Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Well, here it is. Started on this back in 2024. I think everyone here was excited to see this video, except for one very vocal Patron who made his case, and then left.

As usual, a proper thumbnail and subtitles will be coming in the next day or two.

Files

Self-Driving Car? Yes, it works!

Support The 8-Bit Guy on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/8BitGuy1 Visit my website: http://www.the8bitguy.com/ Unedited video of the drive to Dallas: https://youtu.be/prBBdoJ6fjc 1956 - A future vision of driverless cars: https://youtu.be/F2iRDYnzwtk?si=sId7Uu18iJDk6dg2

Comments

Paul Mills

Glad you mentioned in the full video that you were using HW3. I have a HW3 running v12 and an AI4 car running v13. Glad to see the HW3 car did so well. Also, I love the wrap. If you don’t mind where was it done and are you happy with it?

Gabriel Herman

Thanks for keeping the content coming. It's too bad that there are armchair warriors out there who try to bring others down all the time. I enjoyed the full video. I've used FSD in rural Minnesota areas and it still works well there. Glad it goes okay on busy city streets too

Mels Van Wees

Do the pedals also move? like the wheel. Nice video! Drive home to its home, the factory had me laughing hahahaha

Counter Surprise

Loved your video. I know very little about FSD so thank you for this video! I enjoy that you do an EV or Solar video every once in a while. This one is really good! I don’t drive Tesla but I’m pretty sure this level of FSD unfortunately is not allowed in Europe - only autopilot - which is a shame. Thanks again. Highly informative and entertaining!

Bo Zimmerman

Heya David -- just FYI. Not only is it legal to use the shoulder as a right-turn lane in Texas, but it is also legal to drive in it (briefly) to allow someone to pass you. This is stuff that those of us growing up in rural areas learn. BTW, if someone pulls into the shoulder to allow you to pass, you are also required wave a thank you to them. :)

The 8-Bit Guy

Yeah, I have seen that when driving down rural roads before. Didn’t know about the turn lane though.

The 8-Bit Guy

No the pedals don’t move…. Or at least, I haven’t noticed it. It’s possible the brake moves during a hard stop. But most of the time it uses regen to slow down.

The 8-Bit Guy

A local independent shop called bespoke automotive in pantego, TX.

Jake Bohr

Very interesting video. I want to take a ride in an FSD car now! A few questions if you don't mind. How good is the car at handling imperfections in the road? I know you showed it swerving around the garbage in the highway, but does it know how to handle potholes? What about speed bumps? Also, I noticed in a reply to a comment on an earlier post that you said the car one day said "take control immediately" and disabled FSD. Any reason why? Was there a situation it couldn't handle?

Daniel Sass

My issue with self driving cars isn’t so much the technology, it’s that I don’t believe we should be focusing on advancements in automobiles when climate solutions tend to favor less car dependent development. I’m in the GNSS industry and so my work is very adjacent (and I was even offered a job years ago in the self driving field), and so the technology is fascinating to me from an intellectual point-of-view. I just want our society to focus on transitioning away from the purely car centric development we have in the U.S. and Canada. There’s a YouTube channel called “Not Just Bikes” that did a long dystopian video where he shared his opinion on self driving cars. It was very opinionated because we don’t have proof on how they will affect our society in the long term, but it was interesting.

The 8-Bit Guy

I’ve never seen it avoid a pothole. At least a normal one. I’m not sure I’ve driven over speed bumps yet. As for the “take control” it was because a mobile home going down the freeway started veering into my lane. It didn’t seem to know what to do, so it just disengaged, and I slammed the brake. But that happened months ago on the older version. Not sure how it would react now.

The 8-Bit Guy

Yeah. There are some regulatory hurdles to overcome in a lot of countries. Even here I think Waymo is the only one that can drive around without a human.

Bud Siddhisena

Really enjoyed watching this video and felt it was put together with much consideration. I’ve watch a lot of FSD videos and yet this felt unique. I’ve been an avid FSD user for a while but few yrs ago after v12 release, FSD passed the spouse test and so my wife always drives with it as well.

SantaClaw

Really put me off. There are so many issues with this.

The 8-Bit Guy

Perhaps you could elaborate? Is it a problem with the video production or with the content itself?

Icebones

love this, glad you clarified this and also explained the Mark Rober issues

The 8-Bit Guy

Well I’ve always wished we had a proper public transit here in Texas. But I don’t think it will ever happen.

SantaClaw

Don't let me put you down. You, are a good dude. I just have problems with the object in your video. The issue is Tesla. It is not leading this field. And their approach, is both dangerous, and not actually viable. They do not use the right technology to safely implement this. Visual sensors, aka cameras alone is not enough. Tesla's are lacking essential safety features that most other modern cars have. You need radar and/or lidar in addition to the cameras. They are lacking basic tech, such as emergency breaking systems that you don't have to enable, that isn't disabled if you decide to grab the steering wheel if you are about to crash. You can buy 10 year old cars that have such systems in place. If you look at Mercedes Benz's full self driving cars, they represent a safe and viable solution. https://www.mbusa.com/en/owners/manuals/drive-pilot The biggest difference is that they have more than just visual sensors. Thermal cameras detect living things, . AI identifies if it's a dog, a hamster or a human. Radar detects cars and other obstacles, so does Lidar, even if an oncoming hillbilly with 8 light bars are blinding the cameras. Tesla self driving = A marketing wank, to hype up the company as leading edge, when in fact, they are lagging far behind, and have opted for cheap, inferior tech to seem like they are at the forefront. Your video, in my opinion is somewhat misrepresenting Tesla as having viable, usable, and safe self driving systems. And they do not. The Merc system costs 10 times more, for a reason. It works. It is safe, and it does not turn off the emergency breaking systems if you grab the steering wheel when you are about to crash. I'm sorry, but I get pissed off when people fall for Elon's marketing wank. It's me, not you. I hope you, and your family, has a good day. Much love.

The 8-Bit Guy

So… I’m glad you voiced your concerns. Many of these I’ve heard before, some are new to me. But the reason I tend to brush these off is just my personal experience with it, as you saw in the video….. it works, and it’s constantly getting better.

SantaClaw

Like many things, it works until it doesn't. That's when you'd wish you drove something that actually stopped if you where about to crash. Teslas will disengage auto pilot if you grab the steering wheel. When it does, it turns off any driver assist, inducing automated breaking. That way, Tesla, can, in 9 out of 10 cases say, "autopilot was turned of when he crashed" and "The driver is ultimately responsible". It's somewhat like having an Air-Bag that only works if you don't grab the steering wheel.

Mike in Texas

Heh...there is a pin at your house location...I think it is from your side business?

The 8-Bit Guy

It should be 8-bit productions, LLC… which is the actual legal business name for the 8-bit guy.

Chris Munch

Great video - I love this tech and it's so much better than most people think. I've been watching FSD evolve over years to get to this point, and it's so far ahead of everyone else it's incredible. I know from talking to people who don't follow this stuff that they're convinced this is incredibly unsafe. In fact over Easter I was talking to someone who was telling me how FSD doesn't work and is dangerous, and when I pointed out I've probably watched around close to 100 FSD long-form unedited videos over the years, they told me, nah, those were fake, the 10 second clip on TikTok they watched was the real deal and we're never going to replace humans with robot drivers. Anywho, stay safe from the psychos who will be in full attack mode just seeing the T word, regardless of the context of the video.

The 8-Bit Guy

Well, I think to be fair, I tried it 3 years ago and was not impressed. So anyone who hasn’t experienced it recently probably lt has an outdated view on the topic.

Chris Munch

I think a lot of it is people just like failure videos, and that tends to get likes and views. Personally I'd love to get a Tesla for the FSD, but I work from home and don't really drive enough to justify the cost as my current car is completely paid off. But if I had to do any sort of commute, I'd get one in a second.

J Ruonti

I think the gap between a chimp and drunk human is unfair to the chimp. ;) In fact I'd probably rather ride with a chimp than a drunk.

The 8-Bit Guy

haha.. I think it would depend on how drunk the human was.

The 8-Bit Guy

That sounds like a bizarre set of circumstances. I mean, if I'm taking over, I'm taking over. In fact, if there appears to be any sort of safety concern, the way I'm disengaging is typically by pressing the brake anyway. So I'm already on the brake. But look, I'm not saying it's perfect. I think I made that clear in the video. But I think its much better than most people are giving it credit for, and that was the reason I made the video. I'd also be interested in your opinion of a vehicle, at least one that I can buy in the USA, that has more advanced self-driving? You say Tesla isn't leading the field. But at the same time, I'm not aware of any vehicle I can actually purchase in the USA that can actually drive me around the way mine does. I understand there are some Chinese cars that can do this, but we can't buy those here.

SantaClaw

Let's face it, with full self driving, people are going to be: Sleeping. Reading books. Driving Drunk/inebriated. At the very least, people will not be as alert as they would be if they had to drive the car themselves. Emergency! An obstacle is about to go in-front of the car. The dashboard/car beeps/flashes to alert you! You drop the book, and grab the steering wheel. How long is your reaction time? What happens when you do grab the steering-wheel? The car stops self driving. You are now in charge of stopping. You are traveling 102.67 feet every second at 70 mph. Taking into account reaction time, thinking time, thinking distance, and actually moving your foot to the brake pedal is on avg about 2.3 seconds. At 70, you would have moved 236 feet, before the brakes have started to be applied. IF the car has an actual function emergency breaking system (Tesla does not). It would be fully breaking before you even realize you have to stop. In a situation like that, MOST people, will not be stomping the brake. They will be trying to figure out what is going on, grab the steering wheel, try to comprehend the situation, then decide what to do. That takes time you do not have. There is a reason why no other cars offer full self driving yet. It isn't ready. It isn't safe. Tesla is doing this, so they can have an edge. Tesla, said they had "Auiopilot" back in 2013. That' 12 years ago. And they have been announcing it every single year since they first announced it. "Coming now, Ready Now." etc. They didn't then, and they do not have it now. With the sensors they have on offer, and the liability laws the way they are, Teslas will never be safe enough to be fully self driving. It is just an advanced cruise control. Meaning, YOU are always the driver if an accident occurs. The Mercedes I mentioned do offer safe self driving, but not on every road. No. Because they are a responsible car brand, that actually puts safety first. Like most car-brands do. Tesla, has often put safety in the backseat of looks/styling and rushing tech that isn't ready so they have a sales pitch,that sets them apart from every other car brand.. Take the Cybertruck as a blatant example of stupidity over function. A car so lethal it is illegal in most of Europe. No concern for pedestrian safety at all. Many other brands have pedestrian airbags in the hood. Tesla put stainless knife edges on their truck in stead.

Daniel Sass

It's definitely an uphill battle. I think it's happening some places neighborhood by neighborhood. Some places in Houston do have excellent transit. The problem is there is no way to fix decades of car dependent development overnight. So, cars definitely have their place and will for the foreseeable future. So, it's exciting to see advancements like this! And the technology is fascinating. I just fear it'll divert attention from what proper climate solutions require.

MrHammond

I think soon the automatic driving will be better than a human could possible do! Lawyers and politicians should start making good legislation for that. But the bias problem will also stay around for some time, that might slow things down... Until I (I don't have a driver's license) will be able to use a car :-P. The display with the colored path in front of the car picture reminds me of ETCS level 3 (European Train Control System) for trains, which I think is still nowhere implemented yet: it shows the braking distance, there communication between the vehicles is also a point, but on railway tracks, that is of course easier to implement than on the road. BTW: ETCS does not forsee driverless trains at the moment, which the German predecessor LZB theoretically does.

The 8-Bit Guy

Well, I think there is one big problem with your hypothetical situation. Once FSD is certified to operate the car without a driver, there won't be any disengaging. There won't be any alerting the driver. I mean, what would be the point if there is no driver to alert? I've only had FSD disengage one time, and that was like 4 months ago and 3 major software updates ago. It isn't like autopilot where it just disengages for any little thing that is unusual. So, if there is something that requires hard braking or evasive maneuvers, FSD will have to handle that itself.

SantaClaw

I do have some questions/concerns, first of all: 1. Who will certify it? 2. What is involved in this certification? 3. Who is responsible when an accident occurs? You? Or Tesla? 4. Like I said earlier, a natural, and normal response for anyone with a drivers license if an emergency occurs, is to grab the steering wheel. If, for nothing else, just to have something to hang on to. FSD needs, at minimum, to be difficult to disengage once turned on. Maybe even requiring the car to be stationary. Will, for example, the steering wheel stop being mechanically connected to the wheels? With FSD, can you overpower the car? What happens if you slam on the brakes? Does it turn off FSD? 4. If my 2012 Mercedes thinks I am about to crash, 0r run over someone, It will start emergency breaking, until the car is fully stationary. It does not stop breaking until the car is standing still. That is how, every single car out there should behave. Regardless of the settings you have in your car. Teslas, do not do this today.

The 8-Bit Guy

I don't have great answers for most of this yet. But I think it is safe to assume that once the car can drive without a human, it will have to carry some sort of insurance policy that is tied to that. I'm curious how waymo handles it, since they are already doing this. As for the wheel, the cybertruck has no mechanical linkage, but previous Tesla designs like mine do. Then there's the cybercab, which has no steering wheel at all. I don't have all of the answers. But seeing and experiencing what Tesla has achieved, albeit much later than originally promised, I have faith that they will iron out any remaining issues. And I believe if a human driver can drive safely with 2 eyes, then surely an optical based system with 8 eyes should be able to, in theory, match or exceed a human driver. Whether we are there yet, I don't know. But I think we are really close if not already there. I'd like to get some experience with HW4 or HW5 Teslas, which should be better than mine.

SantaClaw

Self driving is the future, that much has more or less always been clear. Having said that, humans rely on a lot more than Eyes when driving, ears, inner ear/equilibrium, being able to sense angles and direction changes . Experience, and quickly being able to identify dangers that isn't apparent. For example.. What will the Cybercab do in a snowstorm? How does it handle sudden weather changes, aka going from asphalt/pavement to loose gravel, or hitting a patch of black ice? Looking to industries where they have used automation for decades now, in large scale mining self driving machines consume less fuel, have fewer accidents, and are more reliable with less maintenance. That being said, they drive on roads basically without traffic, in pre set lanes that never change, with other machines having 2 way communication to avoid collisions in addition to the sensors, despite all this, they still do have accidents. Big ones. A public road, is almost infinitely dynamic. Safety should always come first. Tesla, decided to do its testing on public roads. And there have been fatalities because of it. https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/feds-say-tesla-autopilot-linked-hundreds-collisions-critical-safety-ga-rcna149512 https://www.cbsnews.com/news/self-driving-vehicles-crash-deaths-elon-musk-tesla-nhtsa-2022/ Etc.

Jason’s Digital Attic

I wouldn't concern yourself at all with the vocal Patron who made his case and left. He needs you more than you need him. For the record I love your blue Tesla.

Markintosh

Nice! The finished version is even better than the preview!

John Tomic

And here I am noticing that the last played song in the car was ABBA and Happy New Year. I had the song playing in my head the whole time! 😅