Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Porting Poll

  • Move the main version to 1.19.4/1.20.1 (or newer) and release patches for 1.16.5 for some extra months 29
  • Stay with 1.16.5 as the main version and release 1.19.4/1.20.1 (or newer) versions whenever time allows 79
  • 2023-08-01
  • —2023-08-31
  • 108 votes
{'title': 'Porting Poll', 'choices': [{'text': 'Move the main version to 1.19.4/1.20.1 (or newer) and release patches for 1.16.5 for some extra months', 'votes': 29}, {'text': 'Stay with 1.16.5 as the main version and release 1.19.4/1.20.1 (or newer) versions whenever time allows', 'votes': 79}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 8, 31, 21, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 8, 1, 16, 57, 52, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 108}

Content

That special time came once again for this mod, the big decision, how to handle new Minecraft versions :)

A. Move the main version to 1.19.4/1.20.1 (or newer) and release patches for 1.16.5 for some extra months

B. Stay with 1.16.5 as the main version and release 1.19.4/1.20.1 (or newer) versions whenever time allows

There are obviously pros and cons on both sides with Minecraft 1.20 notably getting some improvements in its performance and the new stuff of course, while also having that absolute trash report system.

There are also more mods for 1.16.5 however a lot of the new and cool ones (most notably for a lot of people here Valkyrien Skies/Eureka! Ships! combo).

Mac M1 (and beyond probably) users are also known to be unable to play 1.16.5 mods.

Either way you look at it both 1.16.5 and 1.19.4/1.20.1 will still happen, the matter here is what to focus more time on. Cuz if 1.16.5 will be the main focus then a port might take twice as much and release half the builds the 1.16.5 one would for example, with new features taking longer to be ported over.

As of right now 0.10 will still release fully on 1.16.5, as a big chunk of it is already done for it, this poll is more so about future updates.

Polls will be open for the entire month of August.

Note: This poll was also released on discord and forum, and I don't care if you vote on all platforms, results will be aggregated and handled with that in mind

Note2: Not released on Revolt cuz I did not have time to setup bots and all that sorry :(

Comments

Robert

I think 1.16.5 should be be the main. Way more mods to combine with it.

Wynd

While true, a lot of those mods are inactive or outdated, if that's important or not is entirely subjective however

Stephen Jerger

Personally, I liked 1.5.2. What happened to that version? But I think 1.16.5 is the one you should focus on. It's got more mods and I'm not a fan of most of the new features Mojang has been adding.

Wynd

I hope you mean 1.15.2 :)) and in which case, 1.16.5 was simply more popular than it, 1.15 happened because it was more popular than 1.14 and 1.16 was not yet out...so it just kinda snowballed from 1.13 to 1.16 where we are now

F-Jay Playz

I’m scared of wardens so I like 1.16.5

Begemot

I think new versions will open up new opportunities for development, and this is the main thing.

Robert

Well most people agree. Plus with all the extra bs they adding into the newer updates it might be a good idea to just focus on 1.16.5.

Wynd

Sadly a lot of vanilla features are useless or borderline damage the game indeed, but that's why im doing these polls :D

Wynd

Ngl, I'm biased here, but newer versions using newer java versions is soooo good, there are a bunch of small caveats in java that I've always hated, modern java fixed those and I love it...forge also developed a lot over the years so ye for sure....minecraft opportunities tho ?...yeah...not so much, forge and java are the highlights by far (at least for me as a modder).

Andy The Otaku

1.16.5 is the new 1.12.2 and the best of the most recent uptades in my opinion.

Wynd

Honestly both are fine in their own way, porting to smth new is always a lot of work and Imma need to relearn and rewrite a lot of stuff....but even without that as a main version, there's still a fuckton of work to do on 1.16.5 either way...its just not gonna be porting stuff

Ultimate Gamer

I love 1.16.5 cause of the mods and the familiarity with it. I’d probably also be fine with 1.19.4 being the main mod version, but beyond that I have no idea how anything works.