Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hiya boss . This is the early ad-free version of the latest vid 🙂 PS: I've taught Storm to fist bump! I'll have to show you soon 😄

Files

Simpsons Biggest Blunders: Morally Bankrupt Episodes

https://www.patreon.com/c/phantomstrider Thanks to remaining patrons for the support :) Written by Strider, Video Edited by: Zac Quinn: @zacquinn Channel Pup: @ChannelPup ShadeX: @ShadeX Drake Star: @DrakeStar & Josh Strider Produced & commissioned by Josh Strider (Phantom Strider) Boo artwork by Dre Higbee: https://twitter.com/DreHigbee & Charlie Nin artwork by Charlie PhantomStrider BlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/phantomstrider.bsky.social

Comments

Connor Penfold

Fantastic video as always Strider and what a cute picture of you and Storm! ❤️

JB's Creations

I 100% agree with the last one. My medications are what keep me alive and what allows me to feel motivated to do things and be with people. I hate that The Simpsons would dedicate an episode to shaming that.

Josh Strider

I am really glad to know someone else got my frustration on that one. Re-watching that episode felt so raw and made me so upset. I just really had to make a video about it. Thanks JB.

FRAKTOR

Alas, I feel like that is to be expected with shows as big as The Simpsons. They've got so many episodes under their belt at this point. They aren't all going to stick.

Kurt Cobain Died For Our Sins

I have definitely been bullied for getting really good grades in school and acting a little arrogant about it. It was hard for me to fit in with other people

Melinda Williams

I want to comment on the antidepressant message, but I don't feel like I can because I'm on a new medication now, and I don't know how it's affecting me quite yet. Therefore, my own experience is still kind of "wait and see."

Josh Strider

That's perfectly fair Melinda. If you do have issues, don't forget to talk to your doctor as sometimes it can take some adjustments to find what works for your body.

Leslie Helwig

I had to go on anti-anxiety medicine about three years ago or so. I was afraid to be on any medication because I had heard stuff like that made feelings of suicide higher, however realizing I was misinformed I talked to my doctor. I told her about how hard it was to go to sleep and other issues that were paralyzing me and while things aren't perfect, I can at least shut my brain off a little to sleep and I don't instantly fly into panic mode like I used to. It's changed my life and realtionships for the better and I'm glad it exists.

Wincent, The Hollow Knight

Something that have always bothered me SPECIFICALLY about the crayon in the brain episode... The whole mouse vs homer joke? That is not physically possible for a human to beat. (with few rare extraordinary exceptions) See, mice are naturally faster with faster reflexes than humans. Literally able to react faster than we can compute. A mouse would be faster at pressing a button than a human, that isn't human intelligence in question, that is homer not being able to bypass biological limits. (Especially as a man out of shape) Also, mild ciritcism... I DO think that you did kiiinda undersell the... ehm.. "bad" scene in the Marge gets buff episode. I get that you shouldn't focus on it. I just think it is a HORRENDOUS scene to include in an episode where it is legitimately treated as a joke. Where marge straight up commited an unforgivable crime.

Wincent, The Hollow Knight

Also... NOT defending the episode btw... it is not acceptable that they send the message they do. (like the whole "nuclear powerplant" propaganda the simpsons had been spewing, intentionally or not, for decades.) But... It really feels in keep with Springfield to be the kind of backwards place that would see someone suffering from depression (either medical or from outwards influence) and go "Yeah, we should probably just get them high instead" And invent some extremely cheap and low effort drug that just make you high as a kite and doesn't actually tackle the issue at hand. 100% seems like something they would do. (as a message it is awful tho, 100% agreed)

Zarteryuu

No joke, that antidepressant episode stopped me from taking meds for years, because i was terrified I'd lose myself and be unable to feel anything except fake happiness. It's honestly pretty haunting to me when i watch it now, especially how messed up i was before taking antidepressants. Also, thoughts on the boys of bummer episode? Thats my most hated ep with a terrible moral.

Jeff Jones

As someone on antidepressants, all they do is bring you to normal.

Mara

Finally got to view this. The line “Personally, I’d kill a god to save my family.” Goes unintentionally hard for my artist brain, the thought of such art or animation I would poetically die for. Currently forming the idea in my head.

Josh Strider

A line that absolutely comes from my heart. Glad to see another artist appreciate it too

darkest hour

that's the point of the joke though.

darkest hour

I disagree on the depression episode-the point isn't that anti-anxiety meds are bad or anything, the overall message is that FAR too many kids are being overprescribed meds that they don't actually need because schools assume that every kid needs it. This might be a message that flew over your head since it's a much bigger problem in the USA then anywhere else. There's been controversy over kids i school being forcibly put on prescription meds that messed them up big time when they didn't need them. Meds can be helpful but they shouldn't be prescribed lightly, especially anti-anxiety meds, they can have serious side effects if you're not careful. I could relate to this episode as I went to a special needs school and they actually recommended putting me on Prozac and my mom was having none of it, she was furious at the school for trying to put me on something I did not need in the slightest so I could really relate to Marge in this episode. I don't think the episode is "immoral" at all and I highly doubt anyone decided they don't need meds just cause of that episode.

darkest hour

I'll defend the episode because I don't think the message-"hurr durr anxiety meds are EEEEEEEEEVIL" or anything like that. The message is "don't overprescribe people on prescription meds when they don't actually need them", those things are not to be taken lightly and do have serious side effects if they are abused and not tapered off properly and there has been real controversy over schools forcibly medicating kids who didn't need it and it only made them worse.

darkest hour

The episode was not "Shaming" medication at all, the message is that overprescribing meds to people who don't need them can have dangerous side effects, which is true.

darkest hour

Didn't make me upset at all personally, I could actually relate to the episode because my school actually tried to forcibly put me on Prozac when I didn't need it. That's a problem people with autism have to deal with in the USA at times-schools wanting to forcibly medicate them to "Correct" their behavior and those meds can really screw up kids who don't actually need them. My mom was furious at my school for trying to forcibly drug me so I could really sympathize with Marge's position in this episode and i'll gladly defend it because it was a relief to see an episode I could relate to.

Josh Strider

In regards to people deciding they don't need their meds because of this episode, I can literally point to comments of people who went off trying life-saving meds for years because of this episode. So yes. It affected people who could have deeply used anti-anxiety medication. Even to this day, one of the top comments was someone who was deeply bothered by the mis-information in "the good the bad and the drugly." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q0vLSRgvu7E&lc=Ugz_Nf8e1KDNP7dQ8V94AaABAg Many have a strong distaste for doctor-prescribed drugs in America. And episodes like this gave revoltingly simplstic depictions of anti-depressants that further pushed those stereotypes with mis-information. So yeah. Entitled to your opinion. But strong disagreement from me on alot of your points there.

darkest hour

Sorry but I've just heard too many horror stories from people who had severe negative effects from prescription meds to completely discount this episodes point of view, and because of my own experiences this is something I feel very strongly about, so I cannot in good conscious call this episode "immoral" or anything like that. People really shouldn't be letting a cartoon decide on whether or not they take meds, anyone looking to Simpsons for real life info should maybe think twice about that. To me that speaks to a deeper issue, i'm uncomfortable blaming fictional media for real life incidents for the most part as I feel like that goes too far into Jack Thompson territory(he was a lawyer who used to be famous for accusing video games and fictional media in general of causing real life violence)I personally wouldn't blame the episode for that sort of thing. To me someone taking medication and health advice from a cartoon has other deeper issues going on, so I wouldn't solely blame this episode for it personally. This episode wasn't meant to be a realistic depiction of anti-depressants though, just meant to give the general message of "hey, maybe this sort of thing shouldn't be prescribed to everyone". Big pharma has a LOT to answer for with all of the overdose deaths from those kinds of meds, and while I will admit they have saved lives, sometimes they can and have made people who didn't need them worse off, like i've heard some real nightmare stories about people essentially becoming zombies with no emotions at all after being on those kinds of drugs, and I know that's not everyone, but it does happen and care needs to be taken with those kinds of meds. Again this might stem from a different geographical perspective as prescription med abuse isn't nearly as big of a problem overseas as it is the U.S.. I just shudder to think at what would've happened to me if I had been put on Prozac as a teenager when my school was trying to get me on the stuff.

darkest hour

Never got the hate for "Lisa Goes Gaga" personally, I think it's a damn fine episode, way better then Elon Musk one LOL. Also always dug "Strong Arms of the Ma"

darkest hour

My issue with the Itchy and Scratch Movie episode is how little sense it made even for the time it came out-like realistically how would have Homer been able to stop Bart from say catching the movie on TV or sneaking it from the video store and watching it at someone else's house? It just always breaks my suspension of disbelief. It also annoyed me how Bart got blamed for Maggie running off when Marge and Homer should've been blaming themselves for relying on a ten-year old to look after an infant. it's just not a very good episode.

Josh Strider

I definitely get where you're coming from. I was mis-diagnosed with ADHD as well as a child so I can empathise with your experience at least a little. In regards to saying "don't take health advice from a cartoon" yes, obviously. But I think for me personally, it's a bit like South Park telling parents they should hit their kids instead of give them prescription drugs prescribed by their doctors to deal with ADHD. And then the show saying in response "you shouldn't listen to a TV show." Shows like South Park and the Simpsons often try to prescribe life messages ("I've learned something today"), and people do listen to tv shows since 1920's. I try to be thoughtful with what I say to people as well because I know (some) people trust what i say too. It's why mis-information has been so dangerous in recent years. I'm not claiming the episode should be "banned "or anything. But its a situation where no nuance was added to a very complicated subject. Typically, I just see Simpsons as a bit more sophisicated in it's writing than depicting anti-depressants as halluconagens that change a person's personality. But that being said, it's a very old 17 year old episode. And I appreciate you sharing your perspective on it 🙂 It got me thinking about a subject that was very raw to my heart again.

darkest hour

For me personally I don't expect every episode or show to have nuance personally and I don't think they should be required to(especially not when it comes to certain subjects, like there's no nuance when it comes to say neo-nazis being bad people). It being 17 years old is why I don't judge it too much, as that was before social media became big and back when kids being over-prescribed medication was a very real problem in schools, so I just saw it as the writers giving their take on that sort of thing. It was raw for me as well, but from the opposite perspective. Simpsons may have more sophisticated writing, but that does not mean I always expect them to tackle every aspect of more complicated subject matters. Like I don't hold this show to the same standard as say "Bojack Horseman". I will say i'm not a South Park fan though for a variety of reasons(mainly I don't think it's nearly as funny or clever/brilliant as Matt and Trey seem to think it is), Lindsay Ellis did a really good video essay on Nebula(a platform you might want to consider joining if they'll let you) where she went over the problems with that show.