Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

ONE PIECE 1089 SPOILERS!!!

  • SHES A KID 140
  • KID COMPARED TO HIM 276
  • 2023-08-03
  • 416 votes
{'title': 'ONE PIECE 1089 SPOILERS!!!', 'choices': [{'text': 'SHES A KID', 'votes': 140}, {'text': 'KID COMPARED TO HIM', 'votes': 276}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 8, 3, 14, 12, 58, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 416}

Content

WHEN SATURN REFERRED TO BONNEY AS A KID, DID HE ACTUALLY MEANT KID OR A KID IN A SENSE THAT COMPARED TO HIM SHE'S A KID. NGL IM LEFT CONFUSED LOL

Comments

noname

Unless bonney is actually a kid that ate this fruit that makes her grow older then probably compared to him she is a kid makes more sense

Florin

To me at least it wouldn't make sense to call her a kid if it's just the age difference. In that case he could've just said she's young

imaka12

He most likely knows here from Kumas backstory, so he probably just knew her when she was a Kid and still calls her that.

garf

SBS says she’s 24

Brother E

She’s most likely still an actual kid because remember in Chapter 1060 we see Bonney coming out of the water and she’s in the form of a child. And given the little information we have on Kuma’s backstory it seems he aligned with the World Government not that long ago because he was in the Revolutionary Army prior years during Sabo’s flashback. So Bonney is still likely very young and just uses her fruit to manipulate her age.

Sam JoyBoy

Right now she's not a kid, she must be around the same age as Zoro and Sanji or maybe even older. The proof is that we know she's been to Eghead when she was young, Vegapunk told her she has gotten big since he last saw her, also we saw Kuma holding Bonney in his hand before he was transformed into a pacifista, and she looked to be between 5 and 8 years old. Because of that I would say that she's anywhere between 21 and 24 years old right now. So a "kid compared to him".

MartiNReacTs

to me the most confusing part is why is he letting her go??? There must be some past between them of some sort... or between him and bonney's parents/grandparents.... they are okay with killing thousands innocent people, destroying islands, but won't kill someone just because they are a kid?

Bapo224

Neither of the options, I think it's because she's Kuma's daughter (=kid).

Leon

Oda said in a SBS once that Bonney’s actual age is 24

Netsureim114

not to mention, we also saw a glimpse of her childhood with kuma, and kuma looks younger there, so it's safe to assume she's an adult rn

Ben

I think she was transformed into a child when they saw her

Pedro A.

I think the manga is badly translated or Oda lied earlier, because he said that Bonney was 22 (pre timeskip), 24 years old now

i8Grapes

I'm gonna wait for the official because this sentence was a bit weird

Zaj

ch1062: Luffy: You said you've been here before? Bonney: When I was a kid. It was a normal lab back then.

Magic O

Well, one can assume Sea water would nullify her abilities...so taking on the child form in the sea would imply she is actually a child. But due to Oda's writing you never know for sure, unless the narrator talks :D we'll just have to wait for official

Sam JoyBoy

Sea Water doesn't nullily abilities, the devil fruit user just loose is strength, we've seen luffy use is ability underwater multiple time, at arlong park and against Hody Jones. Also when Chopper falls in the sea, he never goes back to his reindeer form. So that's the definite proof, sea water doesn't nullify devil fruit.

Shockzz1234

@Sam JoyBoy Thank you. Biggest misconception in the series is that sea water nullifies abilities. It doesn't. It just makes devil fruit users weaker. That's it. I have no idea to this day where the idea that it nullifies abilities comes from, not once has it ever been stated or shown to do that.

Shockzz1234

She's in her 20s. We already saw her as a child and Kuma looked younger too. DF abilities aren't negated in water, so her being younger when the SHs found her at the start of the arc means nothing. Saturn is just calling her a kid because he's old af, it's very common for old people to call young people "kids", idk why there's so much confusion lol.

Magic O

Thanks for clearing up! Was kinda a brainfart moment on my side :D

Kingslayer

I think once the official comes out it might refer to her being something like small, insignificant, “green”

ronri

give us hero quad tomorrow instead of one piece thx

HarryYeti

Go back to Chapter 1060. When Jewelry Bonney appears she is in child form. Why? Because she was just in sea water. What happens to Devil Fruit users in sea water? Their powers stop working. So if her powers aren't working, then she would revert back to her real age. The answer has been there all along Khan.

HarryYeti

So do you think Luffy would be able to use gear 5 underwater then? It doesn't make sense for Bonney to be able to still use her devil fruit powers, while underwater, to make sure her age is that of a lil girl. Why would it be more important for her to still be a child when she is about to drown? She doesn't turn into a adult until they reach dry land. If she was in her 20s she would have been then a adult the whole time she was in the water.

HarryYeti

The misconception comes from sea prism stone. But that's the key word the "sea." Sea prism stone and the sea do make devil fruit users weaker, but it also makes them unable to use there powers cause they are so weak, which is like nullifying them. For Bonney to be able to still use her devil fruit powers while being weak and almost drowning, only so she can be a child doesn't make since to me. That's going to put more stress on her body to keep her "child form" active while underwater. She would have a better chance at surviving if she were a adult at that time. She would be able to hold more air in her lungs, and give her a little bit longer chance of living. Sure she could still use her powers while underwater, but it doesn't make since for her to be a child at that moment. Unless she actually is....