Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

DWA! is split down the middle on this...

  • Give me that savory, water-simmered stuff! 18
  • Gotta have those smokey, sensory pleasing grill marks! 73
  • 2020-06-03
  • multiple choice
  • 91 votes
{'title': 'DWA! is split down the middle on this...', 'choices': [{'text': 'Give me that savory, water-simmered stuff!', 'votes': 18}, {'text': 'Gotta have those smokey, sensory pleasing grill marks!', 'votes': 73}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2020, 6, 3, 18, 8, 50, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': True, 'total_votes': 91}

Content

It's a seemingly simple question...or is it?

Do you prefer your hot dogs grilled or boiled? 


Comments

Mr. Propane

Boiled? So you like your hot dawgs flavorless?

Chris Rolison

Is the boiling water old and ripe with the souls of fallen hot dog brethren?

Kevin Mikelonis

Love em grilled. By 'split down the middle' you must be referring to how the dog gets from grilling. Would wave 'em for 45 seconds wrapped in a wet paper towel before boiling

Bryan McQueen

Boiled, with the snap that Chicago intended, but I'm a hot dog purist. I don't expect you to understand, and I'll go back to my cave now, leave me alone. :)

Bryan Foronda

Well at least now we know half of the DWA guys are psychopaths...lol

Waylon Klein

How is this even a question. Griiled!

noel bati

The snap from boiled, unparalleled

Brad Desantis

Hot dog water should be classified as toxic waste.

Ben Roget

If grilling dogs is wrong, I dont wanna be right.

Bryan McQueen

"Take a peek inside the kitchens at Gray’s Papaya in New York, Ben’s Chili Bowl in D.C., Pink’s in L.A., or Lafayette Coney Dogs in Detroit, and you’ll find a number of different cooking methods—not one of which involves a grill."

Bryan McQueen

"The more I thought about this, the more the grill became problematic. The problem is the high, hard-to-regulate heat, which tends to scorch the outside of a dog before the interior temperature is right. Soon I was having flashbacks to cookouts full of blackened wieners, dried out wieners—why had I not realized this before?"

Ryan Durbin

Boiled is wrong that’s it

Travis Tucker

There are a lot of ways to cook meat. But who would choose boiled as their preferred method for any type of meat? (and just to clarify, sous vide doesn't count as boiled since the meat isn't actually touching the water)

Bryan McQueen

Snappy, exactly. got to use the right tool for the job. Glad to see not everyone here is living with their head in the sand! Y'all are living with blinders on!!! To a guy with a hammer everything's a nail!

Nick Allain

I think there needs to be some discussion of the superior sausages. When you grill a hot dog, you're elevating it above the mere boiled-meat status of plebian foodstuffs. You're bringing into an age of civility. Having said that, no hotdog will ever achieve the storied history (or flavor) of traditional sausages. Even the humble ballpark sausage (usually cooked on a griddle, sharing grease with onions and peppers) is a better culinary experience. In conclusion, boiled hotdogs are for troglodytes.

Joe DeBattista

See I like a boiled hot dog too though....but prefer it grilled, but the boiled has its place in my belly as well. As the highest ranking fat man, my opinion is beyond contestation. Haha

Bryan McQueen

You talk a big game about culinary experience, yet you have no regard for properly cooked food? Convince me with data about how to achieve a reliable 155 degrees throughout on a grill and then we can start talking. Signed, Confused and Angry in Scotts Valley

Kevin Grace

Got to be grilled! No char, no care. I wasn't surprised that Brian is in the boiled camp, but the $64k question is who is with him?

Bryan McQueen

You all care more about visual presentation than function. All this dried out weenie talk is making me check the address to make sure I'm not in a stance nation forum! You guys are all probably installing underglow kits as we speak (No disrespect to underglow, I'm down with underglow).

Bryan McQueen

Just Art, Noel, and every chef out there who's intended to present their weenie to the public.

Bryan McQueen

haha. Super down with better wieners, not really a big fan of hot dogs actually so don't have any preferences :).

Adam Hove

Can’t get grill marks or that beautiful casing “snap” if you boil a weenie.

Travis Tucker

this is by far the best part of my day

eminshahh

Prefer grilled, but don’t mind boiled

Kyle Belchem

Where is the “it depends” option? If it’s a Ball Park or Nathan’s hot dog, grilled. If it’s a Casper’s (or any kind of) Frankfurter, which uses a sheep casing, boiled for the snap. So, american hot dog, grilled. German frankfurter, boiled. And yes, there is a distinct difference. Frankfurter is typically all pork. A hot dog is usually beef and pork.

Drew Greenslate

ITT: We learn Bryan boils his sandwich meat

Tom Jutzy

Why is there not an option for turned on a gas station rotisserie? Asking for a friend.

Nick Allain

It's all in the technique. Most people use their grills wrong. They think it's a 1 temperature operation - it's not. A grill should be divided into 2 zones: direct and indirect. Ever wonder why gas grills have two temperature controls? That's because in a lot of cases, you should only use one side at a time! The dogs should be cooked with indirect heat until their internal temp comes up then finished on direct heat for the perfect little grill marks. It's science!

Nick Allain

Also, let's give a shoutsout to the best indirect heat of all time: the smoker. Smoked sausages are the jam.

Liam Cahill

You don’t boil sausages, do you? #grillguy

Kevin malone

I can’t do it. I can’t argue about food with a bunch of car GEWBS.

Kevin Grace

You do, because the internals aren't cooked like a hot dog. However, after boiling you transfer it to the grill to cook the casing! Love a beer-boiled brat that's been seared on the grill, don't get any better for haute cuisine

Ryan Randall

Sounds like whoever grills your wieners doesn't know how to grill a wiener, come over and I'll show you how to dry out a wiener

Adam Hove

If you grilled your dogs, you’d find out and your opinion would be irreversibly altered

Kevin malone

Yeah what do I know though? Seems like this place is full of Wiener experts.

Tom Francis

I prefer them grilled. I've spent enough time in NYC that I've had a dirty water dog from time to time. Each has a place. Can we all agree that the worst way to cook a hot dog is in a microwave? I would just like to add that I have no experience with microwaved hot dogs, and I hope none of you do either.

Travis Tucker

But I live with Mexicans and have eaten plenty of boiled chicken. And let me tell you, that is not the way to cook chicken. I'd happily pan fry my shrimp if I could get boiled meats out of the house.

Alex Staidle

My man Fred Durst was not with it when he spoke of hit dog flavored water. Also I think chocolate star fish is a butt hole?? Limp Bizkit was weird.

Alex Jordan

@Bryan McQueen is this going on a bun or is it going to be eaten out of a cup?

Chris Ryan

If you're younger than 85, you should not be boiling hot dogs. #grandmafoods

Taylor

Grilled until it’s splitting and spitting

Ron Wahlig

I'm just wondering why they are called hot dogs...but I'm too lazy to Google it.

hushypushy

Boiled hot dog is the perfect snack after a nice juicy root canal

Mike Tjensvold

You are all wrong. Souvee before souvee was cool. 😁

Daddy Jamaican

I suggest both. Mix beer, onion, garlic, veggie oil, and red pepper flake in a disposable aluminum pan. Put the pan on the grill, get the liquid boiling and put in the dogs until plump. Take them out and grill on the other side of the grill until caramelized. Great way to spice up your tailgate. Works even better with sausages.

Jason Maciejewski

I’m late but steamed is the only way to do it in Chicago. Grilled isn’t bad but they tend to be saltier and you wouldn’t do that to a high quality Vienna. Also, if you are going to grill make sure you’d team the bun, that’s the game changer