switch and Breath of the Wild at release—the first console I've ever bought at launch ever—because I think there'll be an audience for it. So if there is a lesson here I haven't learned it. I'm always debating what games to do, and I weigh how much I think my subscribers will want to hear about it with how much I want to play it. Because that's what I'm trying to push the channel toward now: cater more to current viewers since there are now so many of them, and don't worry about getting new people. They'll come along if they want to.

Thinking back I wonder if the big Uncharted+TLoU and Bloodborne videos are better than I remember. They were gigantic projects that I was so certain would get a lot of attention and then they didn't. The Bloodborne series is the fastest I ever put videos together. I think I made the 80 minute Commentary one in a few days because I stupidly gave myself a short deadline. And then the DLC one was due right after that. Maybe that's making me remember them a bit worse than they actually are. It's also marred by how difficult Souls fans are about any dissenting opinion on their games.

It's so hard to judge your own work.


3) Do you have any favourite games that are pretty much universally considered mediocre/bad? (Don't say DS2! The internet hates anything new, most people have nothing but good things to say about it now DS3 has been released). For example, I love Alpha Protocol, despite that game being a huge pile of steaming shit, it holds a special place in my heart as the only game to do the whole "Choices" thing well. That game allows your actions to actually shape what happens, and despite all the terribleness that the rest of the game is, I replay it pretty much every year.

I read all of the questions as they come in so I can think about the answers for a while. I've been dreading getting to this question, haha. I've been straining so hard to think of an answer. Most games don't get panned, right? And those that do are usually so obscure or unplayable that most people don't bother with them.

Games that are viewed poorly but I still liked a lot...

I really can't think of any, sorry. I can give you a bunch of examples of games that I think are still thought of favorably, but not favorably ENOUGH. For a few I've made videos on:

Uncharted 3 is better than Uncharted 2. And it's a shame that it gets put under the second game so much. Uncharted 4 is also better than both of them but I still see people put Among Thieves at the top spot. I also think The Last of Us has better gameplay than most give it credit for.

Don't Starve has been reviewed as only average by many critics. I'm looking at some metacritic scores for some games as I write this. That's one of my favorite games and I think some people who played it didn't understand what it's trying to do. All niche games are like that really. I want more focused games like that, even if they're not for me.

Furi deserved so much more praise. For some reviewers it was too hard, and yet they were insulted by the easy mode? I don't understand. The game isn't that difficult on normal mode either. It's very forgiving if you're willing to put the time in and master the combat—which is the whole game. Really that's the whole point of the game. If you don't want to master a combat system then you shouldn't be playing it. That would be like playing Doom when you don't want to shoot things. And to call it a poor action game because there's no melee weapon switching is something I can't begin to understand.

Secret of Evermore for the SNES doesn't get a lot of attention and I loved that game. I was surprised when I got a PC later in life and read so many people trashing it on early message boards. I thought it fit right in with a lot of other SNES RPGs. It's not as long as Secret of Mana but I thought it was a better experience overall.

I think Enter the Gungeon is far, far, FAR better than Spelunky and Binding of Isaac, yet I hear way more praise for those two games. Could be that Gungeon is too new. The other games have quite a history.

New Vegas is miles better than Fallout 3 and 4. KoTOR 2 is way more interesting than KoTOR 1. I tried playing Alpha Protocol a few years ago and couldn't stomach more than an hour. I think I got mad about the twist in the opening, after the guards were apparently using live ammunition? Is that explained? Because I went in looking for a great story experience and that killed it for me.

Can I turn this question back onto you? Or anyone else reading this? I more often hear about critics praising a game and it ends up receiving poor user reviews. It's a lot rarer for big sites to pan a game and then players respond saying it's great. And by "pan" I mean 4 or 5 out of 10, not the infamous 8.8. That's still a great score.



Chris B asked:

The last set of answers you provided in your Q&A have really made an impact on me, and I'm specifically impressed with the professionalism and clear passion that you can put into all this work for your patrons. Anyway, I have some technical questions:

  1. What programs and equipment do you use to create videos? Like editing software, capture cards, etc.?
  2. What types of footage do you look to capture when you're recording in game? Do you try to preserve the cinematic layout, or are you ever tempted to rush through and play things "your way"?
  3. Last time you mentioned that you spend a lot of time in "structured writing time". It sounds like a great idea, but how did you first establish that in your home and to yourself?


Hey Chris. Glad to hear you got so much out of it! I figure that, in a manner of speaking, people are paying for this feature. It's a bonus really so it's exactly like that, but some people might be giving more specifically for this type of interaction. So I try to give everyone who asks a question at least an hour of my time for a message back. Sometimes it ends up more than that. Sometimes way less though if the questions are simple. It depends.

1—I get this question a lot on YouTube. I don't mind answering it but I should probably make a video about it at some point. I think a lot of people might want to try making something for themselves and getting some information from an already existing channel can go a long way.

Starting at the most base level: you need a console capable of recording footage, or a computer capable of the same thing. PS4 has this functionality built-in but you'll be transferring a lot of files to your PC at the end of it. I use an Elgato capture card for that part—it's a small black rectangle box that connects between the console and your TV. They're expensive for what they are in my opinion, but that's what you have to do if you want quality footage. I recorded all of Bloodborne, Uncharted, and The Last of Us with the PS4's recorder. It looked okay but not great.

Simply having a computer probably isn't good enough for recording. You need a second hard drive to record to, or else your computer will be overusing your one drive for both writing this new footage you're making, and loading the game you're playing. Please know that I might be giving you outdated information here. I read this a while ago and I needed the extra storage for files anyway, so I'm assuming it's still true. I have three extra hard drives now for footage because I collect so much of it on so many games. High resolution video is very greedy on space.

For recording software you have a lot of options. FRAPS is the classic one. I use nVidia's Shadowplay, which I've read is very light on system resources and still looks good. It's also "free" if you have an nVidia card and use their GeForce Experience thing, which you might not want to do. I've heard OBS is better than both of these but I haven't tried it. You'll want to fiddle with recording quality a bit—make sure you're recording in 60 FPS if that's what you want, the resolution, and bitrate.

So you play your chosen game with a PC that's good enough to run it, or on a console with your Elgato machine making your TV and computer look like they're on an IV drip. The most important bit of tech for this part is pen and paper. Make notes while you play. I'll jot down some times that I noticed things I want to reference in the script later on—an important glitch, or something I want to show about combat or the story. On PC I'll sometimes pause the game and stop the recording, and then start it up again immediately so that the video files are split. Then I'll know there was something important that I need to use in the video at the end of the first file. If that makes sense.

Pen and paper is crucial. Especially on bigger games. You won't be able to remember everything and you need examples.

Next you write your script. I use OpenOffice. It doesn't matter really. This part takes a while.

You'll need to record it next. Some people might put parts of the video together first but I find it far better to have the audio recorded and match all my video examples to that. Sometimes I will do a little bit of video editing first to make sure I can speak about it in the script. Almost all of the examples I had of shitty hitboxes and munched animations in Dark Souls 3 were lined up before I started writing, so that I could actually speak specifically about them. That was important and it'll be a judgement call on when you need to do this.

A good quality microphone is essential here. Don't use a shitty five dollar one like I did for my first few videos. You'll want to mess around with the settings and make sure you're not getting any distortion or clipping (audio gain might be too high. Your microphone might have a dial setting to turn down on the thing itself, or you might have to lower this in your recording software).

Some video editing programs come with audio recording built-in. I personally prefer to use Audacity. It's simple, free, and if you're familiar enough with computers you should be able to get it working. There's a lot of questions and answers on forums about it too since it's so widely used. But if you like your video editing software a lot you might prefer to do that.

I've used PowerDirector 14 for all of my videos so far. I tried a lot of different programs before I settled on that one. Some I couldn't try because they were too expensive. Some people swear by Sony Vegas. Others say Adobe Premiere is the best. Adobe now has a monthly subscription service for Premiere, Photoshop, and I think AfterEffects? It's not cheap but it's not expensive either if you're going to be using it a lot. I'll be switching to this soon because I'm not happy with PowerDirector 14. That said, it was a GREAT program to learn how to do this stuff on because it's so straightforward. But if anyone was starting out I'd recommend exploring other options.

When you're done you produce or render the video. You upload it to YouTube. You can create some fancy thumbnails if you like but I don't do this.

You also need twitter to beg everyone to go watch your stuff.


2) What types of footage do you look to capture when you're recording in game? Do you try to preserve the cinematic layout, or are you ever tempted to rush through and play things "your way"?

I actually just did this in Breath of the Wild last night! There's a semi-regular event called the "blood moon" and I wanted a good shot of Link running under the sky. So the answer is yes, sometimes I try to get a more cinematic look at something while playing.

However, it's far more important that the footage I use is genuine gameplay, so for the most part I just play the game normally. As I've made more videos, I've gotten better at recognizing what I'll need special footage of so I'll go out of my way to act like a camera man for some sections (I'm probably bad at it but I try!).

Othertimes, like in The Witness, SOMA, or even Fallout 4, I can tell I'll need to let part of a story or some imagery play out with a stable view of something. So I'll try to park myself in a pretty place and let the character/recorder play while being as unobtrusive as possible.

I record everything I do while I play. Even first playthroughs. Usually I forget I'm recording if it's a gameplay-heavy title and that's a good thing. I can focus on the game. It's important to always have it running though so I can pull lots of examples. If I try to play a game without the recorder on I end up regretting it, because inevitably something cool happens or there's a glitch I wish I had footage of. This is when pen and paper is essential.

The last thing to know is that I end up repeating a bit of content in some games. Usually bosses. I want those fights to look good in the video, especially if I'm going to criticize them. So if I accidentally opened a menu in the middle of a fight, or if I made a really stupid, simple mistake and ended up eating the floor, then I'll restart and go again.

Oh, and of course sometimes I'll be playing a game just for one specific part. Because it's relevant for a reference in a video on another game. Then the pressure is on to make sure I get it right the first time, and hope I saved beforehand if I didn't. Cheats to skip to later parts can help here. I used a bunch of console commands in New Vegas for less than a minute of footage for the One Year Later video. I'm not playing the game at that point. I'm a camera man.


3) Last time you mentioned that you spend a lot of time in "structured writing time". It sounds like a great idea, but how did you first establish that in your home and to yourself?

Eat the frog.

What?

It's a mindset I think proposed by Mark Twain? And it's been churned into something else since then. Basically it means, each day there's something you have to do that you're dreading. If you do it first thing, before anything else, then your whole day will be that much better. Get it over with. Eat the frog.

I hate writing. Every writer hates writing. They love HAVING WRITTEN. But HATE writing. I think it's more like they hate beginning to write. Once you're into it, you're good. But for myself and many other writers—even for scripts—writing is like a period of self-imposed torturous madness. Do you know how frustrating it can be to try to thread a needle? Or when you're trying to turn a screw and the driver keeps slipping? Writing is like a series of things like that when it's going badly. It just keeps sliding away from your grasp. But even when it's going well it's like trying to grab a bunch of fish out of a bowl and put them in another bowl. It's really hard to make this tangible because it really is like you're going crazy trying to put pieces of something together, while making it look effortless.

That's why I'm sympathetic to video game developers. Because they must do this toward the end of a project, in a team of dozens of people who are each doing this on an individual basis and then trying to make it work with others. That's insane. I'd hate that.

I can only hope I have the chance to do it one day.

For me, it was all about eating the frog. I'd get it over with as soon as I could. That didn't always mean first thing in the morning because I have more pressing responsibilities—and my sleep schedule is rarely set in one place so "morning" for me might mean waking up and immediately going to the store for something we need. But the goal was to get the writing for the day done as soon as possible. That way it could reliably get done, which means it enters that routine phase. Which is arguably the most important part about it.

Now it is also important to say that this doesn't mean I am superman when it comes to writing and I never miss a day. I miss days all the time. Life happens. Big events get in the way. I've found that missing a day or three is recoverable, but anymore than that and it's like reconditioning yourself to a diet or an exercise regimen. And that sucks so bad that I try to avoid it. When I'm really busy with other things I've found that even a few minutes of work or some extensive planning can stretch that grace period a little bit. But the writing does have to happen again. The issue with writers like George RR Martin is that they have constant distractions or aren't entering those productivity phases fast enough. And writers like Stephen King and Brandon Sanderson hardly ever leave them.

I fell out of routine recently with the baby. Which should be a surprise to nobody. I'd probably be a bad father if it DIDN'T happen. So back to eating the frog. Get stuff done. Make it a daily routine. I'm finding it easier to slip back into it than ever before, so maybe that's a sign that the longer you spend in a creative routine the more it becomes a permanent part of you.



arthur D asked:

  1. What do you write your stories on 1st paper, typewriter or straight to the computer?
  2. Any tips for script writing for videos or comics if script writing is the same for all visual media?
  3. Have you tried writing for games, TV, or any other media than books?


Hi Arthur. More writing questions! I remember yours from last time.

1—I don't have a typewriter. I've never used one. Which might be surprising since I live in Toronto, hipster capital of the world. I'd like to try one someday.

I used to write everything by hand but I had to stop that when it added too much typing time later. I used to enjoy that part since I could edit while I transcribed my own work, but eventually I got better at my first drafts so it wasn't that useful. The way I hold a pen is also unusual so I find it painful to write by hand for extended periods of time. I wasn't taught how to hold one properly and it's too ingrained in me to learn another way.

So now it's straight on the computer. Fresh word file. Blinking text cursor. Type a lot. Edit even more. You might prefer a different system. I find I make more mistakes when typing because I can write faster than by hand, but those are easy to fix and I might make new ones when I'm transcribing it from paper. I also like that in a text file I can quickly type up some notes for a scene later on, or an idea I want to include in a future scene. So there's a big "dumping ground" of ideas and quotes and loose lines I want to include at the end of the file, far from what I'm currently writing, that I can also scroll down to see.

I will suggest that the computer has a giant drawback in that you have internet access to distract you. My awful habit when script writing is that after every paragraph I finish I'll want to check twitter or my subscriber count—something like that. Usually I can resist this and write for a while but even with this Q&A, I did it a bunch of times. So it might be worth pulling your ethernet cord or turning off the wifi.

And leaving your phone across the room.


2) Any tips for script writing for videos or comics if script writing is the same for all visual media?

3) Have you tried writing for games, TV, or any other media than books?

I'm not qualified to answer these questions, sorry. I've done no writing for comics. And I haven't done any creative writing for videos. I wrote a script for something as an exercise in school once and I enjoyed it, but I didn't do anything more than that.

The only thing I can say is that you can't ignore the visual part of the process. There have been many times when I watch my videos back months later that I wish I had incorporated more visuals to support what I was saying. I always have some sort of visual reference from the game when I'm speaking about something, but sometimes that isn't enough. Having some sort of example that I can manipulate or zoom in can work much better. Or even going as far as to pause the footage and make it more blatant that I'm backing up what I'm saying on the screen.

This can double or triple your work if you try to do it after you realize, so it's not feasible. If I got to a point in video editing and I decide I want to improve a part, I have to scrap part of what I have, rewrite it, read it aloud into the microphone again, clean up that audio and make sure the background noise is equal to what's already recorded. That I don't sound vastly different (look to the end of my first Fallout 4 video for how jarring that can be when it's done badly), and then slot it into the video editing.

I think what I'm trying to say is that you need more planning. And you need more experience to know what parts should need those more thorough visual examples. It isn't easy and comes with practice.

I can hazard a guess for some creative writing pitfalls: for a comic, you have to be aware that every word of dialogue that you write will take up space on the page and will destroy the visuals created by the artist. The artist, I would think, also has to be aware of when there will be dialogue and therefore plan accordingly but the whole picture still needs to be done. Words aren't as important when you have visuals to tell a story. You can write with those just as well when you're writing the whole plot. Dialogue, even in a novel, is usually less of the story than the narration and describing character actions.

For films and tv, you have budgetary concerns. You might write an epic car crash scene that might be cut in favor of a car breaking down instead, because they couldn't afford to do it. Things change all the time and you have to know what's important for the story. Is that car crash something that's so integral to some sort of subtext or hidden meaning for later? If so, then maybe you should find a way to mark it as that important, or think of a cheaper alternative way to do it in case they can't afford to make it a reality. Same goes for anything that requires special effects, or stunt work, or an acrobatic camera man.

There are limits that come with the strengths of each medium.

Sorry I couldn't give you a better answer here.



Oliver asked:

Hey Jo, my first question would be how are you doing is life treating you alright these days? I would also like to know if you had ever played table top RPGs like DnD or something similar, because I think your story writing and analysis skills would make you an excellent dungeon master.


Hey Oliver. I have never been more stressed than I am right now but I can't complain. I have a wife and two kids and a job where people love what I do. They want more stuff that I produce so how can I be upset about that? I feel like there's a lot of expectations on me right now and I want to be worthy of them, so I'm trying to micromanage it all. It's more difficult than anything I've ever done but maybe that's what success is really all about? I don't know if I am all that successful. It's still new to me. Having just one kid is still new and now I have two. Time passes so quickly now that I feel as though I'm always trying to catch my breath.

But I'm good, I really am. I feel immensely lucky for the first time in my life. I think that might be a big part of it. I don't want to squander these opportunities. I read on reddit recently about something called cherophobia.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aversion_to_happiness

And that's me right there. Obviously I enjoy being happy and I don't think I'm a cynical person even though I may appear so sometimes. But I do obsess over accepting happiness or feeling content will lead to some sort of disaster appearing to balance it. And I'm not superstitious or religious or anything like that either. I don't believe in karma—in fact you could objectively prove that it doesn't exist. But I can't deny I feel this way. I'd be lying if I said I didn't.

For the other part of your question: I've never played any tabletop RPGs or Dungeons and Dragons. I love board games but my family never wanted to play any. When I was a teenager I had some friends that were into Warhammer but I couldn't afford to share that hobby. I did a little bit of Magic but mostly because I liked collecting the cards, not playing the game. Same with the Pokemon TCG.

I don't think I would be a good dungeon master but I'd love to try. I like planning and editing my stories. Responding to players on the fly might be too much for me. I think it would be a lot of work too. I want to try a lot of board games with our boys when they get older. My wife loves them too but there's only ever been two of us. Our family is awful and a big reason why we had kids was to create our own family that we feel we missed out on. So there'll be lots of games and puzzles and stuff like that. Maybe that'll lead to something like D&D. We'll see!



David S

1) Have you thought about making a critique on the witcher series?

Yes.

...

Sorry I can't give much of a detailed answer to this question. I've spoken about it a lot in previous answers in this Q&A and the January one. It's the next big project for the channel and it should be done sometime this year. I can't speak much about the games just yet. The next question prompt should be up soon. Think of three questions I can dig into. I feel bad this is all you got.



And that's all she wrote. Thanks everyone! I'm keeping this outro brief because I want to run back to Zelda. I want that video to be out soon.

Comments

GiantPurplePen15

Day 17: Still haven't finished reading Joseph's Q&A.

Ben Taylor

"Can I turn this question back onto you? Or anyone else reading this? I more often hear about critics praising a game and it ends up receiving poor user reviews. It's a lot rarer for big sites to pan a game and then players respond saying it's great. And by "pan" I mean 4 or 5 out of 10, not the infamous 8.8. That's still a great score." So I'm cheating a bit here given your clarification about a "pan," but I think Splatoon kind of fits the bill. It was averaging professional review scores in the mid-70s right after launch (and for the IGNs of the world, that's definitely a mixed review), but the player base quickly embraced it. This is partly on Nintendo for drip-feeding the content throughout the summer. But I think the larger issue was the "big site hive mind," where all the pro reviewers approached the game thinking, "shooters MUST have voice chat, weapon customization, 25 maps, 110 adjustable settings, custom servers, etc etc," all while completely missing the point. A brightly colored shooter that was inclusive (appealed to male and female, young and old), oozed charm, emphasized teamwork, de-emphasized K/D ratios, and invented a whole new mobility system. In some ways, it was Overwatch before Overwatch.

Riccardo Broccoletti

- Man, if you wanna see some more dual tech in combat done right, I'd urge you to play at least the first Mario&Luigi: Superstar Saga. It's an absolute classic to me, expecially for the snappy, engaging and wacky combat system. Easily my favourite (original-to-)GBA title. - Also, I think you may have already heard of this book from Mark Brown or others, but A Game Design Vocabulary is a book I'd really reccommend to you. It's got surprisingly few definitions for a self-nominated vocabulary, but in part that's a strength of the book, since it manages to condense the basic parts of games and game design in few, very meaningful concepts. It helps a good deal with breaking out of the usual epiphenomena-like terms commonly thrown around ("fluid gameplay", "engaging story" and more assorted formless mist) and actually focusing on the building bricks, the prime movers of the experience. Not that you really need it, but you know, games have had a need for a common, useful vocabulary for a long time, and this piece is a very good step in the right direction. - I'd have to (sadly) agree that controversy/crazes help a good amount with the popularity of longer videos, to justify the average viewer going through that: I'd picture that either some would long to experience a newly-released game in a distilled, yet comprehensive manner, or people in the middle of a craze may come to the video and judging from the length, expect someone with fully-formed—thus likely valid—opinions, that will both settle their uncertainty, AND give them good arguments to throw around in their own discussions. Also there's the people just frothing at the mouth with their OWN opinions, just looking for pieces that either confirm their preexisting view, or that need a bashin' in case they don't quite line up to the gospel. However all that is just a very cynic view, not to mention something that I pulled right out of my ass just now, so I really wouldn't let it influence your process aside from maybe the priority schedule, and even then, within the constraints of everything else: I'd never forgive myself from seeing you burn out from chasing after some receding release date or ongoing drama! Besides, some of those people are less likely to be repeat customers. - Just sayin', but I really value the enthusiasm you put in your critiques (that in turn influences the voice tone, the drive to deconstruct, the attention to details etc.) I may have come for Infinifactory but I surely stayed for the passion (and the insight that springs from it). - Also there's that mail I sent you a bit ago about your books ;) (On that, I don't want to hear any excuses. You've been unthinkably busy, that's plain to see, and besides I'm a patient man) - About those bad games that we ended up liking... For me, I'd nominate Harry Potter 1 for the GBA, also Yoshi's Story for the N64. Infatuations of youth, surely, but nonetheless I played both of them at least twice to completion, or at least did my damnednest to 100% them. It's two of those games that have tried somewhat hard, but have still done something palpably, unquestioningly wrong, to the point it'll be mostly enthusiastic kids willing to overlook those flaws that will be able to enjoy the game. And, apparently I was one of those kids at the time.

Anonymous

im actually a he...