Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Eyo!

I'm sure some of you have heard some buzz about Unity (the game engine Rack 2 is using). If you haven't, the short story is that Unity is rolling out an extremely exploitative and ridiculous monetization model that's especially bad for indie developers of F2P games - and importantly, they intend to apply it retroactively, to games already made (or in development) using the old licensing model.

Needless to say, this blows, and everyone (including me) is extremely upset about it. Several developers and publishers have spoken out against Unity, and many people are abandoning the engine moving forward - some even pausing development on current Unity projects.

For the time being, I'm waiting with some tempered (and slighlty pessimistic) hope to see if Unity walks the decision back. I definitely won't be using the engine for future projects, even if they do, but I'd obviously prefer that R2 doesn't get stuck in development any longer than it needs to. Porting, at this point, would be a nightmare.

Anyway, I'll keep you guys posted as we learn more. No matter what happens, this won't affect Rack 1, Midnight Fireworks, Bedplay, Pawstitution, or Spellbound; none of those games use Unity!

Comments

Michael Hunt

There is no feasible way to apply this retroactively. The raw logistics alone would be so wrapped in red tape and coding hell it just doesn't seem like it will actually happen. And given the suspicions of insider trading by I believe the CEO it's possible that this is some high end table shenanigans

Ember

time for Unreal engine 5.3!? :O I'm willing to pay so much more for a game on UE5+ !

JervNorsk

yeah Unity Runtime Fee is pretty scary. Is it possible to open Rack 2 project and get help by your community? Maybe no for a lot of reason, but I still want ask it.

King

Unity messed up big time

Final_Reckoning9

There are pokemon games made with unity so their gonna have to deal with Nintendo and their bloodthirsty lawyers so that's a pretty funny idea

Treble Sketch

Have heard a few game dev friends saying they're likely going to be finishing their current projects before moving on to learn other engines like UE5, Godot, GameMaker or whatever other engine that's out there. I do recommend giving Godot a look! It's come a long way from when I last checked it out 6 years ago, 4.1 looks really good and the 3D engine has hoenstly improved. Gonna look as that as my next engine since it has C# support :P

Mircea Kitsune

Was going to say if you have any games in Unity, consider switching them to Godot instead of abandoning: I think more people have seen where the proprietary model leads and why it's a bad idea to rely on closed source corporate owned engines.

Lazy Mist

Retroactive changes to contracts are illegal basically everywhere in the world, unless all parties involved in the contract agree (which obviously isn't the case with unity). For non-retroactive changes to contracts it differs, but usually it requires either agreement of all involved parties, or alternatively non-agreeing parties must be able to terminate the contract before the changes come into effect. (In the case of unity this would mean that the license to use the unity engine becomes void) However, I am not a lawyer.

Michael Hunt

I mean there is that to But the tech to monitor downloads for this would either be considered an invasion of privacy. At the very least to actively track downloads to that degree would require individual monitoring of devices which in turn would make unity programs close to spyware. Though given the recent actions and the insider trading incident this could be corporate sabotage to tank unity value so it can be bought out by another company.

anonnymousspacething

I saw a posting that sounds like they might be backpedaling faster than the last winning rowing team in the Olympics

rugarou

um theres the rest of the world, then theres china... so i mean....

Bazzal

Even if they backpedal their trust is gone and I say we all just use Unreal and others now. If Unity did a model of lets say.. "Every purchase of any game that uses their engine/Software being used a 20 cents charge would go to Unity." That would of made more sense. But install? The people behind the thought process of that are literally mentally deranged or not in reality.

Gabriel Tolley

we've already waited over 2 years for an update. Someone grab me when half life 3 comes out and the rack 2 update probably wont be far behind.

rugarou

didnt think you were even working on rack 2 I mean no offense, but you havent done anything to it that has translated to us in what 3 yrs? or is there an updated version I have missed? cuz last one was 2020 mate.

Azzy

Been a minute since the last rack 2 update is there any progress we havent heard about since april you made it sound like the update was almost done i think i speak for everyone in asking is there anything NEW you can tell us

Ralathar44

Gotta admit its been a few years so i figured I'd toss him a bit more money and download a new version for my new computer rather than just toss the old one over. Turns out its still the same version. I get that they are juggling multiple projects and as a CPAP user myself Im super glad they got a CPAP, but it's basically vaporware at this point until a new update actually happens.

non_user

Don't worry about the unity install fee thing. It doesn't apply to any games made in the current versions of the engine. So as long as you don't upgrade to the next Unity LTS release which is due to come out in 2024, you can continue development on Rack 2 for as long as you want without owing those scoundrels any extra money.

Azzy

Its been almost 2 months since fek has said anything on the patreon what is going on

Quantum

Ello first time supporter here, just curious on what's going to happen to Rack 2 since it's been 2 month since this post was made and I've heard that Unity backpeddled a bit on the changes. Is the development continuing or is it still in limbo atm Fek?

Fek

Eyo! Unity backpedaled (for now) - I'll be continuing to finish out R2 in Unity, but then I certainly won't be using it for any future projects, just to be safe. (Frankly, I'll most likely stick to 2D games for at least a while after I finish R2; 3D burned me out much faster than I expected)

Branwen

Hopefully Unity gets their act together, I was looking into learning that engine myself

Max RedLine

Ik this is random but, pawstitution? is it a game they have made or can i just not find it?

Azzy

Would be nice to see some updates on rack 2 https://trello.com/b/ULIAJ0Ik/r2ck it seems the trello is just abandon its been 4 years since anything has been updated on the trello

Shady Wulf

I love Rack 2, it has so much potential! Here's hoping you (Fek) find all the love and awesomeness you need to keep on making this great game. Definitely looking forward to seeing what comes next from here on! Also, is there a Discord Server somewhere that I missed out on? I'd love to join and check in there if there is somewhere I can look to for more regular updates. Many thanks!

Azzy

Theres a telegram channel and no there has not been any updates on when rack 2s next update will be out

Fenrir

Getting back into this game after so long, I just looked at this derbacle myself, looks like they pulled their pants down, mooned their customers and crapped on their front door for good measure. That is the technical end of Unity and they can now call it disunity.