Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Literally the first show I ever watched. How's it held up since 1990?

Files

Does Fireman Sam S1 hold up today? - Ep 1 - Windy Day

That intro still seriously slaps. I've known this show longer than any other show ever. Written by Strider, PhantomStrider BlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/phantomstrider.bsky.social

Comments

Hannah Vincent

Ah heck yeah! I love stop motion and the theme song is a absolute bop in the earlier series :))

Emilio Vega

Very nice. Seasons 1 2 3 and 4 of fireman sam are Good. But Season 5 is THE GOAT!

Kurt Cobain Died For Our Sins

I'm posting this before watching but I assume it holds up pretty well. I was more of a Postman Pat child myself, though.

M L

I definitely do enjoy the first 4 seasons of this show and I definitely agree with your point that it has aged very well. Plus it helps that it’s available in YouTube here in the US.

Miss Kedabory

I was first exposed to the show through the CGI series, but I do enjoy the older stop motion! I think both versions have their good qualities! (Except Series 6/7. Skip those ones, they suck)

Calvin-Skye

One of the origonal 'this theme song goes far harder than it needs to'. WRT the downed pole, power lines and telephone lines are actually different, so less zapping risk.

Leslie Helwig

I'm so happy you're reviewing these! Thanks Josh. Also if I remember the DVDs I used to watch with my son back in the day Norman becomes quite the little ponce in later episodes.

Garfield_NotNermal

Fair play Strider! 🙌 the YTP in the video caught me off guard 😂 I remember the original run was full of charm and honestly quite funny at times yeah I just realised how convoluted the town becomes in the CGI series they added a feckload of characters and it’s overstimulating to look at 😖 these old ones are chill though

Garfield_NotNermal

Those later episodes are shite aren’t they? I’d seen snippets of them with my sister cus she used to watch it when she was small We had the DVDs with the stop motion episodes from the 80s-90s and 2005 (I think) but she preferred the CGI ones to my mums dismay 💀 it’s rare in the CGI episodes where normans not causing all the fires lmao little bastard is like a preschooler version of Cartman minus the humour and funny voice (not in the stop motion or claymation episodes he was alright there from what I remember)

Jeff Jones

In 1990 I was stationed in Germany until we deployed to Saudi Arabia.

Chris Merrick

This looks like a delightful show. So, you watched this originally back in 1990, before you got into Sonic? Well, that might be because Sonic the Hedgehog was released the following year.

Dishboy Duke

Irish here! The chutney that goes in curry is made with mango and has its origins in India, but here in Ireland and nextdoor in the UK we use our own savory chutneys (often called relish) on cheeses and sandwiches. If you ever feel like revisiting cheese and chutney I'd recommend a tomato chutney such as Ballymaloe Relish or Ploughman's Pickle if you want something closer to Vegemite. That's what my family made for me when I asked for the same thing after seeing the powercut episode.

Enderpigman9

It’s interesting that the first episode of Fireman Sam doesn’t actually have a fire, but I do like that about it. Personally speaking, as someone who grew up on Season 5, there are things that I like more in the CGI Series than in the Classic Series and vice-versa, but I genuinely believe both have their merits. (Except for Season 6…I have issues with other CGI seasons, but Season 6 is on a whole other level.)

Garfield_NotNermal

Gee that detail about the first episode was something I didn’t even pick up on til you mentioned it 😅 I would’ve been a baby when season 5 was released (turns out it was 2003 not 2005 lmao) Just out of curiosity what are the elements you like in the CGI version more than the classic seasons? I struggle to find anything good to say about the CGI series or at least what I’ve seen anyways 😅 if we can argue a lot of the voices are insufferable in the CGI series it sounds like someone got incredibly tipsy and did a mockery of the Welsh accents even if they got actual kids to voice the kid characters it would’ve been a bit better

Enderpigman9

So just to be clear, some of these are subjective, and the CGI seasons are 100% more inconsistent than the Classic Series, but I digress. (And to be clear, this is Seasons 1-4 vs the CGI seasons. Some of these might apply to Season 5, but I’m not taking that season into consideration.) 1. I like that they made Sarah and James more independent from each other, even if there’s times where each of them becomes unlikeable. Twins they may be, but they don’t have to do everything together. And the fact that their parents are actually seen now adds a dynamic in Sam’s family that I really love. (Especially Sam’s relationship with his brother Charlie.) 2. It’s something I only noticed recently, but Penny feels a bit wasted in the two original seasons she appears in. She never even fights a fire. Sure she’s meant to be a Firefighter from Newtown, but couldn’t they have at least let her fight one fire with the boys? I also feel the CGI seasons somehow managed to give Elvis both his best moments (Think saving Sam in Great Fire of Pontypandy and leading Arnold and Ellie in Heroes of the Storm) and also his worst moments. There’s a few more, but I think they’re more subjective and will come down to personal taste. e.g. there are aspects to Norris Steele that make me like him more than Basil Steele, but I wouldn’t say that I think Norris is a better character than Basil. But overall I think both have their merits even if they feel like two different shows. And I’ll definitely take Classic Norman over the CGI Devil any day, even if I think he has his moments.

Garfield_NotNermal

Ah these are some very interesting takes! Would I be right in thinking Season 5 isn't considered because the stop motion was for the 1 season? It's good they distinguished Sarah and James from each other in the later seasons I don't recall them having too much personality in the classic series bar being Sam's niece and nephew and being twins, they were flanderised in the later seasons too their voices grate through me and that's not even the worst part of it. I forgot who Charlie was then I remembered he was a fisherman (I think idk I haven't seen it in ages). Penny was absolutely underutilised in the first 2 seasons you're right there she definitely had a lot of potential there given the points you mentioned she should've put at least 1 fire out with the boys. The CGI version did improve on that for sure. Oh yeah it was cool of Elvis to save Sam there in TGFOP and leading Arnold and Ellie in Heroes of the Storm (never seen it is it any better than TGFOP did?) it's probably just me but I've never liked the name of the town its just a nitpick I have idk why it bugs me, back onto topic I do remember an episode where the photo frame was too small for all 3 firefighters and Steele Elvis wanted Penny to keep the job which was well intentioned but he did go about it the wrong way by making daft mistakes continuously I wasn't too fond of how they dumbed him down even more I get he wasn't supposed to be particularly bright to begin with but idk he was flanderised there also is it just me or does Sam make no mistakes with the CGI episodes? I get he knows how to do his job but I remember he got a bollocking off Steele in the classic seasons a few times, could be a nitpick and I could be wrong. Also I've never heard of Arnold and Ellie are they firefighters aswell? I think my sister outgrew the show by the time they were introduced it's how I even know of the show existing I remember some CGI episodes (The ones I've seen sucked ass and I don't recall an incident where a certain character didn't start or was involved in) Wait, you mean to tell me Basil and Norris are 2 DIFFERENT PEOPLE ALTOGETHER?? Jesus just goes to show you how little I recall of the show am I missing something are they twins or is he the same officer? They were both grey haired and old anyways and had authority. I haven't seen enough of the CGI series to see the merits I guess it's cool enough seeing the town evolve over the years but I miss how calm easygoing it was in the classic seasons it just felt really dramatic and anxiety inducing in the CGI series another reason why I didn't like it there were definitely a few "Oooh shite" moments in the classic seasons. It goes without saying I can't stand norman at all I really do not like that character in the CGI series, hoo boy I got a bone to pick with him, gives gingers a bad rep. I don't remember him being too bad in the classic episodes he did cause mischief and was naughty but it wasn't ever out of malice, but because mischief is funny and to be fair I've certainly chuckled at some of his shenanigans in the first 5 seasons, he definitely had a few moments where he went a bit too far but he did show genuine remorse and didn't repeat them as far as I remember. One good thing I can say abt classic norman was he didn't always start fires or was involved and when he was he didn't seem to know any better I forget he's a little kid like where he had this science set and I think he was trying to concoct a perfume for his mum I forget but I think something went wrong and he was afraid Sam wouldn't have gotten his mum out in time and genuinely remorseful, he was also resourceful at times in the classic era too, in short he was a good kid that was frequently up to something. The CGI series just made him a bloody prick and the spawn of Satan (ok not literally lol) I probably wouldn't loathe him as much if not for that godawful voice, still be like a very toned down version of Cartman but that voice just sends me into a fit of rage and its been over 10 years since my sis watched it, I wasn't too gone on the voice direction in season 5 neither it sounded uncanny same with his mum she sounded uncanny but better than later seasons and he was a bit stupid at times there. I made it this far without bashing the CGI demon surprisingly I could've flat out said I hate that little prick (Not classic or stop motion but CGI) but I wanted to focus on the other aspects first. Season 5 was ok there were some flaws like a few voices were off and the characters looked a little uncanny but the new additions were good from what I can remember and I liked how the characters were calm in emergencies, they utilised Penny more, I can surprisingly remember a lot of episodes and moments from that season and its been over 5 years since I rewatched it, norman was funny most times (moreso his lines than pranks he was a bit stupid that season but not malicious either he wouldnt have locked James in a changing room yeah real good friend right there NOT) and the theme song was a bop still

Enderpigman9

I’ll only touch on a few things, and leave Norman out. So Heroes of the Storm, to me at least, is not just my favourite thing to come out of CGI Sam, but of Fireman Sam in general. It’s what convinced me to give CGI Sam a shot, and while, yes, the do dumb down Elvis, what Heroes of the Storm shows is that while he might not be the smartest on the force, when it matters he’s no less competent then his teammates. And the characterisation of Sam, Steele and Penny is on point, at least for me. This film is what introduced Arnold and Ellie as new Firefighters, and despite Arnold getting more to do than Ellie in the film…in the show, it ended up being the other way around. But I like them both regardless, like every character in CGI Sam, there are episodes where I like them, and there are episodes where I don’t like them, same goes for Penny, Elvis and especially Steele. Oh, and to clarify the Steele thing, Basil and Norris are meant to be the same character, just renamed. I just used the different names to identify the Classic Steele (Basil) from the CGI Steele (Norris). I will say that there is a bit of a sense of self-awareness in some of the later CGI seasons, (10 onwards), which I enjoy but your mileage may vary with that. And there are some episodes in seasons 15 and especially 16 that feel phoned in, but there are some gems. (And the less said about the redesigned Jupiter and the Season 16 Fire Station the better.) Overall, I enjoy both for what they are. Seasons 1-4 are cozy and nice, Season 5 is the one I’m most nostalgic for, (We don’t talk about 6), 7’s a step up from 6, but not by much, Seasons 8 & 9 exist, with that episode you mentioned involving almost everything I like, (well-intentioned and sweet) and don’t like (Being overly dumb) about CGI Elvis, with Elvis, in all his forms, being my favourite character despite the flanderization. 10 and 11 are my favourite seasons (despite the former having the episode where Norman locks James in the change room), while 12, 13, and 14 are fine but are also signals to the flaws of Seasons 15 and 16. So yeah, I’d recommend Seasons 10 and 11 if you want to check out CGI Sam again, but if they’re not your cup of tea, then I don’t think you’ll like any of the other seasons. But that’s okay, different strokes for different folks.

Josh Strider

Hey no way you asked for the same thing too? 😄 Glad it wasn't just me lol. I believe tomato chutney is the only version I've tried before. I wonder how cheese and chutney actually tastes lol. If we weren't both super young when we asked our parents I'd ask your opinion on the taste 😄

Swousey

Small towns here in eastern North America are mostly like this. Everyone seems to know everyone else and a strong sense of community is had by all. I oughta know. I’ve lived in several such rural places.