Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Comments

Anymouse

My only critique is something that is a modern comic convention that I've always had a problem with: using verbs as sound effects. such as "CATCH!" when someone catches something, "SHOVE!" When someone is pushed out of the way or, in this case "REST". A "CREAK!" to remind us of his mass would, to me, be much better. ("FLUUSSH" works because it is an onomatopea of sorts, like "CRASH"). But, this is a personal issue for me...

Battu

well thanks for letting me know, ill change the sfx, its how i make this comic better with comments like this! this will be updated shortly!

Dave Sanders

I thought Japanese comics did this all the time, which is part of the vibe Gill is going for.

Anymouse

This is a personal peeve of mine, and not an admonition of Gill's wonderful work. It's their comic to do with as they see fit and perhaps I should have held my tongue. My experience with manga (translated AND reversed because I'm desperately monolingual) is that they use lots of subtle sound effects that western comics ignore such as the hiss of a flight of arrows or the patter of rain. I've never seen the use of verbs as sound fx. Not to say they aren't there in some manga, of course. I just haven't seen them.