Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I think AI in general has not stayed in its lane.

In 2022 AI programs like Midjourney and others basciyl scraped Billions of images. Compiled them into a Data Center.

The problem with this is they are taking and not giving. Its the intellectual property but they try to EXCUSE that by saying 'Its Learning' which is a bullsh** excuse .

Its Learning or Training off your work. Its like a common thief . And they use Tech to create a facade . Connect it to your Phone and what ever. Its BS.

Ive used NanoBanana but with my own art and its a Blender Filter . Its not legit AI in the sense im Lying to everyone and saying "Hey look at what i drew' . When its a 3d rendering just clearing that up . But you knew that.

Files

Comments

supernet2

It's interesting where people choose to draw the line on data and 'learning.' The reality is that algorithms, automated data collection, and machine learning have been scraping the web, tracking habits, and training systems for decades to power everything from recommendation engines and financial models to targeted ads. ​Nobody batted an eye when back end tech was ingesting massive datasets to optimize commerce or corporate profits. The sudden outrage and branding of AI as 'common theft' usually only happens now that the technology has become consumer facing and directly intersects with creative fields. It’s less about a sudden ethical awakening regarding data consent and more about the fear of personal and professional disruption. Just weird how people think its bad when their using platforms that are heavily utilizing ai on the backend. I don't see the issue. I mean, you and I are using numerous things with embedded ai. For example pateron uses ai. Suddenly its not acceptable because its easily available to all, front facing, vs behind the scenes. I think the real concern is when ai actually has a grasp on morals. Then it becomes a real problem. Like people. Good and bad.

iksbob

What a tone-deaf and misleading response. Just about everyone that was paying attention did not like the idea of their activity being tracked, data assembled into a profile or other such nonsense. It invades their privacy while providing no tangible benefit to the user.

supernet2

People complaining about tracking online didn't stop them from using the web, shopping algorithms, or social media daily. The outrage was abstract until AI started doing something visible. Conflating data tracking privacy concerns with the sudden panic over generative art isn't the same thing. Weird, your still using patreon, which proves my point. You sound like the tone deaf one.

J D

i don't think it's so much "doing something visible" as much as moving into sphere that, culturally, we believe should belong to humans rather than algorithms. people historically haven't been too bothered by algorithms working in the background to help you see more relevant ads— some people, like me, have been VERY bothered by it, but we're privacy conscious— but when subjects such as art, writing, music (humanities) are 'invaded' by something that lacks an essential human essence, it is more intimidating than simple computing. we have no problem with a machine counting from 1 to a billion, but when it starts to write poems we get very concerned. it is part of our human-centric thinking and exceptionalism, and i don't know enough about anthropology to decide whether it's good or bad. what i do know is that artists' work being scraped by AI is very different from shopping habits and post interaction, because artists' work should be protected and copyrighted as it's their way of making a living. then again, nobody came to the defence of shop workers when self-service checkouts took *their* jobs...

Randy Starfru1t

I honestly dont think its going to end with Everyone is Happy. I personally think its about control at the end of the day and the more control they grab without you noticing the better . Meta is getting their Asses Handed to them with Lawsuits going into the Billions for their Framkenstien monster platforms that are self seeking for their benefit . Thats what i think people are outraged about and its becoming like a frankenstien where they cant stop it . Think about that people are not giving them money they are getting sued. Its like a bad pharmaceutical company or Car Manuf . A Tarnished reputation thanks to AI.

supernet2

Yeah i both love and hate ai. You nailed it. It truly boils down to data control. My personal biggest gripe is data control which is why I prefer my local LLM I constantly keep rebuilding and working on, vs say any of the other networked ai. Because then, how much of that data is truly mine? I still favor Google gemini ai but the reality is even googles now training some data when the original premise was that on gemini pro and above tiers that wasn't the case. Its one thing if that data is strictly trained for my variant of a siloed gemini. Its another thing once that data sets used w/out my consent for mass utilization. Thats nolonger personalized but putting my data at risk. Same issues with copilot, but its significantly worse because of how muddled things are in the copilot configuration and roles section(s) depending on which tier is in use. Scribe ai, so many to name, so many tos and how they misuse the data heavily claimed to not be used based on a tier but if you dont dig down and actually disable training info, your data's still at major risk of mismanagement. Totally 100% a control thing. Yeah I can feel your pain on the artist side of things. But generative ai is learning in similar capacity (massively accelerated though) like a artist. The only difference, is that its machine learning vs human. Thats why its important for the laws pertaining to ai usage and copyright to be heavily reviewed. Similar problems but different with ai since humans usually cannot branch into so many styles and methods where as ai, well it can.

supernet2

Also its not just artists work. Its just from the looks of it easiest to emulate and "learn" by machine vs coding. I mean i deal with ai in all faucets of my IT career. Even personal life. But the thing is, ai cant even get things right given how frequently it is wrong and hallucinate. Gotta know their is data poisoning too. Ai cannot differentiate what is bad data from good, to stop it from becoming unusable. Well.. depends on the ai were talking about and what guard rails are in place. All about data control, and how you safeguard your data not just from ai but the ai "trainers" who look over the data ai parses through. The bigger problem is how that violates alota privacy. Gotta really pay attention to each aims subscription tier and personal use logic. Its why LLMs are safer but harder to utilize given lack of trained data sets. On one hand you give up the convenience the other hand you give up privacy.