Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hiya boss 🙂 I'll be focusing on the highest voted main video next but this topic really ignited my passion so I focused on what I knew I could do first. Thank you so much for offering your kind support this month.

Files

The Books Banned in 2026

https://www.patreon.com/c/phantomstrider ⬅️ See Patreon link for free weekly videos - & thanks to remaining patrons for the support 🙂 Written by Strider Video Edited by: Zac Quinn: @ZacQuinn ShadeX: @ShadeX Channel Pup: @ChannelDogYT Castiel: & Josh Strider Produced & commissioned by Josh Strider (Phantom Strider) Boo artwork by Dre Higbee: https://twitter.com/DreHigbee & Charlie Nin artwork by Charlie PhantomStrider BlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/phantomstrider.bsky.social

Comments

Kurt Cobain Died For Our Sins

There are certain books that I don't mind being forbidden. Like, you know, mein Kampf or something like that. But most banned books just feel like parents didn't like it because it shows gay things or whatever.

Monique Star

They didn't bat an eye about the fact that the book had gun violence in it. Look at the society we're in

Monique Star

9:31 Joke's on the list makers: I've already read Part-Time Indian

Chris Merrick

If kids can't watch certain movies without parental consent, certain books should receive the same treatment. It will (hopefully) create open dialogue between them and their parents about why they can or can't read it. When I finally get married and have kids, I intend to never use "because I said so" as a reason.

darkest hour

Honestly there are legit issues with 13 Reasons Why, especially the show. Some argued that it kinda promotes suicide, and the scene where Hannah kills herself in the tub in the season 1 finale was actually removed by Netflix after a few years of being up on there after some accusations that people had actually committed suicide after watching the show. I actually tracked down the original version of that episode out of morbid curiosity and holy shit that scene was disturbing, that made me wince more then any horror film i've ever seen, like goddamn I don't think any scene in a TV show or film will ever disturb me as much as that scene did.

Josh Strider

I agree that there's certain things I would personally never depict in film or television. I gave alot of flack to family guy in the past for giving clear instructions on suicide. I haven't seen the show, but suicide is a subject that needs to be treated with respect and care.

Josh Strider

Was this the scene you meant here? I will say that they're not laughing at the subject matter and are taking it extremely seriously. They're certainly not encouraging the behaviour. But it is still deeply distressing and real. I can understand why it was removed https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79G7WihDjBs&rco=1 The family guy scene certainly makes me angrier as they treat the subject much more lightly. Interestingly, apparently the creators of the show consulted experts on suicide issues before originally depicting the scene.

darkest hour

I'm OK with it being depicted depending on the context, but having a teen character doing it in such a realistic manner is definitely something that the creators should've thought about.

darkest hour

The Family Guy scene was so quick it barely registered for me and most people know not to imitate cartoons, but when you see that kind of thing in live-action it makes it more likely for people to try and do that kind of thing(the show may not have been directly encouraging it, but considering how Hannah's suicide ends up solving a lot of problems it does lead to unfortunate implications) that's why one episode of the American version ofThe Office removed a suicide joke gag in reruns after protests from the American Foundation of Suicide Prevention but you never saw any of the suicide gags for Moe in The Simpsons ever get cut, live-action is treated a lot more strictly then animation is when it comes to this sort of thing. Smarter people then me made some good points about how problematic 13 Reasons Why can potentially be for influencing teens: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S027795361930214X#:~:text=When%20the%20popular%20Netflix%20series,to%20media%20and%20actual%20suicide

Kova

I swear Ellen Hopkins cannot get a break just because she writes about REAL experiences that young people ACTUALLY face daily. I know she’s had some pusback for other reasons too, but her material is real and I myself and people I know can really relate to her writing because of that. Her writing brings awareness to the parts of our world we like to pretend aren’t reality-how we treat children matters, religious institutions/systems faults, trafficking happens to anyone, drug addictions aren’t malicious or lazy in nature. People are too uncomfortable with the reality that the topics she writes about are not only happening, but horribly common. Do I think it should be in school libraries for K-5? No. Just because you don’t want a child picking it up and reading it without understanding it but taking it out of high schools and public libraries like some states are doing/wanting to do with banned books is way too far. Taking it our of middle school libraries is on the line for me, I can see arguments for both ways for that l group because some middle schoolers are still very innocent and can be traumatized by the material if they read it without knowing what it is about (many kids just pick up books out of pressure for school and start reading) while others, especially those who have experienced these things in their lives, may find it comforting or cathartic to read and others may read it to gain a better perspective of life outside their bubble. It builds empathy for those kids who can handle it. So yeah, K-5, I’d say no. 6-8 probably, and high school definitely.