Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey Gaytrons! As I was deciding what ep of "Return to Amish" we were going to do for the March Bi-curious, I realized that the current season 7 is not yet up on D+ (🙄) and the only way for people to watch would be broadcast TLC, the TLC app (with ads), or to buy the episode. This is fucking annoying--sorry about that! However, I wanted to ask: for those who consistently watch the show, is S07 super compelling? Or, is there a bonkers classic ep in the first 6 seasons (those are on D+) that we should cover? I'm leaning towards S6 E10 "The English Makeover," but if you have other suggestions, please leave the episode descriptions or titles in the comments. Tell me what you think--I'm all ears! Pop off, queens!

Comments

Sydney Townsend

Is that the episode where they go to the Lilly Pulitzer store and also go try on bathing suits?! That was a good one!

Lauren Woodward

Previous!!!! They are wild and a perfect example of the human condition

Kylie Dunmire

That’s a good episode! This current season has been good throughout, so it’d be hard for me to choose just one episode.

Jill

S6 E8 is pretty good too. Anything with a big Jeremiah storyline is usually compelling garbage.

Jill

Season 4 is also kind of awesome because WTF is Chapel even doing?

Shelley Kimbo

Whatever y’all do imma listen…

Lisa Morris

Please do an old episode! I'm dying to watch the new season, but I'm waiting for D+ to have it. At least with an old one I would know who you are talking about! Thanks!!

Reality Gays

Another option would be S01 E01, the pilot!

JH

I’ll listen to whatever you post and be happy - too many crazy moments to recommend just one

K8lnmarie

Season 6 is my vote it’s on discovery plus and fairly newish at least we can watch whatever episode on that season with y’all

Tom Buell

The episode where Mary opens the bed and breakfast and the couple leaves after the guy tries to use the outhouse in the dead of winter (season 2 I think?) is pretty funny.

Brenna Parhad

I vote for one this season because watching one of these new kids say “I want to be the first Amish basketball player” and then get absolutely destroyed was beautiful actually, in the most recent episode, we have that, first time Brazilian waxes (which don’t get finished so only half a vagina is waxed), a pregnancy scare, and basically a DARE lecture at a baby shower

Kristina

I’ve never watched the show so an older one would be cool!

Daniella Howard

The latest episode was SO good. But am good with whatever.

Rose P

S3 ep 8- Jeremiah and Carmela get married, Rebecca clashes with her mother in law, and Sabrina deals with her custody issues.

leslie brown

I think an old episode would be great. I've watched the first 3 seasons and there were plenty of good ones early on.

MicaS

Having never watched it, I like the idea of the pilot

LuvyC

OG….the series tells a story from the beginning, and the wacky will make more sense from the beginning.

Cami

I say Pilot as well or a recent episode from the current season.

Jennie

This last weeks episode was pure gold. Amish girls getting a Brazilian!

Amanda K

Def this season. I need to hear the guys’ take on Rosanna’s brother.

Megan

I wish I knew which episode it was where she overheard the other Amish girl having sex and said they sounded like pigs rooting around 🤣

AnitaBonghit 69

The real question is what's the next classless and I swear to god if it's Chantel I can't justify the $15 tier. You said pop off so I was a bitch who said shit

Arden

ENGLISH MAKEOVER Clearly, you have things to say!

ColeenSkygal0330

Because of D+’s broadcasting issues, I vote for a past episode. The English Makeover sounds good. 👍

Sally

I’m just hoping this show is like Sister Wives and sucks Poodle into watching the entire thing. This current season is really good. But, I’ve been watching since it was Breaking Amish- so I’m just excited to hear them talk about it

Kelly Manning

I quit watching this show years ago. I know all reality shows are fake to a extent. But read where this one is totally fake

mess_this_blessica

I’m an awful person, but season 6, episode 5 of Return to Amish. Southern stories y’all.

Jill

Pretty much anything Amish is going to be extremely fake. Still fun to watch here and there.

Izzy Rivers

I second the kiss ep!!!!

Lyndsay Schock

Ugh return to Amish is a bummer lol, can't get through a whole episode

Victoria

D+ is so annoying.

Lissete B

Do S6 E10! or any episode on D+ really

Reality Gays

Thank you ALL! It’s official—We will be doing S06 E10 “English Makeovers” and I will be forcing Mattie to watch a clip of the kiss episode

Lexie Soprano

cover a previous one cause i don’t think the new ones will be on discovery

Marie

Previous 🩵

Brenna Parhad

Though as long as Jeremiah’s terrible attempt to pretend he’s not balding is discussed, I’m happy

Julianne

y'all, i wasn't sure which episode the boys were doing and i assumed season 7, so i went ahead and watched all of season 7... and i'm hooked.