[TAM: Evening the Odds] Chapter 36. (Patreon)

Chapter 36: They want to experiment and explore.

The two girls shared a knowing look, easy smiles and relaxed postures all around. I couldn’t decide if it put me at ease or made me more anxious.

“So… we talked this morning,” Emily began. “I told Megan what I did with you.”

“So in turn I told Emily what I did with you,” Megan continued, her cheeks reddening.

“We were both… well, shocked, really. We got mad at you for all of, like, 20 seconds at most, but in the end we just laughed at the fact we both ended up falling for the same guy.” Emily chuckled.

“I mean, we did kiss you AFTER confessing how we felt about someone else,” Megan added. “Didn’t make much sense getting mad when we knew what we were doing, too.”

My mom always told me I had to always make sure to clean my ears well, and up until now I thought I was doing a good job at it, but it seemed I’d have to redouble my efforts because I couldn’t possibly have heard that right.

“W-What?” I coherently exclaimed.

“We told each other everything,” Megan clarified. “From how good your kiss felt, to how you… used your fingers on me.” She cleared her throat in embarrassment but pushed through. “I even told her how… I’m kind of in love with her.” Megan blushed even deeper as she looked at Emily with an embarrassed smile.

“I told her how I was really curious about all of this, and how I wanted to… explore this side of relationships,” Emily said, returning Megan’s smile. “And eventually, after a little… exploration of our own, the topic came back to you. She told me she really likes you and… to be honest, I think I really like you too.” She squeezed my hand and interlocked her fingers with mine.

“So we decided that, if you were okay with it…” Megan swallowed and took a deep breath. “We’d like to try something.”

“What kind of… something?” My whole body was going numb, and yet my heart was beating dangerously fast. This kind of situation couldn’t be healthy.

“We want the three of us to go out. Together,” Megan said, her voice becoming softer as she spoke. “You and me, you and Emily… Emily and I.”

“We both want to go out with you, we want to go out with each other and… it seems you at least have feelings for us, too?” That tone in Emily’s voice was the most vulnerable I’d ever heard from her up to that point.

Megan swallowed again, and now that they’ve explained everything, their smiles were replaced with nervous, expectant looks as they waited for my response.

It took every fiber of my very being, every ounce of willpower, every last drop of self-restraint to not answer with a big ‘YES’ in this very instant like an over-eager child. The reason? Emma.

I already had a girlfriend whom I really, genuinely loved. Just earlier I was thinking how all this crap happening was just karma catching up to me for getting greedy. Maybe it was something I deserved. 

I would come clean. I wanted to talk about this with Emma first. It was only proper. Though I admit that I was hoping, maybe even expecting, that those affection and love scores of 100 would see me forgiven, at least. There was… also that trait I gave her. The ‘Sharing is Caring’ trait. An impulse purchase precisely for a situation like this, but…

I took a deep, deep breath.

“I… I do. I have feelings for you girls. Very, very strong feelings.” I admitted. “But please, give me some time to think. Just a day will be enough.”

Emily shot me an incredulous look, as if asking, “What is there to think about?”

I answered her unspoken question. “Let’s just say I’m… not in a situation where I can think with my brain.” That caused Megan to giggle and Emily to pull away slightly, though she didn’t release my hand.

“I… see. Well, it IS really a lot to take in, isn’t it?” Emily chuckled. “And you do have a lot on your mind right now. Sorry, I guess I was a little impatient.”

“Though that’s nothing new, just so you know. She’s always impatient,” Megan said with a grin. “Still, let us prove that we’re serious about this.”

“Uh… H-How?” I nervously asked.

Megan took a deep breath and looked at me resolutely. “Let us… make you feel good,” she whispered. And despite that my dick heard her loud and clear because it was already hardening in anticipation all on its own.

My eyebrows shot high up, my jaw half-hung in disbelief. I glanced from Megan to Emily, who pursed her lips but nodded, and then back to Megan, who looked into my eyes as she waited for my answer.

I swallowed hard, or tried to. My mouth felt dry. I heard myself uttering the word ‘Okay,’ but it didn’t feel like I was conscious of what I was saying. It felt too surreal. 

I knew I shouldn’t be accepting this right now, but again, it wasn’t my head doing the thinking. I felt my heart pounding hard, my legs growing weak, my crotch… heating up.

In one way, though, it was the correct answer. Relief washed over the two best friends, clear in their faces. However, there was a hint of anxiety as well. This would be their first time doing it, after all.

“Do you mind if we kiss first?” Megan asked. 

I… I answered by wrapping my arms around their two narrow waists and pulling them closer to me. I had already said yes, and being honest, I needed this.

“Someone’s excited,” Emily giggled, repositioning herself so she had a good angle on my face.

“Yeah, me!” Megan replied and dove straight towards my lips, unceremoniously shoving her tongue inside. We both moand loudly into the other’s mouth. Megan was… surprisingly wild, like a starving lioness. She devoured my mouth and ran her tongue all over the inside of my mouth. I had to return it with equal passion, still holding tightly onto both athletes. After a minute or so, Megan broke our kiss by suddenly pulling away. “Your turn, Em.”

We were both breathing hard, and in my ecstatic rush I turned to look at Emily. Her face was flushed. She licked her lips in anticipation and gave me a few moments to breathe until she slowly closed in. Her kiss was deep and tender, slow. She let her tongue thoroughly savor every corner of my mouth. The change of pace caught me off guard, but I was quick to adapt and returned the kiss eagerly.

It all felt so mind-numbingly good.

I don’t know how long I spent making out with these gorgeous soccer stars. I lost track of time. The physical contact and the… well… the emotional support was doing wonders to lift me up. After what had been undoubtedly my worst day at Hayes Academy, Emily and Megan came and made everything better.

“How do you do it?” Megan asked as she watched me make out with Emily and licking her own lips. “I could kiss you all day. It feels so good.” Emily agreed, moaning into my mouth and interlocking her fingers with mine. It seemed the Great Kisser trait was really paying off, even more than I thought it would.

Megan pulled away to kneel in front of me, unbuckling my belt and unzipping my pants. When Emily noticed, she hastily broke the kiss and went down to join her friend.

“Don’t you dare start without me!” she tells Megan.

“I wasn’t going to.”

I took a deep breath and looked down at the two gorgeous girls, their faces so very close to my crotch. To think things would turn like this. It was hard to ignore the uneasiness I felt, but my lust is reaching critical levels. Neither my mind nor my body were capable of saying no at this point.

Megan pulled down my pants while Emily pulled down my boxers. Their eyes widened in shock when they laid eyes on my cock, fully erect and twitching in anticipation.

“Oh my God!” they exclaimed in unison. “They tell you in Sex Ed. to not expect guys to be porn-star sized, but…” Megan muttered to herself and I saw Emily swallowing hard. They looked up at my face and I could only give them a sheepish smile.

In one of those wordless conversations that only best friends have, they nodded towards each other and I heard Emily quietly count, “1, 2, 3!”

Both girls licked the sides of my shaft. They were hard, resolute licks that went from the base to the tip, sending a strong shock through my whole body. I shivered while hearing the girls giggling. 

Their little laughter only lasted a moment and they quickly went back in. They licked and kissed my long, thick cock like it was a tasty, juicy treat. Honestly, it was kind of sloppy and neither of them could hold a candle to Emma, but holy fuck did this make my brain go crazy. The fact that this was their first blowjob, that two best friends were doing it together, that they offered it to prove how serious they were to be with me… It’s not technique or experience, but the feelings behind every little kiss and every lick that made me shake from pleasure.

I threw my head back and groaned as they kept going, better syncing up with every moment that passed. I felt the warmth and wetness of Megan’s mouth around the head of my cock. Her tongue swirled around it as Emily kept savoring my entire length, running her tongue up and down from one end to the other. They sometimes got in each other’s way, but were quick to fix their angles and start again. This went on for… what? Fifteen minutes or so? Every second I could feel them getting the hang of it a little more.

It happened when they switched to have Emily take me in her mouth. The sensations and feelings overwhelmed me. I gave a quick warning, and though Emily heard it, as noted by her eyes rising to meet mine, she did not heed it. She stayed there like a champ as I came in her mouth, shooting rope after rope into it.

Megan pouted, looking a little disappointed until Emily pressed her lips against hers. The brunette hugged the blonde closer, opening her mouth and letting her use her tongue to share with her the reward for their efforts.

I watched them with warmth filling my chest. As passionate and dirty as their kiss was, it was as if these longtime friends and confidants were reaffirming the bond they feared could be broken. They giggled after swallowing every last drop, erotically licking their lips.

“That was really fun!” Megan said with a smile from ear to ear and practically bouncing from lingering excitement.

“And I always thought it’d taste a lot worse.” The blonde licked her lips again. “But it’s actually not that bad.”

All my strength just fucking left me. As if freed from this mortal coil, I fell back on the bed and lay there with an arm over my forehead. “Girls… that was… just… Wow…” I eloquently added, earning me a chuckle from my friends.

“We’ll leave you with that for now. We have work to do tomorrow, so there’s no time for awkwardness, okay?” Emily told me firmly. “We don’t want you sneaking around and trying to avoid us.”

“Yeah!” Megan nodded strongly. “Let’s leave the details for later. For now, this was just what we wanted. Sound good?”

I swallowed hard. “Got it…” I said with a gasp.

“Great. Now… Good night, David. Sleep well, okay?” Megan leaned over me and sweetly kissed me on the cheek. It would be a very innocent move if my dick wasn’t still hanging there for them to see. Emily mimicked her and both girls said goodbye. It felt a little abrupt, but if they had stayed we would’ve been forced to actually talk about all this and it would’ve gotten awkward.

Really, I couldn’t even imagine how they agreed to propose something like this. I took out my phone and looked up their scores.

[Grant, Megan - Affection Score: 82 / Love Score: 75 / Lust Score: 72]

[Miller, Emily - Affection Score: 73 / Love Score: 52 / Lust Score: 76]

How on earth did Emily make such a big jump in scores? Last time I checked, she had no romantic feelings for me. Now she was at 52? Maybe… Maybe it was a combination of the Sex is Love trait with the kiss and the blowjob? Maybe even things I said? And Megan. Oh boy Megan!

With Emily’s new scores, my points now looked like this: [170 Friendship points / 300 Love points / 115 Lust points]

It… felt good. Everything did. Even as exhausted as I felt, the post-orgasmic bliss cleared my mind. It was something I needed. And now with a clear mind, there was something important I had to do.