Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Let's review the Carlos Maza / Stephen Crowder situation

Files

Previews only

The #VoxAdpocalypse

What's happening?

Comments

Daniel Warren

My impression is that Maza is primarily critiquing youtube, and making a case that they have a moral obligation to address their functional material support for homophobic trolls. Particularly if they want to wrap their platform in a rainbow flag for pride month. If youtube did not have a track record for demonetizing and shadow-banning non-explicit LGBT content. They would be in a better position to claim that their hands are tied by their general tendency toward restraint, if they showed restraint towards LGBT content. I think Crowder does have some moral culpability for the fact that he has chosen to cultivate a shoockjock/edgeloard community and that he has a large enough following that naming and denigrating identifiable people is not an inconsequential action. Part of the problem here is that youtube is enforcing editorial oversight, they have to make decisions about issues for which there is no consensus, and there is no winning position. Should youtube be a utility, without editorial oversight? Probably. Would that solve the problem? Not even a little.