[Castle] Ch: 82 & 83 [Case Closed] (Patreon)
Content
[12th Precinct] [Later That Afternoon]
The elevator doors opened, and Castle hurried into the bullpen with his coat hanging loosely from one shoulder and his phone clutched in his hand. He moved straight toward Kate's desk, looking considerably more excited than someone who'd spent the past several hours reading reports about aircraft accidents had any right to be.
Kate stood beside the murder board with Travis, studying the photographs and diagrams they'd collected from Zalman Drake's workshop. Ryan was working at his computer nearby.
Castle barely slowed as he approached them.
"Beckett! I know who Zalman Drake was paid to kill!" he announced, waving his phone toward the board. "And you're never going to believe how I figured it out."
Kate glanced toward him with a small smile. "Christian Dahl."
Castle stopped.
His mouth remained slightly open as he looked between Kate and Travis, apparently waiting for one of them to explain how she'd managed to steal his dramatic revelation.
"Wait, how did you know about Christian Dahl?" Castle asked, lowering his phone with visible disappointment.
Kate stepped aside and pointed toward the murder board, where a photograph of a small private aircraft had been placed beside Zalman's reconstructed schematics. Below it was a newspaper article featuring billionaire philanthropist Christian Dahl standing proudly beside his plane.
"Because we finally connected Lanie's organophosphate findings to the explosion reports," Kate explained. "Christian Dahl was attempting to break an aviation speed record when his plane exploded in midair. The accident happened around the same period Zalman was killed."
Castle stared at the photograph for several seconds before looking back toward her.
"That's exactly what I found!" he exclaimed. "Dahl was preparing for this spectacular record-breaking flight, and Zalman was secretly designing mechanical equipment and buying enough C4 to destroy the aircraft. Somebody hired him to arrange Dahl's death, then murdered Zalman to cover up the entire thing."
Travis, who'd been leaning against his desk, gave Castle an amused look before picking up another folder. "That's one possibility," he replied. "Although I found something about Dahl that makes the whole situation considerably more interesting."
Castle immediately turned toward him. "Please tell me you've discovered he was secretly a supervillain with an underground laboratory filled with dangerous weapons and a ray-gun."
"I'd personally prefer a lightsaber, but sadly no. He ain't a supervillain," Travis said as he opened the folder and placed several documents on the desk. "At the time of Dahl's supposed death, the Securities and Exchange Commission was investigating him for massive financial fraud."
Kate leaned closer while Castle examined the first page. Travis continued explaining what he'd uncovered while going through Dahl's business history.
"Dahl built his reputation as a brilliant investor and generous philanthropist. People trusted him with their money because he consistently reported incredible returns, even when the market was doing terribly. The problem was those returns never existed."
Castle's expression became more serious as he started reading the financial summary.
Travis tapped one of the documents. "The SEC believed Dahl was running a massive Ponzi scheme. He was using money from new investors to pay earlier investors while falsifying stock returns and financial statements. Most of the money his clients thought they'd earned was completely imaginary."
Kate frowned as she examined the investigation timeline. "How close were they to charging him?"
"According to the records, the SEC was only a couple of weeks away from referring the completed case for criminal prosecution," Travis answered. "Federal prosecutors were preparing charges that could've put Dahl in prison for fifty years. His entire reputation was about to collapse, and everybody who'd trusted him with their savings was going to discover they'd been robbed."
Castle slowly lowered the paper.
For several seconds, he looked toward Christian Dahl's photograph without speaking. Then his eyes moved to the mechanical arm schematic beside it.
His expression changed.
"Wait a minute," Castle said, stepping closer to the murder board. "Dahl knew he was about to lose everything. His money, reputation, freedom, the entire billionaire philanthropist act. He needed a way out before the investigation became public."
Travis watched him with a satisfied expression. "Keep going."
Castle pointed toward the aircraft photograph as his excitement returned.
"He didn't hire Zalman to kill somebody. He hired Zalman to make himself disappear! The plane explosion was his grand finale, and the mechanical arm was part of the illusion."
Kate folded her arms while considering the theory.
Castle continued, barely stopping long enough to breathe. "Think about it. Dahl stages a spectacular aviation disaster in front of an audience, everybody believes he's dead, and the federal investigation loses its star defendant. Meanwhile, Dahl slips away with whatever money he managed to hide."
"And Zalman would be the only person who knew exactly how the disappearance worked," Travis added.
Castle snapped his fingers and pointed toward him. "Which makes Zalman a loose end! Dahl couldn't risk someone revealing that the world's most famous dead billionaire was still walking around somewhere, so he killed the magician and staged his death as a suicide."
Kate looked from the aircraft photograph to the cut-up plans.
The theory explained several things, including why Zalman had suddenly become confident about saving his financially troubled shop. A secret arrangement with a billionaire could certainly provide enough money to solve those problems.
However, the explanation still had a considerable weakness.
"It's a good theory," Kate admitted. "But it's still conjecture. We don't have proof that Dahl survived the explosion, that Zalman helped him escape, or that Dahl had anything to do with Zalman's murder."
Castle opened his mouth to argue, but Kate raised one finger before he could begin.
"Right now, all we've got is a suspicious plane crash, some explosives, and blueprints for a mechanical arm," she continued. "That's enough to investigate. It isn't enough to establish what actually happened."
Travis nodded as he looked toward the aircraft photograph. "Which is why we need to find out exactly what happened before that plane took off."
Ryan approached from his desk with an excited expression.
"Then you're going to love what I just got," he said, holding up a folder. "The FAA is sending us the footage of Dahl's takeoff. They had cameras covering the preparation area and the runway because the record attempt was being documented."
Kate turned toward him immediately. "Can we watch it?"
Ryan nodded and returned to his computer. "The file just finished transferring. Give me a second to get everything running."
The others gathered around his monitor while Ryan opened the video.
The first few seconds showed a small private airfield on a bright morning. Several spectators stood behind barriers near the preparation area, while members of the ground crew moved around a sleek aircraft positioned outside its hangar.
Christian Dahl appeared beside the plane wearing a flight suit, sunglasses, and an expensive-looking watch. He smiled toward the cameras before turning toward the cockpit.
Castle leaned closer. "There's our supposedly doomed billionaire."
Kate watched Dahl climb into the cockpit and begin his preflight preparations. Ground crew members moved around the aircraft while the camera occasionally shifted toward the spectators waiting for the record attempt to begin.
Then a white catering van entered the frame.
It drove directly in front of the plane, blocking most of the camera's view.
Kate immediately leaned forward.
"Hold it there."
Ryan paused the recording.
Kate pointed toward the logo printed across the van's side. "That logo. We saw the exact same one inside Zalman's workshop."
Travis examined the frozen image before nodding. "Yeah, I remember seeing it on one of the delivery containers near his workbench."
Ryan resumed the footage.
The driver's door opened, and a man climbed out wearing a catering uniform. He walked around the vehicle, opened the rear doors, and unloaded a large rectangular meal crate onto a wheeled trolley.
Castle leaned closer until his face was nearly level with the screen.
"That's Zalman Drake."
Kate studied the driver's face as he turned toward the camera for a brief moment. The resemblance to their victim was unmistakable.
Travis nodded. "And there's our delivery. Zalman used that crate to bring the equipment and explosives onto Dahl's plane."
They watched Zalman wheel the crate behind the van, disappearing from the camera's view. Several minutes passed before he reappeared with the same trolley and crate, then loaded everything back into the vehicle.
The van eventually pulled away.
The aircraft was visible again, and someone sitting inside the cockpit lifted a hand toward the spectators.
A thumbs-up.
The crowd responded enthusiastically.
Castle smiled as he watched the plane begin moving toward the runway. "There he goes, giving everyone one last wave before his spectacular disappearance."
Travis didn't answer.
He'd leaned closer to the screen, his eyes narrowing as the aircraft moved through the frame. 'Hahaha. Gottcha motherfucker!'
"Ryan, play that again," Travis said, pointing toward the monitor. "Start from when the catering van pulls away."
Ryan rewound the footage.
They watched the van leave, revealing the aircraft and the pilot sitting inside.
The hand rose again.
Travis studied the movement carefully.
"Pause it there."
Ryan stopped the recording.
Travis moved closer and pointed toward the pilot's arm. "Look at the way that hand moves. There's almost no natural movement in the shoulder, and the wrist stays at exactly the same angle."
Kate leaned forward as Ryan advanced the footage frame by frame.
The pilot's arm moved upward in a strangely controlled motion, then lowered without any visible adjustment of the torso. Through the cockpit window, the figure's head also remained remarkably still.
Travis pointed toward the screen again.
"That's a dummy."
Castle stared at him. "You're saying Dahl wasn't inside the plane when it took off?"
"Exactly," Travis replied. "The catering van blocked the camera while Zalman switched Dahl with the dummy. Look at how the figure moves after the van leaves. Every movement is stiff and mechanical."
Ryan continued playing the recording.
They watched the aircraft begin taxiing, the figure inside maintaining almost exactly the same posture throughout the movement.
Kate's eyes moved toward the reconstructed schematics on the nearby table.
"The mechanical arm," she murmured.
Travis snapped his fingers. "Yep! A remotely operated mechanism capable of manipulating the aircraft's controls. The dummy made it look like Dahl was still sitting in the cockpit, while the mechanical equipment handled the necessary movements."
Castle looked toward the recording again, his excitement growing.
"And the box provided the perfect transportation method," he said. "Zalman brought the dummy inside, switched it with Dahl while the van concealed everything, then used the same crate to get Dahl off the aircraft without anybody noticing."
Travis nodded. "Dahl went through the entire performance, right up until the moment the cameras couldn't see him. After that, Zalman completed the illusion with the dummy and the mechanical system."
Kate studied the footage as the aircraft accelerated down the runway.
"And somewhere during the flight, the C4 detonated," she said. "Everyone watching believed Dahl had died attempting to break his speed record."
Castle turned toward the murder board. "The billionaire pulls off the greatest disappearing act of his life, and the magician who made it possible knows exactly where the secret is buried."
Travis folded his arms. "So Dahl removes the one person who could expose him. Zalman gets murdered, the suicide note is planted, and Christian Dahl remains officially dead."
Kate looked between the two men.
"Assuming he's alive, he's probably already disappeared into a country without an extradition treaty," she said. "He's had plenty of time to prepare, and a man with his resources could vanish almost anywhere."
Castle remained quiet for a moment, staring thoughtfully at Dahl's photograph.
Then a familiar smile slowly appeared.
"Except Christian Dahl isn't the kind of man who enjoys being invisible," Castle said. "Look at his entire life. Charity galas, newspaper interviews, record attempts, public appearances. Everything he did needed an audience."
Travis raised an eyebrow. "What are you thinking?"
Castle's smile widened as he looked toward Kate.
"I think I've got an idea."
...
...
[Christian Dahl's Memorial Service]
The church was crowded with mourners, reporters, and too many investors who had been grieving their missing money rather than the man of the hour. A large portrait of Christian Dahl stood near the entrance, surrounded by white flowers.
Kate waited near the back beside Castle, who looked far too pleased with his own idea.
"If you're right, we're about to arrest a man at his own funeral," She murmured, watching another group of mourners enter. "That's going to be difficult to explain to the captain."
Castle adjusted his tie. "Think of it from Dahl's perspective. He's spent years making sure every room knows when Christian Dahl arrives. Now the entire city is mourning him, and he's supposed to miss the performance? Dahl likes an audience. He's going to want to hear the speeches, watch the tears, and enjoy his own legend."
Kate studied the guests while a speaker praised Dahl's charitable work. Several people seemed more interested in the cameras than the service.
Then she noticed a man standing near the side aisle.
He wore an ordinary dark coat, with long brown hair brushing his collar and a thick beard covering much of his face. His posture was slightly hunched, and he kept his head lowered whenever somebody passed. Yet every time the speaker mentioned Dahl's achievements, his attention lifted toward the front.
Kate watched him turn his head. The hairline looked strange beneath the church lights, and the skin around one cheek seemed smoother than the rest of his face. When he shifted, she caught a glimpse of makeup near the edge of his beard.
"I think our billionaire just attended his own funeral."
Castle followed her gaze with growing delight. "Bingo!"
Kate left him beside the pew and made her way toward the side aisle. The man noticed her approach almost immediately. His expression remained calm until she stopped in front of him and opened her badge where he could see it.
"NYPD, Mr. Dahl," Kate said quietly. "We need to have a conversation outside."
He froze, then pushed past a startled mourner and ran for the side exit.
Kate drew her weapon as she followed him through the doorway. "NYPD, stop right where you are!"
Dahl reached the small passage beyond the church and stopped just as abruptly. Ryan stood at the opposite end with his gun drawn, leaving Dahl staring at two armed detectives and a locked service gate between them.
"Hands where I can see them," Ryan ordered, keeping his voice firm as Kate moved into position behind their suspect.
Dahl searched for an escape route, then raised his hands as Kate approached with the cuffs.
Castle appeared in the doorway, delighted. "I have to admit, Christian, your return from the dead needed a stronger third act."
...
[Later] [12th Precinct]
Christian Dahl sat across from Kate and Castle inside the interrogation room, his false beard and long-haired wig now resting inside an evidence bag on the table. Without the disguise, he looked exactly like the man on their murder board.
Kate laid out photographs of Dahl's aircraft and Zalman's reconstructed mechanical arm. "You knew the SEC was preparing criminal charges. You were facing decades in prison, and your investors were about to discover that the returns you promised them were fabricated."
Dahl leaned back with an amused smile. "Congratulations on the investigative breakthrough, Detective. You've discovered that wealthy people sometimes have legal problems. Shall I applaud?"
Castle leaned forward and slid the airfield photograph closer. "You also discovered a wonderful solution. Pay a magician to make you disappear, leave a dummy in the cockpit, and let an expensive plane explode while the world watches."
Kate pointed to the catering van. "Zalman used that crate to bring the dummy aboard and take you away. The mechanical arm controlled the aircraft while everyone thought you were flying."
Dahl laughed openly this time. "Do you two make up stories whenever you can't solve a crime? Because that's quite an imagination you've got working in here."
Kate pushed forward Zalman's crime-scene photograph. "Drake knew you were alive. He knew how the illusion worked, and he could've exposed everything. You killed him and staged his death as a suicide."
"That's a very entertaining accusation," Dahl replied, folding his arms. "Unfortunately, I haven't heard anything resembling proof. Perhaps you should consider writing fiction for a living."
Castle gave him a wounded look. "I already do, and I would've given your escape a much better ending."
Dahl shook his head and began rising slightly from his chair. Then he suddenly stopped. "What the..." Something pale had appeared in the dark glass beyond Kate's shoulder. Dahl stared at it, his mouth slowly opening as a familiar face took shape against the reflection.
Zalman Drake, soaked in water, stood there, looking directly at him.
Dahl gripped the edge of the table. "What the hell is that?"
Kate looked over her shoulder, finding only the ordinary observation mirror. "What's wrong, Mr. Dahl? Are you feeling alright?"
"You know exactly what's wrong!" Dahl snapped, pointing toward the glass. "You're doing something to me. Both of you are making that happen!"
Castle glanced around with an expression of genuine confusion. "What exactly are we making happen? You're going to have to be a little more specific." He had no idead what was going on.
The figure vanished. Dahl blinked hard and pushed himself farther back in his chair, breathing quickly as he searched the room. He tried to steady his breathing.
Then Zalman's face reappeared in the mirror, illuminated by a pale wash of light and white, ghastly eyes.
Dahl jumped to his feet so violently that his chair fell behind him. "You can't possibly be here! I killed you myself!"
Kate kept her eyes on him as the recorder continued running.
Dahl stared at the mirror, his face drained of color. "I killed Zalman with my own hands! He was supposed to stay dead! You..." He pointed at the mirror. "...this isn't possible."
Kate rose slowly, leaving him nowhere to hide from what he'd just said. "Christian Dahl, you're under arrest for the murder of Zalman Drake."
Ryan entered with a uniformed officer and led Dahl away in cuffs. He kept looking toward the mirror, demanding to know where Zalman had gone.
Kate watched the door close behind them before turning toward Castle. "You didn't know about that, did you?"
Castle shook his head slowly. "For once, Beckett, somebody else arranged the grand reveal. I'm almost offended I wasn't invited to rehearse."
The door to the adjoining room opened, and Travis emerged with Tobias Strange and Edmund Drake. Edmund was soaked in water and wore makeup that gave his face the pale, recognizable appearance of his dead twin, while Tobias carried a compact lighting device and a folded reflective panel.
Travis looked toward Kate with a satisfied grin. "Figured Dahl might be a little more talkative if his favorite loose end showed up to haunt him. I called these two while you were collecting him from the funeral."
Kate glanced from Edmund to the observation glass. "You could've warned me before turning my interrogation room into a magic show."
"Would've ruined the surprise," Travis replied, nodding toward the two magicians. "Besides, they did the difficult part. I just helped arrange the audience."
Kate smiled at Tobias and Edmund. "Thank you, both of you. We might've been arguing with Dahl all night without your help."
Tobias inclined his head, looking pleased with the result. "It was a pleasure. Zalman designed some extraordinary illusions over the years. Using a little of that knowledge to help find his killer seemed appropriate."
Edmund looked toward the closed interrogation-room door. "I'm glad I could help find my brother's killer. Tobias and I have been talking, and we're going to try keeping Zalman's magic shop alive. He would've wanted that."
Kate's expression softened. "I think he'd appreciate knowing the shop is in good hands."
...
[Later that evening]
Ryan approached with several pages clipped together and held them toward her. "Beckett, I need your signature on these before we finish processing Dahl."
Kate took the paperwork just as Castle's phone rang. His smile faded when Gina's name appeared. "I'll see you guys tomorrow."
"Good night, Castle," Kate said.
"Good night, Kate," Castle said as he walked toward the elevator.
..
Next: A New House